This is the Rational Reminder podcast, a weekly reality check on sensible investing and financial decision-making from two Canadians. We're hosted by me, Benjamin Felix, Chief Investment Officer, and Cameron Passmore, Chief Executive Officer at PWL Capital.
Welcome to episode 421. And Ben, it was seven, almost seven years ago that you and I packed up our backpacks full of the recording gear and went off to New York City to interview Barry Ritholtz because of course back then you could only interview guests face-to-face. So, we reached out to Barry. We knew Barry through conferences and just by reputation and he was kind enough to welcome us into his New York City office and we recorded an interview with him. That was episode 57 back in August of 2019. So, the pod was barely a year old at that point or just a year old at that point. And we got a chance to meet Barry and today we welcome Barry Ritholtz back to the pod to talk about his most recent book, How Not to Invest. Now, Barry's been around a long time. Founder of Ritholtz Wealth Management, which is a very well-known, pretty high-profile, certainly from their media and content that they create out of New York City, but they're now a national firm. And we've gotten to know a bunch of their team over the years. Like, we've had over the years, his partner Josh Brown's been on.
Like, Julie's been on. Like, Ben Carlson's been on. Yeah, we've had Ben Carlson, so good group of people. Barry's always so gracious and generous with us. We've seen him at many conferences. He's always super friendly and interesting and good guy, so kudos to getting him back on the pod, Ben.
Yeah, he was. You said he was welcoming when we went to his office back then. He was super supportive, too. We recorded with Barry, but they also let us use a space in their office to record another interview with somebody else in New York City that we had lined up. So, that was very cool. We've remained, I would say, pretty close to those guys over the years, just sharing ideas back and forth and keeping in touch.
He also made the introduction to Prof G, Scott Galloway. That's how we got Scott on.
Yeah, very cool. So, Barry doesn't need much of an introduction. His track record and online presence kind of speaks for themselves, but he did graduate from Stony Brook University with a degree in political science and a minor in philosophy, did graduate studies at Yeshiva University's Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, and became a lawyer. Kind of a neat part of Barry's background. And then he created The Big Picture, which is his very popular blog. He also hosts the Masters in Business podcast from Bloomberg, which has been a huge success. He does a ton of writing in various publications, but he's, I mean, you know, if you're in this industry or even consuming content in this space, like even if you're a DIY investor trying to learn about this stuff, and you don't know who Barry is, I'd be surprised.
I don't think we were. We were inspired way back when from listening to Animal Spirits and his colleagues with Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson. We're like, these guys are two guys talking. We could be two guys talking. Right?
Yeah. That's right. Yeah, 2018. Yeah, we were both listening to Animal Spirits, and I said exactly that. We could probably talk to each other with a microphone.
Yeah. So, Barry's book, How Not to Invest, it's a thick book. I read the whole thing cover-to-cover. Lots of good stuff in there though, and this conversation I think it feels very organic, and I don't think it feels like we're talking about a book. But the questions that we asked are really inspired by the content of the book. So, I don't know. I just, I'm glad I read the book. I'll say that. It was a good read. Lots of good nuggets in there. A combination of references to academic research, and also Barry's experience. Lots of good stories.
His experience is incredible.
I mean, he gives a couple of stories, some people from Masters in Business, and the people he's interviewed on that podcast are phenomenal. Like, he's been at communicating in this space for so long.
And he's got such energy and character, and storytelling, it's quite something.
Tons of good stuff. Make sure you listen to the end to hear whether Barry thinks you should buy a new car or not. I loved his answer to that question, and the whole discussion that followed.
All right. Good to go, Ben?
Yeah, let's go ahead to our episode with Barry Ritholtz. Barry Ritholtz, welcome back to the Rational Reminder podcast.
Thank you so much for having me.
All right, Barry. What happens when billionaires go on TV to make economic forecasts?
Well, they tend to do two things. Some of these things are very similar to what other forecasters do, and some are very different. The thing they do that's similar is they talk their book, like everybody else does. Hey, I own these assets, and I'm very enthusiastic about it. There's nothing wrong with that. The bias is there. You can't help it. But the things they do that are different is first, they're pretty unqualified to make even an economic forecast. Most of the time, they're not really qualified to do a deep dive into whatever they're talking about. But what makes this so dangerous is what we call the halo effect, which is when people see someone who's really successful in one specific sphere, hey, we apply a halo to everything they do and we imagine that that success is the same in everything else they touch. Spoiler alert, they're not all that successful elsewhere. They're really good at what they're really good at and like everybody else, they have no idea what the future holds.
Mhm. Yeah, so we obviously see that all the time on business news. But how well does this phenomenon extend to other domains like film and music?
So it's really fascinating in the creative arts because not only are you exercising as somebody working for a film company greenlighting a movie or let's say a recording studio and you have to greenlight a new artist, you might know a lot about that space, but films are great because you're effectively making a prediction as to where will the public's taste be five years from now? If we say go today, it's five years or so before this hits theaters. Even if you do a small little indie film, it's still two to three years. Taste changes really rapidly and what we've seen in this space is that people have a deep expertise in understanding their field, but what they don't really have much of an expertise in is forecasting what's going to happen next. I like to think of the formula in the space as, you know, forecasting ends up to be some combination of skill plus outside events plus random luck and that's what determines outcomes. So, yes, skill is helpful, but it's only a small part of the total equation.
Speaking of forecasting, Barry, you've been on and around Wall Street for decades. How well do you think experts forecast future stock market returns?
Well, as long as they're not, you know, trading on inside information about when the Venezuela assault is going to happen or when the bombs will start dropping in Iran, I'm not talking about inside information being used to make bets in prediction markets. Just general predictions, Wall Streeters are terrible at that. They have a lot of valuable skills. They focus on understanding their space. They can provide some insight and context, but confidently predicting the future is not what they do best. I like to channel John Kenneth Galbraith, who said, 'There are two kinds of forecasters. Those who don't know and those who don't know they don't know.' And that sums it up perfectly.
You touch on a couple things there, Barry. You give great cases for where experts are not useful in making forecasts in a bunch of different domains. What are experts useful for?
So, a lot of things. So, people who have a very specific domain expertise are really good at explaining what is happening in that space and why. The best people in specific areas have done the data analysis. They've done the deep dive into history. They know what has occurred in the past. They know what was the result of a random situation or what's more normal. They know all the players, the old guard, the new entrants. They know everybody's track records. And the ability to provide context and color and nuance that comes from immersing yourself in that sort of area for years or decades is really helpful. The best example of this is, 'Hey, your cardiologist can tell you exactly how healthy your heart is. They can't say you're going to have a heart attack on this date.' And if you keep that in mind, you want someone to be able to tell you, 'Hey, how does my portfolio look?' Not, 'Hey, but in October we're going to have a crash.'
What tells can people look for to spot bad advice?
So many of these, and they're really, some of them are more obvious than others. The most obvious one is an appeal to emotion. If they're trying to frighten you or get your greed button pushed, if they want your FOMO juices to flow, it's an obvious tell. Anything with a sense of urgency, we just talked about a crash. 'Hey, the market's about to crash in September' is a giant red flag. That is not an insight. The best advice tends to be both humble and probabilistic. In other words, 'Hey, I don't really know for sure what happens, but here's how I see the various outcomes and the odds around each.' We tend to see bad advice sounding very self-confident and very specific. And then, you know, it's always useful if you're looking for a tell, follow the money. What's in it for them? What are they getting paid to do? And are they just talking their book? Another way to think about this is what I call the three Ds: doubt, depth, and Dunning-Kruger. People who have no self-doubt probably are unaware of their own limits and their blind spots. Depth, you want people with a broad and deep well of experience and a good track record that's part of a repeatable process. And then lastly, Dunning-Kruger is one of my favorite academic research papers about metacognition. This is more than overconfidence. It's how aware are you of the limits of your own skill set. There's nothing more expensive for a novice investor than the sentence, 'Hey, how hard can it be?' That's the Dunning-Kruger effect at work.
Yeah, the scary thing is a lot of the ways he described bad advice are also more attention-grabbing than a lot of the characteristics of good advice.
If you're not paying attention, if you're not, you know, giving them your time and energy, why bother? And what's even worse today is that on social media and elsewhere, the algorithm rewards the more outrageous, emotional pitches. And so the feed from pick your favorite cancer, Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok, go down the list, outrage and excitement tends to feed right into what that algo is providing people.
Yeah, I want to dig a little bit more into that. What role do you think that the 24/7 media is, that could be social media, but also I mean you can watch business news anytime of the day as well. What role has that played in the dissemination of bad advice?
You know, sometimes a phrase gets so commonplace we forget what it means. So there's a website called The Daily Beast and people tend to forget, I forgot what piece of literature that comes from a century ago. But the news media is the daily beast that must be fed. There are always column inches to fill, newsletters and columns to write, radio, TV, cable broadcast have 24/7 that must constantly be filled. But, you know, nonstop demand for your attention tends to be chronologically incompatible with what should be an investor's goal, which is allowing your portfolio to compound over years and decades. And so, there's this inherent conflict between the daily fire hose and, yeah, I'm saving for retirement in 30 years.
So, how useful do you think it is for investors to actually pay attention to the news?
If you want to be a good dinner party guest and have, you know, good cocktail party chatter, it's useful. If you're a professional trader, it's really important. But if you're a long-term investor, it's not only useless, it's a negative. It can impair your returns because the media tends to urge you to action. We all have a bias towards action, and history tells us most of our financial decisions that we make are not especially good, and it turns out the fewer decisions we make, the better off we tend to be. So, anything that is constantly pushing your enthusiasm, your excitement button, and urging you to don't just sit there, do something, tends to hurt your portfolio. Most people are better off don't just do something, sit there, as opposed to what the media is urging, don't just sit there, do something. By the way, Henry Bessembinder, who did a number of really great studies, had a piece out very recently where they looked at all of the regular changes, rebalance, additions, subtractions to the S&P 500. And talk about don't just do something, sit there. It turns out if you just left it alone from inception and never touched it again, significant outperformance from everything that's been going on, which is really kind of hilarious when you stop and think about it.
Yeah, those studies are super interesting. Specifically short-form media like TikTok and Instagram, we're talking about whatever 30-second to a minute-long clips. How bad has that been specifically the short-form for investors?
So, the algos reward the loudest and most extreme voices for sure. And then all of this stuff is kind of financial junk food. I'll give you two of my favorite takeaways from this. The first is in the United States the Internal Revenue Service had to issue a special 42-point press release debunking 42 separate things on TikTok and Instagram that if you followed them, not only were they wrong, some of them would cost you penalties and fines, others would cost you a clawback and interest, and some of them will get your ass sent to jail. So, that's how bad it is. The IRS had to say that. But to me, the biggest takeaway comes from what all of our mothers told us. Never take candy from strangers. You guys are old enough to remember when that was a thing. If you don't know who this person is that's giving you this advice, who are they? What's their track record? What's their methodology? Do they have a temperament where they're not running around hair on fire every time something happens? To take advice from a, I love the expression, rando on social media, I mean, it's the financial equivalent of taking candy from a stranger. You don't want to become financially roofied, but that's what social media is. It's junk food or worse.
Wild. How does Gell-Mann amnesia affect the way people perceive the news?
I love this concept that comes from Michael Crichton. Where he tells a story of reading a story in a major newspaper where he was actually at the event, knew the players, knew what was actually going on, and the reporter got it completely wrong. Either they were standing in the wrong part of whatever the event was, or they just didn't have a good framework for understanding what was happening. And so you read this and you say, 'Oh, this is completely wrong.' And then you turn the page and you believe whatever is on the next page. And I'm not saying that media is always wrong and that everything's fallible. It's that we just give way too much credence to an organization like a newspaper or a television channel. And we forget it's more than just a masthead of writers or producers and presenters. It's a collection of human beings, and as we know, human beings are really fallible. So my advice to people about this is create your own list of people that you've vetted and tested out over the years. And people that can become trusted voices for you. And to demonstrate how much I practice what I preach, I don't even, I listed my voices that I trust, but I always tell people, 'Hey, that's my list and what works for me. You got to go make your own list. I'm not selling you my list. I'm not promoting my list. You have to stop outsourcing your thinking to third parties and figure out who's trustworthy and who's not.' But to bring it back to Gell-Mann amnesia and Michael Crichton, it's very powerful noticing how wrong some of the headlines from yesterday or a year ago are and that should just be a reminder you got to take everything you read with a little bit of a grain of salt.
And maybe just for the benefit of listeners, Gell-Mann amnesia is the idea where if you see something that you have expertise in and realize that it's wrong but then continue to ascribe credibility to the source despite that knowing that one thing was wrong. That's the phenomenon.
Right, you go on to that reporter might have been wrong but it's in the Washington Post and you either click to the next article or old school turn the page and you lose that credulity of hey, does this person really know what they're talking about? For the most part I think the media does a pretty good job of covering the news but there's plenty of places where there's room for improvement and we just need to be a little skeptical about some outrageous claims. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof and we often don't see that.
What do you think are the best ways for people to make sure they're getting more signal and less noise from the media?
So a couple of ways. The first thing is to lengthen your time horizon of your media consumption meaning, you know, tweets are the shortest term thing. The Instagram and TikTok super short. There is a mismatch between that timeline of now now now and hey, I'm saving for 15 years for my kids college or 10 years to buy a house or 20, 30 years to retirement. These instantaneous hot takes, what does that have to do with how things are going to be 25 years ago? And the best way to demonstrate that is to look backwards and say, imagine Twitter existed 25 years ago. What was being said in 2001 in short snappy bursts that would have been meaningful to anybody? In the end, the answer is nothing. So, be selective, create that own list of trusted sources, and instead of focusing on short-form tweets or what have you or TikToks, read books. Do the deep dive. Become self-educated. My bias is I happen to like long-form podcasts. I think you get so much more out of that than you do a headline or an op-ed or a really short item that was just cranked out to feed the beast. And so, we have, I keep being told reading is dead. I'll let you in on a secret. Reading for most of history was the province of the elites. You know, it's only in the past few hundred years that most people had learned to read. For a while, it was the high priests and the royalty and the cabinet that had the ability to read, and the average person was illiterate. So, the fact that a lot of people aren't reading books is just sort of mean reversion in my mind, but it's a huge advantage. Is there a better bargain in the world that someone takes, I don't know, a thousand hours, two thousand hours, and a lifetime of experience? You could buy it for $21.95. I mean, stop and think about that. What an enormous... Like, I get paid a ton of money to speak at conferences. Or, instead of taking 40 minutes of me going like this and answering a Q&A, here's 2,000 hours and 30 years of work for 20 bucks. That is the greatest bargain in the modern media world, modern information world.
Barry, what is investing?
My definition is investing is the art of using imperfect information to make probabilistic assessments about an inherently unknowable world. And if you break that down into component pieces, art tells us that it's not just a simple mathematical formula. I will tip my hat to the quants who use math to give themselves an edge, but even that is not perfect. And it's recognizing that whatever information we have is imperfect, meaning it's incomplete, sometimes it's inaccurate, sometimes it's out of context. And it's not about making binary forecasts up or down, it's about assessing things probabilistically, meaning what's the most likely outcome, what's the least likely outcome, how is my portfolio teed up to survive this range of possible outcomes. And then lastly, it's recognizing the future is inherently unknown and for the most part unknowable. Every time we see people make these forecasts, here's why you have to own this because here's what's going to happen. The world intervenes. A year is simultaneously a short period of time in an investor's long-term horizon, but simultaneously a long enough period of time that random events occur so frequently that it derails even the most thoughtful forecast. So, nobody had, you know, in the December 2019 look ahead, no one had a global pandemic closing the economy. Oh, and by the way, the market's going to scream higher. The same thing before the invasion of Ukraine, before the Israel-Gaza war, before, you know, a handful of people were talking about the Fed has to raise, the Fed has to raise, the Fed has to raise in '21, '22. And when the Fed finally raised 525 basis points, it really seemed to have caught people by surprise, which is kind of shocking because that was probably the most obvious change in central bank policy, and yet we still got it wrong. So, the challenge is recognizing how squishy and challenging this is. The people who tell you it's easier are selling you something. I also like to say investing is simple but hard. It's not easy, but it's simple. You just have to not get in your own way.
Given all that, Barry, how do good investors think about the world?
Well, first you have to recognize the complexity and how many different factors and variables are all driving the world forward. That's number one. And second, the best investors take all those variables and we mentioned thinking probabilistically. It doesn't hurt to be a little humble and understand what you do and don't know. But then the step that I see so many people fail to make, the leap. And perhaps it's what's going on in mass media, television, print, whatever, is you have to focus on all the things that you can control. You can control your savings rate. You can control your asset allocation, how much stocks you have relative to bonds. You should be able to have some discipline and A, create a plan, but then B, have the discipline to stick with that plan. And then lastly, you have to manage your own behavior. Every 5% drawdown, you can't run around with your hair on fire. And the flip side of that is you have to learn how to maybe ignore is too strong a word, but you have to learn how to recognize all of the things you cannot control. When the Fed is going to hike or cut, who's going to win the next election, what's nonfarm payroll or GDP, when is the war going to end, what's the inflation print going to be, what are these companies' earnings going to be this quarter. By the way, that list of things that are totally out of your control and are mostly unpredictable, that seems to be the prime focus of print and broadcast media because it changes constantly and when you have to fill column inches 24/7, hey, all that stuff makes for great fodder. The problem is it's not useful, surprisingly not useful to investors.
Which is why I've got this next question for you. Why is not knowing viable as an investor?
So, I'm a car guy and I've taken just about, bear with me on a slightly long metaphor. I've taken every advanced driving class you can take. Skip Barber and Lime Rock, I've been to Monticello Motor Park, I've done the Porsche days here, I've gone to Sebring, I've done a BMW driving school. I've done all these things and all of these classes, they're marketed as high performance racing schools. But, the truth is deep down inside, they're barely disguised defensive driving classes. And the heart of a defensive driving class is, hey, what are the limits of your own skills and what are the limits, what is the performance envelope of the car you're driving? The turning, stopping, accelerating, what is that framework? And you would be surprised at when you know what your own limits are and you don't push beyond those, hey, it turns out to be a really useful skill. And if you know the limits of your car, I'm not going to throw this giant tall SUV into a turn at 70 miles an hour. You know, the big body-on-frame SUVs have an unusually high incident of single vehicle fatalities, typically a rollover. Because someone did something that the car was not capable of doing. So, knowing what you don't know, where the limits of your own skill sets are and your abilities are, that's really meaningful. In your portfolio, it's a money saver and on the road, it's a life saver.
It can be a hard skill to gain. How can people get better at admitting that they don't know stuff?
I mean, beyond just a little self-reflection and honesty, I think there are two ways people get those skills. One is you can just age well and become wise as you get more and more experience and gray hairs. But if you don't want to wait that long, you can do what most people do and just lose a ton of money in the market. That sort of pricey tuition kind of helps you figure out, oh, I'm doing all this wrong. I better learn how to do this better. But those are the only two things I've found. Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger will tell you, and if you are constantly reading books and learning along the way, but that's I think that's implied in age well and become wise.
What are the best ideas that shape your own investment philosophy?
So many. Let me give you a few of my favorites. And all these come straight from the book. Probably I love Sturgeon's Law. He was a science fiction writer in the '50s and '60s, and critics always gave him grief about how bad so much science fiction is. And Ted Sturgeon responded, '90% of everything is crap.' And that has since become known as Sturgeon's Law, and it's surprisingly informative as an insight into decision-making and choice. And look at most of the mutual funds in the world, not good. SPACs, not good. Most of the stocks, not good. Many, many bonds, not great. And that's just in finance. So, if you recognize, I called it Ritholtz's Corollary, 90% of all financial products are crap, and credited it to Sturgeon, but it's really the same thing. Most of this stuff isn't especially good for your portfolio. So, start with that. The second one is something you had asked about, the first question was about billionaires making economic prognostications. Everybody on Wall Street, everybody in finance and investing uses models, and we kind of forget that. I'm going to quote statistics professor George Box, 'All models are wrong, but some are useful.' And what that means is a model is just a depiction of the world mathematically. It's not a perfect depiction. It's not a three-dimensional or four-dimensional if you include time hologram that's identical to the universe. It's a shadow. It's a model that tries to get at the key drivers. And we tend to confuse models with the real world. Have you ever seen a bad backtest, a bad financial model on some new product? They're always great. And part of the reason models are so problematic is built into every model is the future is going to look like the past. And so some of these models tend to work until the future changes. And as soon as it changes, the model stops working and people are perplexed. So that's the second one. And then probably my favorite one comes from William Goldman, which is, you know, the first part of the book, which is nobody knows anything. Now, Goldman was using this to explain why Hollywood was so bad at picking movies. They greenlit all sorts of disasters. They passed on Star Wars. They passed on Princess Bride. For years, they passed on Raiders of the Lost Ark. I love the John Wick story that here's like one of the biggest action stars in Hollywood and he couldn't get them to make, Keanu Reeves couldn't get the major studios to make John Wick. It's since become a two billion dollar franchise. So you can combine nobody knows anything about the future with Sturgeon's Law that 90% of everything is crap and you could see why it is so difficult to beat the market consistently over long periods of time.
Do you think Sturgeon's Law will survive AI or is more than 90% of everything going to be crap in the future?
I just read something this morning that Substack is including for free an AI detector. I think it's called Panagram that will let you know that the Substack you're reading is created by mediocre software lifting information from large language models. It's been pretty clear that there's a ton of slop and hey, I love using Claude for research. I use Notebook, which is by Google and Perplexity, which I use less and less these days and ChatGPT. And it's great for research. If you ask it to write something, so I answered a whole run of questions myself and then I asked three different models to answer it. They did an okay job, but it's mostly unreadable garbage and that's the problem with it. So, I think we'll find out. And here, to be fair, it's still a relatively young technology and it's going to get better and better over time. You know, the risk isn't doing a large language model on the English language, it's hey, take everything Cameron has written over the past 20 years, now write an article with that background in that voice. I mean, that's not 20 years away, that's a year or two away assuming you can't do it now. It's just pricey to build your own LLM, but yeah, this is an issue and it's 90% of everything is crap. I think that's timeless.
What are the worst offenders of economic innumeracy that lead people to make bad decisions?