Welcome to this month's episode of Chopping Wealth. I'm Brian Portnoy, founder and CEO of Shaping Wealth. And Chopping Wealth is one of my favorite features of our Compass content platform, compass.shapingwealth.com. Tons of good stuff for you and your clients. I am thrilled today to welcome my old friend Barry Ritholtz. He has published a really wonderful new book called How Not to Invest. And before we dive in, because I have about five pages of questions, Barry, say hi and give us a quick synopsis of who you are.
Sure. I'm Barry Ritholtz. I'm founder, chairman, and chief investment officer of Ritholtz Wealth Management. Last filing we did, we were about $5.6 billion in assets. I've been writing and speaking in public about markets and the economy for, I don't know, 30 years. Launched the blog The Big Picture on GeoCities in 1998.
I mean, that's how long I've been around. Launched the Masters in Business podcast on Bloomberg in July 2014. That was about five years after my first book, Bailout Nation. The new book, How Not to Invest. I'm like clockwork. I drop a new book every 15 years. So look for the sequel to this one in 2040.
The first one was really a slog, so maybe that's why there was such a gap between the two. This one was really a pleasure to write. It was a lot of fun to put together.
Perfect segue, because it was truly a pleasure to read. I read it through a couple times, and the way I — both of my sons are finance or business majors, and this is something that I'll have them read in due course. And it's really a field guide to surviving the markets. And in true Barry form, it is witty, it is irreverent, and it is very smart. Let me start where I've never started with a guest before.
Wait, I just want to emphasize that: witty, irreverent, and really smart. That's going to be the pull quote for the paperback.
Okay, there you go. There you go. It's yours to use. So it's not often that I look at, let alone get excited about, a book's dedication. But I open it up and I see my two heroes, the Charlies.
The Charlies, the two Charlies, yeah.
Yeah, the twin Charlies. Charlie Ellis and Charlie Munger. And you know, you've written some books, I've written books. When you dedicate a book, it's something you put a little bit of thought into. It's the very first thing that somebody sees, and it's important. It's part of your legacy as an author and as a communicator. Why Charlie Ellis? Why Charlie Munger?
It's a really long story. I'll give you a really short version of it. I've been fortunate enough to interview Charlie Ellis a few times. I never got to meet Charlie Munger. And I had been turning down various pushes from various publishers and various friends and family: 'Hey, it's been a long time. It's been 10 years. It's time for another book,' you know. And I just really wasn't enthusiastic about it because, truth be told, there have been tens of thousands of books telling people how to invest over the past century. None of us are especially great at it. You know the household names because they're such unicorns, they're such outliers — the Peter Lynches, the Warren Buffetts. And so I come home from vacation one day and I'm just thumbing through, you know, that dead zone before January 2nd after Christmas, like right now, and I just start reading a whole bunch of old research notes and commentary and quarterly calls that I've done for clients over the past 10-15 years, and like this theme starts to form, which is just debunking a lot of nonsense. And you know, I'm a big collector of quotes, and I always loved the Charlie Munger quote, which is: the advantage of Berkshire is not that we were smarter than everybody else, it's that we were less stupid. And it's such a beautiful Mungerism because it really tells you, hey, you know, stop trying to swing for the fences. Just get some wood on the ball. I remember my little league coach: 'You're not making Mantle. Just make contact.' And that's what Munger suggested, which is its own inverted thought process. But Charlie Ellis — I'm going to mix sports metaphors — Charlie Ellis is really the guy who told us that investing is two games in one. It's a winner's game and a loser's game. And he wrote a paper in the 1970s that eventually became a book in the 1990s where he likens investing to tennis. And tennis is two games. If you're part of the 0.001% of people in the world who are professional tennis players, you win by scoring points. You hit with power, you hit with accuracy, you put a lot of spin on the ball, you keep it away from your opponent, you serve aces, you control the game. That's not how the rest of us play. The 99.99% of people who are amateurs, we play a loser's game. We don't win by scoring points; we lose by hitting the ball beyond our capability. We double fault on a serve, we hit it long, we hit it wide, we hit it into the net, we hit it right to our opponent's sweet spot. And if we only try to stay within ourselves, just return the ball, make fewer unforced errors, you would do so much better. And as it turns out, the exact same thing is true in investing.
Consistently less stupid, less wrong is the key.
Yeah, fewer errors. And that inversion — and was it Munger who said, 'Invert, always invert'?
Well, he was channeling a 15th-century mathematician, Jacobi, who, when confronted with a problem that seems unsolvable, solve for the opposite. And very often that inversion leads you to a solution. So, but I think Munger is the person who brought that to a modern audience.
Consistently less stupid. So what's kind of brilliant about this book is you point out about 279 ways in which we can be stupid, and in very blunt format you say, 'Don't do that. Don't do that.' And as you were, you know, before we started recording, mentioning, somehow there wasn't a book called How Not to Invest. But in a sense, I read this as a way for you to give wisdom and guidance after 30-plus years of doing this to people as to how to avoid the mistakes. Is that the mission here?
I mean, yeah, to a large degree. Every mistake in the book, I've made. I detail some of my worst, most expensive money-losing or gain-avoiding mistakes that I've made. I throw lots of people up as examples. Some really brilliant investors have done some really silly things, and that unfortunately influences us. Look, humans are social creatures. I say in the book, we have neither fangs nor armor nor claws. We're soft, chewy, and delicious. So we have to learn how to be cooperative creatures in order to adapt and survive. And that cooperation is so hardwired into us, it often leads us to be a little gullible and a little naive. A troop of chimpanzees in the trees with watch monkeys on watch, chattering and warning that a leopard's coming — that sort of wetware is in us, and it leads us to say, you know, that expensive annuity certainly seems like a good deal. This guy seems to know what he's talking about. That cooperative background leads us to be a little too gullible for our own financial well-being. And so I don't want people to become cynical and negative. I want them to trust but verify, and I want them to be, you know, a little more skeptical when a deal looks too good to be true. Stop and say, why is this so good? And very often, it turns out not to be.
So you are transparent and honest in the book about some of your mistakes. You want to flag one, because you made so many. Let's talk about — but one that really had, you know, as you think about your career, one that really sticks with you. And was it an error of commission or an error of omission?
Okay, give me one of each.
By the way, I thought, you know, when I was writing for The Washington Post, I would do my annual mea culpas every year and say this is what I got wrong. I don't think you can call out other people unless you're honest about your own screw-ups. So, probably the omission and the commission. The commission was when I worked at a firm that had about 800 brokers. As their market strategist, I would occasionally make specific stock — I would float specific stock ideas. If enough guys bought it, there was a big bonus at the end of the rainbow for me. And I've been an Apple Mac head since the late '80s. I had a Mac Classic when I was in grad school. And so, having been writing in public, I kind of got to know people like Guy Kawasaki and other folks at Apple. And so when this newfangled iPod came out — and I want to say iPod, not iPhone — I got invited to the demo. Long story short, again, Sony Walkman, the little portable cassette players, a thousand songs in your pocket on this little digital device, right? Think about people used to walk around carrying tapes or CDs. It was insane. Now your phone has a million songs plus streaming, but a thousand songs in your pocket at the time — Apple was $15 a share with $13 cash on the books. This is '02, '03, something like that. And it seemed like, wait, I'm risking two bucks on what looks like a revolutionary product, and Steve Jobs has just returned. Let's do that. And so I write up a description about the new product and float the idea, and the brokers all start buying the stock at 15 bucks. And I'm watching the reports coming every day, millions of shares were accumulating, and I'm thinking this is going to be a double, a triple, a 10-bagger. And then at $20 I start seeing, you know, the sales come in. And this was the tail end of the bear market, and I remember grabbing a broker and asking him about it: 'Hey man, up 33%, got to ring the bell, everything else sucks.' So brokers are — and that was kind of like, oh, I'm on the wrong side of the street, I'm on the buy side, I should be on the sell side. Hold that for a moment. And I'm like, I'm going to show these — hold on to the stock, and I just kept moving my stop loss off. I had some in my personal account, and it crossed 45, it's a triple. Eventually it moved back down and I got stopped out, and I'm like, showed you guys, triple. You guys made 33%, I made 300%. When are you going to start listening to me? And of course the stock proceeds to run up another 10,000%. So that was my thinking like a trader when I had become an investor. That was my sin of commission. My sin of omission was sitting with Howard Lindzon in San Francisco on the seaport with the Oakland Bridge in the background, and he's pitching me this stupid app that allows millennials to trade for free.
What a dumb — I literally said to him, Howard, that is the dumbest idea I've ever heard in my life. Now, to be fair to me, we had moved to the fiduciary side. We had moved away from — this was 2014. We had just launched the firm a year earlier. We weren't doing transactional business. It was all fee-based. It was broad, diversified indexes, not stock picking, not any of that. But it turned out that Howard was pitching a seed round of Robinhood. And a few thousand dollars would have been worth tens of millions of dollars 10 years later. And again, to be fair, it was very off-brand. The pandemic pretty much put Robinhood on the map, but for that, which was kind of unforeseeable in 2014. But hey, how often do you leave a hundred million dollars on the sideline? It was a giant win for Howard. And the lesson is, if you're going to dabble in alts, defer to the people who have a good track record and are in the top, I don't know, quartile, decile of that, and don't venture too far afield, because you have no expertise in it. There's a chapter in the book about epistemic trespass. That was a perfect example of, 'Hey, I've had a pretty good track record timing markets and picking broad sectors. What on earth made me think I could do seed investing?' Nothing.
So I want to plant a flag on a very foundational definition. What does it mean for an investor to succeed? Is it beating the market? Is it making more? Is it turning a thousand bucks into 10 million based on the, you know, kind of story that you just told? When not just the financial advisors, who are our core audience, but other folks, you know, friends and neighbors listen to this, and they're thinking about, 'Well, what am I really trying to get done here?' How would you define success for them such that you are teaching them how not to, you know, get in their own way?
Sure. Success starts with two fundamental building blocks: what is money and its purpose, and what are your goals in life, right? I mean, these seem so basic as to be a given. People don't know what money is. I'm genuinely shocked how often I have a conversation with people: no, it's not a way of keeping score. No, it's not a store of value. Money is a medium of exchange that allows you to deploy it in order to serve a variety of purposes. I pay my bills with money. I pay my taxes with money. I specifically use it to invest. I focus all my basic security is covered with money, you know, in Maslow's hierarchy of needs. You go beyond that, your entertainment, your ability to spend time and build memories with friends and family. To me, that's what the value of money is. I can exchange my time, energy, and expertise for money, and then I use money — I can exchange money for these other things I want. Some people get that, but they don't make the next step, which is: what are your goals? What are your financial goals? Sometimes it's you open a 529, you're saving for a kid's college. A 401k or an IRA, and you're saving for retirement. Generational wealth transfer, philanthropy. Money only has value when it has a purpose. And anytime we see somebody engaging in more, more, more, money for its own sake — look at Archegos, and somebody had just — the purpose wasn't to do anything other than just rack up more and more. As it turns out, that's not the path to life satisfaction or happiness, and it's not the path to success as an investor, because you want to marry the appropriate level of risk to your financial goal. We see this with endowments and with really wealthy people sometimes, that they're just taking on so much more risk. And in a market like 2025, so much volatility, so much up and down. It's like, you have a hundred million dollars, you've already won. Why is half your portfolio the highest-beta, wildest-moving tech stocks in the world? You know, Tesla was down 45% in three months. Why are you loaded up with Tesla? Why are you loaded up with Nvidia, the first company to lose a trillion dollars in market cap? Like, so I sometimes say to people, have to say to people, you've already won, what are you doing? And so having a goal allows you to marry the appropriate level of risk so that you're not dealing with this sort of mayhem. You could go out and live your life and not feel like you're tied to the futures each night. Like, I started on a trading desk. Like, I very vividly remember running around trying to get futures quotes on Sunday night in the late '90s because I couldn't afford a Bloomberg terminal back then. And so, but the people I knew who had one, it's like they would get a phone call from me at 6:01: 'So what do we look like tomorrow?' Like, if you're on a trading desk, well, of course. But if you're in your 50s, 60s, 70s, you're retired, you got family, you turn the world — if you're tied, you know, I had someone say to me, 'I feel like I'm a slave to the market.' Well, then you have too much equity exposure for that politically incorrect observation. You're good. Everything's paid for, your kids' houses and your grandkids' colleges are paid for. Why do you need this? You've already obtained all of what you wanted. So I think I've answered the question and kind of wandered into a field adjacent to it. But the bottom line is, money is a tool. You use it to satisfy certain needs. And when you have a goal, you can marry it to the appropriate portfolio and risk.
Well, you were wading into my home turf of behavioral finance, and we're going to kind of circle that terrain as we go on. But as we've all said many times over the years, simple is not easy. So it's one thing to say, 'Hey, have a goal and work toward it.' But we know that there's a lot more going on, and not to be cynical or conspiratorial in any way, the system isn't really set up to help us smoothly and easily and affordably get to that place. The financial services industry and the financial media complex might get in our way, which is where I kind of wanted to turn next. You know, throughout the book and in a couple of relatively sharp moments, you had some lacerating comments about the financial media ecosystem and what it does to the regular investor who's trying to make sense of it all. I mean, you've been part of this world for decades. You have been on the networks. You've written for all of the publications, and I think it's fair to say that there are some real charlatans out there. So I wanted to get your assessment of the financial media landscape, and more broadly, the information landscape that we live in right now is beyond overwhelming. When you think about all of the sources, through social media and YouTube becoming the global TV network, and more and more and more — what's your assessment of what folks are dealing with, and what's your advice for transcending the noise?
When I was in grad school, there was literally Wall Street Week with Louis Rukeyser, who would come on Friday night, he would chat for 10, 15 minutes to the audience, then he would bring out his panel, and then he would bring out a guest. That was financial television: one hour, once a week, go about your lives. And when you look at how it evolved, first with a single financial channel, the Financial News Network, and then multiple channels — Fox Business and CNBC and Bloomberg, and at one point in time there was CNNfn. You know, I use the metaphor in the book about a gardening channel where they plant a tree, and it's just like a cam — remember the old days of webcams where, you know, you're just watching the wilderness or you're watching a — so private equity buys this garden channel, and they want to get ratings, so they gussy this up and flip it. And so they bring in panels of people to argue about the tree that's planted in the middle of the yard. And it's: is this the right tree for this climate? Is this the wrong tree? Do we plant it too deep? Are we watering it enough? Is it not getting enough water? How do you feel about pesticides? Should we be GMO-free? All that — they're constantly arguing. Nothing they say has any effect on the tree. It just quietly keeps growing. And it feels like that's social media. So we go from one hour a week to five channels to now social media and millions of people wholly unqualified giving people advice. And so you have to stop and ask yourself: why am I watching all of this noise? What does this do for me? If I'm focused on growing my portfolio for the next 5, 10, 20, 30 years, who cares what happens on a random Tuesday? It's not relevant. And so part of the book asks the question: what are they selling? Always ask yourself, what are they selling? I used to do a presentation where I'd ask the audience, what does radio sell? What does TV sell? And the audience invariably would say, advertising. And I had to correct them gently: no, advertisers are the buyers, right? What they're selling is you. They're selling your time, they're selling your attention. And today, thanks to Facebook and cookies and a whole lot of other technology, they cross-reference your time and attention with your browsing history, your credit score, your purchasing history. And so you are the audience. And when you figure that out, you realize I probably am not deriving value from 90% of this. I reference Sturgeon's Law. Science fiction writer in the '50s got tired of people slagging sci-fi: 'Hey, how come so much of sci-fi is not good?' And Sturgeon said, 90% of everything is crap. And that turns out to have held up really well over the past 75 years. Most mutual funds aren't good, most ETFs aren't good, most alts aren't good. Hey, if you get into the top decile of quant funds, knock yourself out. Most stocks aren't good. The data on what drives markets are a tiny handful of stocks. So if all that stuff is bad — people going on TV, selling a product, selling a fund, selling this, selling that — I think you have to recognize that this is a giant distraction. If you're 40 and you're putting money away for the next 25-30 years, what does it matter what this analyst's opinion about this stock or this economist's expectation of a recession in 2026? How does that affect your needs come 2075? It's just so irrelevant.
Yeah, so I think the questions you're asking are helpful. I mean, those are the pathways. Because it's easy to say, 'Well, 90% of it's crap.' But you're in the mix, you're on social media, you're on one of a dozen different, you know, streams. And how do you know what's the 10% versus the 90%? So the questions are the map. The questions allow you to transcend. Part of the problem is it requires someone to take a moment to think about, well, what's being served up to me. And as the advanced form of animal as we are, as you alluded to earlier, that's easier said than done.