CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Barry Ritholtz gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Barry Ritholtz
Co-founder, Chairman & Chief Investment Officer, Ritholtz Wealth Management

Why Money Isn't What You Think: Barry Ritholtz on the Meaning of Money and How NOT to Invest It

📅 Mar 07, 2025 Excess Returns 36 MIN 15939 VIEWS 55 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Buy Barry's Book https://amzn.to/3F7APZP For transcript and deep dive research https://nadig.com In this initial episode of Rabbithole, Dave Nadig explores the psychology of money and investing with Barry Ritholtz, author of "How Not to Invest." Their conversation challenges conventional financial wisdom and reveals insights about what money is, and how we use and invest it. Key topics include: Why money is a tool for freedom and agency, not a store of value or end goal How childhood experiences shape our lifelong money behaviors and attitudes Why market crashes affect us differently at...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 1:00What are we fundamentally getting wrong all the time?
  2. 2:14Why do you say it's not a store of value?
  3. 3:31What do people get wrong about their relationship with money?
  4. 9:12It's almost on a denominator blindness basis, right?
  5. 11:51Do we get too caught up in what these externalities are because there's only so much we can do about them, both as just individuals and as investors?
  6. 14:57I mean, if you imagined a world where there was for some reason structurally zero inflation, but like in that world, would we then not worry about these things and we could say, no, no, no, just holding cash is great?
  7. 16:52Isn't this just sort of Keynesian, the Keynesian money illusion that we all think in terms of, you know, we all think in terms of nominal terms, not the real terms?
  8. 19:31I'm always saying that like the past is an illusion and the only thing we can do about the future is tell a story about it in the present, right?
  9. 20:11... AI and crypto, which add both opportunity and lots of variability into potential outcomes, what should we be ignoring about our ideas about money that may have been true in the past that are definitely not going to be true in the future?
  10. 26:19What are the mistakes we're all most likely making right now here at the end of February?
  11. 29:29Just to fine-tune that, they don't all have to be people you have on speed dial, right?
  12. 31:20And if you make fewer decisions and take fewer actions, you have fewer chances to screw it up. Is it that simple?
Barry Ritholtz 0:00 ↗
Let me just give you a few things that money is not. It's not a store of value, it is a medium of exchange, it is not the path to happiness. Someone once asked Munger, 'Hey, were you and Warren just smarter than everybody else?' He's like, 'No, we don't think we're smarter than everybody else, we're just less stupid.' We've had a century of people telling us how to invest, and let's be honest, most people are pretty crappy investors. Bitcoin isn't a new asset class, it's not a currency, think of it as a technology company somewhere between Google and Facebook. The market crashes, especially the bear markets that lasted a while, that shouldn't really have mattered to me very much, were the most terrifying. And the bear markets and the market crashes where I had the most at risk, where I had something to lose, I was completely blasé about.
Dave Nadig 1:00 ↗
Welcome to Rabbit Hole. I'm Dave Nadig. I've got Barry Ritholtz with me. He's got a new book out, which we're not going to let him talk about till the very end. Barry, one of the themes of your book, 'How Not to Invest', is all the stuff that we get wrong. What do we get wrong about the idea of dollars, the dollars we earn, the dollars we save, the dollars we invest? What are we fundamentally getting wrong all the time?
Barry Ritholtz 1:21 ↗
Money is a tool, it's not a means to an end, it's not an end goal itself, it's not how we measure our success or failure. Let me just give you a few things that money is not. It's not a store of value, it is a medium of exchange, it is not the path to happiness. I know across my lifetime I went from broke to lower middle class to upper middle class to like, 'Oh, okay, now I have enough money to do most of this crap I want to,' and you change your perception along the way. What I've really learned, what money does do, is it frees you up. First, you don't have to do the things you don't want to, you don't want to waste time on things you're not interested in. Money allows you to focus your effort, your time, your energy on what you want, and that is its greatest value.
Dave Nadig 2:14 ↗
Let's dig a little bit deeper into that. You started out with money is not a store of value, yet we built an entire society trying to get people to save it, right? If it's not a store of value, if it's not a store of power, as I often think about it, right, having a million dollars in a bank account definitely lets you do stuff you can't do when that number is zero. Why do you say it's not a store of value?
Barry Ritholtz 2:37 ↗
So if you have a million dollars, you should not have a million dollars in your bank account. You should be investing that money, not necessarily in the stock market, but certainly you should invest that money. You can invest that money in real estate, in starting a business, in yourself. Everybody who went to college made a huge investment of time, effort, and money in themselves. But the point is you should never have a million dollars sitting around. Money does its best work when it's in motion, when it's operating on your behalf. Even something as silly as a bond portfolio, especially like Munger's today, you're getting the taxable equivalent, a million dollars throws off $35,000, $40,000 a year, so it has some value over and above inflation.
Dave Nadig 3:31 ↗
Okay, that's cash. See, to me, that's a problem with cash, which is different than talking about money, right? I wanted to dig into some of the sort of nittier-grittier stuff on this. So like Keynes talks about money being an illusion, Georg Simmel talks about it being sort of this absolute artificial thing that we chase. We've got, you know, Marx calls it what Marx called a fetish, like a sexual fetish, nearly, like people have weird emotional relationships with money. You're in the business of running a financial advisor firm, which is a lot about talking to people about money. What do people get wrong about their relationship with money?
Barry Ritholtz 4:09 ↗
So there's really no one correct answer because everybody has a very different relationship with money. It depends on your specific history, how you grew up with it, what sort of traumas you have around money, whether you had too much money and have become complacent about it and don't recognize its value. It's really funny, my family of three kids, right? I'm the oldest, my sister's three years younger than me, my brother's almost nine years younger than her. So we grew up in the same household. I kind of grew up, you know, lower middle class, I went to a state school, paid for it myself, paid for grad school. My sister, three years behind me, kind of went through more of a middle class upbringing, and my brother, way behind her, you know, we were doing well then, Dad was making money, everything felt a lot looser. By then I'm, you know, out of college and thinking about grad school, and it's funny because we each have a very different attitude with money due to our upbringing.
I don't have the emotional bandwidth to balance a checkbook. I don't care, I have like a running total in my head, and I recall having a conversation when I was younger with, 'Hey, you can't go through life spitballing checkbooks,' and I kind of said, 'Well, I better make some money because I don't want to bother with this, I don't want to think about, you know, I still have checks left, I should be good.' My sister who grew up in like a slightly different class, I think she was solidly in that middle class, keep up with the Joneses sort of thing. And my brother, which is crazy because he grew up with the most amount of, like, the family was going on vacations and weren't driving old crap boxes, they were driving new cars, not wealthy but, you know, solidly upper middle class, he's the guy with a million dollars in the bank because he's freaked out. Because I think the transition from being broke to having money very much affected him. How you experienced it growing up, it really has a big impact on your relationship with it, and that is pure emotionality, it is pure just very, you know, primal level, you know, am I safe, do I have enough to eat, can I get new clothes, can I do what I want, that whole hierarchy of needs.
Dave Nadig 6:36 ↗
As you work your way up it, as you go from lower class, lower income to middle income to upper middle income, all those things change. Do human beings, particularly sort of Western American type human beings, have a very similar pathway as they go from younger to older, and what can we learn from that?
Barry Ritholtz 6:55 ↗
So the standard answer, which is technically correct but I don't know how useful it is, is we go through three phases: accumulation, maintenance, and distribution. That's the textbook answer. When you're young, you trade your time for money and experience. As you get a little older and have some expertise, you start making a little more money. Now you actually have cash at risk, you have a 401k, may have a mortgage, and then as you get older, you move from that maintenance era to the distribution era where you're drawing down money in retirement, philanthropy, wealth transfer, etc. That's technically accurate, but I came to realize that, and that was kind of a funny realization, and then it kind of dawned on me, you know, I started on a trading desk in the mid-90s, I had switched careers so I didn't have a 401k. By the time we rolled around to the dot-com implosion in 2000, maybe my wife's 403b was 10 grand. I don't think we had even bought our first house by then, and when that crash happened, it was, you know, it was kind of horrifying.
A decade later, coming out of the GFC, I had some 401k, her 403b was no longer tiny, but it still was like a very impactful thing. By the time a decade rolls around and we go to the COVID crash in Q1, I was fully invested, I had a funded 401k, not only that, but I'm the big owner in Ritholtz Wealth Management, and you're a couple of billion dollars in assets, that's a real asset tied directly to the market. And the funny realization was, you know, as you grow and mature and go through life experiences, hopefully you pick a few things up along the way, and one of those things is everything is a cycle. You've seen this movie before, you know how it ends. The Solomonic phrase, 'This too shall pass,' is very much in your head. And so the shock was the crash where I had the most at risk mattered. It was just like, yeah, this is what happens. Oh, is this a surprise? You know, markets go up and down, it's not just one way.
Dave Nadig 9:12 ↗
Is some of that just endowment effect, that, you know, when you're younger and you've got $10,000 in the market, $10,000 matters a lot more? It's almost on a denominator blindness basis, right? It's like it actually matters more when you got nothing. If you've already got a million portfolio, losing $500,000 may seem like an awful thing, but you still have $5 million, you know.
Barry Ritholtz 9:37 ↗
It sounds like it's rational. I think when, especially when you're younger, you're probably more at risk for your income and your career than what's actually happening in the market. And when you're older, yeah, you understand the cycle a little bit, the cycle and how temporary these things tend to be, but you also become a little more self-confident in your own skills to navigate this and more secure in where you are professionally. So I think that is a big part of it. My wife and I were joking about how broke we were when we were first married. She's like, 'I thought I was marrying a lawyer, you declared you were going to switch careers a few years later.' All right, it all worked out, it's all fine. But when you're in your 20s and 30s and you have no idea if your career will work out and how it'll work out, the stress of not knowing is really substantial. And the best part about launching our own firm and having a sense of agency and control is that you're no longer subject to the whims of third parties. It's more than just freedom, money buys freedom, hopefully it buys a degree of agency.
Where I just told a story the other day about when I was an attorney, I got assigned something on a Friday afternoon, 'I have to have this Monday morning at 8:00 a.m.' Kills my weekend, I bust my ass. Turns out that having really good research skills is not an asset in a law firm. Someone hunted me down and like, 'Ritholtz can find that crap,' and so I handed the assignment in on a Monday morning and then don't see that lawyer for like two weeks. And when I finally bump into her again, 'Hey, I didn't get any feedback on the piece, how did it go?' 'Oh, I haven't read it yet.' And that's just a debilitating sensation of, oh, I'm her... I didn't realize that I am just a grunt worker, I'm the lowest rung of the totem pole, and I have to rethink my career because I can't do this crap. But that kind of lack of agency is how I think a lot of people feel.
Dave Nadig 11:51 ↗
Not so much money, but the dollar, like specifically as an American investing in American dollars and American markets, getting paid in American dollars. I think a lot of folks, a lot of investors feel like a lot of this is out of their control because they read all the headlines about what the Fed is doing and we're printing too much money and now we're going to stop all this money. Do we get too caught up in what these externalities are because there's only so much we can do about them, both as just individuals and as investors?
Barry Ritholtz 12:21 ↗
So I have three answers to this: a glib one, a snarky one, and a thoughtful one. Okay, the one which I used to do when I was giving presentations, where someone always say, 'But isn't the fiat dollar collapsing? Isn't it going to be worthless?' And the answer is always, 'Send me all of your worthless dollars for proper disposal. I will take care of making sure they are disposed correctly.' So that's the glib answer. The snarky answer is, what are your other options? You're going to go to the euro? Hey, go buy some Chinese yuan. And if that's too risky for you, perhaps the Russian ruble is where you want to get paid in that. If you want to say it's the cleanest shirt in the hamper, I think that's wrong. The United States has a number of economic advantages over the rest of the world, and there's a reason why we enjoy this exorbitant privilege.
Hey, you know, it's not that a recession is imminent, but I had written a piece a week before saying just tune out all this noise, this is all garbage, and I woke up on Sunday morning thinking I don't want anyone thinking I'm too blasé. So here are areas where risks are rising, and one of the areas was the collapse of the dollar is still at this moment highly unlikely, but the probabilities of that happening have ticked up a little bit, and you should be aware of it. The last answer to the question is what is a dollar's purpose? As a medium of exchange, you trade your hours and experience for money. When you're young, you're trading your time and your effort, when you're older, you're trading your hours and your expertise, and you get an exchange. Cash, it's a medium of exchange, and it needs to be a store of value for the very short time between when I get paid and when I pay my mortgage or rent, if you're a renter, buy food, enjoy travel and entertainment, invest in my business, invest in the market, and it does that splendidly and normally.
You know, just a perfect example, we've been shopping for a vacation property for a couple of years, and I've been putting money in a money market fund because all I wanted to do was have liquid cash that wasn't falling behind inflation. And for most of the past five years, it did that. Even with this inflation spike, I'm still effectively ahead of where I would have been had I just left that sitting around in dollar bills.
Dave Nadig 14:57 ↗
So inflation is really the major reason why it's not a store of value then? I mean, if you imagined a world where there was for some reason structurally zero inflation, but like in that world, would we then not worry about these things and we could say, no, no, no, just holding cash is great?
Barry Ritholtz 15:11 ↗
Well, here's where the psychology is so fascinating. When you have a zero inflation world or worse, a deflationary world, it's not everything is flat zero, some of the stuff is going up, some stuff is going down. What tends to happen are the things where there are economies of scale, the prices fall, and in a zero inflation world, they tend to fall faster than other prices rise. And so you run into the risk that the consumer is going to say, 'Why do I want to buy this today if it's going to be cheaper tomorrow?' And so suddenly you're in this negative economic spiral.
Dave Nadig 15:47 ↗
Yeah, so there should be some modest amount of inflation, seems to be reasonably healthy. When we're talking about inflation, what we're really talking about is the loss of purchasing power, right? That's really how the consumer interacts with that. But when you go out and buy something today, you're not spending $1 of 1925, you're spending $20 of 2025.
Barry Ritholtz 16:11 ↗
And this is a variation of denominator blindness where you're just looking at half the equation. Really, this is more of a framing issue. Hey, if the dollar has fallen that much, how much have wages increased over the same period? It's double-entry bookkeeping. If you're concerned about purchasing power, what happened with your earning power? And once you look at it that way, you're better off today. You can purchase more goods, more services beyond mere survival today with a median income than you could have done a century ago, to say nothing of the quality of life and the health advantages today versus a century ago.
Dave Nadig 16:52 ↗
Isn't this just sort of Keynesian, the Keynesian money illusion that we all think in terms of, you know, we all think in terms of nominal terms, not the real terms? I mean, that's basically saying the same thing.
Barry Ritholtz 17:02 ↗
So I have a... I'll start with an anecdote and then I'll explain it. I have a very vivid recollection of the 2000s leading into the financial crisis, housing peak in '05 in volume and '06 in price, unless I have that backwards. And I have a vivid recollection of speaking to people in '08, '09, 2010, 'Hey, Bob down the street has the same model house as me and he got $700,000, why can't I get $700,000?' My answer was always, 'You can get a time machine and go back to '04, you get $700,000, but now following what happened, your house is $450.' There was an excess of credit available. The underlying basic philosophy of credit used to be the borrower's ability to service that debt, and it very briefly, for less than five or six years, became the lender's ability to sell it to a securitizer. So who cares if they can pay the debt? And that obviously didn't work out so well. But it just goes to show you the psychology behind how people are stuck in the past. Always, consumers, buyers, sellers are always stuck in the past mentally, we're always a little behind the curve.
There's a great Paul Graham quote: 'When experts are wrong, it's because they're experts on an earlier version of the world.' And that's really a brilliant insight. But let's extrapolate that bigger. All of us have a view of the world, whether we're an expert or not, and that view was foundationally formed in the past. And so what Keynes called the money illusion is to me really just the fact that we are traversing through time, and the gray matter between our ears is filled with experiences that by definition are old. In fact, you and I had a conversation a couple of years ago where what you're seeing right now, because of the 200 milliseconds it takes to get passed back to your brain and then the whole processing, you're looking at immediate history, you're not seeing the world. And that's just like a small example. We created our very cognitively expensive models of the world in our past because we are not time travelers.
Dave Nadig 19:31 ↗
So what does that tell us about the future then? Because I first of all, I completely agree with you. I'm always saying that like the past is an illusion and the only thing we can do about the future is tell a story about it in the present, right?

20 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Ritholtz, B. (2025, March 7). Why Money Isn't What You Think: Barry Ritholtz on the Meaning of Money and How NOT to Invest It [Interview transcript]. Excess Returns. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3172506/

MLA

Barry Ritholtz. "Why Money Isn't What You Think: Barry Ritholtz on the Meaning of Money and How NOT to Invest It." Excess Returns, 7 Mar. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3172506/.

BibTeX
@misc{ritholtz2025_3172506,
  author       = {Barry Ritholtz},
  title        = {Why Money Isn't What You Think: Barry Ritholtz on the Meaning of Money and How NOT to Invest It},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Excess Returns. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {mar},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3172506/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}