We just find ourselves in a little bit of a moment where, you know, the suits are overwhelming the cypherpunks, but I don't think that will last forever.
>> Welcome to Galaxy Brains. >> An infinite amount of cash. >> I'm your host, Alex Thorn. >> The US banking system is sound and resilient. >> Bitcoin made a new all-time high. >> If you're not long, you're short. >> Satoshi's going to come on there, laugh hysterically, go quiet, and all Bitcoin's going to be erased. >> Bitcoin's the best crypto asset. >> Bitcoin is going to be zero.
Welcome back to Galaxy Brains. As always, I'm your host, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. Bitcoin not zero. We have a great episode for you this week. It's me. You're getting me this week, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. I've got a little bit of a rant. I'm going to go through some Bitcoin data, and I'm going to talk about the ongoing pendulum swing, the tension between the suits and the cypherpunks in Bitcoin and crypto. It's quite an interesting time. It's sort of like everything that is old is new again. And where are we in that current pendulum swing between the forces of decentralization and centralization?
Bim and Bibi are off this week, and so before I get to that, let me remind you to please refer to the link to the disclaimer in the show notes. And note that none of the information in this show constitutes investment advice or an offer, recommendation, or solicitation by Galaxy or any of its affiliates to buy or sell any securities. All right, let's hop right into it.
All right, this week I want to give a little bit of an update on how I'm looking at Bitcoin at the moment. I'm going to show some data. Then we'll go into some news stories in the crypto world that I think are interesting, offer my take on those, and then I'm going to talk a little bit about the ongoing tension between the suits and the cypherpunks in the Bitcoin, crypto, and blockchain space. Let's start though with Bitcoin here, and I'm sharing some data. This is the drawdown from all-time high for each of the prior Bitcoin cycles, and you can see our current cycle is the orange line. Now, we bottomed sort of around here in June. Sorry, right about here at minus 53% from prior all-time high. It was the shallowest bottom drawdown in a bear market cycle in Bitcoin's history. And as you can see, we're now pretty far to the end of this chart. And this is the all-time high plus 400 days, which has typically been the time it takes to start sort of a bullish uptrend following a bear market drawdown. And you can see we are at substantially higher than this same amount of days out from all-time high in the prior cycles. So, you know, I've written about this, but that if the bull market peak was suppressed, the bear market drawdown appears to also have been suppressed. Maybe the cycles are compressing. And if you've looked at the log price of Bitcoin, you can see that the price appreciation has been leveling out. Now, some people think that leveling out will then go up again, sort of like an S curve. And obviously only history can tell us the answer to that. But here's the state of where we are, right?
Now, if we look based on halvings, right? So, this chart shows an indexed price, so we make every Bitcoin price over the years normalized. And you can see, I mean, this is sort of another view of what I was talking about about the flattening of the growth of Bitcoin over the years, you know, on log Y axis scale. It almost looks like we barely moved at all in this cycle. Of course, we are up from the halving, right? The halving was April 2024. We're about in the 50s, around that. And of course, we went through a lot of chop consolidation in 2024, something like 237 days between post-ETF all-time high and President Trump's election new all-time high. But here we are sort of right in the middle here. And you can also, I don't know if you can tell, both of the prior cycles there, the green and the magenta, they were bottoming around here, right? Or just before here. And whereas we bottomed probably a couple months ago. You know, we can't know for certain, but it's looking pretty certain that that 58K range last touched in June was the bottom. But just some, you know, historical empirical reference for you here. And by the way, if you're listening on audio, then I apologize. This week's episode is going to have a lot of charts shown on the screen. So I recommend watching us on YouTube.
Another version of the same cycle price index chart. This one though measures from the prior cycle low. And so the 2022 low, which was post-FTX and was down at 15,460. You can see actually we will have performed this number of days out better than the 2018 cycle. We didn't get as high as 2017 did at our peak in the 2022 to 2026 cycle. But, you know, performing pretty well I think from cycle low. It's one of my favorite things to look at is the annual low price of Bitcoin rather than, you know, all the volatility. That annual low has been basically a steady march upwards. And to me, that's the growing and expanding base of long-term Bitcoin believers.
All right. So, 2026. This is annual performance by year, every year. And we're towards the bottom. I mean, I think right now, you know, on a yearly basis, we're down about 12 or 15%. So, in the middle to the bottom of annual performance.
This is the seasonality chart. I think everyone knows this chart. So, on the left, the rows on the left are years from 2011 to going up to present, 2026. 2011 sort of the first full year where we had a price for Bitcoin. And then the columns are months. And you can see obviously we're in October. October, historically, the best-performing month for Bitcoin. April also quite a good one. And July. We haven't had back-to-back red Octobers since 2011 and 2012. Now, we're right about almost even in October of this year. Obviously, it's not complete. We've got 10 more days of October as I record this on October 21st, and we're down 0.8%. This has typically been a positive month. So, you know, time to go here, but something worth considering.
So, this is interesting. This is an all-time chart. So, this is the trading session performance chart. So, we break the price action up into thirds. So, Asia hours, Europe hours, North American hours. And Asia here is in the kind of ugly brownish color. Apologies for that. Asia has been the worst-performing time of day for Bitcoin price historically. That probably makes a lot of sense over the years because a lot of Bitcoin miners in Asia, and Bitcoin miners historically are net sellers, right? But if we zoom in a little bit, this is just month-to-date October 2026. The story is different, right? Asian hours have seen the more bullish price action. European hours, particularly since the middle of the month, European hours have been a drag on Bitcoin. Whereas North American hours, US hours have been mostly flat, a little bit down in the middle of the month, but now sort of recovering. But look at Asia driving the gains in October.
Here's another chart that people like to look at, the so-called Coinbase premium. Now a lot of that, typically what companies and analysts are doing is they're comparing the BTC USD price on Coinbase to the BTC USDT price on Binance. You know, there's a lot of noise in there because a lot of that is just the minor fluctuations in the USD to USDT exchange rate. We've normalized that, removed the USDT USD exchange rate from here. And so these are very tiny premiums and discounts, as you can see. We're talking about, you know, the biggest drawdown on this chart of the year is, you know, maybe around minus 0.03% discount on Coinbase versus Binance. But you can see that there's some help here, right? Like the premia on Coinbase tends to correspond to, you know, price increases in the overall market price of Bitcoin. And for sort of the last month, we've been mostly in a Coinbase discount. The suggestion being that, you know, people are selling more on Coinbase than they're buying in the broader market, at least versus Binance. Which kind of goes with a little bit of that Asia bullishness, you know, if I go back, the Asia bullishness versus the, you know, US flat and Europe weakness.
All right, another good view of where we are in this market is the percent of the supply that's in profit versus loss. Now, that looks at the unspent Bitcoin supply and the price at which it last moved on chain and whether the current price is higher or lower in aggregate across the whole supply. This is looking okay here, right? I mean, there have been times where, you know, if you look at '23, where about this amount, you know, we have right now 69.4% in profit, 30.6% in loss. You can see a little stutter step here in '23 where we got up almost to 80% in profit and then went back below 60. So, it wasn't at these levels necessarily indicative that a bull market was upon us, but you can see in general the sort of correlation between these metrics. Now, it's not like predictive, right? Because obviously when Bitcoin runs really high, the price, more of the supply is in profit, but I think a good marker of where the aggregate network holders are in their profit and loss journey.
Another way of looking at Bitcoin supply is the UTXO realized price distribution, URPD. And that is a view of the current supply as of today and the price at which that supply last moved on chain. And so, gives you sort of an idea of where people's cost basis is. I will say I haven't removed centralized exchanges or custodian moves from this chart. I have removed the very first bucket where if I had included it, which includes like coins in the Satoshi pattern that are thought to have been mined by Satoshi. If I included that, then the chart would become much less legible because it's such a big bar down here in the first chart. Another thing, by not removing centralized exchanges and custodians, we know that in the 84K range last year there was a bunch of custody rotation by Coinbase and others. So, we've got to take this giant bar here a little bit of a grain of salt. But, you can see it's quite interesting, right? You know, a lot of the network basis, especially if we exclude the first bucket, bought coins in these areas and above the 60K range, right? Below, you can see why there was a lot of support down here sub-60 because a lot of the owners of Bitcoin had bought above it, meaning that they are comfortable buying and owning Bitcoin above a 60K range. This one might be a little hard to see on the video. I'm making it a little bit bigger.
Okay, this is the risk-adjusted returns year-to-date of the sort of Sharpe of major macro assets. So, indices, commodities, individual equities, and major cryptos. You can see obviously because Bitcoin's down on the year it's got a negative Sharpe. MSTR, gold down on the year, Solana, ether down on the year, XRP down on the year included here. The best performing asset we track on this chart, it's heating oil. We know that oil and gas products, the next best is gasoline. And then I would say notably the best performing on a risk-adjusted basis crypto this year is Hyperliquid. People following that one. No, I don't have Zcash in this, but it's very telling that you've got heating oil, gasoline, zinc, Brent crude, and WTI crude all in the top seven. And then you've got SPX and SPY, both the index and the ETF that tracks it, also up there. So, we rerun, I can rerun this chart any timeframe any day.
We know that this year hasn't been Bitcoin's year. But, you know, we're in the 80s. We're well above the 50-week moving average at this point or decently above it. The bottom of what we think was the bottom in the 58K range looks like it might be in the rearview mirror. So, potentially positive things coming up. And one thing that has been pressured in Bitcoin, I think people know, is the awakening of old coins. Now, I know people criticize me sometimes for looking at coin dormancy and sort of implying that the heuristic is that when old coins move on chain, it suggests that they're being sold. I still believe that in aggregate that's a pretty good heuristic to rely on. People that have coins in cold storage typically don't move them unless they intend to do some kind of transaction with them. And you can see just enormous awakenings, you know, '24 to present. Lots of older coins, so the redder the red right here was in July 2025. That was Galaxy facilitating the sale of 80,000 Bitcoin for that anonymous whale. I think and others. Not us, others necessarily, but I mean other 10-plus-year-old coins moving on chain. But look at this. I mean, look at this dormancy here. Now, obviously this chart shows one and two year all the way up to 10-plus year. Right? So, it's not just very old coins. But again, one thing to look at is the consistently larger candles '24 to '26. But then I would say also the consistently smaller candles, '26 in '26. These are monthly candles. So, and particularly if you leave out the blues, just look at the purples, the browns, the reds, those are down a lot in '26. So, it does feel like what my guest last week, Jordy Visser, called Bitcoin's IPO moment, that was the distribution of early investors to newer investors has abated. Here it is by year. And you can see the slashed columns on the far right here. That's this year, right? Not yet done. Again, even forget about the one and two-year and two and three-year, look how much smaller the purple and below will be than the prior two years. I mean, we're looking at possibly less than half the on-chain distribution of three-plus-year-old coins in '26 than we saw in both '24 and '25. So, some of that headwind, if you agree with me that the heuristic of dormant coins moving on-chain may mean sell pressure, looks like we're facing a lot less this year than the last two years.
And this is another way of looking at it. This is just this year. What I do in this chart, we call institutional absorption versus OG distribution. We're effectively taking the aggregate Bitcoin treasury company purchases plus the ETF net flows, and then we're subtracting five-plus-year dormant on-chain Bitcoin movement from it. And so, the idea is that the net is treasury company and ETF purchases, and when they outweigh the on-chain dormant coin movement, that can lead to, you know, better tailwinds and fewer headwinds. And you can see that pretty well here, right? You can see the price action from March until May going up, and then similarly the monthly net absorption being higher. And then similarly as we draw down into June, you see substantial net decline or net distribution versus absorption. That's that green line on the chart. And again, here, you know, again, we have a nice rise in August. And, you know, chop but positive in September. And we have for the first two months since April, we had net absorption versus net distribution in August and September. Now, the ETF acquisition has been okay in October. But the treasury companies and ETFs combined have not outpaced that dormancy, and we've seen a bit of weakness in October. Again, this is just data. I'm not saying that's the reason.
This is the same chart, 2020 to present, by quarter, and so you can see obviously the rise of the treasury companies. You can see the first of these salmon treasury company candles back starting in mid-2020. Obviously, this is MSTR, and when Michael Saylor first bought, I think summer 2020. He didn't buy a lot from literally '21 until, you know, late '23. Obviously, started buying at scale in '24, '25, and then you see the ETFs launch, the purple candles, in '24. That is the last of the Bitcoin data that I'm going to show.
And instead now, I'd like to talk a little bit about some news, and I'll stick with Bitcoin market news for the moment here. So, JPMorgan Asset Management Research put out some research, their annual report on asset classes. I guess the 31st consecutive edition of this. And for the first time, they rated Bitcoin, and they rated it first. They said they expect 10% annual appreciation over the coming years, beating stocks and other asset classes. But they did warn that that comes with higher volatility. So, it's not a risk-adjusted measure they're giving, right? They're saying it could appreciate more, but it will also be more volatile than others, which a lot of people have been talking about the story. I think it is positive. One, that they're writing about it and yes, writing about it positively, but I think, you know, it's really part of the story that I want to talk about sort of a lot of the rest of the show, which is the thing I like about the JPM research is the, you know, adoption by institutions and them covering it. You know, when I was in Korea for Korea Blockchain Week at the end of September, I spoke on a panel about markets and about Bitcoin. Almost every other panel at that conference was about tokenization. Maybe hundreds of panels about tokenization. And this is sort of part of the tension that we're seeing rear its head again, which is the tension between the suits and the cypherpunks.
Before I get more deeply into that, this is some data that we compiled at Galaxy Research. These are initiative announcements by quarter and stage by the largest banks and brokerages. So, initiatives and announcements about their adoption of blockchains and crypto assets. And obviously, you can see this trend, right? From 2021 to present, it's basically up into the right. That's a good thing. In my view, that's what winning looks like, but it also, you know, when I was at Korea Blockchain Week and I wasn't at Token2049 in Singapore this year, but my team at Galaxy reported to me that it was very similar. Maybe hundreds of panels on tokenization, real-world assets, TradFi. You know, suits galore. And that's what it looked like in Korea. That's also what it looked like in 2016 and 2018 and '19. Right? This is why I said in the opener that sort of everything old is new again. I recall that in 2015 and '16, sort of following the Silk Road, there was this mantra in the banks and brokerages. Of course, at the time I was at Fidelity Investments and the mantra was blockchain, not Bitcoin. It was sort of like, well, yeah, we think blockchains are really cool, all right? But Bitcoin, no, no, no. That's for criminals. And I don't think people are, it's not the criminal question that people are raising today with crypto.
But we are sort of swinging back and sort of as a reaction in 2016 to that mindset, you saw the rise of what I called then enterprise blockchains. R3's Corda, Hyperledger from IBM, and others. And ultimately none of those really worked and meanwhile, of course, Ethereum launched. Bitcoin rose again. You have the ICO and Web3 and NFTs and blockchain gaming and meme coins and DeFi and all of these things that flourished in the crypto world while, you know, traditional adoption of permissioned blockchains never really happened. Now, here we are in 2026 and you genuinely have a giant amount of blockchain and crypto adoption inside the banks and brokerages. Some of these are permissioned blockchains, but many of them are offering Bitcoin exposure to their clients through ETFs, prime desks onboarding, you know, offering leverage on Bitcoin ETFs or options, trading on ETFs. It's custody at banks like Bank of New York Mellon, the first bank in the United States founded by Alexander Hamilton himself, one of the most advanced banks on digital assets. Not just maybe on tokenization or RWA, but they custody Bitcoin, right? And they are a Bitcoin and crypto custodian, and they're doing other stuff in that space, too. So, you got this massive adoption now happening in TradFi, but a lot of it is blockchains, not Bitcoin.
And, you know, one of our teammates in Galaxy Research, Will Owens, a great researcher, he tells us, he's a young guy and he tells us that, you know, currently it's a negative aura to tell people you work in crypto. And I can understand why. I've lived through this cycle many times at this point in my professional life, not just since I've been interested in Bitcoin. You know, a combination of the failures of the, you know, if we go back, right? All of these great ideas in crypto, many of them haven't worked out, right? It's not just that the ICO didn't displace venture capital, it also destroyed a lot of capital, that era in 2017 and '18. NFTs, I personally think are still pretty cool. You know, things like Art Blocks and unique generative art, digital art that's unique and created by artists and digital collectibles, I think will have a big part in our world. The 10,000 PFP NFT collections, well, you know, empirically, those didn't really work out, the vast majority of them. And there was just enormous, you know, bloat in supply of them. I mean, how many monkey JPEGs can one market withstand, right? Same thing, read, write, own, the thesis from Chris Dixon and the broader concept of Web3. I know we just saw the network state by Farcaster, which is Ethereum-based social network. But broadly, right, FriendTech, Farcaster, and some of the others, they haven't taken off and yet X, Threads, Blue Sky, Facebook, Instagram continue to thrive, right? The idea that you would own your followers, your social footprint, and be able to move it interchangeably or otherwise own the IP of it or somehow own the data behind it, it hasn't worked out, right? Meme coins, a lot of people are critical of the speculation that meme coins and prediction markets have driven and, you know, is there real value there? You know, big questions about that. So, I understand why people are jaded about crypto but excited about blockchain as we look at this chart.
Now, I'm also excited about upgrading our capital markets with the most transparent ledgers in human history, ones that bring substantial efficiency and cost savings both to the banks and brokerages and to their clients and depositors. I'm very excited about that. I think people know that I worked very hard to tokenize Galaxy stock and we're still working now to make use of the SEC's innovation exemption to enhance the features available to our on-chain shareholders. I'm very excited about the innovations in capital markets. And I think in many cases more than most, my excitement. But I don't want to lose sight of the power of decentralization. I think right now it's almost contrarian to remind people that blockchains and decentralized blockchains like Bitcoin provide substantial individual liberty and self-sovereignty. And the characteristics of the world that Satoshi launched Bitcoin in, I would argue that that made the case for self-sovereign money, censorship resistance, permissionless finance. The features in the world where Satoshi launched that, I think, are only bigger today and likely to get bigger, particularly in the age of AI. It's not just surveillance. Something like AI, both the businesses, you know, the companies that develop the frontier models, but also the power that it can give to power, make a strong case, I think, for self-sovereign money, stronger, perhaps, than ever before. It's not just privacy, it's also debasement. You know, the US and indeed all nations, really, are facing a substantial fiscal deficit, pressure on their finances and their debt. And I think, you know, the case for a hard money, at least as a store of value, will only get stronger.
I think people would be wise not to discount, even though the pendulum has swung so firmly into the blockchain world, do not discount the empirical truth that it has historically swung back towards the Bitcoin and crypto decentralized route. I've seen it happen, you know, four or five times now, this pendulum swing. And I'm very confident it will happen again. So, look, if you're deep in Bitcoin and crypto and looking at this market and adoption metrics like I just showed you at the banks and brokerages, do not despair, okay? Bitcoin is here to stay. We're doing quite well, a 58K bottom in this cycle following a 15.5 bottom. That looks like substantial growth in ownership to me. And I will say also DeFi. I think DeFi has a lot of promise. I think the concept of peer-to-peer transactions and finance have empirically shown to be very valuable. I said, you know, on this show after 2025's inauguration early in 2025 that it was crypto's time to put up or shut up. That there were three very clear product market fits in crypto. There was Bitcoin, which empirically speaking millions of people around the world love to own and I won't, you know, go into a diatribe about why that might be. I think our audience will know what my arguments for that are. Stablecoins, number two, empirically and very verifiably useful. Faster than wires, more transparent than wires, more collateralized than bank deposits. In fact, collateralized by law under the Genius Act. And then DeFi, right? Particularly lending and swaps, permissionless lending and trading. Very, very useful and proven its resilience, the best of the DeFi world across multiple market cycles now.
And I think the problem with DeFi for broader adoption has been that the assets that you can use in DeFi aren't as good as they could be, right? So, you can wrap Bitcoin and put it in DeFi, you've got native tokens like Ether and Solana that you can use, stablecoins, you've got maybe other app tokens, but you don't have, broadly speaking, equities, fixed income securities, right? Foreign exchange, right? Things that are massive markets and that the broader world might benefit from the more transparent credit risk and faster settlement of DeFi. Now, that's what a lot of people are working on and I'd like to see that happen, but I don't want to lose sight of the value of truly permissionless finance that decentralized blockchains bring. And I want you to know that we are still all in. We're all in on both. I mean, we want to upgrade the traditional capital markets system, but we also believe in the long-term value and importance of decentralized money, decentralized finance. And so, we'll continue to work on that.
All right, let's talk about a couple interesting stories that have been happening here. I'm going to start with a big story of the day on Wednesday, October 21st as we record this. Major vulnerability found in PHP code that an enormous amount of the internet relies on, WordPress, which by some reports 40-plus percent of all websites on Earth use. Major vulnerability disclosed this morning, October 21st. So, the internet is upgrading here. Was it found by AI? Who knows? I don't know. Another big vulnerability found. This one doesn't even seem AI-related. Turns out they just did a really, really bad job. So, a certificate authority based in India called eMudhra. These are intermediate certificates that are widely used and trusted by browsers, operating systems, even Cloudflare. When you go to a domain, you see the certificate, your browser knows, 'Okay, this is the domain it says it is.' Well, it turns out that the private keys used by this company to create these certificates were, well, they had really low entropy. It's actually like Coldcard. And they've been compromised. And so, all over the internet, browsers, servers are going to have to reject these certificates and find new ones. So, these two vulnerabilities together, the eMudhra certificate key exposure, but it looks like the keys were really, really low entropy, and the PHP, big, big stories in cyber this week, and one of the reasons I mentioned them is because it's not just crypto and Bitcoin hardware wallets that are being breached in this new cyber era. Really, it's everything. And I'm sure there are a lot of other vulnerabilities that big companies that we all know and use that we may not have heard of that are being feverishly patched. Sort of yet another skirmish in the latest salvo of the clanker-enabled cyber wars. We need to get high-quality models in the hands of defenders so they can patch and stay ahead of the attackers. It's one of these long-standing stories where in warfare, the attackers tend to have better capabilities than the defenders. If you think about, you know, the Mongols conquered so much of the Asian continent and Europe even, with a major innovation, right? Effectively attacking from horseback, shooting arrows off horseback. There was no defense for that. Many such examples, right? Once you get attacked, then you can patch and see what the attack is if you are a defender. So, you know, same thing, take the American Revolution. You know, one of the ways that America, revolutionary America defeated the British was with a technological innovation, which was hiding behind trees. Guerrilla warfare. You know, at least partially certainly utilized, but maybe even invented by revolutionary America. It absolutely decimated the British lines, and there's many such examples of this, but similarly, we keep finding that the malicious attackers have a little bit of a step up against the defenders now that AI is enabling certain things. So, I'm for access to frontier cyber models for defenders, you know, trusted defenders. We don't want to give it to people that might use it to attack, but this is just an ongoing story, so be wary where you put your information. You know, I haven't talked, I don't think, about the Ledger hardware wallet vulnerability on this show yet, but be wary of that. If you're buying a hardware wallet, buy directly from the manufacturer, even if they list a trusted reseller. We've seen that still those can be compromised. Buy from the manufacturer, take care of your privacy, try not to give your email and other personal information to every single website on the internet, all right? And feel free. This is what I do. I don't always start a fight. You know, you go and buy something in a store and they say, 'Oh, can we have your phone number?' You can say no. I do. I say no. They say, 'Oh.' Or they say, 'Do you have a phone number?' And I'll say, 'No.' 'Oh, you don't have a phone number?' 'No, I have one, but I prefer not to have my data mined every time I buy something.' And it's not a matter of being rude. One, they're probably reselling your information, but two, third trusted third parties are security holes. That's what Nick Szabo wrote, and the reality is, you know, does every website you go to on the internet really need to possess a copy of your information? I think not, and that's a big security surface vulnerability surface.
All right, a couple other stories here. This is the JPM one I had meant to bring up before. Specifically what they said, they project a whopping 10% annual growth for Bitcoin over 10 to 15 years. Followed by REITs, real estate investment trusts, small cap stocks, and US large caps, gold at 5.5%. So, they put Bitcoin as the number one asset. It's the first time it's ever appeared in this report at all, which I think is that maturity story.
Let's talk about something else, tokenized stocks. People know that I'm interested in this topic. Obviously, I worked hard to tokenize Galaxy stock. We were the first ever Nasdaq-listed firm for its stock to be tokenized on a permissionless blockchain. And we're still working, as I mentioned before, to bring additional utility and trading capabilities on chain to tokenize GLXY utilizing things like the SEC's innovation exemption. The New York Stock Exchange and OKX, so ICE, the owner of NYSE, and OKX, a partner, to launch a tokenized securities venue at TSB, in the parlance of the SEC's innovation exemption. One of the interesting disputes or debates in the tokenized stock conversation in the United States has been whether to only allow issuers themselves to tokenize their stock like Galaxy did, an issuer-sponsored tokenized stock, or whether to also allow third parties to tokenize the securities issued by others. Now, in the innovation exemption, they did allow, of course, they allow issuer-sponsored tokenized securities in the innovation exemption, but they also allow for the third-party tokenization of securities. However, they do give the underlying issuers a notice period and the ability to opt out and prevent the third party from issuing a tokenized version of their stock. And indeed, OKX ICE, they're launching a tokenized securities venue. And indeed, now several big companies have notified OKX ICE that they intend to opt out, including major US large-cap equities like Microsoft and Alphabet, also Goldman Sachs, Qualcomm, Caterpillar, McDonald's, Western Digital, CoreWeave, and others. So, by my count it's about 10 to 15 today that are opting out. Decrypt here says 16 objecting issuers, UnitedHealth, Horizon, Rocket Lab, Broadcom. So, very interesting dispute here and there was an interesting debate between the CEO of GameStop and the CEO of Robinhood on Twitter, I guess at this point a month or two ago, about this same question. I don't know where this is going to land. I think we have to see whether a vibrant tokenized securities market can emerge from the SEC's innovation exemption onshore. If one doesn't, I can assure you the offshore issued ones like those from tZero and Ondo and Backpack and others, they are not going to slow down. So, there is an innovation question here. If we don't get a vibrant on-chain securities market in the US, there will probably be one offshore. How policymakers and market participants reckon with that will be a very interesting thing to watch.
This is big news. I haven't yet had a chance to read it, but the OCC did finalize, the OCC, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, which is the primary national bank regulator, has finalized its Genius Act rules. And I did see some commentary that these rules are favorable for issuers and stablecoin issuers. So, again, the Genius Act rulemaking implementation is ongoing and, you know, the Genius Act signed into law in July 2025, I believe in general the sort of key timeline for rulemaking to be proposed and I think maybe enacted is 18 months from then. So, you're looking at the end of this year and sort of the first half of next year, we should get some pretty firm rules on how stablecoin issuers, but also the venues that support the trading and conversion of them, like crypto exchanges, can interact with stablecoins. So, we are probably on the cusp now, getting close to the cusp of the beginning of a major adoption of stablecoins, not just in crypto, where they're already large, almost 200 billion in stablecoin issuance, but perhaps also in the traditional system. The days of sending a wire and waiting for it to land, paying $35 to send money, quote unquote, instantly, they may be coming to an end.
And that's it. That's it for these stories. I want to reiterate that I like the adoption of crypto assets and blockchains by our capital markets, but I also want to point out that Satoshi didn't write, 'The root problem with fiat currency is that it'd be really great if we could save a couple basis points and a few minutes on the settlement of stock trades.' All right? Satoshi wrote that the root problem with traditional currency is all the trust that's required to make it work. And the history of fiat currency is littered with breaches of that trust. So, let's not lose sight of the foundation of what a decentralized blockchain really offers, which is self-sovereignty, censorship resistance, permissionless, peer-to-peer transactions. I can assure you we haven't lost sight of it, nor have millions of other people out there. We just find ourselves in a little bit of a moment where, you know, the suits are overwhelming the cypherpunks. But I don't think that will last forever. Everyone stay safe out there. Have a great weekend, and I'll see you next week.