Welcome to Galaxy Brains. An infinite amount of cash. I'm your host, Alex Thorn. The US banking system is sound and resilient. Bitcoin made a new all-time high.
If you're not long, if you're not long, you're short.
Satoshi's going to come on there, laugh hysterically, go quiet. Oh, Bitcoin's going to be erased. Bitcoin is the best crypto out there.
Bitcoin is going to zero.
Welcome back to Galaxy Brains. As always, I'm your host, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. Bitcoin not zero. We have a great episode for you this week. Tyler Williams, former counselor to the Treasury Secretary for digital assets, former head of policy at Galaxy, our friend. He is back to talk to us about the election results, the midterms.
I'm going to say historic Democratic sweep. That's what Polymarket was pricing. And honestly, it was even more — the magnitude was even higher than expected. If anything, the polls were wrong to the downside. Tyler is going to talk to us about what we think that means in Congress for digital asset policy, for AI policy, if anything, and how things are going to be different. I will say Tyler was very optimistic about this. He said, 'Look, everything is different, but everything's also going to be fine.' So, we'll talk to Tyler about what we can expect from this new Congress when they take office in January. BIMNet is off this week, and so before we get to Tyler, I've got to remind you to please refer to the link to the disclaimer in the show notes. And note that none of the information in this show constitutes investment advice or an offer, recommendation, or solicitation by Galaxy or any of its affiliates to buy or sell any securities. Let's hop right into it with Tyler Williams.
Let's go now to our guest, Tyler Williams, former senior counselor to the Treasury Secretary for Digital Assets, lawyer and friend. Tyler, welcome back to Galaxy Brains.
Thanks for having me, Alex. Always good to be with you. So, it's here. It's Wednesday morning. We're in New Orleans for Galaxy's Gravity Conference. And last night was the midterms.
And dare I say, it was a bigger blue wave than expected. Actually, the polls were wrong to the downside. Republicans look like they've lost what, net seven seats in the Senate or something.
So, we're going to have a Democratic House and a Democratic Senate with the Republican president. I don't know. What's your first reaction on maybe just the wave itself, but we're going to talk a lot about what it means for crypto, financial services, AI?
Yeah, I wouldn't say I'm an electioneering expert. I spent most of my time, as you know, on policy issues and sort of trying to find bipartisan solutions in those policy issues. So I would say, you know, I would break it into two different sleeves of matters: like what Congress is going to focus on and how Congress is going to react in this midterm shift, and then how does that new governing legislative body, how do they function on a go-forward basis with divided government, because you still have President Trump in office while they're in the majority, right? And then I would say the second sleeve of issues to talk about is what happens from a regulatory perspective. And I think both are different and interesting for the digital asset policy efforts in Washington, and for different reasons, and we should unpack all.
So everything is different.
Everything is different. So —
But also fine. But also fine.
It's going to be fine. Okay. So, one of the clear things that has come to my mind with like what might happen here is that you have Sherrod Brown back in the Senate.
You're on the Congress button.
I'm on the Congress. Let's talk about Congress. We'll talk about the agencies after. You've got Sherrod Brown, crypto antagonist, who had been knocked out by Bernie Moreno in 2024, who has now won re-election. Was that like JD Vance's special seat? Like what did you get to run, or was that Bernie Moreno? Was that —
Yeah, JD Vance, when he became the vice president, his seat went to Jon Husted in a runoff race, and then that was up for — he was on a two-year basis.
Yes.
So it's JD Vance's seat that — so anyway, Sherrod is back.
He was an antagonist to crypto at the end of his prior time in the Senate, and was Senate Banking Chair. Now, I don't know what the Dems in the Senate are going to do with their caucus, but most likely Elizabeth Warren will be chair of Senate Banking, or Sherrod. They might honor his tenure and give it to Sherrod, but either way, we're going to have a hostile Senate Banking Committee to crypto. Are we going to get hearings?
Well, that's your opinion that we're going to have a hostile environment.
You think it's an unlikely opinion?
No, I think it has to be moderated in some capacity because the timing of coming back into office in 2027 from the previous point in time, where 2022, 2023 — that is, it's just things have changed, and we have a stablecoin bill that is enacted. Those markets are continuing to evolve and change, and the law, the GENIUS Act, will become effective in January of 2027. And so you have a different governing environment. You have real businesses that are using stablecoins, and that market will continue to grow and expand. And in my experience, no Treasury Department and no government, regardless of who is in control, doesn't want the Treasury markets to succeed. And if you think about stablecoins, like what are they? They are fully collateralized instruments that are collateralized by Treasuries.
But you really don't think we're going to get mean, angry Elizabeth Warren hearings about something in crypto?
I'm not saying that's not going to happen. I'm just saying if you want to produce results and prove that you can govern, then you have to find some mediated balance, and there's going to be some tough conversations within the Senate Democratic caucus as well. You mentioned who the leadership of the committee is. Chuck Schumer and his team are going to have to decide how they want to proceed forward in a divided government time.
So the main mitigant you're talking about is like responsible governing. I think there's also going to be a need for the Democrats to show they can be a viable governing body.
Yes, I think that is right. And if you could take back in past precedents where you've had divided governments and you have seen some narrow legislation move forward in a capacity where there has been bipartisan interest. The most recent one that I can think about is post-2010 midterms, when you had Republicans retaking the House, we saw the JOBS Act efforts to revitalize capital formation and help small businesses. Now obviously that was a different point in time because we had the OA crisis, then we had Dodd-Frank as a response to it, and then I would say the JOBS Act and some of the legislative efforts that are around sort of financial services policy issues were more narrowly tailored, but it was again in a divided government. You had President Obama in office and then you had a House majority that was Republicans. Now it's sort of the reverse of that. So I think in the Democratic majority coming in next year, you'll have to find opportunities for oversight, but also opportunities for legislative progress.
But the Democrats have been so viscerally anti-Trump. Do we really think that they're going to be able to moderate here and get something done with him?
I'm not convinced that they can moderate completely. I think there will be an attempt to moderate, and then that will dissipate over time. However, I think for the crypto space, like yes, it has been politicized in terms of — it's, you know, most recently we had the CLARITY Act fail, and most of the narrative and the reasons that the CLARITY Act failed had nothing to do with crypto policy.
No, and nothing to do with like the, you know, 97% of the text in the bill either.
No, no. And if you think about where the policy issues were earlier in the Trump presidency, we obviously had the GENIUS Act that had bipartisan support in both the House and the Senate, got enacted. I think there was 18 Democrats in the Senate who voted for it.
Then we had the CLARITY Act, and time had moved on, and time had changed the politics.
That's right. And so, but still, if you look at the substance, in the House when they voted for the CLARITY Act, there was 100 Democrats, a lot of bipartisan support. And even if we rewind the movie to 2022 and the time frame in which, like, the post-Celsius, 3AC, and FTX — they were trying to work on a bipartisan solution together, and the FIT21 Act was a bipartisan —
I think it had 70 Democrats.
Yeah, it was something like that. 74, I think.
Something like that. So wait, so do you even think it's possible we see crypto legislation that could be bipartisan still emerge in, you know, the Senate or the House?
It's possible. I'm not like holding my breath on it. I think what I think is the more likely solution, if you have crypto legislation, is take apart the bill and like break it up to what the meat and potatoes pieces get out of it. Then you can have sort of piecemeal efforts that have bipartisan support. And there is always a strong effort to interdict illicit finance, to try to have the markets domesticated in the US.
And the reality of it is, if you don't have some type of tailored legislation to create new registration requirements, how can you elevate intermediaries to complying with things that everyone in Washington cares about? Do you comply with the BSA? Do you have like strict sanctions restrictions, like every US person obligations?
One of the things that drove me crazy, though, was like the meat and potatoes of the CLARITY Act was a registration requirement for intermediaries in crypto. You know, you're a broker, you got to register as a broker. You're a dealer, you got to register as a dealer. You're an exchange, you register this way.
Surely everyone agrees with that on both sides of the aisle.
I think if you ask people objectively in sort of a one-off capacity, do you think brokers, dealers, and exchanges that live in the digital asset economy should have to comply with similar requirements as other financial institutions? Like they would just say yes. And I think what is interesting is in 2022 and 2023, we had nowhere near the same type of traditional financial institution involvement in the crypto markets, right? And now, because the markets have evolved and changed, and as have sort of the ethos of what crypto is — and I know you and I have talked about this many times — but every two to three years the narrative of the industry has changed and it's evolved quite a bit from the cypherpunk ethos to where we are now, and where we're focused now specifically on like infrastructure, value settlement, how value transforms sort of the plumbing and the infrastructure of our markets. And I do think that, as we talked about, the GENIUS Act, that is to me sort of the lubricant for all of this, and we're just talking about how value settles on the internet and what collateralizes that, and it is regulated in the US. Like we want to have control over this, or the government wants control over it, right? And the best way to make sure that happens is putting smarter rules around the other intermediaries.
Yeah. And how many — what, eight of the top 10 exchanges in the crypto markets are not US entities, right? I mean, it's basically what, Kraken and Coinbase in the US, and everyone else is —
And that started because the nature of the industry is global. However, but also because there was no pathway to registration and no —
And frankly, in some cases, a hostile attitude towards it, and so setting up offshore was —
Correct. Yeah. So I think the smarter answer still is the same bipartisan solution that has been discussed for quite some time. Will there be tweaks and gives in a different capacity if there is legislation? Yes, 100%. Because the makeup of Congress is going to change and people want things. So like when you're negotiating bills, it's always a balancing solution of like —
The balance of matters. I mean, we're going to see it, but you still think something could emerge, obviously rebalanced to — you know, in light of the new balance of power, but you still think there might be an effort.
I'm saying it's possible.
Do I think it's probable? No.
Right. But if you were advising a current senator or committee, you'd say there is an opening for a deal if you want to try.
Yeah. I don't think the delta between where Rs and Ds were at on CLARITY is that significant. I think the policy substance, the line of divide, so to speak, is pretty narrow. Now you have new members who are coming in who have new positions on issues, and there is sort of a rank order of how they want to approach legislating. And is crypto going to be the top three issues that they focus on in the run-up to a presidential?
So, if you're focusing on oversight and sort of like hold accountable, and then you're also focused on progressive policy matters in the run-up to the next cycle, the presidential cycle, you have to think about like what does the polling say in terms of producing results. And if the conversation is about affordability and household issues in that environment, then I think it's hard to see how you have a big piece of legislation move forward. But it doesn't mean there's like not progress to be had.
All right, that's a great take overall on crypto and Congress. Let's stick with Congress first. Let's talk about AI and Congress, because this is one where it feels to me like the horseshoe theory of politics — that as you go all the way to the right and all the way to the left, it wraps back around and there's potentially overlap. To me, animosity towards AI and data centers is both a right- and left-wing populist issue. What do you think the odds are of a Democratic Congress passing some — I'm going to say anti-AI, I don't know what that would be, tax or oversight, governance, something — anti-AI bill that the president actually signs? What do you think the odds are of that?
Yeah, I think it's really interesting. I would say from a product fit, the people in the country use AI in just a completely different manner than they do in the digital assets markets. And so I think it's a very tough balancing act to figure out like what is going to work for people. If the narrative and the sort of like local exit polling from this election show — and I'm sure there'll be tons of case studies and like focus groups and people trying to underwrite this — but if the narrative comes out that people believe that data centers and sort of the electricity consumption component of AI was an immediate effect on household, like tabletop issues, like dining, family room table issues, then absolutely, I think there's something to what you're saying.
Oh, so I think the theory is a little unproven. I see. You think the extent to which something like that happens in Congress, you think, is very reliant on did people actually vote against data centers? Did they actually — we don't know if they did.
Yes, that's what I'm saying. I think there is a theory that's articulating. I don't know if it's right. I'm saying —
And you do think it'll be reliant on what the consultants and analysts figure out about its actual political value as an issue.
Yeah, I do worry that — I don't think personally that this new Congress, what are we, the 120th now? We will be —
120th Congress, which sits in January, right? Will get, you know, sworn in in January. I think it's more like — my just intuition here is that it's more likely that we get bipartisan AI legislation than bipartisan crypto legislation between the two issues. And because, you know, everybody basically on both sides don't like Sam Altman. I think that's what it comes down to. You know, they think he's weird. I don't have an opinion on that.
I know you don't. I know you don't. I mean, I don't think he's weird.
It's possible, but is Congress great at enacting legislation on like very new topics?
Not great. No, I wouldn't say great. I'm not sure that, you know, if you think back at all of the legislating that has happened in like innovative technology or innovative fields, like most of them have happened post-crisis in some way. And I only can really think about the GENIUS Act where it was bipartisan legislating on a new topic.
Shouldn't we have jammed through CLARITY along with GENIUS right then? My opinion is that if you have a trade in front of you and you have like willing counterparties in Congress, you take the deal. And we had that on GENIUS, but we could have pressed CLARITY. They just waited a long time, you know, and then like the politics changed. It got too close to the election, and like, you know, the field was ripe to be sown, right?
I mean, I think at the time there was so much interest politically of getting the GENIUS Act done, and I think the appetite in the Senate to renegotiate a massive other piece of legislation at the same time on both sides of the aisle — I don't think there were Rs or Ds in the Senate that wanted to do that.
I don't know if fatigued is the right word. I think that they had produced a result that they felt could get to 60 in the Senate, and once that happens, there's just too much inertia to go try to tack something else along onto it.
It's such a high bar that once you clear it —
You're like, we're running here. We're going with that because it's —
All right, let's switch to the other facet. You mentioned the two: Congress and the regulatory. So the agencies now. Of course, the Congress changing party control has no direct material effect on how the OCC or the SEC or the CFTC does its job. But what is the effect?