Welcome to Galaxy Brains. An infinite amount of cash. I'm your host, Alex. The US banking system is sound and resilient. Bitcoin made a new all-time high.
If you're not long, if you're not long, you're short.
Satoshi's going to come on there, laugh hysterically, go quiet. All Bitcoin's going to be erased. Bitcoin. Bitcoin is the best crypto.
Bitcoin is going to zero.
Welcome back to Galaxy Brains. As always, I'm your host, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. Bitcoin, not zero. We have a great episode for you this week. Sid Powell, co-founder and CEO of Maple Finance, is our guest. I talked with Sid last week on the sidelines of Galaxy's Gravity Conference in New Orleans about how Maple Finance works, how they underwrite off-chain credit and put it onchain, how a dollar flows through Maple Finance, and also the future of onchain lending. Having a very interesting conversation with Sid, and you know, we track Maple Finance in Galaxy Research's quarterly lending report. Check that out as always, and our Q3 one's coming out soon. We'll have Zach Pokornney back to talk about that. And Maple doing a lot of onchain business, an interesting business that's been around now for several years. Great conversation with Sid. And before we get to that, of course, we'll check with our good friend Bimnet Abebe from Galaxy Trading as always to talk about markets. A lot going on in markets. You know, we're whipsawing between like a correction in equities and now new bullish earnings reports come out and people, you know, the AI trade has deleveraged a lot of hedge funds over the last month. But where do we stand? We'll also do a little chat about my Bitcoin thesis from about two weeks ago. Why now is the time to add and hold BTC. I did, unfortunately for me, release that four days before Binance was hacked and then the Democrats swept, and now Jensen, this thing at Nvidia. Anyway, all impacting markets, Bitcoin drifting a bit lower since I wrote that, but still very much intact, and we'll talk about that. Before we get to any of that, I need to remind you to please refer to the link disclaimer in the show notes. And note that none of the information in the show constitutes investment advice or an offer, recommendation, or solicitation by Galaxy or any of its affiliates to buy or sell any securities. Let's hop right into it with Bimnet Abebe.
Let's go now to our friend Bimnet Abebe from Galaxy Trading. As always, Bimnet, welcome to Galaxy Brains.
Thank you for having me. We haven't been together very often over the last few weeks.
Yeah, you hate me. I was traveling. I was in New Orleans last week. But we are together now, and the equity markets have been bleak in October. October was not a good month for risk. Not for Bitcoin, not for stocks. But it seems like some respite has occurred in the last week or last few days. Let's start with equity markets because that's the biggest market that we talk about typically. What has happened? Where are we now?
Today NASDAQ's up 3%. You know, the miners and some of the AI supply chain names are performing very well today. You know, CoreWeave had a very strong earnings print and a good outlook. That stock is up, you know, 25%. But that's, and there in particular is what's easing some of the anxiety people have about the demand for compute, right? And so, and you're seeing that trickle a bit throughout and kind of the debt picture and whether or not, you know, it's sustainable. And so I think what, you know, the earnings print did was it eased a lot of the concerns, and it also didn't help that you had, you know, the whole Nvidia situation happening as well.
Oh, you're talking about Jensen. This story with Jensen. Yeah.
Yeah. And but we had already seen a little bit of positivity, right, with SK Hynix's... was it their earnings like a week or two ago? Like actually also memory, they were like, nope, we have a lot of demand way out in the... Yeah. No, I mean, yeah, you know, a bunch of those names are up. Core was up overnight. SanDisk is up like 15% today.
It's been the AI wall of worry the last two months, two, three months.
Absolutely. And I think what contributed to the move, you know, lower when you had that down 6% day is, you know, you had a couple hedge fund stopouts, like very large ones.
So people that were levered long into that trade, and I saw something, I forget from one of the primes, maybe it was Goldman, put out data showing that the hedge funds had deleveraged a lot over this period.
They had, yeah. So, but even then they still got...
But where in your mind, in the AI fundamentals, the demand for memory, the demand for SanDisk hard drives, and for compute, like do you think that the anxiety was justified by over the capex and the debt?
I mean, you also have to mention, you know, the election results and kind of concerns...
But the AI trade in the near term had turned pretty south before that.
Correct. You know, not pretty, but yes.
Well, you know what I mean. Like we came down in, you know, as early as September we were... there were the anxiety, the wall of worry was in the worry part of the wall, not the climbing of the good part of the wall. I just mean like we keep seeing pretty good data on demand for compute, demand for energy, demand for memory, right? And that every... it's not every time, I don't have them all in front of me, but these fundamental data points seem to be coming out and reinforcing that the AI buildout is going to continue at scale, but yet the markets have been all jittery. Like, do you think that that was justified, the jitters from again pre-election? We'll talk about the election in a second. Or was that just the worry?
I think the amount of different paths the world and the market can take over the next six months to eighteen months is, you know, there's a wide distribution, very diverse. Yeah. And you know, I think, you know, when S&P was at all-time highs, you know, a month ago, you know, I think the distribution of outcomes was probably not fairly priced where, you know, your left-tail risks were probably really underappreciated. And then, you know, you also just, I think, you know, people were just too long with too much leverage. And so, you know, you've had a correction. I think in terms of, you know, what drives us on a go-forward basis, you know, the next big thing obviously the Fed, but you also have the Anthropic IPO coming up. It seems like, you know, they're pressing ahead, people are optimistic, that helps support, you know, the rest of the supply chain. Anthropic gets more cash on hand, they can invest more in AI capex, they can give more to neoclouds who then, you know, buy more chips, buy more memory, and so on and so forth. And so, you know, the Anthropic IPO being well supported is a good thing, and that's kind of helped.
So it needs to go well, though, for the...
It will go well. I mean, they will raise as much money as they've asked for.
We've seen plenty of headlines about that, that there's demand to buy the... oversubscribe. Yep.
Yeah. And then I think, you know, the big thing that's kind of underappreciated about the election is that the rhetoric around Iran has meaningfully shifted from the administration, less about, you know, kinetic warfare and more about, you know, increased economic pressure. You know, it seems that, you know, the Iranians have made a few concessions with respect to nuclear inspections by the IAEA. You know, by concessions, I mean like talking about doing certain things, talking about maybe letting the inspectors back, correct? Not agreeing to anything. But I think kind of your left-tail kinetic outcome feels less right now. Feels less. And that's why you've had oil come from 100 to, you know, 86 bucks a barrel.
The volatility in oil markets has been really incredible this year. Insane.
But, you know, the counterbalance to a lot of this stuff, and not something that's concerning because I think, you know, stocks can go up with yields moving higher, and they have. But you had a really hot CPI print, and it was the third hot CPI print.
We were hoping for what, like 0.1, but it was 0.3 topline number or something like that.
The headline came in at 0.4. The core came in at 0.3. And the number was hot. And the components that are huge parts of the index, like, you know, rent, right? Owner's equivalent rent, healthcare. You know, those things were up a lot. And this is the third report in a row. And so, you know, what you've seen happen, the heat is a trend clearly at this point. I mean, we've been above target in inflation for over five years.
Yeah. I forget that it's been that long.
It's been that long. Like above 2% core PCE.
It's because of the stimulus. The stimulus kicked this off, right? The PPP loans, all of that.
I mean, it's just, it's a lot. And essentially, I mean, what you had happen was you were in zero interest rates and negative interest rates for so long. Everybody borrowed, borrowed, borrowed. They got the stimulus, etc. Spent, spent, spent. And then you kick off a once-in-a-generation like tech boom with the AI spending, and we still haven't seen all those dollars flow into the real world. Like, what's the inflationary impact of like, you know, trillions of dollars being spent next year on energy and buildings and... yeah, a lot. So it's a lot, and you know, it's really hard to stop the inflation train. And like the two things you have to weigh is like, okay, how do you kill inflation for sure? Well, you can take the stock market for sure, you know, jack up rates by...
The main reason being, the main reason being that everybody's accounts are lower, and so they all start saving and spending less because they feel... it's the wealth effect, though. Basically, the wealth effect. Yeah. Reverse of it, I guess. Correct. Yeah.
But there's no appetite to do that.
So, so inflation has to trend higher.
I don't think an incremental 25, 50, 75 basis points is really going to like...
Isn't this what Volcker was famous for, was recognizing finally at some point in the 70s and 80s that it was so... I mean, didn't they jack rates to like 20% at one point? And that's what finally... or I don't know if it's what finally did it. I'm not an expert, but that it was that type of drastic action.
Correct. But it's just so counterintuitive where it's like, okay, I'm going to jack up interest rates. What does that do? That jacks up the costs for the US government. And so they have to raise... fair point, too. And we were, I would just say our national debt picture was not the same 50 years ago as it is today.
Correct. And it's just the level of indebtedness globally is just way, way higher. And so the economy, like, you know, in one way can handle higher interest rates, but at the same time, like the fiscal deficits and the amount of debt that's got to get issued, like...
The economy can, but the debt situation... it's just, it's hard. I mean, again, I want to be like very clear, the fiscal situation gets worse, but in theory, as long as the markets are smooth functioning, they'll be able to continue to roll the debt, etc.
Just at higher rates, but the interest, the portion of the national budget that is paid as interest on the debt will go higher and higher, and that puts political pressure on the other spending, which is stuff that people actually want, right? It's healthcare and militaries and government operations. So like that, to me, is where the... while the market can handle it, and if it's smooth, you could... yeah, I mean, someone will always lend to the US and sovereigns, the question is just at what rate.
Yeah, and it's like a lot of paths lead to yield curve control or more QE, but you know, like this is why we like Bitcoin.
QE, that's money printing.
Yes. So, okay, let's get more specific though, because with the hot CPI print this week, I've seen now that Wall Street is convinced we're guaranteed a hike now in the next Fed meeting. That's the consensus, right? That's going to be a 25 basis point hike probably, right? Does that... with risk of potentially higher? I mean, Bitcoin has made new all-time highs during hiking environments and during high rate environments, stocks have done well. Do we expect any... has the market priced that in now over the last day or two? Is that... I mean, we've been like... what has been the impact of the change in the hike expectation? Any material?
Yeah. I mean, here's the thing, like, you know, these companies that are doing AI capex, like they're forecasting that, you know, with rates that are 75 bips higher, like the return on invested capital still makes sense, right? In theory, like it's also like, I mean, dude, who... like let's just say like the housing market's already pretty frozen.
Right. If you jack up interest rates more, like what, people are going to like buy less homes? It's like not really like concerned about rates already. We're already not in a highly speculative like buying and selling market with lots of transactions. In fact, I've seen stats that say we're... it's among the most frozen it's ever been.
Yeah. And it's also like you have to keep in mind like people that are in fixed income, like they are earning this yield, and like there is, you know, an argument to be made that, you know, it's really hard, I haven't done the academic work, but like these higher rates for fixed income holders are really good.
Pay them money more than all the time.
More than they have in decades.
Yes. And so like I don't know, it's a really... you're stuck between a rock and a hard place. But you know, for me it just means that, you know, Bitcoin ultimately is going to win.
Well, it's the nothing stops this train. Nothing or gold, you know, whatever it is or hard assets, you know, it's just like every day that passes, it's just like things get worse.
Honestly, I don't want to get like too philosophical, maybe we should do this at some point in more depth, but like I don't think the sovereign debt ever gets paid off, right? Like ever. I mean, really, it's too big now. I mean, it's not like, oh, a couple years of like austerity and we're back. No, like we're at a $2 trillion budget deficit in the US. So that means we're adding $2 trillion at a minimum of principal net new national debt annually, right? And so like that's not a small gap to close. You know, it's not like, oh, if we just tighten for a couple years, we'll clean up the situation at all. It's way beyond that. And so does this end in like a debt jubilee? Does it end in just... do we print our way out as a strategy? And by us I mean like the whole world, I mean it's not even just us.
Yeah, I mean it's every country basically has this problem.
You know, and that's I think this is why it is the nothing's... it probably does end up in again never-ending inflation, maybe drastic intervention of inflation, of money printing, right? Or some kind of like we just, you know what, some international accord occurs, there's some, you know, it's like the treaties that end major world wars, there's a similar treaty has eventually happened where it's like, yeah, we all just like forgive each other's debt and start over, basically. That would be the debt jubilee, right? Outcome. None of these are good. But it feels like at this point, I mean, this is baked in. It's hard to bake things in until like stuff happens.
But yeah, I mean, I think you're seeing like, you know, 10-year yields pushing like 5% again, the 30-year yields up to like 5.36, 5.37 area, and it looks like these things are just going to continue to trend higher. And I think there's a really high chance that Powell fails to deliver on hawkish expectations and you have another bout of, you know, gold, BTC being like, are these people really serious about inflation? I also think the setup of like the board right now where you've got these, you know, you had Waller come out being like 50 basis points might be on the table. You had Goolsbee come out overnight and say that the last inflation print was alarming. And so these folks on the Fed are like, guys, this is a big problem. And so if Powell doesn't deliver on that in a way that kind of sets up a little bit of like a credibility issue, and all of a sudden, you know, you've got a Fed that's not that credible. And then what's going on with Secretary Bessent? Right. Like I don't know how second-term Bessent is going to fare. You've got things like dollar-yen starting to perk up again after like a ton of intervention this year. Does he feel like he's got the ammo to go once again? Right.
We talked about him using the cannon.
Yeah. And it's like, I mean, he already messed up the last time.
Well, it wasn't big enough. It did nothing, right? I mean, or something. It wasn't seen as credible.
Yeah. I mean, it briefly was, but then the next week we were right back where we were.
Right back up and the QR already happened. And so, it's like a pretty interesting setup, but right here, right now, you know, I'm like, Bitcoin at 74K-ish like looks good to you.
Looks good. Well, we're at the point, we've talked about this, but we are now... we've been sitting in these chairs, well, at this point for years together, but last year around this time when you were starting to fully articulate your bear thesis and throughout the time since you've been calling for... you said, 'Hand to God, I'm a four-year cycle maximalist.' And that puts the buying zone in October. I put out that report two weeks ago, 'Why now is the time to add and hold BTC,' which I still very much believe in. But we're drifting since then. I have the ignominious distinction of having put out a bullish report right before Binance was hacked, the Dems swept the midterms, and this story about Jensen from Nvidia. And we've drifted since then, but in the medium and the cycle terms, like where are you now? You said we were in the buy zone.
We are squarely in the buy zone. I think this is buy and hold and don't look territory for someone like Bitcoin specifically. Yes. This is like an 18-month trade.
That's how we view it. We've written this in... and literally just stack.
You know, that's the message.
All right. Bimnet Abebe from Galaxy Trading. Thank you so much. Let's go now to our guest, Sid Powell, co-founder and CEO of Maple Finance. Sid, welcome to Galaxy Brains.
Thanks for having me on, Alex.
It's very fun, too. We're here in New Orleans, which has been pretty cool. We just saw Drew Brees, Hall of Famer, talk about leadership, and I was inspired and I realized I'm definitely not getting up every morning and like attacking the day the way Drew was. I need to up my game, you know?
It's, yeah, it's always... I don't... it's always inspiring kind of hearing the sports leaders speak because you get a different kind of lens. You know, it's not all about growth or, you know, how you attack innovation or something like that. It's more just how do you win? And I think a lot of people like kind of forget, you know, a lot of things are just about how do you win?
Yeah. And I feel like I always tend to underestimate the amount of intellectual depth that's required to play at a high level in a sport. You kind of just watch them play and you assume it's all like raw innate talent, but like when you hear the studying they do of their opponents and the different situations and the mental checklist, I thought was pretty inspiring and can carry over to any other big endeavor like...
Well, that's why I like, you know, I listen to a lot of biographical podcasts and often they'll talk about athletes and you'll hear the level of depth and preparation that goes in behind the scenes, whether it was like Kobe studying the rules to understand gaps in like traveling or different violations to have a slight edge.
Yeah, it's one of the things. You know, I've never been an entrepreneur, and of course I am a head of research, so it's even less than like an operator, but I used to do venture investing, and I think about how honestly kind of insane to be a venture investor who hasn't themselves been an entrepreneur, and why so many entrepreneurs really appreciate like operator-founder venture investors because they really understand that when you are an entrepreneur building a company, a protocol, like how do you think about analysis or investment from people that haven't built before?