I think we're firmly in accumulation zone, and I think we're going to look back in March of next year and be like, 'Wow, I could have bought Bitcoin at 80,000.'
>> Welcome to Galaxy Brains. >> An infinite amount of cash. >> I'm your host Alex Thorn. >> The US banking system is sound and resilient. >> Bitcoin made a new all-time high. >> If you're not long, you're short. >> Satoshi's going to come on there, laugh hysterically, go quiet, and all Bitcoin's going to be erased. >> Bitcoin is the best crypto out there. >> Bitcoin is going to zero.
Welcome back to Galaxy Brains. As always, I'm your host Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. Bitcoin not zero. We have a great episode for you this week. Harry Austin, Galaxy's head of digital infrastructure, is our guest. We'll talk with Harry at length about his on-the-ground view of what the traditional banks and brokerages are doing or looking to do with blockchains and digital assets. Harry is on the front lines. Galaxy's a big purveyor of digital infrastructure solutions. So, very interesting talk with Harry.
And of course, we'll talk with our good friend Beimnet from Galaxy Trading, as always, about markets and Fed Day. No rate hike or cut from the Fed, but some interesting commentary on what the Fed is saying about inflation in the markets. Also, what to make of Bitcoin at these levels. Beimnet and I will talk about my report for Monday called 'Why Now Is the Time to Add and Hold BTC.' Check that out if you haven't already.
And before we get to any of that, I need to remind you: please refer to the link to the disclaimer in the show notes, and note that none of the information in this show constitutes investment advice or an offer, recommendation, or solicitation by Galaxy or any of its affiliates to buy or sell any securities. It's starting to get cold here. I've got the hoodie on in New York. In a month or two, me and Phineas will be complaining about the cold weather, but for now, it's still nice out there. Everyone have a great Halloween this weekend. I know my kids have some pretty good costumes lined up. Stay safe out there. Have a great weekend, and let's hop right into it with Beimnet.
Let's go now to our friend Beimnet from Galaxy Trading. As always, Beimnet, welcome to Galaxy Brains.
So, it's a big day, Fed day.
And it's not a Super Bowl Fed day. It's a divisional championship, maybe.
Still is the playoffs, though. It's not like a regular season.
Yeah, but it's a wild card or an early divisional matchup, maybe.
I say that because expectations were for no cut and no hike, for no move. And that's what we got.
And so, the market was not surprised today. So, that's why it's not a Super Bowl, I guess. Either a big cut or hike would be a Super Bowl day, or something way outside expectations, which of course almost never happens. It'll be interesting for me to go back and look at when their move deviates from market expectations.
What did happen in your mind?
Well, you know, essentially, the Fed has a long-standing policy of not being political, right? And so, not that they approached it from that lens. Williams specifically said that politics were not brought up during the FOMC meeting at all. But it would be kind of crazy to hike just before a midterm.
So, even you're saying, regardless of who's president or what the makeup is, just in general, try not to do big economic stuff right before elections.
Because it'll be perceived as trying to sway the election in one direction or the other, and you want to maintain credibility over the long run and not be political. So, anyway, the statement was very brief. They decided not to hike. There were two dissents. Most market participants were expecting two dissents, but the surprise came from the fact that Lisa Cook dissented instead of like Lori Logan or...
So, the one that they all expected is that Cleveland president. I don't know what's her name. It's a...
Yes, so she dissented for a hike and that was expected. But no one thought Lisa Cook would.
Correct. But that's not a big deal.
I mean, the fact that that's the interesting thing they were talking about on Bloomberg one minute after the dot plot came out shows that it was not that exciting of an announcement.
I mean, I think the things that really mattered were, you know, he acknowledged the fact that inflation's still above target and people feel inflation when they go to the gas pump, etc. And that there is a need to get inflation lower, and that the Fed is committed to its inflation target and its dual mandate. Period. He reiterated that.
Which is ultimately hawkish in this environment.
Hawkish. But at the same time, did he acknowledge the fact that tight or higher interest rate policy has impacted financial markets and has had a feed-through? Absolutely. He specifically talked about, you know, credit spreads, right? That had moved wider since the last meeting, you know, particularly AI-related credit spreads. And so he clearly understands that, you know, there is a pass-through mechanism of higher interest rates into tighter financial conditions.
Which means that he probably appreciates the fact that when the forward curve implies that, you know, interest rates are going to move higher, aka hike expectations being priced in, because going into this meeting you had almost three additional hikes expected into the curve for, you know, a year out. And so that does mean like a reasonable amount of tightening to financial conditions, and it seems like he's aware of that. Which means that, depending on how you want to interpret it, like he's going to approach hiking probably cautiously, right? Even if inflation is...
[laughter] You know, but at the same time it's really hard to, like, his ability to give forward guidance, like, it's not great. I mean, he has the ability, but he just doesn't give that much of it.
No, no, he's very clearly chosen to give less, right? That's sort of one of the key features of his chairmanship.
And he acknowledged the fact that, you know, there's several Nobel laureates that have written about forward guidance. But he specifically thought that, you know, the forward guidance was more relevant in times of crises rather than kind of run-of-the-mill, you know, economic state. You know, I think like the tension in the market is just you have all of this healthy growth and demand from AI-related spending. And the labor market's tight. But a lot of inflation, you know, is somewhat a function of like high energy prices, which are going to be impacted by geopolitical considerations.
And so, you know, what he's trying to do is prevent the supply commodity shock from seeping into like expectations for inflation or like inflation in broad-based things, right? Like higher energy prices shouldn't mean that your health care costs go up by a lot too, right? But once you get into this inflation flywheel of people expecting higher prices and things like that, it gets more challenging. But anyway, in terms of how the market perceived the message, I think the most notable thing is that...
[snorts] You know, he did come off dovish, and you had the two-year point in the bond market rally about seven basis points from where we were before the meeting. And at the same time, you had the back end of the bond curve actually sell off. So, 30s effectively went from 5.3% to 5.37%.
So, you effectively had a twist steepening of the US bond curve. And I think the back end of the bond curve, you know, in my head is a scorecard on inflation credibility. And so, I think part of it is like, 'Hey, you know, if you're not hiking or you're not sounding crazy hawkish when we just had one of the hottest CPI prints of the year into a tight labor market into a supply shock, then like how do we expect you to reasonably be...'
Not hawkish enough is probably what the back end of the bond market is telling you. At the same time, there's some technical considerations where the positioning had really cleaned up in the back end of the curve, a bunch of CTAs that were short and a bunch of, you know, hedge fund guys that were short. That part of the curve got blown out, you know, over the past couple of weeks. So, the positioning was really clean, and the curve, like twos tens, had really flattened for a bunch of sessions in a row going into today.
And so, you know, we're steepening from a very low base.
Wasn't like aggressive steepening, but it had flattened a lot, and so yeah, that makes sense. And like I saw equity markets where I watched them during the announcement, and some of the, you know, up slightly up. We're going to finish around up 1% or something like that, or less than 25, probably 25... Oh, so we went up, we briefly ticked higher though. The markets...
It wasn't a volatile reaction from assets. Bitcoin went up to 81,200 or so. Again, pretty muted. It seemed like the market was mostly satisfied, or at least it was in line with what it had already priced expectations-wise. Do you see any like other like market implications? Not the underlying like story that's ongoing, but like from the meeting, from the minutes.
No, I mean, I think it's really hard to have a view on risk without having a view on the AI trade, right? And so, overnight we got some great news from SK Hynix. SK Hynix was up a ton.
Dragged KOSPI higher, right?
One of the largest memory... you need hard drives, you need cloud.
These guys are making money, and they are contracted to make a ton more money next year and the year after.
There's plenty of demand.
And their stock trades really cheap, and you know, it had been beaten down. So it had been the KOSPI.
And it finally started to rip and trade up.
Yeah. So that provided a boon for memory names here in the US.
I see. So just a little bit of a relief.
Relief, and then Oracle had an investor day today, and they presented some very healthy information.
Yeah. They were up 12% in the middle of the FOMC meeting. And so that, you know, probably eased a lot of concerns around, you know, some of the credit stories that the AI narrative...
And so you're getting a relatively dovish Fed with some healthy earnings news and healthy developments out of the AI story. And you know, the elephant in the room is, you know, Anthropic has...
You know, over a hundred billion dollars in cash. They're becoming cash flow positive. They're going to raise a ton...
And so it seems like the AI story is intact, and positioning among hedge fund guys...
What do you think the AI anxiety of the last four weeks? And by the way, we've been through several phases of this is the AI wall of worry over and over again, right? It's been a couple of the other DeepSeek moment, was that last year, right? Let alone like earlier this year, and you know, it's the wall of worry. What do you think that this current, I'm going to call it the current AI anxiety, which has been largely shown in some of the debt that the hyperscalers have in the neo clouds and in equity markets. Will the Anthropic, right, they're anticipated IPO in mid-November, I think currently...
Will that mark the positive or negative bookend to this period of the AI anxiety in your mind? Like is that sort of what we're all sort of racing towards is...
It kind of feels like it got bookended last night with that AI up and KOSPI up. It feels like it is the Oracle developments today. It kind of feels like...
So maybe we've closed it now.
Yeah, and you, I mean, you had kind of the panic moves and all of that dead market...
Is that Anthropic IPO going to be for the market broadly? Like, I mean, if it goes well, it goes...
Hard to say. I mean, I think it's just one piece of the puzzle. I mean, there's the Anthropic IPO, but there's the fact that, you know, Meta was able to raise, you know, so much equity, the Broadcom debt deal. Like there's so many things that are happening, and everything is working just fine right now. And so yes, like the Anthropic IPO can be a catalyst.
Key moment, for sure. But right now it seems like it's going to go just fine.
That's the market's attitude towards it, not like necessarily our assessment.
Your assessment of the markets.
Correct. The view of it.
My assessment is, you know, I'm not the AI wizard. I don't have a PhD in machine learning or any of this stuff. And I'm not like a deep equity research guy that's looking at every...
...line in the S-1. What I can tell you is that, you know, PB data suggests that hedge funds have de-risked a ton. So, the positioning from the hedge fund guys is, you know, very...
Lesser or flatter, cleaner. Yeah.
Super clean. And so there is a ton of room to add. I can also tell you that the seasonals are really good for October and November.
Right. We are approaching November.
And things like Bitcoin, I can tell you, you know, we typically trade in four-year cycles. This is around when we bottom.
And a lot of guys do not own BTC.
This was one of the key points in my report that I put out on Monday.
Yeah, just that they didn't. Even you can see in the 13F filings, I'm very much looking forward to... Ironically, also mid-November is the due date for the Q3 13F filings. Those are the filings that institutional investors have to make to disclose their positions. And of course, the Bitcoin ETFs are disclosed in those filings. So, November 16th is the 45-day mark when they are required to report by. And historically, all the biggest holders of the Bitcoin ETFs, you know, like the asset managers and stuff, they report on the last day. So, November 17th, we should find out what the Q3 market, you know, September 30th end-of-quarter positioning was in Bitcoin ETFs. And Q2 showed massive reductions by all of the macro and sort of basis trading short-money traders, and additions by Morgan Stanley Wealth Management, Mubadala, Abu Dhabi, right? Long-term investors, wealth managers...
What is it? Mubadala? Sorry. Mubadala, it's not that.
Uh.
Look, look, if somebody mispronounces something, it's because they only read it. They've never heard it said out loud. I think...
Fair enough. Fair enough.
But so, my point being is the Q2 showed the tourist traders out of the trade and the long-term adding. I think my prediction, we'll find out November 17th, is that you'll see that trend continue. You'll have seen in Q3 it was long-term money adding Bitcoin, not the short-term sensitive shops. And I think to your point about positioning, that's why. That's why in this last month of AI anxiety, Bitcoin's been resilient in the 80s, basically, holding 80, pretty much. And it's because the people worried about the AI trade, they don't own Bitcoin to sell. And so they're not positioned for it. So, just adding to that point, you're making the point about the prime brokers and the hedge fund data in the AI trade, I think the same is true in Bitcoin. That's what we've seen.
You see it in open interest. Bitcoin OI is super low.
But yeah, I think we're firmly in accumulation zone. And I think we're going to look back, you know, in March of next year and be like, 'Wow, you know, I could have bought Bitcoin at 80,000.'
Right now I've got people saying, 'Oh no, I missed 60.' I'm like, 'Well, first of all, 80's still low.'
Yeah. And all I mean, it's also so crazy. All the bears right now...
...they're probably going to flip bullish at 84, 85.
Like, we're like one reasonable candle away from people FOMOing into BTC.
I think that's right. I do. And I think, you know, again, so much so that I told the market that on Monday with that piece. Anyway, so if you're listening to this on Thursday the 29th...