Welcome to Galaxy Brains. An infinite amount of cash. I'm your host, Alex. The US banking system is sound and resilient. Bitcoin made a new all-time high.
>> If you're not long, if you're not long, you're short. >> Satoshi's going to come on there, laugh hysterically, go quiet, Bitcoin's going to be erased. Bitcoin. Bitcoin is the best crypto. >> Bitcoin is going to zero.
Welcome back to Galaxy Brains. As always, I'm your host, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy. Bitcoin Not Zero. We have a great episode for you this week. Tyler Williams, former senior counselor to the Treasury Secretary for Digital Assets, is our guest. Tyler used to run policy at Galaxy. So our audience will know Tyler. He's been on the show several times, but he has not been on the show since he went to work in the government. He's now out of government. We'll talk to Tyler about the failed vote for the Clarity Act in the Senate that happened on Tuesday afternoon. Also talk about the future of crypto policy and what he's doing outside the government now. We'll also check with our good friend Bimnet Abebe from Galaxy Trading, as always, to talk about markets. Big day, Fed day, Fed hiking rates. It looks like the start of a hiking cycle. What does that mean for markets? And how did Waller perform here? We'll get into it. Bimnet, before we get to any of that, I need to remind you to please refer to the link to the disclaimer in the show notes. And note that none of the information in this podcast constitutes investment advice or an offer, recommendation, or solicitation by Galaxy or any of its affiliates to buy or sell any securities.
I got to say, a little bit sad here as I record on Wednesday, what, the 16th. The Clarity Act failure in the Senate was very depressing. One, most, I mean, even though, I mean, I think our audience will know I've been on the bearish side of this bill in terms of the likelihood of its passing. I think when it didn't get a vote before the August recess in July, I publicly lowered the odds to 10%. After this past Sunday night, the Republicans released a new draft that I actually thought had some pretty substantial concessions to Democrats. I raised the odds from 10% to 25%. 25% is still pretty low. So I've been saying, you know, more likely than not, the bill will not become law in 2026 now for months. But despite all of that, I want to be very clear: analysis is different than advocacy. And although I have been predicting that it wouldn't end well, I've been working very hard behind the scenes to make it pass. So has Galaxy, and I should say so is Mike Novogratz, who's been very active in advocating for the Clarity Act. So, and it's of course not just us. I mean, hundreds and hundreds or thousands of people have been working on this bill for two years. Some even longer, right? Earlier iterations in the House and Senate have been being worked on since 2022. And that includes, you know, dozens of members of the House and the Senate, their staffs, people on Capitol Hill and in the administration and in industry. So I think, you know, I can speak for a lot of us when we say we're very disappointed to see how it has turned out so far. Technically, well, we'll hear from Tyler a bit about this. He worked on it a lot from the Treasury Department and even here at Galaxy before he went to Treasury. But I have to say, I want to say a big thank you to members and their staffs in the Senate, particularly Senator Cynthia Lummis and her staff, Senators Ruben Gallego and Angela Alsobrooks, Tom Tillis, and all of their staffs, Tim Scott and his staff, of course, on the Senate Banking Committee, John Boozman and his staff at the Senate Agriculture Committee, and literally dozens of other people. Senator Gillibrand and her staff, really staunch advocates for this bill. And I think there's a tiny chance we'll see it, tiny chance, tiny chance, Polymarket pricing 4% as I say this, that we'll see one last attempt at it in the 119th Congress, but we're not expecting it. So it's time to lock in, and let's go right to Bimnet Abebe.
Let's go now to our friend Bimnet Abebe from Galaxy Trading. As always, Bimnet, welcome to Galaxy Brains. >> Thanks for having me. >> It's a very exciting Galaxy Brains, as it is about every six weeks, because it's a big day, Fed day today. And this was a Super Bowl Fed day in some ways. The headline number, right? The Fed's hiking by 25 basis points. A unanimous decision among the FOMC board to hike. But that wasn't so much the story, right? Why was this one? Everyone said they were going to hike and they did. What was the sort of drama around this meeting today?
I wouldn't describe it as like drama per se. I would more describe it as kind of tension in a way. I think the tension lies in the fact that the back end of the bond curve has sold off a ton.
Yeah. >> 10 years at 5% basically, right?
Yeah. And 30s are north of 5.30. And so you are at the highs in the back end of the fixed income curve. Oil's on $100. You've got, you know, almost four hikes baked into, well, now I guess it's three because we just hiked once. Um, but you know, and you've got global fixed income that sold off like crazy, and you have a fiscal impulse that has really never been bigger, and not just domestically but abroad. And so to hike interest rates into this kind of tension in broader markets was probably, you know, not that difficult of a decision because the market already put it in. But ultimately, you know, you have to think about what a hike signifies. And historically, when you start hiking, you don't just hike once, and the market is pricing in a full hiking cycle, not a one and done. Even though we didn't get that much communication from Waller in terms of, you know, what he's thinking for the next meeting because he doesn't like to give forward guidance, you did get, you know, the dot plot, which suggested, you know, more hikes are coming and that the terminal, you know, neutral rate for markets is going to be higher.
Right, the dot plot is every FOMC voting board member's >> and every, not just voting, but all >> yeah, so where they think it will go over, what, several quarters out, you can see.
And so, and you also had, you know, their economic forecasts, and they think inflation is going to be higher, core is going to be higher, at least versus the last round of economic projections. But yeah, like very few times do you only go 25. Most times it is, you know, 50 to 100 basis points because if you really believe that inflation is an issue, so much of an issue that you need to hike interest rates, 25 bips doesn't really do anything.
Right. At the same time, you've already tightened financial conditions because of how much the Fed is pricing, like the interest rate curve is already pricing.
Right. So like by hiking you are like, for example, like if the six-month point in the US curve has 50 bips of hikes priced in, that means that when the government issues a T-bill, it'll be benchmarked to that rate, right? It'll be a function of that. If a corporate was to issue debt, right, it's based off of where those forward, you know, interest rate projections are, right? And so you've already tightened financial conditions. But I think the more interesting point is that, you know, Waller spoke about financial conditions and he said that he finds it hard to believe that they are restrictive or that he's neutral. And in theory, if inflation's too high, you have to move to like very restrictive conditions. And how do you measure financial conditions? It's equity markets, it's credit spreads. And so those things have to in theory like go the other direction.
Right? >> Uh, for >> to call it restrictive. >> Correct. >> And so.
What I would describe is a situation where the Fed has been above its inflation target for 65 months in a row. And they seem to be waking up to that fact because the energy shock is really putting, you know, inflation more in focus. In addition to the issue you're having with the back end.
I mean, they want the dollar's value to go down. They just want it to go down at a slower rate, right? Our money is losing value a bit too quickly for their liking. I was thinking about this yesterday. I think one of the reasons that I mentioned drama, but maybe this was a naive take, I am a novice Fed watcher, but it was, you know, Waller is a dove. He had wanted to be a dove and he's not been able to be, and so that was kind of interesting, right? And, you know, if he had not hiked, it was something like 95% of economists were calling for a hike, markets like almost fully pricing it in, right? And so if they didn't hike, that would have been like a shock, right?
It would effectively be a cut. >> Yeah, it would be, right? >> You already have this baked in, right? >> But the issue is he couldn't do that because the back end of the bond market would go absolutely crazy. And by absolutely crazy, like we're talking about like 10 basis point plus moves, maybe like 20, you know, in the 10-year point. Like you might have been at five and a quarter if he didn't go.
Huge move. Yeah. >> Huge move. But it's like what's going to stop that train if it keeps going? Because there's like, anyway, it would have been a disaster. One of the things. So aside from this, you know, the dove being forced to hike and some of that drama, which you're right, I mean, he did the right thing. He's regained, I think, a fair amount of credibility from when they had thought maybe he didn't have as much. But I was thinking about this, you know, as a Bitcoiner and even a gold bug in my, you know, prior life. A big fan of Ron Paul, who I think first he wanted to end the Fed, later he ran on auditing the Fed, which I think is, you know, was more prudent. I think I >> I think that's kind of crazy, by the way. Audit the Fed. What are you talking about? Their data is publicly available everywhere. >> Well, you know, >> have you ever seen the Fed balance sheet data? >> Yeah. And also comes the most pristine data that we have in markets. >> Okay. But so, but meaning to be a critic of the Fed for, you know, which >> basically as its mandate manipulates the price of money, right? Or it's not its mandate. Its mandate is to keep low inflation and to make sure unemployment's not too high. But the tool that it primarily has is the manipulation of the fiat currency. And that seemed like this very bad thing, and that the programmatic, you know, trustworthy, unchanging monetary policy of Bitcoin might be preferable.
And what I've realized, and I don't know why it took me this long, but it's actually quite a brilliant sort of escape valve for the economy to have this council of elders that does this. And while it is true that probably, I don't know, I should look, maybe 90% of decisions the Fed makes really are sort of algorithmic reactions to the market, it's kind of the same thing like in trading. Like, you know, it's for that 10 or 15% of the time you kind of need a leader. It's not just a human. There are times when there's no good option and you need someone to step up to the plate and make the case of what to do and lead you. And actually the Fed is a really good sort of bubble that can absorb the anxiety of the market or put back in calmness when the market is anxious. And this sort of like semi-independent but not statutorily controlled thing is actually quite brilliant as again, like I think of it like an escape valve or a forcing function or whatever. You know, this sort of like nebulous thing that can give the one or take the one thing from the market that it needs taken or given. And it's kind of brilliant in that sense. Most countries, the central bank is directly overseen by the legislature or the parliament, right? And I think here we're actually, I think, quite unique that, you know, I guess they have to report to Congress, but they don't, they're not governed by Congress. Anyway, somehow this was sort of standing out to me that like it actually is kind of brilliant that it's this like unelected group of bureaucrats. And, you know, I think history shows they really >> I wouldn't call them, they're more academics. >> Academics, right? They really are kind of ivory tower council of elders. Anyway, I don't know why I'm sort of admitting this, that I've kind of finally figured out for myself why I think the Fed is actually quite a brilliant organization to exist. And it is for those, like in particular those 15% of times, whatever the number is, where there's really no good option to do, and that's when you need humans to lead. And we've seen some of those times. I'm not saying this one, you probably could have, you know, set and forget. Let the algo handle it. You know, the algo stable probably, right? I mean, this was like basically one of the most locks that there was going to be a hike we've seen in a long time. But anyway, I thought they acted well, and I think Waller seemed to listen to some of his comments too, and he's much less comforting and verbose than like a Jay Powell or a Ben Bernanke had been in the past, I think. But I thought he did pretty well as well.
No, I think he did really well. Early on into his tenure, I just thought he was a little bit of a plant and too much of a dove. And, you know, history says that he's not really a great, like, teammate, coworker. You know, he's the same guy that after leaving, you know, Bernanke's Fed, he wrote an op-ed on Bernanke's policies like literally like the day after. And he's seen as a bit smug and egotistical at times. And, you know, I think versus that reference point, today was better, and so was Jackson Hole.
And I think he's been humbled by the market.
Because another thing that I've kind of noticed too, you know, the argument that the Fed manipulates the market. Well, I mean, this is a clear example of the market manipulating the Fed, basically like forcing the Fed to do.
That's what I mean. There's like, um, they're like two wings. >> Checks and balances. >> That's right. It's a check and balance. It's at least this time, and maybe I should do a study, although I know there are many good books. Somebody suggested a good one where they go through all the past FOMCs and >> um, but I think I would guess at least half the time, if not even much more, it's really quite the opposite. It's not really the Fed, quote, like moving the market. It's often the market moving the Fed, and so.
Depends on the instance, but yeah, the US benefits from being the reserve currency of the world, right? And so there's been a lot of instances where, you know, Fed takes policy that is, you know, very loose and the dollar just holds up fine, right? But now you're on the precipice of a pretty big breakdown in your bond market. And so the stakes are pretty high. And, you know, the endgame and the reason why, you know, going back to kind of what we do here.
The Bitcoin is going to have another pretty large bull run is because the issues are so structural at this point and they've compounded.
That eventually you're going to be at the point where the Fed's balance sheet is going to be increasing. You're going to have explicit yield curve control at some point.
Um, you know, just think about this like.
The only thing to be done is to stop overspending and lower the national debt. Is that, that's the only answer?
Or to grow like crazy and to have like insane, like, taxes.
The one thing we can't do.
Or I mean, you could tax people to death. Like there's enough room.
I know that kills the economy, and then like, you know, I mean, right, technically you could grow your way out.
An adult in the room to make the hard choice and to tell people that you're going to make the hard choice.
But I mean, I'm saying, gosh darn, if you're telling me you spend less and balance the budget, like shoot, that's the only thing we can't do.
Oh, shoot. [laughter] >> Rats. >> Um, but yeah, it's a really interesting setup, but I humbly respect how hard of a job it is. Yeah.
Everybody is quick to be a critic.
And no matter what you do, somebody's going to tell you you did the wrong thing. This guy just went out and hiked rates. And I bet you, I mean, I haven't paid attention, but I'm sure Trump is fuming.
Well, I did see one thing that's been interesting, right? Because of course, Trump was calling for Jay Powell to cut rates. He ostensibly put in a guy who's known to be dovish. That guy has not managed to yet cut rates. So Trump can't be super happy. The White House did put out, I think I saw some headlines on the terminal leading in and before that they would respect the Fed's decision. So that's good. I haven't seen though, I mean, luckily, thank goodness I don't have a Truth Social account, so I'm not like following, you know, I haven't seen the post yet on the, you know, the repost.
I have it on push alerts.
Well, I'm sure he probably is fuming, but it's his guy now, so he can't, you know, be that mad. You know, he can blame Jay when Jay was, you know, appointed by someone else. But yeah. So just to add on to this, Waller is actively engaging in like these different kind of panels, right? To look at what are better measures of inflation, how should we look at them, you know, what's the appropriate balance sheet policy? Like he's looking at a bunch of things. What's like the most effective communication strategy? But unfortunately none of that matters when you've got a war raging in the Middle East and the back end of the bond market that's on fire.
You can't really do all of that.
Because you could make an argument, and some people do, and I was talking to some guy the other day and he's like, yeah, like the new measure of like core PCE, like they're rejiggering it a little bit, actually puts PCE a bit lower. The Dallas trimmed mean PCE is much better than, you know, the current core PCE. Like there's lots of arguments to be made that, you know, even the latest inflation reports, you know, you were seeing like things like airfares and like lodging which aren't like huge, and like there's some aberrations in the data. So you can make the argument that, you know, you are seeing like positive things on the inflation front, but I think that's all horseshit. Because like at the end of the day, prices are just too damn high and they're still going up.
Yep. And they're going up too quickly.
Yeah. [laughter] >> We want >> And the labor market's tight.
Yeah, exactly. Well, there you go. Yeah. That doesn't need to cut for employment because employment's looking good, and does need to hike because of inflation because it ain't looking that good.
Yeah. I mean, the only, the best thing that the Fed could do, which they can't do, is to print molecules.