Hi everyone, today's episode is brought to you by Copper. Copper is the global provider of blockchain infrastructure solutions for institutional investors who are actively trading their digital assets. They have an award-winning custody application that's connected to 25 of the world's largest exchanges, and they ensure safe storage and movement of assets for some of the world's largest crypto hedge funds, market makers, family offices, and high net worth individuals. Copper's Clear Loop is the first off-exchange settlement network for digital assets, and it's the safest way to trade balances in custody across multiple exchanges without requiring on-chain movement of assets. Head over to copper.co/clearloop to learn more. That's copper.co/clearloop.
And today's show is also brought to you by Aave, a decentralized, open-source, and non-custodial protocol where users can deposit and borrow digital assets. You can earn interest on those assets and head over to aave.com, that's aave.com, to experience and learn more about DeFi.
Today on the podcast, Ria and I sat down with Alex Thorne, our friend and former colleague at Fidelity Investments. Alex is now the head of research at Galaxy Digital, and he recently authored two great pieces, one on the phenomenon that is Dogecoin, and one on the state of the crypto venture market. Alex is a deep thinker, and as usual, he had a ton of insight on what's happening in the market. I think you'll enjoy this one. So, without further ado, here's our conversation with Alex Thorne.
Brought down by bad mortgage investments, Lehman, which has 25,000 employees, will be liquidated. The federal government loans American International Group AIG $85 billion. This is a different kind of mortgage and THE FED IS ASLEEP. The federal government is stepping in to stabilize Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the two mortgage giants that have been threatened by the housing crisis. The Bank of England has pumped 75 billion pounds more into Britain's ailing economy with a new round of quantitative easing. You print a couple trillion dollars and all of a sudden people start to worry. So out of this worry, we have something called the Bitcoin. Bitcoin.
Welcome to On the Brink. I'm Matt Walsh.
And we are very excited to welcome a former coworker, Alex Thorne, the head of research at Galaxy Digital. Welcome to the podcast, Alex.
Yeah. Hey, Matt. Hey, Ria. Great to be here. Huge fan. First podcast that I've done in a long time, certainly since I joined Galaxy.
Well, who would have thought that the first time you come on our podcast, it's not to talk about Bitcoin, not to talk about institutional adoption. We're here to talk about some Dogecoin.
Yeah, dog money. All about that dog money. Yeah, who would have thought that? It's quite hilarious. It's not a flash in the pan project either. This thing's one of the oldest cryptocurrencies and, you know, it's sort of Bitcoin's Peter Pan shadow, right? My view is always, especially as we started looking into it deeply, is that it's going to last as long as Bitcoin lasts. This joke has legs.
It's so funny. Well, we're going to talk a lot about that, but maybe before we do, can you just tee it up with a little bit of background how you got into the space and what led you to Galaxy?
Yeah, absolutely. So, I only joined Galaxy three months ago. Prior to joining Galaxy, I had spent my whole career, 12 years at Fidelity Investments. Most recently co-managing Avon Ventures, Fidelity's early-stage crypto venture fund. And before that, I was director of blockchain research at Fidelity Center for Applied Technology, the innovation lab. But before all of that, I started at Fidelity in 2009, right after I graduated from college as a paralegal at Fidelity Legal. And eventually they figured out that I was a technology aficionado, is the only way to say it. I studied poli sci, so I'm not a trained technologist, but I had my first website, alexthorne.com, shout out, 1998, and a bunch of other fun stuff. And anyway, so I started doing forensic investigation, eventually managed legal and compliance investigations before finally in 2015 when Abby Johnson, Fidelity CEO and chairman, directed folks, including yourself, to start looking into Bitcoin. And I think it was discovered at the time that I was one of the more advanced Bitcoiners at the company. So I was working in Fidelity Capital Markets compliance and it came to me, someone came to me and said, hey, we hear you know about this Bitcoin thing. So I started consulting a little bit with that early group of people that was looking at Bitcoin and, you know, eventually weaved my way into the actual department working on it and that sort of is the story of how I did it. I think I worked in more Fidelity departments than anyone I've ever met from at that company. So, it was at least four different major business units in my time there.
It's such a cool story. I remember it distinctly because we had a, it was a design thinking team that was going around and speaking with people that were really into Bitcoin at the company and you were definitely one of the people that was really into it. Do you remember what made you excited about Bitcoin in the first place and how you even got into it?
Yeah. And it was funny too because what first intrigued me about Bitcoin is not, it certainly isn't the only thing that intrigues me about it now. Sort of different, the value proposition I saw in it has evolved significantly. When I, so I, you know, again, sort of a hacker at heart, been into encryption, operating on the internet and IRC, BitTorrent for my whole life basically. I actually ran a huge file sharing server on a protocol called Hotline Client Connect, like years before BitTorrent, if anybody out there knows that. And so it was right around the Arab Spring, the tail end of the Arab Spring, also a huge international relations fan and geopolitics is a big interest of mine, and I was following the Arab Spring protests in Egypt and around the Middle East and then somebody had mentioned in an IRC chat that there was this Bitcoin thing. So this is probably 2012 and I thought it was cool. I thought it was internet money. People were talking about trying to send support to the protesters. Later during the Euromaidan protests in the Ukraine, the same thing was happening. There were people holding up donation addresses, QR codes in the streets of Kiev. And I thought that was really cool. I sort of put it in the bucket of Tor and encrypted messaging and sort of internet money. Thought it was awesome. Had accounts on Mt. Gox. I think my first purchase on Coinbase was June 2013. I scrolled all the way back in my Coinbase account. Sold a ton of Bitcoin in the run-up to that, like, I probably sold around 800, 900, a lot of Bitcoin in 2013. And, you know, it wasn't until Fidelity started looking at it maybe a year and a half or two years later that I sort of really, really decided to, you know, take the orange pill and develop that thesis a lot more and got a lot more conviction in it. Of course, regretted those sales of Bitcoin. Still do. Still do. And yeah, and it's sort of the rest is sort of history. I mean, it's only gotten more interesting since then.
So, you're someone that I think identifies just really strongly with some of the core ethos behind Bitcoin and why it matters. And you've become really well known in the community. You host the Bitcoin meetup on Clubhouse. And I'd say you're quite popular in the community. I'm curious how you think about the other projects and in your role now at Galaxy in research. You have to research all types of things. But how do you think about just following the other ones? Are you passionate about anything else? How do you just contextualize what else is happening?
Yeah, absolutely. I'm passionate about decentralization. I'm passionate about self-sovereignty and disintermediating centralized parties that add counterparty risk and censorship. And so, you know, there's a lot in the space that's really interesting to me. I think when I look at projects, I sort of view a lot of the technology that's being built in the space as one giant canon, one big academic work. And we see this a lot of times, you know, new projects will come out with something that they give a new term to, for example, and they say is really innovative. And then you realize, well, this was proposed a few years ago by either Bitcoiners or another project. And you sort of realize that the protocol design and differentiation is really a lot more about trade-offs and design choice than in many cases any actual innovation, any new innovation. Of course, there is a lot of new innovation. There's a ton of innovation at the application layer, whether that's tools to make it easier for Bitcoiners to run nodes or store Bitcoin or spend it. There's a ton of innovation at the application layer on Ethereum and similar networks on designing new financial primitives. I love all that stuff. When I evaluate certainly layer ones though, what I see is mostly changes in design and implementation sort of along the same lines, right? It wasn't that people tell me Bitcoin can't do smart contracts. Well, that's not true by the real definition of a smart contract, but the reason it doesn't do stateful, Turing-complete smart contracts like Ethereum is a design choice. It's not because it couldn't do it. It's because Bitcoiners don't want to do it, right? Different protocols make different trade-offs to achieve different ends. And that's sort of how I think about when I evaluate projects. I mean, broadly speaking, I like anything that you can use your own cryptographic keys to store on your own. And that includes obviously Bitcoin, but any kind of cool assets. I love some of the incentivization that we're seeing using, you know, cryptoeconomics to see whether we can use game theory and economics to incentivize different behaviors. I will say that automated market making is one of my favorite innovations that is truly a crypto-native financial innovation. Did not exist in the world before Uniswap and sort of others have worked on it. And that's, everyone said it couldn't work, that no liquidity would actually go there. And we just know that's not true. And that's been really exciting as well.
It's such a cool innovation. There's a bunch of those. I think perpetual swaps are also in that bucket for me where I'd love to see some of this crypto innovation merge into the quote-unquote, you know, centralized traditional finance world. It would be great to see.
Absolutely. I mean, the perp is like such an amazing derivative product with no expiry that it's just... Did Arthur Hayes invent that? I mean, did it exist before BitMEX?
Yeah, I think there were like similar ideas, but I had never heard of it described as a perpetual swap until then.
I think BitMEX definitely popularized it. I'm not sure if they invented it, but they definitely popularized it.
Yeah, game changer in crypto liquidity for sure.
Yeah. I have a quick question. So, just piggybacking off of Matt's prior question, you know, in your role as head of research at Galaxy to date, there's been this massive growth in the amount of content that's available on Bitcoin. How do you kind of decide what comes next? Like, what kind of questions are clients asking? How do you prioritize what you want to research and what you want to produce content on?
It's an awesome question because it isn't easy, as you know, Ria. And I sort of start with one major question when I think about how to describe and share insights that we're generating from following the space, and it's: does this matter? Why does this matter? Why is it important? That's sort of how we frame our research reports. We want to bring signal. We don't want to explain how things work and give a regurgitation of white papers or an update, a pure update. We always want to be trying to bring some insight right at the front. And so that's sort of how we kind of figure out what to prioritize actually publishing too, because the question isn't what is interesting to us. The question is what is important, right? What is moving markets? What innovations are going to change markets? What trends and themes are impacting the world or will impact the world that we see, right? So, you know, that's why we focused, I don't want to do the transition, but this is something, one of the reasons that led us to look at Dogecoin was, you know, we've known this project for years, right? And so, but we see it covered in the media. We know everyone on Earth for the most part, I mean, that has access to a device of any kind has probably heard of Dogecoin, but no one knows the history of this fascinating project. And I think when we looked at it, we found that first of all, it's a lot more interesting than 99% of people realize, but also it's frankly a lot more robust than anyone gives it credit for. And that is, why is it interesting? Why is it important for Dogecoin? It's not interesting because it's part of a retail mania, which it certainly is, right? But it's interesting because the project itself is interesting in the history. And so, you know, that's just more broadly on your question directly, Ria, too. Like, we're looking for things that stand out that people aren't covering correctly that we think we can add or shift the mentality on in a way that's, you know, obviously factual, but additive to the overall conversation and broadly, you know, educate and bring insights to our clients.
You know, since you brought it up, I think it'd be great to just jump into the report. And you touched on it a little bit already, but I'd love to know and I'd love for you to expand on what were some of your assumptions heading into the report and then in the process of researching, you know, what proved to be true and what really surprised you?
Yeah, I mean, I've known about Dogecoin for a long time. I know you guys have as well. To be honest, it's always been funny. I mean, that Doge meme, that Shiba Inu sort of looking over his shoulder, I think that was sort of rated by the internet as the meme of the year in 2013 when Dogecoin was created. And I thought it was just funny that, oh, this is a, you know, an altcoin that was made as a joke and that was funny that that happened and nobody could seriously still be using this thing or really interested in it. And that even when Elon Musk tweeted about it in April 2019, it couldn't have taken up, you know, any kind of uptake after that. This had to still be just totally this joke coin that we've been chuckling about for several years, but has never been important. And I mean, we just found the opposite. We found that transaction volumes are up more than they've ever been on-chain. There's more addresses that have a non-zero balance of Dogecoin than ever before and it's going up significantly, which, you know, is a proxy at best for, you know, adoption and user ownership, but that trend is instructive. We looked at the mining revenue. It's through the roof. There's an interesting situation with not a lot of supply of Litecoin miners. So Dogecoin is merged mined with Litecoin. So basically its miners are Litecoin miners who can also mine Dogecoin at the same time with no additional cost. But there haven't been any new Litecoin ASICs manufactured recently at all. We looked into it and talked to some folks in the secondary market for mining machines and found that the Litecoin miners are like mooning right now, something like from $50 to like over $500 or something. We have the chart in the report, like just over the last couple months, because Dogecoin is making mining Litecoin extremely profitable. And I, you know, just broadly, it was like there is a lot more usage and ownership of this thing than we thought. And then, you know, you look at the price chart, we have a relative price chart in this report, you know, that calculates the percentage increase from year to date. And I mean, Doge is 10,000%, it's up 10,000% or something year to date. Bitcoin's like a meager 100%, right? So, I mean, it just stands out. You can't ignore it. And then the story is so funny. I mean, we knew some of the story, but when we actually started going back and cataloging it out, we were just laughing so hard. Just, it's really funny.
You have that one chart in there that shows that, you know, what portion of Litecoin miner revenues come from Litecoin versus Dogecoin. Just to see how it significantly expanded as a portion of total miner revenue is insane.
Yeah, it's like, you know, I think on a, we ran this last on Monday or on Tuesday, the chart, and I think it was something like $6.5 million per day in miner revenue, of which 4.5 was Doge and only two was Litecoin. And you can see the little tiny line of Dogecoin revenue throughout the whole prior history of the chart.
Yeah, exactly. Then yeah, it's like then it explodes.
Yeah, it's just, and it was also just like the on-chain metrics are encouraging. There's a lot more activity. It's clearly more widely adopted than ever before. There's no doubting that. But then sort of because we were thinking about Doge so much for like a week and a half or so, we just started to realize that the world has merged free and open-source software and money. And that means anyone can create any money that they want. And people are creating really good, sound monies like Bitcoin or internet Web3 monies like Ethereum, but they can also create joke monies. And it turns out, you know, this joke money wouldn't be funny if it was VC-backed or had an ICO. But if it was totally pure, if it was Bitcoin-esque, if it was mined for fun as a joke, that joke is pretty funny. Turns out jokes are valuable. Like they have monetary value. And this, it's a new paradigm that you could literally create a joke money and have it be worth $85 billion. We just can't, I still can't get over this joke. I'm gonna be laughing at this joke forever.