There's nobody being like, 'Oh man, we got to take this company public on Ethereum instead of just like the New York Stock Exchange or the NASDAQ,' right? Like they might if there was an actual pathway to do that, but we've never, no one's really ever been even allowed to try.
Okay, welcome to Brainstorm by Membrane Labs. I am your host Craig Burchell, and I am here today with a very special guest, a friend and former colleague, Alex Thorn, Managing Director and Head of Firmwide Research at Galaxy, and also the host of Galaxy Brains, one of my favorite and one of the most insightful podcasts in the industry with new episodes every week. Alex, how are you? Welcome to the pod.
I'm great, Craig. Thanks for having me. Excited. It's an exciting time. The markets are moving.
They're definitely moving. You know, before the podcast we were talking about XRP, you know, and I'm not sure if you've been riding that rally or not.
I typically don't trade a lot of altcoins, but I will say I think this might be the most hated rally in crypto history that I've witnessed. I've been working in this industry pretty much full-time since 2015. I don't know a lot of people that own XRP. I don't know a lot of crypto funds that have this position. It's up like 3 or 4x in, you know, five days, and that is painful to people who are supposed to be trading this market actively and seeing things like that. So yeah.
Yeah, I'm curious. You, I'm sure, have been really busy in the post-election period, especially like in your role as research. Generally, like, what have you and your team really been primarily focused on?
Definitely following who the picks are for the cabinets and relevant agencies. We don't really have any of the market or banking regulator leads chosen or named yet. There are some names that are front-runners. I don't even want to say as we're recording this, there's some reporting I'm seeing, some news as well, that Paul Atkins may be named as the SEC chair, but that's just reporting from sources, so we're waiting for an actual announcement. He would be great as the SEC chair, to be clear. So he's an SEC veteran, he was a commissioner during the Bush administration, he's a supporter of innovation and a progressive approach to regulation and digital assets, he's built a great firm, Patomik Global Advisors, that advises firms across many industries, including some in crypto, so would be a great pick. But I think in general, mapping out what is likely to happen across the various vectors and segments of policy that matter to the crypto industry has been a big focus for us.
Yeah, that's things like, again, at the market regulators, the SEC and the CFTC, the banking regulators, the Fed, OCC, FDIC, NCUA, and at Treasury, right? And there's a, the list of issues that crypto markets broadly care about isn't small, but it's known, right? Like we, I've certainly been covering it for years. So right now I think the market is in an interesting position where you, you know, you're supposed to be bullish. There's, you know, at least apparently this pile of positive catalysts from the policy standpoint forthcoming, right? You know, President-elect Trump has said that he wants America to become the crypto capital of the world, the Bitcoin capital of the universe, or something like that, right, in Nashville in July.
So, you know, I was there in Nashville, and it was definitely great for the industry. I'm curious if there's anything that you would be nervous about from what you're seeing, aside from, you know, the portions that rely on the Senate with respect to like confirmation.
I mean, Scott Bessent is widely respected. I think he would be a great Treasury Secretary. Howard Lutnick at Commerce is great. Commerce doesn't do a ton in financial markets, but, you know, if Paul Atkins is the one named, that's a great choice for markets in general. I haven't seen anything too controversial there, so I'm not expecting much difficulty for confirmation for most of these so far.
Yeah, we're just kind of in a wait-and-see period and see if these policies actually play out. And, uh, no, that makes sense. Some of the viewers have been asking about also like just the future of general taxation for folks like expats, because there are so many folks that left the US like in this industry. And, you know, I guess maybe we can tackle the question just generally more broadly.
The most important tax issue to the crypto world is how to tax miner and validator rewards. Today, the guidance from the IRS says that they have to be taxed with a cost basis of zero at the point that they're mined or earned through validation, right? So if you mine a Bitcoin at 95,000, you know, you have a Bitcoin delivered to you in a coinbase transaction, which is lowercase c coinbase, the first transaction in a newly mined block, not the company Coinbase, that's your gain right there. So that actually forces effectively some selling right at the moment of mining just to cover the capital gains. That's not how commodities are taxed. When you pull gold out of the ground, you don't immediately owe capital gains on that, right? So one of the clear, there's some great people, Abe Sutherland, one who's done some casework on this, some lawsuits against the IRS on behalf of home validators who similarly face the same tax guidance, and that should be changed.
I think when it comes to things like exit taxes or, you know, like capital gains taxes for American citizens working abroad or income taxes, I don't know where those stand. I don't think there's any indication that capital gains tax is going to necessarily change. The president-elect and his team have signaled pretty clearly that they actually do want to try to tackle the deficit. You know, there's some talk of growing their way out of it, but rather than, you know, certainly not raising taxes. So I don't know where that's going to go. I think before the election, a lot of people said and sort of the consensus was that tariffs are likely to be inflationary. You probably would be not looking at something like, you know, reducing those major tax revenue avenues. Now, I think with Scott Bessent and the other language coming out of the transition team, I think the probability that they try to do some work on the deficit is increased. I still don't know the likelihood. I mean, nobody since Bill Clinton, I think, once has actually run a budget-neutral government. There's obviously a million stakeholders involved in trying to get that to happen anyway. But I think that, you know, I haven't heard anything about the expat stuff or those income or capital gains taxes necessarily.
I know you and I have definitely spoken recently about the recovery and kind of reconstitution of the CeFi market, that had been the CeFi lending market specifically, that had kind of been decimated post-Luna and FTX. We've done some work on this, and we hope to publish a report on this actually this week. So if you're listening, you know, take a look on Galaxy Research with galaxy.com/research or our Twitter handle @glxyresearch for that. If not this week, then early next week. We did some analysis on the size of loan book, the aggregate loan book size of the CeFi lending market. So imagine all of the now bankrupt lenders, right, the BlockFis, the Celsiuses, the Genesises. Most of these we can get information about their loan book size either from the bankruptcy documents historically speaking, or even like Genesis used to post this basically every quarter, right? So I mean, yes, of course, we're relying on, none of those companies were publicly traded companies, right? So like we're relying on what they reported either in bankruptcy or otherwise. You combine that with Galaxy's publicly reported stuff, we're a public company in Canada, right, and or Coinbase's, which also does some lending, they're public, and some data provided to us by other CeFi lenders, and you can get a pretty interesting picture of just the enormity of the loan, the aggregate CeFi lending market, you know, outstanding loan book size, you know, basically through the collapse and into present, right? I mean, but you know, the peak is something like Q1 2022, which makes sense. Q2 is when Luna unwound, and Q3 is when like Three Arrows and Genesis we now know basically unwound. Like I think Q3, Q4 is when BlockFi like had to basically go belly up, right? So like you remember that.
A fun time in the... very bad, no good.
You know, totally awful. 2022 lending markets were hit huge. I mean, we went from like over 20 billion in loan book size to basically like zero, right, all at once in that market. That market has slowly rebounded over time, right? So that's good. I think that adds liquidity. One interesting wrinkle here is the launch of the Bitcoin ETFs, which you can now do margin on, right, securities lending. So now you've got just in general like the prime desks at a variety of top-tier brokerage firms like Fidelity, right, that will lend you cash on your Bitcoin holdings if they're the... So the market is evolving. I think you're also likely to see more entrance from the traditional side, big banks, right? I mean, even for example, Cantor Fitzgerald had previously announced that they were going to, at Bitcoin Nashville, that they would open some loan facility that would lend cash on Bitcoin collateral. So with regulatory changes from the banking regulators, you could imagine that expanding, right? So that CeFi market has gone through a real roller coaster. I mean, people remember like the sort of excesses of Genesis and Celsius, and during that time that obviously like contributed to that massive rise, but there is significant demand still for lending in the CeFi markets. I mean, they're different, they're different than they were, right? Galaxy is a good example, like I think Coinbase too, as far as I know, that we don't lend to retail, right? There's no giant pot of retail CeFi money that was being accumulated in '21 and '22, but the demand from the institutional side is growing.
Well, and I'm curious to hear too about that, because a big, because a lot of the CeFi market is also kind of this like wholesale market between the lenders themselves. A lot of those retail aggregators kind of disappeared, and we hear, you know, we've met a few folks that are like mainly out of, you know, Europe, frankly, maybe Europe and Asia, that are coming around and trying to become more of like a funnel for that activity. I'm curious if you're seeing anything on that retail aggregation side, the folks that are borrowing from retail or lending to retail and then in turn going into the wholesale markets themselves.
I haven't seen that myself, but I'm not... I, you know, definitely could be true. I think, you know, where savvy crypto retail is on-chain, there's a robust, as you know, lending market now in DeFi across chains, and so I think that's been quite resilient, and, you know, we see pretty strong growth. I think it was something like 11 billion in open borrows across 20 lending applications and 12 blockchains as of Q3 '24, like so the end of September. That's a lot. That was a 57% increase in open DeFi borrows over the previous seven quarters. If you were around then and you're still around now, perhaps you've learned how to use, you know, DeFi, right? I think at the retail level there, you know, one of the things that's not talked enough about in 2022 was how well DeFi actually performed.
Yeah, there'd be things like whale alerts on Twitter that would show like prominent borrowers and what their expected liquidation prices were, and like the market was able to track that and price that in pretty much real time. Like basically none of the true DeFi apps had any kind of like significant blow-up. It wasn't like in 2020, in March 2020, when Maker basically was spiraling out of control because ETH was spiraling out of control, right? Like that didn't happen in '22. I think DeFi actually performed quite admirably, and if you were there then and you're here now, I think it performed how it was supposed to, at least.
Yeah, yeah, right. I definitely like, you know, TVL and loans went down and many got liquidated, no doubt, but they did get liquidated, right? They didn't like cause the systems to collapse, and unlike in 2020 when there was so much congestion on ETH, like in general, that caused problems for oracles and stuff, the networks worked primarily as well. So like DeFi, I think, was a real winner out of 2022, and I think people use it.
It has. I mean, TVL, I think we're at or near an all-time high now across all DeFi applications, so it's kind of back. I mean, some of that, plenty of that is, you know, appreciation of collateral that's put into these pools, but it's a story that I don't think is told enough about 2022.
I'm curious your opinion on the evolution as more of these kind of hybrid on- and off-chain solutions may come about, where like I think they're doing, you know, they're setting up their own broker-dealer, but then when you know, when you purchase Tesla stock or something, you're getting a Tesla token that's coming from them, but it's actually held with the brokerage. Do you think that there could be a rise of some of these kind of like hybrid CeFi solutions, given that we might have a different opinion, at least on the US side, of how to treat them?
I think there definitely could be. I think some of that requires a like truly progressive approach at the SEC to allow for some sandboxing and sort of proofs of concept, and I think you might get that. I think that's what the SEC should do, right? If you're JP Morgan and you want to come in and tokenize something or whatever, let's call it a publicly traded equity security, right? Like you should be able to do that in an environment, in a controlled environment that shows the SEC how it might work, that works back and forth, right? Like that type of iteration is how you get to innovation, and I think that's what the SEC needs to allow, and I hope that's what will happen, so that you can start to play with more innovative token structures, right? Whether it's like you said, whether it's, you know, lending-related backing, you know, bring more types of RWA on-chain, or if it's, you know, new types of structured products, or if it's just bringing other types of assets into crypto in a way that can actually, you know, be done in the US, in the US capital markets, like that is, I think, long-term what DeFi needs to actually thrive, because right now DeFi is quite useful, but it's really just servicing a cohort of on-chain wealth, right? I mean, even firms like Galaxy, we interact with DeFi as well, but like there's nobody, I always use this joke, like there's nobody being like, 'Oh man, we got to take this company public on Ethereum instead of just like the New York Stock Exchange or the NASDAQ,' right? Like they might if there was an actual pathway to do that, but we've never, no one's really ever been even allowed to try.
I'm hoping, and then you get more integration of DeFi and TradFi, or the usage of DeFi tools in traditional finance or capital markets, instead of just like some innovative TradFi firms, of which there are some, sort of bringing off-chain yield on-chain, which is basically the RWA movement we've seen, which is great, but that's really just servicing the demand for off-chain yield among this crypto-wealthy cohort. It's not really a merger of TradFi and DeFi, so I hope you'll see that.