CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Barry Ritholtz gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Barry Ritholtz
Co-founder, Chairman & Chief Investment Officer, Ritholtz Wealth Management

Barry Ritholtz — Make Fewer Errors, Make More Money | Episode 261

📅 Mar 27, 2025 Infinite Loops 90 MIN 1501 VIEWS 65 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Barry Ritholtz — Make Fewer Errors, Make More Money | Episode 261 My friend Barry Ritholtz has spent his career being an astute market observer, investigating behavioral finance and data analytics. He runs Ritholtz Wealth Management which has been named ETF Advisor of the Year, Financial Times Top 300 Advisors, and one of America’s fastest-growing RIAs. He’s also the host of Masters in Business, Bloomberg Radio’s most popular podcast (50+ million streams/downloads), which he started way back in 2014. In his new book, How Not To Invest, Barry emphasizes how avoiding rookie mistakes can signif...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 2:36You have a fantastic new book out which I love the title because this could be the infinite book, right?
  2. 5:57How do you deal with that?
  3. 11:36How do you, how do you and your colleagues at your shop, how do you stop your clients from doing this?
  4. 20:27The interesting, and again, I know you're such a historian, the word capitulation, which is often used to describe bear market lows, it literally means surrender. How do bottoms get made?
  5. 27:44Do you have a sense of, okay, this is going to be a great client or oh my god, this is not going to be a great client?
  6. 36:00What are some others that both good and bad that you've seen and give me your views on them?
  7. 48:28How did you walk me through that transition? Did something happen?
  8. 59:37And we hear it especially if you have an account or if a client has an account with you and somebody else, and hey, how come every time the shit hits the fan, you're the only guys that call me?
  9. 1:01:21Were they unified? Were they very different?
  10. 1:13:07And you know, I think at the end of the day, if you have an underlying philosophy that makes sense to you, resonates with you, you'll be okay, right?
  11. 1:14:03And so one of the things that I find really interesting in the book is not only the underlying philosophy of it, but the way it is consistently applied, right?
  12. 1:24:37What are you going to incept in the world?
Barry Ritholtz 0:00 ↗
The worst thing that can happen to someone who steps into a casino for the first time is that they win. Good investing is simple, but not easy. Everybody's trying to find the next Nvidia. Everybody wants to tap out before the tariff sell-off starts and then jump back in at the bottom. We impose our desires and our wants on the market and ask it to do things it really doesn't do. Stay out of your own way. Don't make any mistakes. Let the market work for you and you'll be fine. Compounding will take care of itself as long as you don't get in the way.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 0:43 ↗
Well, hello everyone. It's Jim O'Shaughnessy with yet another Infinite Loops. Today, I have my good friend who I think I've known you for like most of my adult life, Barry. Barry Ritholtz, the chairman and CIO of Ritholtz Wealth Management, one of the hottest wealth managers out there, host of Bloomberg's Masters in Business. I think it's probably one of the most popular business podcasts out there. Certainly the oldest. It would be coming up on 11 years and over 550 episodes. And you're also one of the first bloggers, 2003.
Barry Ritholtz 1:21 ↗
Actually, 1998 was the blog on GeoCities. And to tell you how old I am, I taught myself HTML to be able to post. And back in the '90s, it would take me like 20 minutes to write up my notes that I want to post and then 2 hours to code it. You literally are doing it, you know, open paren, you know, a equals href slash like, and if there was a space in the wrong place, everything would break. And when Typepad reached out and said, Six Apart reached out and said, "Hey, we have this new blog software called Typepad. It's WYSIWYG. You don't have to do any coding." I'm like, "All right, I'll check it out." And suddenly, 2 hours a day magically disappeared. That's why I, one of the reasons I pushed back on the we've seen no productivity gains from technology. Like this used to take me hours and now it's seconds. I don't know what you guys are doing wrong, but I don't believe you're measuring productivity correctly.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 2:36 ↗
Well, that, you know, leads us into why we're talking today. You have a fantastic new book out which I love the title because this could be the infinite book, right? You're on Infinite Loops, it could be an infinite book. How Not to Invest. Essentially, make fewer errors, make more money.
Barry Ritholtz 2:56 ↗
Yeah, this comes back from an idea from two of my favorite Charlies. A sentence that isn't said, I don't think, ever. So you go back to the 1970s, and I know you are a market historian and a data junkie as am I, but Charlie Ellis was on the board of Vanguard, he ran Greenwich Associates, he was chairman of the Yale endowment, like a serious player in the history of markets. And he wrote a paper in the '70s that eventually became a book. And the book was Winning the Loser's Game. And he draws the comparison, it's festooned with all sorts of charming, wonderful sports references because Charlie is this charming, wonderful person. But my favorite sports metaphor he uses is tennis. And I've been playing tennis for about, you know, 10 years. And most people are amateurs. The 0.01% of tennis players who are professionals, they're really, Charlie draws the, makes the conclusion, there are two different games. Tennis is two different games. The winner's game is the game that the professionals play. You score by hitting aces, by just kissing the line, by slicing, by hitting with power, by putting the ball in all sorts of challenging places with all sorts of swings that require a lot of technique and expertise. Professionals win tennis by scoring points. The rest of us, the 99-whatever percent of us amateurs, that's not how we win a tennis game. We actually lose by making unforced errors. We double fault on a serve. We hit it into the net. We hit it wide. We hit it long. We hit it with not enough spin, so it just bounces right up to the sweet spot of our opponent's swing. And so, if you just make fewer of these unforced errors, if you ever take any of the performance driving classes, it's kind of the same thing. If you just stay within your own skill set and don't try and do much, let the other person beat themselves. That's how amateurs win games. And Ellis draws the parallel to investing. Everybody's trying to find the next Nvidia. Everybody wants to tap out before the tariff sell-off starts and then jump back in at the bottom. And the reality is, that's not how you win as an investor. As an investor, stay out of your own way, don't make any mistakes, let the market work for you, and you'll be fine. Compounding will take care of itself as long as you don't get in the way.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 5:57 ↗
Yeah, and the challenge that I always have, Barry, is you and I have been saying this to people for 30 plus years? And yet, human OS seems to be impervious to much of this what we think of as self-explanatory information, data. I mean, literally data. We have more than a century of data that proves your points, proves my points. And yet, we are always constantly, even ourselves, right? I'm human, you're human. We have the same problems with falling into traps, with thinking, you know, that's true of everyone else, but not me. I am the only exception. How do you deal with that?
Barry Ritholtz 6:49 ↗
You know, I wrote up a story the other day that it had come up because I started getting, you know, all the March Madness advertisements. And so, I've been a big Knicks fan my whole life. Like, I kind of came of age basketball-wise during the Larry Bird-Magic Johnson era, which was followed by the Detroit Bad Boys, and then of course the Bulls and Michael Jordan. And I always thought the New York Knicks, of which I am a big fan, never got a fair shake from the refs. And the Patrick Ewing, Charles Oakley, Mason, Starks era, they were always on the verge, they never could get past Jordan. It always felt like the refs gave Jordan like, how many steps was that, refs? It was four steps to the... And I always used to be so frustrated, so infuriated. And then one day somebody who I was a regular on CNBC with I met in the green room like I met you, big Joe Bessecker of Emerald Asset Management was a big, I keep saying St. John's, but it's not St. John's. He went to a school like that and he's a big, you know, alum and donor, so he gets fabulous tickets to the NITs, which take place at the Garden. And so he invites me to a game. And all this has to do with our own biases and our blind spot as to our biases. And so I'm a professional basketball fan. I'm a Knicks fan. I went to a state school. I didn't go to North Carolina or Michigan. I could care less. I could not care less about college basketball. I have no skin in the game. Don't care about the outcome, but hey, I'll see a game from the fifth row. That's awesome. Like my seats were up in the boondocks for the Knicks, section 205. Wait, center court, five rows back? Where do I sign up? So I go with Joe to see this game. And he's a big guy with a booming voice and he is just haranguing the refs all game. Ref, that's a foul. Like what? Not really. Yeah, the hand is part of the ball. That's not a foul. Ref, travel. And I'm like, Joey, two and a half steps on a layup. That's, you know, given. Charge. That was a charge. Joe, the guy was still moving. He wasn't planted. That's not a charge. You got to be there and, you know, own the space. You can't jump in front of someone. And on and on this is going. And suddenly I have this sinking feeling, this realization that oh my god, I'm this bad when it comes to the Knicks and I'm objective here because I don't care who wins. And not only am I recognizing my own bias blind spot, but suddenly I realized, man, I've been operating in this world that's wholly delusional and completely of my own creation. And what else do I think I'm right about? What else am I biased about that I simply have no idea that I'm clueless? And so, I want to say that was like 2011, 2012, something like that. And it was very eye-opening, because up until that time it was everybody else.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 10:17 ↗
You're 100% right. It was... Well, first of all, frequently when clients call up freaked out about something, it's usually either bad information or a fundamental lack of framing or context. And you know, I... Do you... I don't know if you remember this? Sometime about a decade ago, I don't know who first started putting this chart out, but it's like, how are we going to get by? Look at the New York Stock Exchange margin levels. They're at all-time highs. And it's like, well, where's the rest of the context? What do you mean? Well, here's the chart if we put the value of the market and the margin debt at the same time, they just track each other. So, when 2014, all the memes, NYSE margin is at an all-time high. Yeah, so is the market. That's how it goes. And so, you know, you were... It's so easy to spot these things in other people, and it's so hard to spot it in yourself. And to some degree, that was the thinking behind the book. Hey, if I could get people to spot some of the silly things that I do and other investors do and billionaires do, maybe it'll be a little easier to recognize those mistakes in yourself.
Yeah, and it's sometimes I think we would both feel like Don Quixote, right? Tilting at windmills because like I remember conversations and as you know, they're almost always when markets are at extremes, right? Like the dot-com, I remember everyone telling me, you know, Jim, what are you doing investing in these bricks and mortar companies? They're history. I mean, you're crazy. And then of course the great financial crisis comes along and Barry, I'm not kidding, I had one of our most devoted advisors. This guy could do our pitch at my old company O'Shaughnessy better than I could do. Honestly. Go down my... Ari Rosenbaum, who you know, Sure. Jim, you really got to come down with me because I think he's, I think he's shaky. And so I'm walking... He's broken. I'm walking into his office, Barry. This is February of '09, okay? So you know what happens afterwards, right? So I'm walking into the office. He's got a beautiful office in DC. He stops me. He's sitting at his desk. He just puts his hand up and he goes, O'Shaughnessy, I know that briefcase is filled with all sorts of charts and tables about why I should be getting really crazy long here. I don't care. It's different this time. I mean, literally Barry, every one of the faults that lead us to these horrible decisions, and it was just like literally here was a guy who was about as devoted to the process as I... and then decides let's throw the towel in. How do you, how do you and your colleagues at your shop, how do you stop your clients from doing this?
Barry Ritholtz 13:37 ↗
So there's a couple of ways to bring people to a headspace where market turmoil doesn't affect them the way it used to. So the first thing is proactively. Meaning if the first time you're calling your client to have a conversation about, hey, you know, markets don't just go up, they go down also. If the first time you're calling them is 10-15% into a correction, well, you're already late. So rule number one is be proactive. Rule number two is manage people's expectations, especially when you have a great year. So you know me, I'm not big on making forecasts and predictions, we don't do that. But we do a quarterly call for clients and here's the broad overview of the markets and here's the broad overview of the economy and here's what all this means for your portfolio and here's one last tidbit to think about. But when we, in January of this year, when we did the Q1 call, rather than make a market forecast, what we tell people is, hey, admittedly small data set of years where the market is up 20 to 25% plus for 2 years consecutively. Really only happened like a dozen times and a big chunk of that is the '96 through 2000. But historically, what this means is sometimes the market's up, sometimes the market's down following this, but generally it means just lower your expectations for this year. Hey, we just had two great years that are roughly the equivalent of four or five years in a bull market. We could go sideways for 3 years. You're still above the historical average. So, let's just ratchet down our expectations. Don't think about 20 plus percent gains for a third year in a row. Think more along the lines of plus 10% to minus 10%. That's the historical range you should be thinking about. And so, but you know, if I came to you at the end of '22 and said, "Here's the deal. Two consecutive years plus 25, two consecutive years flat to minus 10%. Would you sign on for that?" You would say, "Hell yeah." So, the second thing is managing expectations. And then the third thing is just showing people here's what market history looks like and here's how often you can expect it down 5%, down 10%, down 20%, and by the way, down 30%, back up the truck. And even if we end up down 50%, that's your second leg in. But understand that unless you're late 60s and about to retire, especially if you're under 30, 40, 50, hey, this is an opportunity if you don't need the money for 15, 20 years. Well, hey, you've been complaining about chasing these, how expensive everything is. Now they're on sale down 20%, not that we're there yet, but we want people to think about major sell-offs as an opportunity, not as a oh woe is me moment. And as long as they go into that, you know, I started on a trading desk and the most interesting thing I learned from the senior traders, one was a former army ranger, one was a Navy SEAL, another was a Marine jungle combat instructor, and these guys used to tell stories, literal war stories, about the prep they did before they would go on a mission. And they literally map out everything that happens, and what do you do if this goes wrong here? There's a plan A, plan B, plan C, every step of the way. But the thing that the SEAL had mentioned that I found so fascinating was, all right, your gun jams in a firefight, what's your plan B? How do you deal with it? How much time do you take to try and fix it? When do you abandon the weapon? And what is your emotional state? Like if your reaction is panic, you're going to get yourself killed and your teammates killed. But if your reaction is, "Hey, mechanical things break. I have another sidearm. I have another piece. I could grab this weapon." Panic is when things go bad and you don't know what to do. But if you have a plan A, plan B, plan C, and you are prepared for the emotionality of the moment, they just say we just do our jobs and keep working, you know, keep moving towards the objective. And that attitude is incredibly, you know, insightful and helpful to say, "Not only do you have to intellectually anticipate the ordinary course of events where markets will fall 3, 4% in a day, 20% in a quarter, but you have to imagine what your emotional state will be. So when it happens, you kind of recognize, 'Oh, we planned for this. I knew this could happen. And it is happening. So here's what I'm going to do. I've already gotten rid of the stuff I thought was speculative and junky. I'm sitting on a little bit of cash. Hey, down 20% I'm a buyer, and down 30% I'm a buyer again.'" And so if you go in, I'm going to take advantage of this once-every-five-year opportunity that presents itself. So, a lot of it is getting people emotionally prepared, making them think in terms of opportunistic investing, adding, rebalancing into equity when it falls a certain amount. But then lastly, thinking about the downside as not a negative, but as a positive. And it's funny because you learn that financial literacy has a really short half-life, and you have to constantly drum that in, because if you educate somebody, a year later, a lot of that's kind of faded. Hey, I kind of remember you said something about how often a down 10% happens. What are we supposed to do? And you know, our advisors, God bless them, they are deep into that. They spend a lot of time. Josh had a really great comment in the morning meeting today. This sort of environment is where advisors earn their keep. It's where advisor alpha comes from. You prevent someone from panic selling at the worst possible time, you've earned your fees for the next 10 years.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 20:27 ↗
The interesting, and again, I know you're such a historian, the word capitulation, which is often used to describe bear market lows, it literally means surrender. How do bottoms get made? When enough people throw in the towel, I can't take the pain anymore. I uncle.
Barry Ritholtz 20:49 ↗
Well, you know, when you give, that's how bottoms get made. And there's a section in the book that talks about the crazy thing about bear market bottoms is a little over 30%, almost a third of people who sell, panic sell into a bottom, never return to equities, which is just shocking. And just think about what that means for those families' retirements 10, 20, 30 years hence.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 21:18 ↗
Yeah, it is such a sticky wicket. I used to, when I started my career, I was going to publish these books, say, here's a level playing field, here's how you can do it, you can do it yourself. And then I had, you know, years and years of experience that taught me, you know what? I'm going to change my advice. I'm going to tell everyone get a financial advisor because literally I was watching people who were big fans of the books, they liked the strategies, everything, and literally throwing the towel, capitulating, throwing the towel in. But if somebody, so somebody picks up your book, How Not to Invest, and they don't, maybe they're young, maybe they don't have enough yet for an advisor. How would you guide them? Take me through how they can use the book to maximize their ability to not screw up in all of these situations.
Barry Ritholtz 22:23 ↗
Sure. So, you know, it's an old joke, a gambler's joke, the worst thing that can happen to someone who steps into a casino for the first time is that they win. And similarly, the worst thing that can happen is the first time you buy a stock and it goes straight up. So, I want them to understand some of the basics. And our whole business model is we give great advice away for free. And hey, if 0.1% of you don't want to do it yourself, which you can, you could do it yourself if you're a little thoughtful, spend a few minutes a month, and manage your own behavior, you're great. If you don't want to do that, if that's not of interest, we're happy to do it for you. But the basic concept is have a broadly diversified portfolio that at least the core of it is low-cost broad indexes. You could rebalance those every couple of years. I think if you're in your 20s, 30s, 40s, you really don't need fixed income unless you're so risk-averse and you're going to be so panicked every time we get, you know, a month like this. It's a drag on returns for a 20-year-old. It's a necessary part of the portfolio for a 50, 60, 70-year-old. Although 60/40 seems a little high when rates are as low as they've been for a 50-year-old. But that's the first thing. Have your core portfolio. I don't care if it's SPY or VTI or VOO or pick your favorite broad index. And then if you're like enthusiastic about, I know you're a fan of momentum. I'm a fan of small-cap emerging market value. Like there's a lot of little ways you can, you know, hang ornaments on the tree. Hey, India seems to finally be making economic progress. Let's buy an India ETF. So the 50, 60, 70% of your portfolio is just broad-based low-cost indexes and you know, we've been looking at Europe as a perennial laggard. All right, now the US seems pricey enough and Europe seems cheap enough. If you want to add a Europe ETF, go ahead. And you know, the idea is that all these little things give you an opportunity to express your perspective or not. Like whether or not you think the Nasdaq 100 is where you want to be for the next 20 years or not. Putting 5% of a portfolio when the rest is pretty broad-based, when you're looking for 8, 10, 12% a year over long periods of time at a very low cost basis, adding a little flavor to that if it keeps you from doing something silly with the rest of the portfolio is fine. And then your next goal is to continue to add to that, to dollar cost average into that over the course of your career. And then the most important thing is to not interfere with the market's ability to compound. That's the great gift of the market is there aren't a lot of guarantees in life. Over, you know, longer periods of time and you could, I feel comfortable saying 20-plus years. I used to say 10-plus years, but, you know, '66 to '82, 2000 to 2013, 10 is a little tight for the worst-case scenarios. But over 20-year periods, compounding works miracles. And by the way, if you continue to dollar cost average as some people did from 2000 to 2013 and the stories abounded in '66 to '82, think about how frustrating that must have been for the 13 years between the dot-com implosion through the mortgage bubble, through the financial crisis, through the flash crash until 2013 when you finally, all the indices surpassed their previous highs and you've been making no returns and then suddenly it explodes upwards because you're just slowly buying over time and nothing's really happening and it's going up, it's going down, it's stuck in a range. And then once that breaks out to a new bull market, as it did in March 2013, you're off to the races and 10 years later, you, depending on how you invested, you five, six, seven X'd your money. And the money is made during the bear market, the gains aren't realized until the subsequent bull market. All bull markets pull gains forward from the next decade and people forget about that. So, my advice to those folks are stay out of your own way, let the market work for you. If you insist on picking stocks or market timing or whatever stuff you want to do, do that in a small basis, but leave your primary investment dollars alone to operate with the highest probability outcomes for highest probability for successful outcomes.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 27:44 ↗
Yeah, and I've often said good investing is simple, but not easy. And it's that part where I just continually try to come up with ways, and you're very good at this, like you've just done, to get people to not be hyperbolic discounters, right? When the TV news is screaming at you, you know, tariffs and the Nasdaq is down 13%. It just automatically kind of shuts down the prefrontal cortex, goes right to the emotional center of the brain, and people are often forgetting all of, you know, this very, very straightforward advice. Is there any kind of process, I'm a huge believer, as you know, in process over individual outcomes. If you can follow a process, and through thick and thin, right? You've got to make that deal with yourself. You're going to be ahead of 90 plus percent of everyone out there doing hit and miss. When you're first chatting with a potential client, do you have a sense? Do you have a sense of, okay, this is going to be a great client or oh my god, this is not going to be a great client?
Barry Ritholtz 29:10 ↗
So, very often the recency effect colors everything everybody says and does. And so, you end up with, you know, hey, what... This is why it's so hard to really find out what someone's risk tolerances are because what just happened over the past 3 months affects how they're looking forward. If we're in the middle of a rampaging bull market and we're up 20% for the year, oh, no, I'm fine with risk. I'm very tolerant. It doesn't affect me. The market, I mean, we're barely off the highs. That's what's so amusing. Have that same conversation with someone today with Nvidia down a trillion dollars in market cap. No, no, I'm a very conservative investor. I'm very risk averse. I want a moderate portfolio. And so, that's the challenge is trying to figure out who they really are and what they'll put up with, but I have found a lot of success in getting people to understand the broader context. And I'll give you a great example since you brought up television and tariffs and all the stuff that's on TV today. Most of what we see in financial television and financial media, it could be prints, newspapers, magazines, it could be radio, and of course, the infinite more of the internet and social media and TikTok and Instagram and all that stuff. Think of what the world was like, and I love having this conversation with a 20-something or a 30-something who just assumed the media world is the same as it always was. Like, let me explain to you what happened before you were born. There was one financial television show on. It was 30 minutes once a week on Friday night. It was Louis Rukeyser who would come out in a very grandfatherly way, tell you what happened that week, tell you why most of it was just noise, and then he would bring a guest out and talk about a specific thing, and that was it. It wasn't 24/7 constantly being pushed to you. And then some years later FNN, Financial News Network, merged with, I don't remember the other merger, and that was the birth of CNBC. Not long after that was Bloomberg Radio and then Bloomberg TV and then CNNFN, which has since gone away, and then Fox Business, which isn't nearly as available as Fox News is. And so we barely need one financial channel. Why do we have four financial channels? Because if you are investing for retirement or generational wealth transfer or even you have a newborn baby and you're saving for their college in 18 years, who cares what happens on a random Tuesday? It's not, hey, you know what? January nonfarm payroll in 2022 is irrelevant if your kid isn't going to school until 2040 or if you're not retiring until 2050. We are so immersed in the here and now, we lose context of... You know, I'm a big watch guy, but not for the reasons you would think. I became a watch guy as a kid because I was fascinated by the concept of time. Right? So, we see each other because photons bounce, you know, the particle that carries light, that part of the electromagnetic spectrum bounces off me and hits your optic nerve and you see something. We have yet to discover chronons or time particles. And the philosophical argument that's been made by some people is that time is a completely human concept that does not exist outside of human consciousness. There is the here and now and that's all that's ever existed. It has progressed measured by the relative positions of different things as the universe expands, but when we think about the past and we think about the future, the past is just tinged recollections and faulty memories with the rosy glow of nostalgia and the future is a lot of our hopes and dreams and wishful thinking. And those two elements dramatically impact how we think about money, risk, and time. And so, gee, you know, I really want to buy that big house on the beach. I really want to take that vacation. I really want to do this. And if only I could find that stock that will be a 10-bagger I can afford to do this. Like we impose our desires and our wants on the market and ask it to do things it really doesn't do. Instead of just saying, "Hey, there's the here and now and 20 years from now, that here and now, future Jim, future Barry, will need money to live on in retirement." I like to tell clients you have to learn how to time travel. And the way you time travel is not getting into HG Wells' time machine or a TARDIS and travel somehow always back to London. But just picture yourself, what's the world going to be like in 15, 20 years? What are your financial needs going to be like? And you know, I jokingly tell my wife about nighttime Barry and morning Barry. Every morning, morning Barry is thrilled that nighttime Barry set the coffee maker so that when morning Barry rolls out of bed at 5:00, there's hot delicious steaming coffee. And that's, you know, an 8, 9 hour difference. If you can plan ahead 9 hours, well, can't you plan ahead 10, 20 years? You can even make the argument that this administration, as wacky and crazy as all these things are, if you don't need money for 15 or 20 years, yeah, this is going to be a very volatile ride. Tariffs are on, tariffs are off, tariffs are on. The implication that a lot of this is sort of hard to understand the reasoning and very, very variable. Hey, you got to look past 2028 and think about I don't need this money till 2034 or 2042. And so the next 5 or 10 years is not relevant to me.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 36:00 ↗
What do you think about another thing that we have seen, I think some of it very good, some of it really not great for investors, is over the last 10, 15 years there has been a huge amount of innovation both in terms of things that you can buy, for example, ETFs. They've been around longer than that, but like they were a real improvement in my opinion, for most people because of the way taxes got handled, because of the, you know, all of that. And then things that we did that you were one of our, you actually were our first, That's right. advisor to give us great advice where we build custom portfolios, and it turns out, we were chatting about it the other day, we thought it was all, everyone at O'Shaughnessy thought it was going to be, oh, people are going to be delighted that they can customize their portfolio, or, you know, if they're anti-smoking, they can get rid of all the tobacco stocks, and then when we saw it actually being used, what was number one with a bullet with number two way below, number one was tax alpha, tax management. I think that's a great innovation. What are some others that both good and bad that you've seen and give me your views on them?
Barry Ritholtz 37:25 ↗
Sure. And by the way, the genesis of this section in the book comes from the very amusing quip from former Fed chair Paul Volcker, who said, "There's been no innovation in finance other than the ATM." And while there was some elements of truth to that 25, 30 years ago, it clearly is no longer true. And I'll give you a handful of my favorite examples. So, first, it's not just ETFs, but it's the ability to explore any aspect of the world that you think has a possibility of being an interesting investing, and there's already some sort of ETF. I don't care if it's a microcap sleeve or a momentum sleeve or an emerging market small cap value, somebody has already done that. It's already out there. So, that's number one. Number two, and this is a double-edged sword, is the ability to trade for essentially free. Now, you and I both know that there's a little bit of a spread, and there's, you know, there is no free lunch. There is a cost to it. But spreads have narrowed. I started on a trading desk where regularly there were, and back then it was fractions. It wasn't even decimals. And it was eighths, quarters, and halves. Like, we used to joke, "Look at the spread. You could drive a truck through that." And you could make money if it was 11, you know, if it was a stock that was 24 by 25. I'm a buyer at 24 and an eighth, and I'm a seller at 24 and 7/8, and you would get filled. And eventually the market shrinks those spreads. Now, the spreads are tiny, so you're not paying up when you want to buy, you're paying down when you want to sell. And the cost for execution is next to nothing. In fact, since you brought up Canvas, I think we were one of the, we were, if we weren't the first, we were certainly one of the first clients. No, I think you actually were the first. the first, and I think we may still be the largest. We're of the, we're 1.5 out of almost... Our last ADV was five. We're really... The next ADV will probably have a higher handle on it, but we're about 25% of our assets, and the old way of doing tax-loss harvesting was kind of modest and kind of routine, and you were just taking the average of all your funds. The beauty of direct indexing is you get to open up the wrapper, reach inside, take the bottom 10-20% of the worst performers. Like, even in a year where the market's up 15%, you have a handful of stocks that are down 10, 20, 30% or more. Sell those, replace them with something that quantitatively looks very simple. Hey, it's this size, it's this sector, it's this valuation. Find me something similar. And so, capturing those losses on paper, but replacing it with something very similar, it's been a game-changer, especially for people who are sitting on, you know, if you're in any of the, forget even Magnificent Seven, it's like the top 50 stocks, you're sitting on massive gains. A founder stock, IPO shares, low cost basis, inherited stock, employee stock option plan. You know, if you get someone an extra 50 basis points over the benchmark or you underperform by 50 basis points, people kind of shrug it off. But regardless of the size of someone's portfolio and if you say, hey, you know, we managed to reduce your ordinary income tax versus the capital gains that you have by 50 or $100,000, oh my god, it's the greatest thing since sliced bread. Nobody is happy sending a big check to Uncle Sam. It takes it... Listen, you have this windfall and it takes a little of the joy out of it that 20 plus, about 4% goes to Uncle Sam. And if you have the ability to say, by the way, you have all these unrealized losses that we were able to realize on paper without affecting your portfolio and now your million dollars in capital gains from all the Nvidia you've sold is only going to be 750,000, so we've saved you, you know, do the math, $80,000 in taxes, they're like, this isn't crazy Wesley Snipes stuff. This is not... No, no, this is all IRS guideline approved, black letter law. The IRS has signed off on this. Everybody's happy with this. This is just straightforward. So, that's another innovation. Just to show you how much the world has changed. And let me again reiterate the free trading and on apps like that have gamified trading on like Robinhood, I think that's a negative. Just go back and look at all the 2020 and 2021 Instagrams and I love the Twitter feed, TikTok investors, and you see the incredibly reckless, irresponsible things that people say without any guardrails, without any gatekeepers. And unfortunately, it got so bad that the IRS literally had to put out a list of things that aren't true. You know, if it turns out that if you're out on a boat in international waters on April 15th, you still got to pay taxes. That's bad advice. And that's sort of crazy. Crap, the IRS literally put out 42 things or 39 things that are not true that keep showing up on social media. I link to, I think it's a footnote, the actual URL in the book. But there's so much of this has really become positive. For first, your ability to just... I told the story the other day when we used to do our quarterly updates to clients, we'd have to print out everybody's results. Then you'd have to print out a run of labels, sticky labels, and then you got to goddamn make sure the right account goes to the right person. And it was like a week of work. And now, everybody can see their actual performance year-to-date, week-to-date, tick by tick, since inception versus benchmark. It's just software, it's easy as pie. Moving money has become much easier. I rebuilt a truck down in Colombia to... send money internationally used to be expensive and time consuming. And now there are apps like World Remit or Remitly where you can move, you know, $10,000 at a time and it's again, it's IRS compliant, it's know your client compliant. It does all the checks, all the boxes it's supposed to. The other downside of all this progress is we are continually playing catch-up and playing defense in the arms race against cybercrime. And that's, you know, the fact that we've moved everything online, people sometimes forget how dangerous a place it can be. So that's another form of education where you're constantly saying to clients, here's the password, here's the safe word, here's how, like if we get a phone call and someone says transfer all this money over here, blah blah blah, like there are certain things they have to do for that to happen. And it just continually gets more and more stringent. We're constantly educating people. I just put up a link, I don't remember if it was today or yesterday, but teach your parents who are targets of scammers and fraudsters, anytime they get an unsolicited phone call from somebody that asks them for information, say, what company are you...
calling from? Great, I'm going to look up the number and call you back. And even something as simple as that, I got a phone call from my bank the other day. And I'm like, hey, why are you calling me? Well, we saw some activity on your account. I'm like, great. The number on the back of the credit card, is that where I can reach you? Yes. Hang up, call them back. Hey, can I have so-and-so in this department? And it's just simple things like that.
So, whereas there are just endless innovations in terms of software, the trading and it is a golden age for investors. You can get exposure to not just the local market, but an international market for hundredths of a basis point. It costs you nothing to trade. It costs you no minimum at most custodians. You can do all these things. It's so easy. Just make sure you're aware of the risks that happen that are the other side of the double-edged sword. The free trading or the fact that you can so easily see your accounts and access money and move it means you have to be extra vigilant against fraud and scams.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 47:02 ↗
Yeah. Um, they've even got some voice cloners now. And really? For you and I who have such public voices...
Barry Ritholtz 47:09 ↗
Yeah, everybody and same with my partner Josh, everybody in the firm is told that if you get an angry call from me or Josh insisting you do something, call the other one and find out if it's real. Because half the time these are, you know, public figures and AI, you can make them say anything.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 47:30 ↗
Yeah. And I've had that demonstrated and it's really freaky. A little scary. An acquaintance called me with my voice.
Barry Ritholtz 47:42 ↗
Oh, really? You know, the old scam was calling grandma, 'Grandma, I got arrested. I need money for bail. Mom and dad aren't answering.' Like that was literally an email scam and now it's a voice scam.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 47:57 ↗
Yeah, and it's funny because I'm always trying to think countermeasures. How are we going to defeat the grifters and the scammers because they're very clever and it's the preying on the weakest part of society that just boils my blood.
Barry Ritholtz 48:17 ↗
100%. These people have, you know, scraped and saved, invested and then, you know, all of it goes away. And I think that's really good advice for your clients.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 48:28 ↗
I was thinking as I was listening a little earlier, you started on a trading floor. And how was your transition from a trader mentality, which requires a really different kind of skill set than an investor mentality? How did you walk me through that transition? Did something happen?
Barry Ritholtz 48:52 ↗
It was gradual. First, I loved being a trader. And back in the '90s, they threw everybody in the deep end of the pool. Whoever didn't drown, hey, you're a trader. Congratulations.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 49:02 ↗
Exactly.
Barry Ritholtz 49:04 ↗
I don't really think of myself as particularly self-aware. I tend to think of myself as a little more oblivious than that. However...
Jim O'Shaughnessy 49:13 ↗
Welcome to the club, by the way.
Barry Ritholtz 49:15 ↗
And listen, we all have our own neuropathies and some of us are a little more neuroatypical than others. But you want to learn how to use your personal advantages and disadvantages to best effect. And one of the things I was kind of fascinated by was why does all these guys, and back then it was all guys, on a long desk, you know, and there were rows of them, why do the results vary so much from person to person and even from month to month? So, he's killing it this month and the next month he can't trade his way out of a paper bag. This guy is making a ton of money this month, then... And so, I got really lucky in, I want to say it was like '96 or '97, I read a book from Cornell Professor Thomas Gilovich called 'How We Know What Isn't So'.
Jim O'Shaughnessy 50:11 ↗
Certainly.
Barry Ritholtz 50:12 ↗
The first two-thirds of it is just a deep dive into why we make all these emotional errors, and why that's so. You know, you call it the OS, I call it the wetware. Why is it evolutionarily built into our operating system? And it kind of sent me down... and I want to say that book was like '91 or '93. Like, probably the first major book on behavioral finance that was published, unintentionally about behavioral finance. And so I kind of learned how to ask different traders, 'Tell me why you like this position. Tell me why you keep adding to it as it goes up.' Or I have a vivid... Do you remember the MicroStrategy collapse in the late '90s, when it was a fake note? Someone figured out how to get Yahoo to publish notes, and the stock got collapsed. And I watched this guy just keep buying the whole way down. The company comes out, it's a fake. This isn't us. And the guy who actually released it eventually got arrested. And the stock was like 120, and it had fallen to 20 or 30, some crazy number. And it recovered to like 60 or 70. There still was some stink on it. But the guy who was doubling up and tripling up all the way down, like I was fascinated by his risk-taking. And hey, what happens if this is true, and it opens up, and it's down 20 from where your last buy? He's like, 'I'm out of the business.' Hey, do you really want to engage in that sort of existential risk-taking? Does that make sense? He goes, 'Well, at the time I wasn't thinking about the risk.'

31 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Ritholtz, B. (2025, March 27). Barry Ritholtz — Make Fewer Errors, Make More Money | Episode 261 [Interview transcript]. Infinite Loops. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3277037/

MLA

Barry Ritholtz. "Barry Ritholtz — Make Fewer Errors, Make More Money | Episode 261." Infinite Loops, 27 Mar. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3277037/.

BibTeX
@misc{ritholtz2025_3277037,
  author       = {Barry Ritholtz},
  title        = {Barry Ritholtz — Make Fewer Errors, Make More Money | Episode 261},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Infinite Loops. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {mar},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3277037/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}