Top of the morning, Dan Proft here, and Larry Fink's, BlackRock's Larry Fink sat down with our friend Bret Baier. Larry Fink, over the last several years, the biggest proponent, in a thuggish manner oftentimes, of pushing ESG and all the associated noxious acronyms dressed up as public policy. Identitarian politics and neo-Marxist economic policy all dressed up as do-gooderism. Actually, it's even worse than that. Which is why it's really tough to listen to this guy, because he's just an inveterate rent seeker on both ends of the deal, trying to push bad government public policy and then capture the benefits of the government putting its finger on the scale for his clients and their bad investments at the expense of real market economics and people that don't have the, that aren't part of the combined sway that Fink has because they're not big players. He's really, to me, a disreputable figure. But because he commands, you know, billions and billions, or trillions—well, well, no, not trillions, but I don't think, but hundreds of billions of dollars in assets to deploy, you know, people dance to the tune that he's playing. So, what about ESG? Reflecting on the last five years as it has subsided, the zeitgeist behind it has subsided in recent years, particularly since Trump's election.
Do you believe the woke era a failed experiment? The ESG, the DEI, the kind of push for that. That when you talk about things now, you talk in a practical sense, what we can do, what we can get done. Looking back at that, how do you see it?
Society moves, the pendulum moves all the time. In BlackRock's case, you know, we are responsible for managing money for everybody. And even today, as you said, maybe these, you know, renewables are less talked about. I can tell you right now, we have many investors worldwide investing in renewables, trying to emphasize solar and other things like that to try and... We're working with Occidental Petroleum right now to build the best carbon capture factories in Texas right now. So, do I believe the pendulum five years ago was too far? Yes. Do I believe we're more pragmatic? You know, I'm personally more pragmatic, too. And I believe...
But do you think BlackRock pushed some companies a little bit further left than you thought?
It was never our intention, because our job is to be—I'm going to be a fiduciary to everybody who gives us money. Our responsibility, Bret, is to making sure if one of our investors wants to invest 100% in hydrocarbons in Texas, I'm investing 100% of the money in Texas. But if another state fund wants us to invest in, let's say, all green energy, we're going to do that. It's their money. But today, because of AI and the overwhelming need for power and electricity, it can't just be one way right now. Can't just be hydrocarbons. So if you see what even what China is doing right now, China is rapidly building more nuclear than any other country in the world. They have the largest solar fields in the world, yet they're the biggest importer of gas and oil. And so, to me, more importantly today, I think society has moved into a better position of having more pragmatism, and what you're hearing from me is I'm echoing what we're hearing from our clients.
What a fork-tongued... By the way, my first instinct was right. I just looked up $13 trillion under management, BlackRock. $13 trillion. The only time I was wrong was when I thought I was wrong. Text 2247. This guy figured out how to take shareholder voting power from ETFs and other mutual funds and use it for his own desires and power. Yeah, that's a good summation, too. That's just part of his portfolio, if you will. For more on this topic and others, pleased to be joined by Don Boudreaux, American economist, author, professor, co-director of the program on the American economy and globalization at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Don, thanks for joining us. Appreciate it.
Do you share my low opinion of Larry Fink despite all of his power and money?
Yeah, yeah, very much. ESG is just a sham. I mean, it's what he's trying to say. You can, if you earn the money, you can invest it in whatever way you want. But the vast majority of people want money invested in a way that's going to make maximum returns for them, and there's nothing wrong with that. Those market signals indicate where resources are best used and where they're not used. If there was a great demand among wealth owners to have their resources wasted on ESG products, you wouldn't need to have people like Larry Fink go around the country promulgating ESG. The market would supply it. It's just terrible. I mean, the...
Well, that's—I mean, sorry to interrupt, but that's just what's so difficult to listen to him. Like, I'm just a guy who, you know, I got some investor comes and says, 'Hey, Larry, I want to invest in switchgrass facilities to produce energy in central Texas.' I say, 'Well, if that's what you want to do, I'm just here to pass through your money to whatever investment you want.' Give me a break.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's—I mean, ESG, I'm glad it is on the wane, and I wish it would completely disappear. It's a solution to a non-existing problem, and that solution creates problems by allowing corporate decision-makers to escape having to maximize returns for their shareholders. It gives corporate decision-makers a lot of leeway to do whatever the heck they want to do. It frees them from the discipline of the market. That's good for corporate decision-makers. It's good for people like Larry Fink. It's bad for people whose money is on the line, and it's bad for the economy.
Well, and the way he got away with it, it seems to me, is sort of backdoor industrial policy. Like, I'll get the government to prop up these investments so that there's limited downside for you, and that's where we put your money. So you're insulated, and we're moving the flag in the policy direction I want to move it.
Yes, that's exactly correct. That's exactly correct. By avoiding market signals, it replaces those signals with the whims and the fancies of people like Larry Fink and industrial policy advocates, and then it's good for them, but it's bad for the rest of us.
All right. Well, this is a good lesson in economics, and I read your piece with interest, reflections on your four decades of teaching economics or teaching Econ 101. So let me play you a clip and see if this high school English teacher in Kansas City is reflective of your current experience teaching Econ 101. I can't believe it's this bad, but you never know. This is an English teacher in Kansas City reflecting on her students' comments on Romeo and Juliet, which I don't think they're reading. I think they're watching a version of it. That's even more depressing. Here it is.
High School English Teacher
7:56 ↗
I teach high school English, specifically freshman, and we are in the middle of reading Romeo and Juliet. These are a few of the things my students have said about the story thus far. Was there time back then? Like, did it exist when Romeo and Juliet were alive? Oh, so you actually hate us. I had asked them to get the books out. Is Shakespeare a real person? Because I thought he was maybe one of those Greek gods, so I've been confused. Bro's a hella stalker. This is in regard to Romeo. Bro also has bad rizz. Oh, he wants that hottie hus, huh? This is about Romeo pursuing Juliet. Romeo is hella cringe. Get him off my screen. And finally, we don't need subtitles. We're not old.
Thank you. Now, to be fair, this English teacher, a freshman high school English teacher, she has she/her pronouns on her profile, too. So I'm not sure she's doing the Bard any great service in trying to transmit his work to the next generation. But I'm just wondering if that is similar to you trying to explain the idea of there is no free lunch to 18-year-olds, to freshmen in college.
I'm happy to report that I've never encountered a student quite that bad.
Yeah. I have students who, you know, some are better than others. But look, economics is fairly straightforward. And if you teach it in a straightforward way, anybody of ordinary intelligence can get it. And my students have ordinary intelligence. Now, I will say I've seen over the years a decline in their ability or willingness to apply brain power to carry through a train of reasoning. I don't really blame it on social media, because I saw it before social media was really a thing. I blame it on the poor quality of government schooling, which I think is getting worse. But it's still the case that you take a person of ordinary intelligence, even someone who hasn't been well educated by the government schools that they went to, and you teach economics to them well and clearly, they will get it. They will get it. Some of them, I think, get it more deeply than others, but most get it.