CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
John Spencer
Executive Director, Urban Warfare Institute; Chair of Urban Warfare Studies, Modern War Institute at West Point, Urban Warfare Institute

War Expert Debunks Gaza Lies - John Spencer

📅 Aug 17, 2025 Triggernometry 77 MIN 891075 VIEWS 74 SEGMENTS · 3 SPEAKERS
John Spencer is a retired U.S. Army Major and leading expert on urban warfare, known for his frontline experience, strategic insights, and influential writing on modern combat in cities. Triggernometry is proudly independent. Thanks to the sponsors below for making that possible: Hirsch Organic Grass Fed Beef Organ Supplement: Triggernometry exclusive 10% off at https://hirschorganic.com/pages/trigger Protect your wealth with The Pure Gold Company. Get your free investor guide at https://pure-gold.co/trigger Grab your free seat to the 2-Day AI Mastermind: https://link.outskill.com/TRIGGERN...

Questions asked in this interview

10
  1. 5:54... big picture, in your opinion, what is the correct frame and way of looking at what's happening in Gaza and Israel's war in Gaza that people who don't understand military conflict, particularly urban warfare, probably don't understand?
  2. 8:35What are some of the contentious issues that people keep claiming that you don't agree with?
  3. 26:23Could these women be combatants as well?
  4. 32:40But John, can I just interrupt you there?
  5. 37:24Was there a three-month aid and food blockade by the IDF preventing food and aid entering Gaza?
  6. 42:41But my question to you is, which is what I'd like to ask them really, is what is now being achieved by continuing this war? What is the rationale here?
  7. 1:02:10But John, is it, I can't believe I'm asking this question, but is it actually possible to defeat an enemy that refuses to say that it's defeated?
  8. 1:03:32How long is this going to take? How will this end?
  9. 1:11:46We are at war, but we do not use this type of language or rhetoric.' And Marjorie Taylor Greene, I think a) you were right to describe her as crazy, you didn't need to correct yourself, but b) she's not in the cabinet, right?
  10. 1:14:50Before we do though, the last question in all our interviews as you well know is what is the one thing that we're not talking about as a society that we really should be?
John Spencer 0:02 ↗
I'm fine if people are anti-war. I'm not fine if people are anti-fact. Nobody's ever built 300 miles of tunnels underneath their civilians for the sole purpose of using their civilians as a shield and as a sacrifice. Every individual in Gaza could fit in Hamas's tunnels with ease. Why is it that Israel is held to not one double standard but a whole list of double standards in war that no other nation in history has ever been held to?
Interviewer 0:31 ↗
What is the goal now by pursuing this conflict in this way? It alienates a whole generation of future Western decision makers, and that is a reality that Israeli politicians have to reckon with, surely.
Narrator 0:43 ↗
Relax, relax. This is not an ad. I just wanted to let you know that you can watch this video without any advertising at all. No interruptions, no pop-ups, nothing. Just go to triggerpod.co.uk or click the link below and join thousands of our supporters who watch all our interviews with exclusive bonus content ad-free.
Interviewer 1:05 ↗
John Spencer, welcome to Trigonometry.
John Spencer 1:07 ↗
Well, thanks for having me. Longtime viewer, longtime fan.
Interviewer 1:10 ↗
Well, appreciate that. Um, you're one of the world's leading experts on urban combat and urban warfare, which is why we want to have you on in the context of what's happening in Gaza. Obviously, you messaged me somewhat irate after our last couple of interviews on Israel with Piers Morgan and Andrew Fox. You had a lot of disagreements. Before we get into all of that and your perspective on what's happening, and perhaps answering some of the questions that those two guests raised that we as non-experts are not able to address, tell everybody a little about your background and what gives you the ability to talk about these issues with some authority.
John Spencer 1:44 ↗
Sure. So my name is John Spencer. I'm the chair of urban warfare studies at the Modern War Institute. Also executive director of the Urban Warfare Institute. I spent 25 years active duty US Army as an infantry soldier and then officer, two combat tours to Iraq. I did the invasion and then I was there during the height of the sectarian violence in 2008 in Baghdad, to include the Battle of Sadr City. I don't rest on my own experiences though. I've been studying urban warfare for over a decade. I started in the Pentagon actually in a research group and advisory role to our top four general of the US Army in the Pentagon. After that tour, where we were looking at large cities like megacities, I moved to West Point, the United States Military Academy, where I was teaching strategy, leadership, military tactics in echelon. But really that strategy class has helped me a lot since then. I started a research center called the Modern War Institute as a co-founder of that and started writing a lot about urban warfare. Now I have three books. I started a podcast, although I don't consider myself a podcaster. Not that that's a bad thing. I've been doing it for over six years, interviewing top commanders of past battles, technical experts, veterans. I've started in a research role though since 2018 really. I've been traveling the world, going into combat zones, using different research methodologies like ethnographic, you know, basically getting on the ground in combat areas and recording what's happening and then the lessons that other people can take from it. So I write case studies on past wars. So I've covered most urban battles of the past, from Stalingrad to most of the battles of urban of World War II, actually walking the ground of battlegrounds. I went into Ukraine weeks after Russia withdrew from Kyiv and been into Ukraine four times, Azerbaijan to study their wars, India, and then Israel of course. So I've been to Israel now five times, four times embedded with the IDF actually with the commanders, with the division commanders and others. I've interviewed the prime minister three times, the defense minister, the head of the IDF, the chief of staff, multiple numerous commanders, observed them in the field. And I didn't start studying war on October 7th, and that's unique in some aspects to other people who we call who have opinions. I didn't start studying Israel on October 7th, and I sure heck didn't start studying war. I had been going in and out of Israel for years, writing case studies, writing research reports on their past urban battles from the 1973 battle of Suez City, the first intifada, second intifada, ancient Jerusalem battle, etc. So I consider myself knowledgeable in urban warfare, but to be honest, in order to understand Gaza, you have to understand a little bit of history on what's come before. And I've studied a lot of urban battles and I can help provide people like, it's really weird what you're saying about Israel here and all the double standards. But you also have to have an understanding of things like civilian harm mitigation, which are the steps that militaries have taken even over the last 20 or 30 years to protect civilians. And I've been arguing with groups in the United Nations. I've spoken multiple times at the United Nations and with UN humanitarian groups about how do you help protect civilians in urban warfare, but also the law. So then you have that part where you have to understand the full nature of the laws of war, from what is the humanitarian requirements of the attacker to like what munitions can you and can you not use. And I've been writing, podcasting, and researching all of those topics. So I think I have some information to share about what's going on in Gaza, but also to give people the framework, because we have a lot of people that say things either that are just wrong, and we can talk about some of those people, or just that are not informed by an actual research methodology.
Interviewer 5:54 ↗
Well, it's great to have you on the show because of your knowledge and expertise. I was going to say I'm surprised how much hair you have given that you've probably been tearing a lot of it out with the way that this conflict's been covered. So, broad perspective, big picture, in your opinion, what is the correct frame and way of looking at what's happening in Gaza and Israel's war in Gaza that people who don't understand military conflict, particularly urban warfare, probably don't understand?
John Spencer 6:23 ↗
Absolutely. That's an amazing first question. The framework is war, right? So although Hamas is a non-state actor, the law of war actually covers an internationally armed conflict or a non-internationally armed conflict, and I know you had Natasha Halldorf to try to explain the framework of the legal. What the world has been doing though has been applying a counterterrorism, counterinsurgency framework to Hamas because there is a heuristic of, you know, this is what people know, this is whether they understand Iraq, Afghanistan, the battles against ISIS, they keep considering Hamas a terrorist fight, a counterterrorism fight. And that's not the framework. That's not in any way the framework. On October 7th, the terror army that was Hamas's military and other terrorist groups and a whole lot of civilians from Gaza invaded southern Israel. Israel waged war in accordance with the framework of nations against Hamas as the political and military apparatus of the area of Gaza. Although it's not a nation, so this isn't a nation on nation conflict. It's a nation against a non-state actor, but also very unique in the context of it, unlike others, right? All these other frameworks that people talk about, and this is really where I've been playing whack-a-mole to people's analogies, people's comparisons, is like, why are you comparing this to Iraq battles? Why are you comparing this to ISIS battles? I mean, those are all insurgencies within nations where the US or others are helping even a host nation fight an insurgency. It's the wrong framework. So at the very top is war. You have to frame it in the way of war. Now, how do people compare it? And I can give you all kinds of comparisons that you probably haven't heard of that are more applicable to Gaza than anybody else is using. And it's crazy. And I've tried to help people understand that from the size of the military, the terrain of Gaza, there are some very unprecedented aspects of this where there is no comparison. And I can make really bold claims. I'm sure we'll talk about them. Like this has never happened in war before.
Interviewer 8:35 ↗
So explain all of this, John. What are you talking about? What makes this conflict unique? What are some of the particular challenges that the Israeli Defense Force faces? What are some of the contentious issues that people keep claiming that you don't agree with?
John Spencer 8:54 ↗
Well, I don't know if we have enough time to go through all the contentious issues.
Interviewer 8:58 ↗
That's right.
John Spencer 9:00 ↗
So the number one things, let's talk about the things that are unique in war. Gaza. Gaza is a very unique situation. Hamas. So unlike any other comparison, Gaza is a small area relatively. It's 25 miles long. And sorry, I don't do the kilometers. 25 miles long, 5 to 7 miles wide. It's a really relatively small area, but it actually has 24 cities. It has multiple cities of over 600,000, if not a million. You're talking about Gaza City. It's not a battle. It's a war. But there I can't find any other situation, again because I've studied urban warfare for over a decade and I have a little military service myself, where the enemy defender has prepared the ground for 20 years for that battle. Most urban battles, from Stalingrad to Aachen to Fallujah, all of these things are meeting engagements where the enemy gets inside the urban area or is there and then for a short amount of time prepares it for a battle. And we can talk about some of the numbers of previous battles. But the fact that Hamas spent billions of dollars and prepared every bit of Gaza for war is unique. And that means if you're an attacker, again, if you just take the word Israel out of this and give the context of the war, there is no parallel. There is no parallel to the 300 to 400 miles of tunnels underneath every urban area in Gaza and connecting them all. There are tunnels around the world, and I've studied the Vietnam War from, you know, the tunnels of Cu Chi to the tunnels currently in North Korea and China. Nobody's ever built 300 miles of tunnels underneath their civilians for the sole purpose of using their civilians as a shield and as a sacrifice. That's their strategy. And I know other people have talked to you about that, is that Hamas wants its population to be killed. That's also unique. The Nazis didn't do that. The Japanese didn't do that. Even ISIS didn't say, 'Look, my strategy is to get my people killed and then hope that the international world community stops Israel short of victory.' The aspect of the size of the enemy, right? I can hopefully we'll talk about a couple of the previous battles that people use to do some type of comparison. Hamas was estimated to be 30 to 40,000 fighters on October 8th. That's just Hamas. As you have heard as well, there are other combatants that join the fight in other terrorist organizations in Gaza. You have the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, you have Lion's Den, you have like 14 other terrorist groups. And this is where a major contentious thing I have is people calling combatants and civilians. In my world and in the law of war, there's combatants and there's non-combatants. A non-combatant can turn themselves into a combatant more easily than people think. You don't just have to shoot at the IDF or whoever to become a combatant. If you hold hostages, if you report on intelligence, if you carry ammunition, whole list of reasons. But just the size of the enemy in Gaza in a 20-year prepared defense is what it is, is very unique and was going to make the IDF challenge astronomically hard to even get to the enemy. The other aspect I would have liked to save it till the end is that there's never been a war, and you've challenged people on this, where the civilian population is forced to stay inside of the main combat areas. The fact that Egypt on October 8th said not one person comes out of Gaza towards the Sinai desert. Just from a military analysis, let alone a political analysis, I can't find that ever happening. Right? You in Ukraine, which I've been there, 3 to 5 million people left areas, massive civilian displacement in areas that Russia invaded. Even still today, Syria, every war, every war, the civilians get out of harm's way so that the militaries can have their fight and there be safeguarded or even move to humanitarian areas. Those are just the variables that before the war even actually starts, before the ground invasion starts, before the bombing starts, every aspect of the war against Hamas and Gaza is unique and there is no parallel. Hopefully we'll talk about the double standards, but I can keep going because that's the other uniqueness. As I've studied, again, I'm currently studying other wars. There's no other war where Israel, if you put the word Israel in it, then there's a whole different standard in what can be done, the way they assess the war, the state, you know, the false claims of war crime, genocide, all these things contrary to what Israel does. This is all very unique. But war is a contest of will. So you had to get into, okay, fine, but how do you defeat Hamas? Even that standard, right? So the idea that Israel was supposed to have a day after plan in Gaza in October of 2023, like what? Okay, fine. What's your plan? That would be like saying, okay, you know, you started against Japan and your goal is to defeat Japan, but what's your day after plan? No, you have to defeat the enemy. You have to take his power and then you start to work on post-conflict operations. Every aspect, the number one thing that I've been fighting since October 8th though has been this counting obsession. It's all a version of, which is a great book, 'Lies, Damn Lies and Statistics', where the goal is to make any number as big as a number to make it as big as a problem. And for this war it's been a global problem and it's just repeating the number that comes from a terrorist organization. As somebody who studies war for a living, there's never been a single battle in history, not a war but a battle, in which there is a running daily count of how many civilians are dying down into the single digit coming from the enemy inside the battle, coming from Hamas. And the reason that is, is because it's impossible to know how many civilians are dying. And all these other battles I can tell you about, years later they still don't know how many civilians died. But the idea inside of Gaza, and there's all kinds of these nefarious actors who are trying to invent ways to validate Hamas's casualty numbers, if not say, 'No, Hamas is not right, it's actually more.' It's crazy that this statistical war, that this is how many civilians are dying and how many combatants are dying. There's never been a military in history in any war who's ever been asked, 'Look, I know your war is just, your goals are just, but what's your civilian to combat ratio?' Because that's not the way the law works. That's not the way war works. And you would actually give people, every terrorist organization around the world, a recipe for success. Oh, just make the number as high as you can. And it wasn't like this is the first time. Again, if you started studying war on October 7th, you could probably imagine like all kinds of stuff. This is the worst I've ever seen. Okay. Have you studied any other war? Have you ever studied any other humanitarian aid operations? No. Okay, then I can show you other times when it's worse and worse and worse and the numbers in the chaos, even though the context of Gaza is so unique that the world won't even acknowledge it. Right? So the fact that going back to Egypt, and I just interviewed the Minister of Defense again to validate that in the last 21 months, not one delegation, not one nation, especially the UK, have ever brought up the topic of what about Egypt? Couldn't we move the civilians out of harm's way? Couldn't we get them out of Hamas's hands and set up a humanitarian area in the Sinai? Not one delegation brought that up. So you have to ask the question, why is that? Why is it that Israel is held to not one double standard, but a whole list of double standards in war that no other nation in history has ever been held to or would be if it happened to them?
Interviewer 16:54 ↗
But John, there's a lot to unpack in what you're saying. But on the Egypt thing, I would imagine what the pro-Palestine people, so to speak, would say is what Israel really wants, I mean Piers Morgan said this on our show, what Israel really wants is to displace the civilians from Gaza, is to get rid of the Palestinian Arabs who live there. Therefore, they would love nothing more than for those people to flee to other countries. And the reason that the neighboring countries don't want that to happen, a, they already have hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from previous eruptions of this conflict. We know that in many countries to which those groups of people have fled, that has caused a lot of instability. Egypt is a poor country with its own security problems. And so they don't want to play into Israel's hands and facilitate Israeli, quite, ethnic cleansing on the one hand. And on the other hand, they do not want to destabilize their own societies.
Narrator 17:51 ↗
Organ meats are some of the most nutrient-dense foods on the planet, rich in B vitamins, iron, and bioavailable nutrients that most modern diets are missing. But let's be honest, most of us aren't about to start pan-frying liver every day. That's where Hersh Organic comes in. They make organic grass-fed organ meat supplements, liver, kidney, and heart from British cattle, freeze-dried to preserve everything your body needs. No fillers, no gimmicks, just real food in capsule form. Check them out at hershorganic.com/trigger. Adding Hersh to my routine was one of those quiet changes that ended up making a big difference. I wasn't looking for a miracle pill, just something foundational, and that's exactly what this is. If you're a parent trying to keep your energy up whilst looking after everyone else without living on caffeine. If you're coming off a restrictive diet and want to rebuild with real nourishment, not another hack. Or you're a busy professional who's tried every optimization trend and now just want something your body actually recognizes as food. This is for you. The reason I trust Hersh isn't just the product, it's the people. Hersh was founded by a mom who went deep into nutrition after her son was born. When she couldn't find clean, organic, convenient organ meat supplements that met her standards, she made them herself. This is a company that cuts no corners. They're fanatical about sourcing, transparent about every ingredient, and absolutely committed to health over hype. This is what real nourishment looks like. Check them out at hershorganic.com/trigger or find the link in the description of this episode.
John Spencer 19:28 ↗
Yeah. So, there's two things here. One, I can't help people that have BDS. So, not the boycott, divest, sanctioned awful thing that happens against Israel, but if you have Bibi derangement syndrome and you believe that he's just a, you know, the nefarious actor that's guiding all this, or if you have TDS, Trump derangement syndrome, I would point like you did recently to somebody going, 'Well, wait a minute. During World War II there's massive population displacement in every war actually.' And you could talk 2020 war of Nagorno-Karabakh, 23 war of Kharkiv, Ukraine, Syria, Yemen, population displacement is historically exactly what happens to get civilians out of harm's way. Now if you're, I'm not, you know, people want to put me in a bucket of pro-Israel or put other people in the bucket of pro-Palestine. I think that's not the right framework. I'm pro-truth and some people are anti-Israel, that becomes a fact. They actually don't care about Palestinians or the cause. So if somebody's so adamant that Israel just wants to eradicate people, it's been, you don't listen to the words of actually Israeli leaders like Minister Dermer who's the minister of strategic affairs who has said like in the beginning like absolutely you'll pass a UN security council resolution saying that the people can come back after Hamas is defeated. But mainly I would say, and I hope you can put it in a picture, take out a map. Look at where Gaza is and look at where the Sinai desert is and then look at where Egypt is. There's a massive area. So I think it's bollocks that that's the excuse that people give and one, historically it's never been the case. And they're actually prolonging the war. They're actually causing civilian death. All you would have to do on October 2023, right afterwards, Egypt launched an armor brigade and many other troops to the border to make sure no civilians got out. They built a new wall. There's actually three walls. They built a new wall to make sure that nobody got out. Now, if you're so adamant that you think that Israel, and there is this in a lot of these positions, there's this nefarious Israeli theory underneath it like, oh, they're not, they're trying to do things sneakily. They can't do it in the open. They have these ulterior motives. Like look, I look at it as a war objectively as possible. The fact that you say Israel because you think they're nefarious can't move the civilians out of the harm's way. You're not even, if you're United Nations and you want to create a humanitarian area where there won't be chaos, where Hamas won't cause the chaos, you could build a humanitarian area. And we're talking 2 million people. I fought in a neighborhood of Baghdad that has 2 million people. It isn't the scale that's the problem. It's the fact that this is Israel. So, of course, you can't create a, even if you want to create a fenced-in area in the Sinai desert where every international agency, every even international militaries or security forces could help provide security of that area. Well, no, no, this it's not an option because we believe Israel has nefarious goals. But I'll go to the double standard in war. If somebody starts a war and there is a response to that war, absolutely there is population displacement until the end of the war. And then if somebody's saying, well, the border shouldn't change either, right? So this everything should be the exact same as October 6 before Hamas, the government of Gaza and its military invaded Israel. People don't understand the second and third order effects of trying to create this standard because it's Israel because you believe you know the Israel-Palestine history which most people don't or what we call revisionist history where they try to invent the history of things that have happened. It's because it's Israel. So I say that that argument, right, I don't attack people, I attack their veracity of their statements and that just, you know, as one of my, the president said, that dog don't hunt, like your facts are not right that Israel can't do this and that the Trump plan, you to call the Trump plan ethnic cleansing is insanity. It is straight tedious that the movement of people to allow people to voluntarily leave somewhere where there is suffering, combat, awful things happening. But no, no, because it's Palestinians, you got to stay in there. That's insanity. And it needs to stop because if not, and what I write about a lot as well is like if you say this about Israel, are you just saying, well, well, this won't apply to us, you know, UK, France, whatever, this won't happen to us. We won't have to follow these rules. This is just, we just want Israel to follow these rules. Let me give you something that nobody I've ever seen on your show do is what would happen if this happened to the United States? You know, I could talk Britain as well. What would the United States do if an October 7 style attack? And I don't even have to do the comparative numbers, right? The fact that it's like 40,000 civilians dead and thousands taken hostages. The United States military would respond immediately with overwhelming force. And I have to give people a class on what is proportionality in war, like what is disproportionate. The United States would have responded to October 7th with amazing military force because we have 10 active divisions. We have the ability to dominate the sky. We would have made sure not a single rocket came out of enemy areas headed to our cities like Los Angeles. If you talk about the southern border, there were 4,000 rockets launched by Hamas on the morning of October 7th, and then there were about 8,000 more launched since then. The US military would have immediately invaded that territory to retrieve our hostages. It would have encouraged other countries and used all of our forms of national power to encourage them to allow people to get out of harm's way and we would have tried to end it as quickly as possible. And I think that's where people misunderstand. We would also have done the same things Israel is doing to try to protect civilians. And I have boldly said, and I challenge anybody prove me wrong, that Israel has done more to protect civilians as in the measures that any military has ever created in history. And because people don't know these, they don't, they haven't studied, these are called civilian harm mitigation measures. Israel has done more than any nation in history to include any Western nation. What they have done to protect civilians, we would have done some of those, but we would have immediately responded with overwhelming. That's the goal in war is to use overwhelming military force to convince your enemy to do your will as in to either give back the hostages, surrender, or you take what it values most, which is its population centers and its land. That's war. That's why the framework of this is all wrong.
Interviewer 26:23 ↗
John, I'm really glad that we're having this conversation because the old adage says the first casualty of war is the truth. And one of the difficulties that has been for me when I've been following this because we've been conducting these interviews and I'm sure everybody is working out what is true and what isn't. So let's talk about the casualties. How do we know that these casualties, the stats, are accurate or as accurate as they possibly can be? They say women and children killed. What do they mean by children? Does that mean up to the age of 18, 21? Women? Could these women be combatants as well? Explain a little bit more for us.
John Spencer 27:00 ↗
Sure. One, I've already explained that nobody in the history of wars, everyone asks, but what's your civilian to combat ratio? Nobody's ever taken the enemy's word on the casualty count. But fine, even if you took the enemy's casualty count, so Hamas, the Gaza Health Ministry, one, if you believe that there's a number or a story or a photo that leaves Gaza without the permission of Hamas, then you're just biased.
Interviewer 27:24 ↗
Mhm.
John Spencer 27:25 ↗
So, of the casualty counts, and I know I heard Piers Morgan say there's been 20,000 kids killed in Gaza, which is a lie. I really find it weird that people that are just anti-Israel will say numbers that even Hamas doesn't say.
Interviewer 27:40 ↗
You're absolutely right.
John Spencer 27:42 ↗
If we talk about children, right, because that's really where they go to. Like, John, I don't care that you say Israel has done more. They're not effective. I'm like, that's not true either. The Hamas Gaza Health Ministry numbers have been shown to be methodologically and statistically, even data-centrically wrong, full of errors, full of double names. Have you ever asked any of these people that use these numbers, have you seen the Gaza Health Ministry list of people who have died by natural causes? No, it doesn't exist. So, 20,000 kids supposedly, you're right, the United Nations puts kids at 18. So that's a list of people, anybody below the age of 18. I joined the military at 17. I would have been on that list. The fact that Hamas has radicalized the entire population and deploys child soldiers, they don't care. Nobody cares. But what about the babies, John? I'm like, okay, I absolutely agree. And this is the insanity of you want perfection in war. You want a bloodless war. The laws of war account for civilian death and say you have to take everything reasonable and feasible to prevent it, and Israel has done that. But back to the numbers, there is no way, and this is again, you have people, insane people, and I'm sorry that they're in the UK, who say they've figured out a way to figure out how many casualties have died. So they won't even take Hamas's numbers, right? Which again every statistic that has spread around the world has been shown to be false. That's not what Hamas says. You know, the majority women, majority children. False. False. The fact that they try to say, well, this many innocent civilians, and this is where I really, as an analyst of multiple wars, is that we believe, not me, but other people, that there is somebody in Gaza who can point to a body, even if it's an adult male, and say, 'Well, that person was a combatant and that person was not a combatant. They weren't partaking in the hostilities.' Is there civilian death in Gaza? Absolutely. It's a war. And Hamas wants, Hamas kills people themselves. I mean, over 20% of Hamas's rockets, so over 13,000 rockets they've launched at Israel, have landed inside of Gaza, killing Gazans. They go on the list. Really, anybody who's died for any reason goes on the list. If you were a Hamas terrorist who crossed the border into Israel to kill, slaughter, rape, and maim and died, you're on the list. The list is insane. But I and other people have picked it apart from a data perspective. I think it's insane that there's a fascination on the list when the actual question for any military other than Israel is, is the military following the laws of war in distinction, necessity, proportionality, and overwhelming? It is yes. There's actually not been a single case to be shown that Israel has targeted civilians. Has there been collateral damage? Yes. But here's some numbers in case people are so fascinated with the numbers, which I think is really problematic because again when you have a combatant, a non-state actor like Hamas who purposely doesn't wear a uniform, doesn't distinguish itself, just that, I mean, in Ukraine millions of civilians joined the fight against the Russian invasion and they wrap the yellow or blue tape around their arm. I don't know where they got all this tape, but they immediately distinguish themselves even if they're carrying ammunition or whatever as partaking in the hostilities. But let's talk about numbers, right? So everybody, I was getting the number early in the war like 10,000 people killed. I'm like, okay, it's a war that nobody's seen in modern history. All those variables, the size of the combatant, the dense urban areas. But there's only one battle in American history, I can't find one in British history, that has any of the parallels, as in the density of the urban terrain, the presence of civilians, a vicious enemy, and that's the 1945 Battle of Manila. I don't know if you know it. In 1945, after the US military was defeated in the Philippines, we returned and there were roughly 3 to 4,000 POWs and internees, so hostages, men, women, and children being held in the city of Manila, a city of about 1.1 million. There were 17,000 Japanese defenders. The US military attacked to retrieve our hostages and liberate the city with about 35,000 combatants. So this even the scale is not correct. In that battle, we retrieved our hostages, but again, 35,000 American and other attacking the city of 17,000 Japanese defenders. There were 100,000 civilians that died in that battle. And nobody made a New York Times op-ed that was on the cover saying too many civilians died in this war. Why was that? Well, because it's war. Because the Japanese were the ones who were slaughtering the civilians in that war. Or let me give you one other one. Again, this fascination with the numbers is crazy.
Interviewer 32:40 ↗
But John, can I just interrupt you there? I know you were saying this fascination with numbers is crazy. I do understand and from an academic perspective, I agree with you. But let's also be honest. You know, this is a war that has not just been fought on the battlefield. It's not just been fought diplomatically. It's also been fought in the modern day arena of social media. And there are millions of people all over the world, particularly in the West, who are having horrific images shown on their phones of horrendous suffering of civilians. So I know what you're saying, but also as well I do understand the fascination because if you've just seen a baby blown up, then that's going to be at the forefront of your mind, surely.
John Spencer 33:27 ↗
Absolutely. And again, if you started studying war on October 7th, you wouldn't realize that that is a uniqueness as well. Right. The fact that a war of this scale and of this viciousness is aired on the phones, the algorithm actually drives it to their phones. Every awful thing that's happened in war gets driven to the uninformed minds of massive populations. That is unique. And this is where, you know, if we would have had TikTok during even the Korean War, right? In the Korean War, over two million civilians died in the Korean War. It's a 37-month war. That's 50,000 civilians dying a month for every month of the war for 37 months. Had we had TikTok during that, of course, there would be something different. Had this not been Israel, there would be something different because they start with the image and like, that's awful. Israel did this on purpose and they don't want to listen to anybody with any contradictory information about why is this happening. And the idea that, well, of course it's awful. Look what's happening. And there are innocent civilians who are dying, but that's not the intention, which we could get to this baseless claim of genocidal intent. That is not the intention of the IDF in any way, shape, or form. It is actually the intention of Hamas. Do you realize that every individual in Gaza could fit in Hamas's tunnels with ease? There's over 400 miles of tunnels. All 2.2 million civilians could fit in those tunnels, but you've never seen an image of a single civilian in those. And I again, I do war around the world. In Ukraine the civilians sought refuge because Russia didn't give notice in the tunnels and they still do in the subways and all that to escape the awful attacks of Russia. So yes, you're right. Absolutely. There is a fascination again with Israel because I haven't seen protest about the awful things, and I don't do whataboutisms, but it's just, you know, actual veracity of comment. Where are you on the atrocities that are happening in Yemen, in Sudan, in all these other areas, even in humanitarian aid distribution? During the Somalia war, 200 to 300,000 people had died of starvation. And then the United Nations and others tried to get aid to the population and failed because the clans took it. They killed humanitarian aid workers. I'm fine if people are anti-war. I'm not fine if people are anti-fact on what is happening in Gaza.
Narrator 35:58 ↗
Let me introduce you to the people I work with to protect my family against financial instability, inflation, and turmoil. For me, one of the best ways to safeguard your wealth is by investing in gold. And that's why I trust The Pure Gold Company. Here's a tip. If you buy UK minted gold coins like sovereigns, you won't pay VAT when you buy them or capital gains tax when you sell them. All the profit is yours to keep. And the best part, gold is completely private investment. It's outside the banking system, so it can't be manipulated by government or anyone else. Unlike digital assets, it's yours in the truest sense. The Pure Gold Company is trusted by first-time investors and seasoned professionals alike. What I really appreciate about them is their knowledgeable, pressure-free approach. They explain everything clearly so you feel confident about your decisions and they never push you to buy. Physical gold has stood the test of time as a store of value and it offers peace of mind that other assets can't match. It's reassuring to know that even if the banking system falters, your gold and its value remain safe. Whether you're looking to diversify your investments, protect your savings, or just gain the security of owning a real physical asset, we highly recommend The Pure Gold Company. Click the link in the description or go to pure-gold.co/trigger to get your free copy of their investor guide. That's pure-gold.co/trigger. Take control of your financial future today.
Interviewer 37:24 ↗
So, and I'm glad we talked about the aid situation because again, explode any myths. I've been reading about this. This may be completely incorrect. Was there a three-month aid and food blockade by the IDF preventing food and aid entering Gaza?

26 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Spencer, J. (2025, August 17). War Expert Debunks Gaza Lies - John Spencer [Interview transcript]. Triggernometry. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3140404/

MLA

John Spencer. "War Expert Debunks Gaza Lies - John Spencer." Triggernometry, 17 Aug. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3140404/.

BibTeX
@misc{spencer2025_3140404,
  author       = {John Spencer},
  title        = {War Expert Debunks Gaza Lies - John Spencer},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Triggernometry. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {aug},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3140404/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}