CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
John Spencer
Executive Director, Urban Warfare Institute; Chair of Urban Warfare Studies, Modern War Institute at West Point, Urban Warfare Institute

Nuclear Iran “non-negotiable” for Trump says John Spencer as President makes decision

📅 May 26, 2026 MirYam Institute 58 MIN 762 VIEWS 34 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
World renowned warfare expert, John Spencer, joins MirYam CEO and IDF combat veteran, Benjamin Anthony, for a major situational briefing on the increasingly fragile Iran ceasefire, renewed US military action in the Strait of Hormuz, Hezbollah escalation in Lebanon and why both Washington and Jerusalem may believe time is running short for negotiations. US President Donald Trump insists a deal with the Tehran regime is close but a bad deal won't fly and Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon. The discussion examines the latest US strikes on Iranian boats accused of laying sea mines near the Strait...

Questions asked in this interview

7
  1. 3:00Do you expect any of that to come as a result of this latest engagement?
  2. 5:19You're referring to the American side of this negotiation, right?
  3. 6:13The muted terms of the deal and the pressures or the engagement by Arab and regional forces with the Americans at this time?
  4. 14:31... to establish between the Iranian front and the Lebanese front both when it comes to Iran's pursuit of nuclear weapons, all of the negotiations that are taking place attendant to that and of course it's proxy right on Israel's border?
  5. 23:34... as though we don't have that, as though we don't actually have the ability to take control of the skies, as though we don't actually have the ability to take over Kharg Island, as though we don't have the ability to sustain a blockade?
  6. 36:38... and readiness to actually go in and destroy and bring about an end to this threat, and not let the Iranians act, talk, and negotiate as though they've won this military campaign against the United States and against the state of Israel?
  7. 48:06... unlikely if you wish, what do you think is the likelihood that we might have some more muscular diplomacy that deals with the relocation of the Gazan population en masse away from Israel's towns, cities, kibbutzim, and citizenry?
John Spencer 0:00 ↗
From what I know at the moment that we're talking, this event won't take us off of that effort, which does have a short fuse or short timeline, in my opinion, of the President of the United States thinks he's close. We think we're close, and they're going to let that play out until we hit, like we did, actually, if people remember, right before Operation Epic Fury on February 28th, and right before restarting operations in the past. This isn't the old regimes or old administrations of just continuing negotiations on forever.
Benjamin Anthony 0:37 ↗
Welcome, everybody, to this episode of the Benjamin Anthony Show, a product of the Miriam Institute, and I'm delighted to be joined by in-house analyst at the Miriam Institute and world-renowned military scholar John Spencer to discuss all that is worthy of discussion today, on May 26, 2026. John, great to have you with us. I want to dive right in. Give our listeners, if you would, a brief overview of the recent engagement by US forces against Iran in what Iran, of course, is, as it's wont to do, describing as a blatant breach of the current ceasefire.
John Spencer 1:20 ↗
Well, hi, Benjamin. It's great to be back with you. As of last night, we've gotten information about Central Command US forces engaging Iranian boats that they say were in violation of, you know, just freedom of navigation in general that I deeply believe is the foundation of the American economy and global economy. But in conjunction with, you know, the temporary ceasefire of Operation Epic Fury, CENTCOM says these Iranian boats were laying mines, sea mines, in the Strait of Hormuz, so they engaged them and then ended it at that. That's what we know thus far. Of course, we live in the world of speculation online of everybody, but that's the official statement from CENTCOM, and we're in a really we've been in multiple weeks of in relation to that event, we're in a wait-and-see period on is there something larger to it? And of course, there is a lot of plausible deniability between the Islamic regime in Iran, and there had been in the past of well, that wasn't us or you know, whatever. But that's what we know so far. I don't think in what CENTCOM says is not a return to combat operations. It is a actually upholding of the ceasefire blockade status that the United States has imposed on the Strait of Hormuz. While you have a lot of rhetoric and talk coming from voices or accounts in the Islamic regime, that's where we think the situation is at the moment.
Benjamin Anthony 3:00 ↗
And do you expect at all that the Iranians will use this as an opportunity to re-intensify their attacks either on US ordnance in the region or the various Gulf states that they've repeatedly attacked by way of their missile program? Do you expect any of that to come as a result of this latest engagement?
John Spencer 3:21 ↗
I don't think so. I think we're still at the negotiation table. I don't think I try not to do predictions, as you know, of the fog of war, what we don't know. Everything from hearing about Saudi Arabia and UAE involved in previous direct attacks on Iran. There's so much that we don't know. I think this was just a moment, and that the priority of effort with lots of countries, actually, not just the United States, Islamic regime in Iran, and Israel, I think there's lots of countries involved. There's some that I don't think are good partners to have involved, but it is what it is. At the negotiation tables trying to get to a term of agreement with a lot of non-negotiables that I personally believe John Spencer should be the United States' non-negotiable. And if you listen to official statements, not all these, which I can't stand, you know, people close to the situation leaks or I won't name names, but you know, reporters that somehow think they have the direct line behind the scenes listening to Secretary Rubio, Vice President Vance, the president himself of where the non-negotiables are for the United States, but that we keep hearing we're close. I think that conversation will continue in this event. From what I know at the moment that we're talking, this event won't take us off of that effort, which does have a short fuse or short timeline in my opinion of the president of the United States thinks he's close. We think we're close, and they're going to let that play out until we hit, like we did, actually people remember, right before Operation Epic Fury on February 28th, and right before restarting operations in the past. This isn't the old regimes or old administrations of just continuing negotiations on forever.
Benjamin Anthony 5:19 ↗
You're referring to the American side of this negotiation, right?
John Spencer 5:23 ↗
That's right. There is a short timeline of even, you know, now there's again, I can't stand rumors until you see what the deal is of a 30-day pause for this, a 60-day pause for that so the negotiations can happen. As we saw with the United States that went actually to Islamabad for that direct negotiation, and they walked away because the non-negotiables weren't being talked about. There's so much that we don't know, but I don't think, Benjamin, that this event from last night of upholding the blockade, upholding no interference or attacks like sea mines and that would complicate opening up the strait. It's all part of the current pause that I believe we're in.
Benjamin Anthony 6:13 ↗
So, let's talk a little bit about some of the muted and I don't think anybody really knows at this stage, but it's worth talking about some of the muted terms of the deal as is being reported and as we're probably both hearing from our respective sources. So, apparently Iran is currently agreeing to bring about an end to the production of nuclear weapons and the United States is also offering a situation whereby the Iranians might sell the enriched uranium, the highly enriched uranium that seems to be. I'll talk about the less highly enriched uranium, why that remains problematic perhaps separately, but there's a notion that America is offering to actually purchase the highly enriched uranium from Iran. And also, together with that, another proposal which speaks to the possibility of moving the uranium to a third-party country or diluting the uranium under the auspices of the IAEA inside Iran. With regards to the Strait of Hormuz, Iran is talking about establishing a permanent Iranian oversight mechanism there that will ultimately decide who will pass and who will not. And of course, the danger with that is that it would give the Iranians a veto over who does traverse the straits and such a demand could well end up bringing about a total collapse of the ceasefire talks in my opinion. I cannot see how the Americans could possibly accept as viable a demand that Iran now takes hold and governance is essentially over that waterway. Those are some of the conditions that the Iranians are said to have put forward, but you also alluded to something that I think our listeners should be aware of, which is just the sheer influence of the Arab and regional powers, several of whom are not good actors. We know that the following spoke to President Trump just yesterday. Those include Sisi of Egypt, of course, Erdogan of Turkey, a senior military member from Pakistan, the Emir of Qatar, the leader of Bahrain, bin Salman of Saudi Arabia, bin Zayed of the UAE, and of course Hussein of Jordan. And apparently President Trump has expressed to them that they need to they will be required to join the Abraham Accords as part of any agreement here. He has expressed the president that the joining the broadening of the circle of signatories to the accords would have to begin with the Saudis and the Qataris. I don't believe that Israel's particularly interested in the latter of those two. And President Trump is said to have asserted that if they do not join, it's an indicator of bad faith on the part of those actors, and that therefore they should not consider themselves to have too much influence over the ultimate terms of any deal that America strikes with Iran. So, I know I've hit two large issues there. What are your thoughts on both of those issues? The muted terms of the deal and the pressures or the engagement by Arab and regional forces with the Americans at this time?
John Spencer 9:30 ↗
Yeah, I don't want to quote Donald Rumsfeld, actually, which was quoted in a Harvard Business Review article. People don't know, it's a really good one about the known knowns and the known unknowns. There are some aspects that I trust as known knowns more. Although you know President Trump speaks his own language. He posts his own information. When he says he we can be assured like the were you know, calls that were made. So, on the first issue of the enriched uranium or what the president calls the nuclear dust. And he made a couple posts over the weekend even about the dust. And that it is ultimately, from my own interpretation, there is a non-negotiable of non-nuclear proliferation. Actually, there was actually an NPT treaty discussion in the United Nations recently. And the United States made a comment that it was unfortunate that we didn't address the Iranian pursuit of nuclear weapons in that conversation. There's only nine nuclear armed countries in the world. We don't need a terrorist state with one and that's a foundational global aspect that I think is worth fighting for. So, we can discuss like you said and people are speculating. But I truly believe that the current administration is a non-negotiable non-nuclear proliferation that the Islamic regime in Iran will not have a nuclear weapons program. Now, everybody will do what abouts on that. Of course, the 60% like you said. Like in order to take that from 60% to 90% and then weaponize it everybody knows that that's limited time that that's a non-negotiable. Whether you destroy it there and there's some really good research that I posted over the weekend, too, about even destroying it on site and burying it. All these things that can be done. Like you said, there are many alternatives and there's actually history of like moving it out into another country. Whether you what they get in return is a part of negotiations. But that's a foundational aspect of a you will not have a nuclear weapons program, period. And that's you know, enriching uranium to me is a part of it, of course, but also centrifuge, you know, enrichment, you know, all these things that are a part of that. The aspect of course, if you know, the president has a bigger view of course, the Middle East that this is about normalizing the Middle East and normalizing relationships with Israel and that I found that really refreshing that that's where the administration is thinking about, look, we're going to address this threat to the world and to the Middle East. And while we're at it, because I think we have seen the Middle East change since October 7th, let's talk about normalization and the hurdles to it with Israel and that's huge and within the Abraham Accords, I think that's important, but we have to get past this gamesmanship, almost not game theory, but gamesmanship of the Islamic regime in Iran guys thinking they can outmaneuver the United States and have a nuclear weapons program and you don't want history repeating itself and I see the administration learning from the lessons of the past, whether it was you know, the particulars of a deal that actually allows a program, but not a enrichment breakout, all these things is that you have a lot of more common sense I see happening. All of those actors they talked to, of course, since it has changed and even the Islamic regime in Iran's response to epic fury and attacking all these countries, attacking not just the Strait of Hormuz, but you know, very significant economic resources and you know, launching missiles at everybody means that there are a lot more people involved in this and having them brought into the deal, I'm a fan of. There are a couple that every country acts in its interest first. But you see this larger plan and actually changed the conversation over the weekend of wait a minute, that's pretty big if all of these countries could be brought into the Abraham Accords, that would be historic as much as the first Accords were. Though we have to address the threat and the non-negotiables of non-nuclear proliferation and freedom of navigation. No toll system and again, this is where the speculation was happening of like all these terms that people were speculating. You can't weaponize that economic throughput and say that, you know, Iran's going to discuss how much they'll control of it. Like no, it matters for the world that there is it's a freedom of navigation. Although you can talk about territorial waters and all of this stuff. That can't be allowed to establish a new standard that would apply around the world.
Benjamin Anthony 14:31 ↗
Yeah, and it's quite clear to me that you're expressing and I agree that the president does not seem to be entreating these regional powers to join the Abraham Accords and that will be the payoff for getting a bad deal with Iran with regard to its nuclear program. Rather it's both. Both have to be accomplished and non-negotiable of Iran ending its nuclear weapons pursuit needs to be in hand and if these other countries want to be part of the conditions and the conditioning of such an outcome, they need according to what's been reported, they need to jump on President Trump's proposal that they join the Abraham Accords. So both going hand in hand. How realistic that is remains to be seen, but it is worth noting that the Iranian foreign minister and the central bank head of Iran were in Doha trying to get the early release of frozen Iranian funds in order to show some sort of success to the home front that they are somehow making some sort of headway with regard to the negotiations with the Americans even if it's just financial and economic relief. So, they're obviously concerned about their own population in terms of how long they can continue this situation in Iran. I don't mean they're concerned about them. It wouldn't seem in a humanitarian sense, but they do want to show some sort of success that on the issue of non-negotiables, John, you know, we are in a situation where America has its non-negotiables and Israel has a completely different set or a different set of non-negotiables. So, we and Israel we have said the following. Iran must end its nuclear weapons program. That would seem to be aligned with the American priorities. Iran's ballistic missile production and delivery systems must be brought to an end. We've also said that we want the end of the arraying of Iranian proxies on Israel's borders. Those include multiple proxies, but the one I want to talk about is of course Hezbollah. So, Hezbollah has been tied by the Iranians as a result of this negotiation or in the course of this negotiation to the outcomes at hand to the outcomes that are being discussed. And Israel has had its hand against Hezbollah quite definitely stayed for now. Now, it's recently been reported that the IDF is about to take on a much more offensive posture and actually start moving. In fact, at the time of this recording start moving in beyond southern Lebanon to start taking the fight to Hezbollah beyond the zone in which the IDF is operating currently in a broadly defensive manner and taking him as I said a much more offensive posture. But there does seem to be a problem here because the situation of having Hezbollah flying these explosive drones onto our troops and even into the homeland is completely untenable. It cannot be expected to be absorbed and it is one of Israel's non-negotiables and yet Iran seems to have negotiated with the Americans that this will be allowed and that the negotiations as they take place between America and Iran encompass Israel's freedom of movement against Hezbollah which is absolutely an Iranian proxy. How do you think Israel can cut that nexus that the Iranians managed to establish between the Iranian front and the Lebanese front both when it comes to Iran's pursuit of nuclear weapons, all of the negotiations that are taking place attendant to that and of course it's proxy right on Israel's border?
John Spencer 18:20 ↗
Well, I don't have all the answers Benjamin of course, but you know the fact is now where some people might have speculated when you say the proxy Hezbollah the terrorist army in Lebanon that is holding the nation of Lebanon almost at ransom, nobody can say it's not a proxy of the Islamic regime in Iran now cuz they say it is and they say
Benjamin Anthony 18:47 ↗
Exactly. They have officially tied it to that which is
John Spencer 18:50 ↗
Yeah.
Which is I mean it should debunk a lot of the misinformation. I mean let alone the financial I mean just in 2025 they provided a billion dollars to Hezbollah. But the fact that they are tying it to this larger operation as in their kind of negotiation point this has to be addressed. When and then people and you and I had I think talked last, this isn't between Israel and Lebanon. This is about Israel and the terrorist army of Hezbollah, which happens to be within portions of Lebanon. And it's almost if this should be a campaign to free Lebanon of Hezbollah. How to cut those ties as we've seen Hezbollah being weakened, but definitely not gone, and how long that would take. Is that it's a very I don't want to say as a kind of wishing it away, a very complex situation. So, you know, that even the peace that supposedly that is to be sought is a peace between Lebanon and Israel. And they actually have a mutual interest to remove this threat, and what Iran, in my opinion, so, there's a very frayed line at this point going from the Islamic regime to Hezbollah on its ability to fund it, to resupply it, to arm it, to now allow it to survive. It's a very frayed line with the loss of a lot of the logistical lines, loss of an air force, loss of the land bridge between Iran through Syria. You know, you have a partner who says that won't happen anymore. Whether you call it it's a dubious partner, of course. How that plays out, of course, I'm surprised, and I think we all should be surprised at the vulnerability of Israel and the IDF to these fiber optic drones, which have been around now in the Ukraine and been the dominant form of low-cost attacks in Ukraine and Russia for a while, that Hezbollah has now caused that, where the one threat was, of course, the rocket supply, to be their asymmetric attack at this point. But there's so much involved in that conversation. Very revealing that Iran will make it a not a non-negotiable, but one of their priorities of the negotiation is the survival of a terrorist army in a state when the government of that state is also in almost with Israel in the campaign to remove them as a military faction within the state of Lebanon. And I know that even within the last few weeks Hezbollah has called for there to be a revolt of the and takeover of the Lebanese government. I think the United States is actually, you know, side by side with Israel on the goal to remove this threat, of course, to Israel and that's terrain-based, but even the threat to Lebanon and the Lebanese people and all that's all that is associated with that. I don't have a straight answer for you to how to cut the tie. I think it's a very frayed tie. And we don't want to say the weakest it's ever been, but I mean, it's the weakest position, of course, Hezbollah with all new leadership and that they've been with no real direct resupply of the armament happening and their future as they try to figure out their future with their biggest partner, Islamic regime in Iran, directly trying to allow them to survive and set the seeds for rebuilding and the next war. I think there are a lot of people involved in that. I don't know how it plays out. I personally, John Spencer, do not think that Israel should give up those five strategic vantage points until Hezbollah is no longer a threat to Israel. And I think that could be part of the conversation. As they push forward, as you were talking about to further destroy the decades of military capability that Hezbollah has built inside of Lebanon preventing the Lebanese army from actually having a chance at disarming them, right? We could talk political military power as we have in other areas, but they have a vast arsenal and you can just watch the IDF feed on the discovery of more and more underground weapons supplies, rocket supplies as they deal with the of course the tactical threat of these fiber optic drones.

13 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Spencer, J. (2026, May 26). Nuclear Iran “non-negotiable” for Trump says John Spencer as President makes decision [Interview transcript]. MirYam Institute. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183755/

MLA

John Spencer. "Nuclear Iran “non-negotiable” for Trump says John Spencer as President makes decision." MirYam Institute, 26 May. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183755/.

BibTeX
@misc{spencer2026_3183755,
  author       = {John Spencer},
  title        = {Nuclear Iran “non-negotiable” for Trump says John Spencer as President makes decision},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, MirYam Institute. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {may},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183755/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}