The US national debt recently hit $40 trillion. It's an eye-popping amount. How did it get this high? One reason is the dollar's status as the world's reserve currency, which allows the US to borrow money more easily than other countries. But is that era ending? Has the US dollar peaked? From the BBC, I'm Asma Khaled in Washington DC, and welcome to The Global Story on YouTube.
To help us make sense of this incredibly complicated story, I decided to call up Ken Rogoff because he seems like just the man to explain it all to us. He was the former chief economist at the IMF, the International Monetary Fund, and is now an economics professor at Harvard University who's written a book called Our Dollar, Your Problem. It's all about the US dollar's dominance. And the reason I wanted to have this conversation with Professor Rogoff in this moment, because as I mentioned a moment ago, the US debt recently crossed this $40 trillion milestone. Now, I think that for a lot of us Americans here, we assume that a major reason that the US government is so in debt is because the government often spends each year more money than it brings in. But I wanted to understand from Professor Kenneth Rogoff how, if at all, the dollar and its status as the world's reserve currency factors into this debt story.
Well, the fact that the dollar is the reserve currency, which means it gets held all over the world, it gets used very widely, lets the United States borrow more. So, the world loves the dollar, but how much? And as time has gone on, they say, 'Well, we love you, but you know what? Please pay a higher interest rate if you want us to love you so much.' And that's been creeping up.
So, just so I understand what you're saying, because the dollar is the reserve currency of the world, it essentially allows us to have, say, a larger credit card limit, right? Like we all are familiar with a credit card limit. You're saying that because the United States has traditionally been this trustworthy economy, its limit for borrowing is ostensibly higher.
Well, it's not just trustworthy. In fact, people today must question how trustworthy the United States is. But because it's at the center of everything, Japan needs to hold dollars to manage their trade and finance. The Middle East holds a lot of dollars to manage their trade and finance. If we were talking about the Canadian dollar, Canada's a wonderful economy, but nobody's doing that. So, if there are more people who are willing to hold your debt, you can have more of it. The debt is how much you can borrow. You can borrow more at a lower interest rate up to a point.
It sounds like some would argue, though, that the dollar being the reserve currency then is a bit of, how do you describe it? Kind of like a golden curse that it has allowed us to borrow as much as we have to this point where now as a nation we are $40 trillion in debt.
Well, it's mostly great. I mean, over the years it lets the United States have a stronger military. It makes it cheaper to own a home in the United States because it's not just the government that gets a lower interest rate, all Americans. So, it's this incredible privilege. But it's true. It puts a bit of upward pressure on the dollar. It lets us borrow more. And you can mess it up. And I think we're in some danger of heading in that direction.
You mentioned a moment ago the interest on the debt, and Professor, I was reading recently that part of why our debt has just ballooned so much is because of the interest, and that the interest that the United States now pays annually is such a large part of the United States expenditure. I believe it's only second to the amount we spend on Social Security. Just to put that in context, that it is so much. Can you help us understand what amount of interest the United States is paying annually on its debt? And again, how does that factor into the conversation around the dollar?
Well, at the end of the day, if the interest rate were really low, like it was during the 2010s through the early pandemic, you owe a lot, but who cares? You know, you're not being asked to pay that much on it, and it doesn't matter that much. Our debt payments five or six years ago were next to nothing, and now, as you say, they're second on their way to being first in the budget. It's not just because the US is borrowing a lot. A great many very influential voices and academics, Paul Krugman, Larry Summers are two famous people, sort of said there's nothing to worry about. The interest rate ain't going to go up. And it has, and people haven't yet totally absorbed that.
We've mentioned a couple of times here the United States' status as the reserve currency of the world. Can you explain what that means in plain terms?
So the dollar is essentially the lingua franca of international trade and finance. Suppose you have Australia trading with Argentina. Now, there's an Australian dollar, there's an Argentine peso, and I don't know, maybe Argentina's selling soybeans to Australia, and Australia's selling iron ore to Argentina. Well, you know, you can work it all out in pesos and Australian dollars, but the people in Australia don't want to hold Argentine pesos. And the people in Argentina, well, Australian dollars aren't terrible, but they'd rather have US dollars. And so, it's just easier to understand. There are more than 180 countries. So, it's a common denominator. It's not the only one. The euro is very widely used. The Chinese currency is very widely used, but the US one most of all. It wasn't always that way. I mean, if you go back...
Yeah. If you go back to 1900, it was the pound. That was the lingua franca.
The Brits, they were on top for more than a century. If you go before that, and this may be hard to believe, it was the Netherlands. It was the Dutch guilder. They were very innovative in finance. Before that, Spain. Before that, the Italian city-states. But the US has been really on top since World War II. It started after World War I. I mean, after World War II, Europe was destroyed. Japan was destroyed. The dollar was the only game in town.
You mentioned that this was not always the case. The dollar wasn't always the dominant currency used around the world, and that this became the norm after World War II. Can you tell us that story?
Well, the US had all the wealth, all the gold, all the industrial base, and was pretty much in a position to dictate what things would look like. And there was this famous conference held in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire.
At Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, delegates from 44 allied and associate countries arrived for the opening of the United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference, where John Maynard Keynes represented Britain, and the US was represented by Harry Dexter White, a far more minor functionary. These meetings are designed to promote trade in the post-war world and to create a foundation for lasting peace.
But White had all the money. Keynes said, 'No, no, no, we shouldn't use the dollar.' He tried to come up with this idea, I think he called it the bancor, that everybody would decide on. And Harry Dexter White said, 'Well, no, we're going to use the dollar.' Keynes tried to come up with some world currency that was managed by a group of countries, and he had some rules, and he was trying to cling on to British power.
All agreements must be ratified by the governing bodies of the nations involved.
The trouble is, after World War I and then after World War II, the US had all the cards because the United States was paying for reconstruction of Europe. You needed to trade with the United States. I mean, if you think today Donald Trump is holding a big stick, he certainly thinks he is. Back then, the United States was by some measures half of the world economy. So, we were in a position to sort of bully our way into that.
So this conference takes place in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, and the United States comes out on top. The US dollar is agreed upon. You could say maybe we dictated the terms of it, but it was agreed that that would be the standard, you're saying, for the world. And what was the system?
The system was that countries who wanted to be in the system, which was not everyone, but it was the European countries, Japan, Canada, they were required to fix their exchange rate to the dollar, but the US was not required to do anything except if countries' central banks or treasuries felt they had too many dollars, they could take it to the United States and get gold in return.
Honest, you and I couldn't.
Yeah. Literally, literally gold bars. But there was a way we were still on the gold standard. I mean, everybody was fixed to the dollar. The dollar was fixed to gold. And that lasted and worked pretty well for a couple decades.
The 50s and 60s seemed like halcyon days sometimes. Did it continue to work well into the 70s and 80s?
So the trouble is, the lynchpin of this system was the US had to be willing to back the dollar with gold. And the trouble is, the US wanted to spend more and more. It had, particularly in the 60s, Lyndon Johnson was the president, started the Great Society, which was a big increase in our welfare system. It was a massive expenditure increase, and then we got entwined in this war in Vietnam.
We intend to convince the communists that we cannot be defeated by force of arms or by superior power.
Yes, which lasted and lasted and lasted, and the government was having trouble living within its means, and it started putting upward pressure on the general level of prices, and effectively that meant we were undervaluing gold because, you know, the relative price of gold and cars, that's not something the government sets, the market sets that. So countries, particularly France, were starting to say, 'Give us gold. We have a lot of dollars. Let's trade it for gold.' And eventually, Nixon in 1971 said, 'That's enough. No more dollars for gold.'
I have directed the Secretary of the Treasury to take the action necessary to defend the dollar against the speculators. I have directed Secretary Connally to suspend temporarily the convertibility of the dollar into gold or other reserve assets, except in amounts and conditions determined to be in the interest of monetary stability and in the best interest of the United States.
That's a huge shock to the system, we call it. Did people know, did other countries know that the United States was just going to kind of change the rules behind the scenes?