Just for basics here, why does a president like low rates?
Well, low rates are good for the government because the government's the biggest borrower, but they care about home mortgages. They care about car loans, student loans, commercial loans. Low interest rates are good for borrowers. That's good for the US economy. That's good for whoever's in power politically. Having low interest rates is a luxury. It's great. The trouble is if you put interest rates too low when there's inflation pressures, it makes the price pressures go up more and get out of control. And so that's the balance that the central bank's trying to have. The central bank can control inflation, but it can't necessarily choose where the market's going to think the interest rate needs to be consistent with that. So, I mean, the whole world looks at the Federal Reserve and they think they're setting the interest rate, my car loan, everything. It's done by the Federal Reserve. That's a gross misconception. The Federal Reserve on the whole, most central banks are trying to keep prices stable. They don't always do a great job. Okay, it's very hard to do, but that's what they're trying to do. And that means they have to ask themselves the question, well, if we want to keep prices stable, is the interest rate too high or too low? And so that's what they're feeling out. And the president typically short-term, that short-term interest rate, what's happening right now, that's what they want to deliver. And often cutting the interest rate does deliver growth in the short run. The trouble is as inflation ratchets up, the longer term interest rates ratchets up, all the interest rates get sucked up and you're sort of, you know, like running on a wheel, you know, trying to stand still.
Is it fair to say that the Fed has the single most powerful tool in the economy?
Absolutely. Controlling the short-term interest rate is the most powerful tool not available to Congress. Congress has a lot of tools, but they don't have the surgical ability to change it in the way the Fed has. The Fed has one job basically, which is to make sure prices stay stable. I want to back up and mention that we didn't always live in this world. We used to have the dollar pegged to gold. And a lot of people think that's wonderful. We should go back to it. It's not easy to do, is all I'll say. Like countries tried it and didn't, but we had that at some level until 1971 when Nixon went off gold and he just cut the dollar loose. And part of the reason we had the inflation in the 1970s, which a lot of people think was because oil prices went up. No, no, no. It's because we didn't know what to do. We didn't have any vision of how to control inflation. It's a modern construct. The whole idea of having an independent central bank is new, that people really didn't understand the importance of it. And it took, I'd say, 15 years before we really figured it out. And it's worked really well, but the problem is that people, it's worked so well people forget it's necessary. I back up with a joke that kind of captures this. There's this man, you know, looking for a parking space because he wants to go to pray at his church. And he looks up and says, 'God, you know, if you'll just give me a parking space, I'll promise I'll start coming regularly. You know, I'll be more devoted. I'll be better.' And suddenly a parking space opens up and he pulls right in and then he looks up and says, 'Just kidding, you know.' And I think that's been like that with central bank independence and inflation, where it came down and everybody, not just Trump, I would also say the progressives, people all over the world have forgotten how we got there. And if you take away central bank independence, you're not going to get inflation overnight, by the way, it takes time, but it certainly will contribute in a big way towards the next high inflation period we get.
What is the cautionary tale? I mean, you mentioned the inflation of the 70s, but of the central bank succumbing to political aims. So for instance, the Burns and Nixon example and what that resulted in.
This happens in extremes all over the world, but in the US in the early 1970s, we'd gone off the gold standard. And Nixon's saying, 'Oh, we can cut the interest rates. There's nothing holding us down.' And Arthur Burns, who was the chair of the Fed, he pushed back, but not hard enough. And Nixon cursed him. And you can actually listen to this on the Watergate tapes, you know, and he told him what he wanted to do. And the 1972 election, Nixon ran against McGovern. I campaigned for McGovern back then, but you know, it was in vain. He won Massachusetts, I think. Nixon did everything possible. So, Social Security, he actually doubled the size of the Social Security boost. And he told Arthur Burns, he said, 'I want low interest rates. Do whatever it takes.' So Burns did. Burns relented. And the reason that it happened is when the Federal Reserve makes interest rates lower than they need to be or should be, actually, nothing happens right away. It takes time. Even really high inflations just take time to build up. But the problem is once they get going, they're really hard to stop. And the 70s, this happened all over the world. We didn't have the worst inflation. England and Japan had inflation over 20%. And of course there are other countries that were worse.
Some people just refer to it as a kind of lost decade, right? There was low growth, high inflation, and I mean, that's the dreaded combo.
Yeah. And it wasn't all caused by inflation. We had the Vietnam War. We had all sorts of problems. But yeah, inflation was very, very damaging.
I'd like to get to Trump 2.0. Early on the Fed decided to hold rates. They'd been cutting rates and they paused. And as we understand it, they heard about the president's ambitious economic agenda, whether it was going to be tariffs or immigration or a tax cut, and they said best for us to pause here, wait and see. What was your view about the economy and about the wisdom of sort of wait and see at that point?
Well, the president was doing things which normally would push the market rates up. So for example, the big beautiful bill was this massive spending bill. We're getting, I don't know, six, seven percent of income deficit, like a massive deficit. The president was deregulating, which in some cases is good, but a lot of cases is problematic, but in all cases stimulates the economy and that was pushing prices up. He wanted the best economy ever, the greatest show on earth. Some of the actions were just not consistent with low inflation at the existing interest rates. I mean, I don't want to get into the particular dynamics of when they were high or low, but it didn't feel like a situation where the next move would be to cut interest rates. They had gotten quite high when Trump took office, so there was some room for them to come down. But I don't know if you recall, Trump wanted to bring them from over 5% to 1% tomorrow. And actually that would have been okay tomorrow, maybe the next day, maybe the next month, but eventually would have been a disaster. It would have led to, I think, a lot of demand and a lot of inflation. And so the Federal Reserve was just trying to hide during this period. We have this, you know, very muscular presidency wanting to do so many things all at once. And I'm not saying the Federal Reserve, you know, was against having the US economy great. It isn't against having the greatest economy on earth. It's just that part of having the greatest economy on earth is having a currency you can rely on, the whole world can rely on.
What was your view of the firing of Lisa Cook?
I thought he was shooting over the bow of the whole Federal Reserve saying, 'I control the CIA. I control the NSA. I control the FBI. I can read all your emails. I can find something on you.' So, if you're not listening to me, you're going to regret it. And that's what that felt like. It's about, I mean, it was really, you know, show me the man and I'll show you the crime, and a little bit ironic Trump exercising that, but I felt it was telling other central bank owners, I can get you, and we may see that still, I don't rule that out, of looking for pressure points, looking for things. I mean, you know, at the end of the day...
I mean, you're describing a shakedown.