CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
John Spencer
Executive Director, Urban Warfare Institute; Chair of Urban Warfare Studies, Modern War Institute at West Point, Urban Warfare Institute

The UN’s Case Against Israel Just Fell Apart (w/John Spencer) | Basic Law

📅 Sep 18, 2025 JNS TV 45 MIN 102089 VIEWS 85 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
As Israel’s ground offensive in Gaza City intensifies, the UN Human Rights Council has once again leveled accusations of genocide against the Jewish state. Their newly released 72-page report, produced by a commission riddled with members already on record as anti-Israel, ignores Hamas’s crimes and skews casualty data to present a distorted narrative. Behind the headlines, the reality on the ground tells a very different story. In this episode of Basic Law, we cut through the noise clouding global discourse on Israel’s war of survival. Host Aylana Meisel is joined by John Spencer, Chair of Ur...

Questions asked in this interview

7
  1. 7:13You've been embedded with the IDF, you follow many, many conflicts around the world, and historically, how do you think the next few months will play out and what needs to happen now and afterwards to win the war?
  2. 13:17And also just on this point about Hamas and human, we'll call it human sacrifice, is it really unique in the sense that let's say ISIS would not have done something similar?
  3. 24:09... you're talking about, while in fact I think morally admirable, are militarily wise, meaning why go so much above and beyond what is considered the moral bar for other militaries, and does that impact the way that other militaries fight?
  4. 30:30... the applicable international law is kind of softly there to the extent practicable, the obligation basically to ensure that people move from a comfortable lifestyle in Gaza City to something that's comparable. So Israeli standard, right?
  5. 31:22So is that a fair way of thinking about it, or is the Israeli standard really just Israel?
  6. 36:58And so at that point, what meaning do they have?
  7. 37:52Does it affect the way that they think about their strategy, their fighting?
Aylana Meisel 0:00 ↗
To the surprise of absolutely no one, the UN Human Rights Council has released a report by a supposedly independent commission of inquiry accusing Israel of genocide.
The council, which includes noted human rights bastions Qatar and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, established the commission, which is comprised of a woman who believes that Israel is an apartheid regime which intentionally targets schools, a man condemned by world governments for previous anti-Semitic statements, and a third member on the record as saying that the IDF constitutes one of the world's most criminal armies.
The death tolls and injuries in Gaza are indeed high. Life is very hard for many civilians, and the efforts to clean out Hamas and other terror organizations mean that Israel has inflicted great damage on homes and infrastructure.
But the 72-page report skews the numbers, the facts, and the law so badly that attempting to debate it on its own terms is the rhetorical equivalent of mud-wrestling. It's sticky, dirty, and probably tops the list of things that are least likely to gain you much credibility or popularity.
So while we'll address the report in part today on Basic Law, we'll try to keep our conversation focused on bigger questions now accompanying Israel's ground offensive in Gaza City.
The operation is in full force and only forecasted to conclude in several months at a minimum. Tens of thousands of Israeli reservists have once again joined the front lines, navigating one of the world's most volatile urban battlefields. Civilians are fleeing the city by the hundreds of thousands to an Israeli safe zone in southern Gaza.
Despite attempts to protect Gazan civilian life from the intensive fighting in Gaza City, critics are calling this evacuation to safety ethnic cleansing. So there's a lot to discuss.
Today on Basic Law we're joined by one of the world's leading military experts in urban warfare, John Spencer, to unpack the reality on the ground in Gaza City, the brutal calculus of civilian evacuations, and how the intellectual smog now enveloping the discourse of the law of armed conflict endangers more than just specific military missions. Mr. Spencer is the chair of war studies at the Madison Policy Forum and executive director of the Urban Warfare Institute. Welcome.
John Spencer 2:19 ↗
Well, thanks for having me.
Aylana Meisel 2:25 ↗
Well, thanks for being here. So as you know, we're mainly going to be talking about other things. However, the report did come out last night, you have been doing a lot of media on this, and I'd love if you could share your thoughts as well with us for just a few minutes about what was written there.
John Spencer 2:40 ↗
Sure. I would say, and I have been saying, that it's impressive. It's an impressive collection of Hamas data and distorted information. Just about everything that's ever been put out since October 7th collected and then attempted to be, which is the impressive part, which is an insult to just critical thinking. I could hand it to my seventh grader and say, here's a statement, does it sound right to you? Like hopefully even she would know like, well, what about this? What about that?
Every bit of it is, I wouldn't say laughable because it's a very serious, credible in many cases, but how it doesn't discuss Hamas, rarely, basically at all, how it makes statements like October 7th, while a war, probably war crimes, didn't warrant a large-scale operation in self-defense in response. It wasn't an existential threat.
How it reposts, I mean, just so much information without any context, which is, I mean, it clearly is an assault on law, jurisprudence, but for me, like even critical thinking, like some of the things in there, like I was surprised by it for sure.
Aylana Meisel 4:01 ↗
I mean, you also have spent a good amount of your time in the past couple of years explaining that there's a unique kind of urban landscape that the IDF is tackling, and putting aside the obvious agenda behind this report, it always surprises me that people don't take it into account at all when discussing this issue, nor do they take into account the fact that Gaza, to some degree, only ran as effectively as it did thanks to Israeli supply of partially electricity, water, and of course, allowing funding to go through to Gaza for many years. For anybody who understands the history of this thing, the whole idea of a genocide just doesn't jive.
John Spencer 4:52 ↗
Yeah, that's the agree, and this is like, even if there's an accusation that Israel has withheld aid for the purpose of eliminating an entire group, an ethnic group, you know, the whole definition of genocide. And then not include information about, which is historic, because I study war, right? So I know what basically every humanitarian operation has been conducted in coordination with wars and battles. And Israel is historic as in feeding an enemy's population or providing all services for an enemy's population in the midst of a battle.
But if there's an accusation of Israel withholding something but not including any information about like the 2.2 million tons of aid that's been delivered since October 7th, or how 14 million liters of water is being delivered daily today to Gaza from Israel, so water from Israel being delivered, this is this assault on critical thinking that any reasonable person would say like this is a part of the conversation, right?
Tunnels, even so, the tunnels in Gaza from a warfare perspective, or even from like you said from the history of Gaza dating back from even before Israel's disengagement in 2005, the investment in tunnels rather than infrastructure, tunnels for the sole purpose of military, so no civilians allowed in tunnels, over 400 miles of tunnels. This report mentions tunnels one time and only to question, which is like any reasonable person could watch Israel's footage of a tunnel in the European hospital where Mohammed Sinwar was questioned, but this report only says the word tunnel once to say that allegedly Mohammed Sinwar was killed in the European hospital complex. Like I said, an assault on critical thinking.
Aylana Meisel 6:55 ↗
Okay, so what we're gonna do now is move to things that require critical thinking. And hopefully speak to an audience that's much more a fan of it than whoever's consuming the report without critiquing it.
So Israel started its ground offensive in Gaza City. We had about a month of preparatory strikes. It's now been reported it's going to take at least several months to gain military control, let alone potentially clean out the terrorist infrastructure. You've been embedded with the IDF, you follow many, many conflicts around the world, and historically, how do you think the next few months will play out and what needs to happen now and afterwards to win the war?
John Spencer 7:38 ↗
So that last bit, it's really hard as somebody who taught strategy at West Point to say what does winning look like, to achieve the three goals Israel set since October 7th, which even that report says are questionable, which is ridiculous: returning the hostages, destroying Hamas's military infrastructure, removing them from political power, and ensuring that no threat comes from the Gaza Strip against Israel again.
This battle, right, and this has been a big problem since October 7th, is the critics grasping for data, most people, most of them who hadn't studied war before October 7th, but grasping for comparative analysis data. And that's what I do, right? I write case studies on the past. And people from the beginning comparing the Gaza war, which is a relatively small area, but it's still a massive Hamas military across many cities in a condensed area, but also in a larger perspective than a single battle.
But now we have a really defined battle that has, like you said, preparation has been set even before the announcements, the expanding of the humanitarian zone in southern Gaza, because of the uniqueness of this war, which has no parallel, where because of Egypt, the civilian population has had to remain in the entire Gaza Strip as a combat area, not because Israel says so, because of Hamas' disposition, composition, intent, its statements, its actions.
The fact that the civilian population had to remain in the Gaza Strip has been a very, an unparalleled situation. But now we're at this point where, because of the hostages, Israel has not gone into Gaza City really since October 7th. They did limited raids into like Al-Shifa hospital and other locations where Hamas was maintaining military capability in violation of international law, of course, but pretty much left the center of Gaza City untouched.
And it really, and I just released the case study of the first Gaza war, 2008. Gaza City, the depths of Gaza City really have been never approached by the IDF. So this will be a challenge that the IDF have not faced really in its history. The density of Gaza City is much denser than any other of the major cities like Khan Yunis, Rafah, even other areas within the Gaza Strip.
The IDF is not the same IDF since October 7th, what it's learned to be able to combat against Hamas tactics of using the tunnels. But there is lots of concerns because this will be the largest operation that the IDF have attempted since October 7th. Right now there's two divisions in Gaza City with a third one being added. Some of the plans say up to five divisions on a single large city in Gaza City, which has a population before the battle began of over a million.
So that one of the biggest challenges, which the IDF started, of course, was the evacuations, right? So I've done my own podcast with law of war professors on, you know, that balancing between military necessity and humanitarian imperatives or humanitarian concerns. Israel has done this since October 8th. Matter of fact, they've done more civilian harm mitigation, what we call kind of the steps you can do to limit civilian harm, than any military in the history of any urban battle, let alone urban-centric war.
Israel started those evacuations and then you have the uninformed or the bias saying that that is some way a bad thing, but Israel of course is actually trying to separate the civilians. In Gaza City, so now we can really compare Gaza City to other battles like the 2016 and 17 battle of Mosul where there was a million residents. So there you can actually compare that battle to the battle of Gaza City, although the disposition of the enemy is much bigger.
I know this is a long answer, but as we see the operation starting, the evacuations of civilians, it's really step one, although the preparatory strikes that you talked about, like eliminating things that would be very important to Hamas's military that's trying to fight in Gaza City. But the evacuations are the biggest thing. Getting the civilians, that's the primary enemy tactic, which is unique, again, unparalleled in war, that the other combatant who violates all the laws of war as an operation, as their kind of techniques, who uses human sacrifice and they're stopping civilians as we're talking in written, verbal, and actual actions telling civilians they cannot evacuate or they'll face death's severe consequences.
So you have this kind of tie between the IDF urging, the prime minister urging civilians, please move out of harm's way. And then the political organization responsible for the people of Gaza, Hamas, is saying, if you leave, there will be severe consequences because they need that human, some people call it a human shield strategy, but I call it a human sacrifice strategy.

9 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Spencer, J. (2025, September 18). The UN’s Case Against Israel Just Fell Apart (w/John Spencer) | Basic Law [Interview transcript]. JNS TV. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3276918/

MLA

John Spencer. "The UN’s Case Against Israel Just Fell Apart (w/John Spencer) | Basic Law." JNS TV, 18 Sep. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3276918/.

BibTeX
@misc{spencer2025_3276918,
  author       = {John Spencer},
  title        = {The UN’s Case Against Israel Just Fell Apart (w/John Spencer) | Basic Law},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, JNS TV. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {sep},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3276918/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}