Welcome back. You're watching our continuing conversations here at Davos 2025, and it is now time for us to bring on a guest. And I particularly enjoy my conversations with him in Davos every year. Kenneth Rogoff, it's wonderful to have you back here on CNBC TV18. Thank you very much for your time. I'm going to start by asking you about the headline that everyone's focused on, and that's Trump in 2016. You said that a Trump boom was more likely this time around. You're less optimistic. Why?
Well, I think, first of all, he's inheriting a boom, and I think a lot of the policies he did in 2016 โ not his behavior, but the policies โ worked pretty well. Deregulation, you know, and other things he did to strengthen the economy helped support it. This time, some of the tax reforms he did were very helpful, or tax cuts. But this time, a lot of the things he's promising are counterproductive. So start with the tariffs, which aren't as bad as some of the extreme views, but it's not a good idea. Then he wants to have all sorts of other expenditures โ not tax Social Security, not tax tips. He wants to make everybody happy, you know, and at the same time, you know, he's saying, 'Well, it'll be okay, we're going to just cut the government spending.' I think he's undoing a lot of good policies he did the first time, and the things he's adding aren't so good. So, you know, for a lot of reasons, I think I'm less optimistic that we're going to get a boom. They're saying, 'Well, Biden grew at 2.7%, we're going to grow at 3%, Biden had 20% inflation, we're going to have, you know, 2% inflation, everything's going to be great.' But his are inconsistent. You can't both cut taxes, raise spending, and not have a problem. And we could go on about deregulation.
When you deregulate โ deregulating things is good up to a point.
Absolutely. Biden and the Democrats were excessive and had much too much of that. But when you deregulate the financial sector too fast, you get trouble. And so I think eventually we'll have trouble on inflation, troubles in the financial sector, and perhaps other kinds of troubles. But near term, this year, happy.
Near term this year, happy. But let's pick up on some of those troubles that you spoke of, and let's address the inflation issue, because with the threat of tariffs โ and if he goes through with them, whether it's 10, 20, or 60%, we don't know, but we probably will, maybe by the end of today or tomorrow โ what will that mean as far as inflation is concerned? And, you know, the promise then to middle-class America that President Trump made โ I mean, you know, what are we talking about, and what could that potentially then mean for the Fed in terms of rate cuts?
Well, first of all, it's small potatoes on inflation. Longer term, when we're talking about what just happened, we're talking about extra inflation of a percent, a percent and a half, one time, and not a permanent change. Of course, when there's the retaliation, that'll add another percent or percent and a half. It's not good, but it's not the end of the world. I think the pressures on inflation come from interest rates. Inflation-adjusted interest rates are in another world from when he came as president. When he came as president, they were zero. You could do everything; it didn't seem to matter. It was wrong, but now they're not. And already markets are putting pressures on interest rates. It's not because of Trump; it was just natural forces bringing interest rates higher. But he pours fuel on the fire. So interest rates are either going to go up, or if the Fed doesn't let them go up, you'll end up getting inflation in the near term. He says he's going to protect the independence of the Fed. We'll see how he feels when interest rates, you know, keep going up.
So it is going to be a challenge then for Powell, given the inflation scenario that you projected or, you know, are worried or concerned about, and what that could potentially mean as far as not now the rate cut, but the potential rate hike cycle is concerned.
Well, near term, absolutely. I think the chances of a rate hike now over the next 12 months are as high as a rate cut. It's not at all obvious that the interest rate is as high as people think; it probably never was. The real challenge is for his successor, when Trump is able to start seeding the Fed with his people. The person he's chosen, Kevin Warsh, is very good and at least as hawkish as Powell. But I think Trump's going to start to put more muscle on the Fed as time goes on. He's not going to turn his attention to it immediately.
Well, one of the other pain points that you spoke about was what happens to debt, and, you know, on the back of the tax cut that he's already announced that he intends to follow through on. I mean, what are we talking about in terms of the impact on debt?
Well, I think the plan is for it to go up. He says it's not, but he said that in 2016, and it went up a lot. And then it went up even more under Biden. We've lived in this long period where both the Republicans and the Democrats just thought, you know, everything's free, you never have to pay for anything. But as I argued here last year, and actually when I talked to you the year before, and I'm pretty sure the year before that, interest rates don't stay that low forever. They always eventually go back up to a more normal level. Now, having the high debt is very painful. I don't have the exact number, but our interest bill tripled over the past couple of years. I think our interest bill is now the size of our defense spending. And if interest rates keep going up and the debt keeps going up, our interest rates will go up even just rolling over the old debt, which was at the low rates. So that's going to be a big challenge. And, you know, he thinks, 'Well, no problem, we'll just keep borrowing more,' but then the debt goes up. I think bond markets are going to worry much more about it this time.
You know, since you're talking about the bond markets, let's talk about what's happening with the dollar. And I was talking to a banker in India, and, you know, with the kind of dollar strength that we are seeing at this point in time, he believes that it's like a suction machine that's going to pull money away from everywhere else in the world and create a problem for emerging markets specifically. How do you see the dollar strength, and what's the outlook from here on?
I mean, a strong dollar is a problem for global trade, partly because so much trade is in dollars. I think the dollar is high, and I've spent my life working on exchange rates, and most of the time you can't predict anything. The exception is when something gets way out of line, particularly adjusting for prices and trading partners. The dollar is just really rich right now. We've seen it twice before, in 1985 and 2002, and it came down. I think it'll come down. Trump, you know, wants a weaker dollar. I think magically it's going to happen. I've written about this, you know, even though he's not going to cause it, but I suspect the dollar is what could lead to it weakening. Well, I mean, one thing is the rest of the world's in a different interest rate cycle, and it will adjust. Everybody โ the US raises interest rates ahead of everybody else, and now we're in a different point in the cycle. And also, you know, there was this euphoria about the United States, and probably we'll have some reality about it coming up in the next year or so.
You think so? A reality check on the American exceptionalism?
I think absolutely there'll be a reality check on the American exceptionalism. We're doing โ you know, the United States are doing well, but the question is not is the dollar good, is it that good? And I feel it's very rich at the moment. We're uncompetitive in a lot of things with the dollar so high.
You know, while he has, of course, said that he's going to raise tariffs and go after Mexico, go after Canada, and so on and so forth, what does it mean as far as global growth in itself is concerned? Because the IMF is also โ while it's put out an outlook, a forecast of 3.3% for global growth, it is likely to have to factor in what eventually happens on the tariff front, you know, and that being a risk factor for global growth.
The big risk factor โ tariffs are not good. The big risk factor is the unpredictability, the instability of it. If you only had tariffs in India, if that was the only problem, your economy would be much bigger than it is now. Tariffs tend to come with a lot of baggage, a lot of other policies that go in the same direction โ non-tariff barriers, as we call them, things that are obstacles to trade and investment, price controls potentially. So I think the problem's not just the direct hit of the tariffs, but everything it sets off. And also, if they're unpredictable โ one day they're high, another day we have a deal โ very hard to do business in that circumstance. But I think the big threat to global growth coming from Trump, if there is one, is the unpredictability of what he's going to do next. And he has a lot of good instincts, but they're not all good instincts. And again, I was a chess player โ you can make a lot of good moves, and you make one really bad move, and it ruins your position. And there's a danger that he will do that.
And you think that his big bet on cryptocurrency could be the undoing?
I think his big bet is financial deregulation of cryptocurrency, and these things always end the same way โ not right away. There's a euphoria, there's a boom, and then there's a crash afterwards. If it doesn't hit the main economy, it's not such a big deal. But if it does, if it gets bigger and bigger, then I think it'd be a big problem.
Let's talk about China and what we're seeing happen in China at this point in time, responding to the slowdown by way of measures, and the expectation is that they will perhaps do more. What's your own read on what's happening there?
I have to look at the fact that they're hiding information, controlling information. They're throwing people in jail for daring to question China's growth numbers. I think historically China has smoothed their growth numbers, but they haven't systematically made them high. We don't know exactly what they are, but I think now they are โ I hear the IMF predicted 4.2%. Some of the people here are saying 5 or 6%. I'm thinking 2% is their real growth rate at the moment, but it's much lower than they report. And I think what everyone's missing is a lot of the action's outside the big cities. It's in the hinterlands, in the small and medium-sized cities, which in China are more than half the economy. They're doing terribly in a lot of parts of the country. So I think we're not seeing those numbers as readily. I've seen them in my work on property โ it's not current, it looks backwards. So my guess is they're at 2%, and that would be good for everything that's going on there.
But you know what we are seeing from investors at this point in time is โ and it seems like China's no longer uninvestable, and that seems to be playing out through the second half of 2024, and I don't know how it'll play out in 2025. What's your take?
We'll see. I mean, I think the rule of law is a problem. They're maintaining control. I think investors have to talk it up to some extent because they can't get out. So most investors aren't pulling out of China because you can't, and they're just investing in India and Singapore and Korea and other places. So I don't think we're going to see a huge flow of foreign capital, except where there are subsidies, maybe in electric vehicles, where China โ if they're sharing technology. But I think it's still a very difficult situation for investors in China. It's unpredictable.