Thank you so much, and thanks to Jen, Jason, Adam, and this audience for coming. It's a great privilege to speak here. Dick's work on international policy cooperation was very influential on my work, hence the title. I got to admit we're not in a great period for international economic policy cooperation right now, but that's another point. I knew Dick for actually 50 years. I knew him as an undergraduate at Yale, but he was, as Jason said, an incredibly vibrant colleague. And just one point I want to make is that he was, you know, a very vigorous debater. When he thought he was right, he thought he was right, and he would, you know, explain it to you or to students who are presenting a seminar. And I'd actually say, you know, particularly in today's environment and what's gone on, I think for a long time in universities in the profession, a thing that Dick was really good at when he debated you is he would try to be very clear about what are you trying to say? Is that your point? And then he would disagree with it, as opposed to use demagogic misrepresentation, you know, selective citation, etc., which has bled over into the profession, particularly in some of the public debate.
And just one final point on that. So we had different views about the risks of the US current account. I won't get into it, but we were both at the World Economic Forum in Switzerland, and somebody thought it would just be a great idea if we had a debate, and it was an interesting debate. He made a lot of great points. Maybe I made a couple. But what I really noticed was afterwards the audience of, you know, the very few academics, they just thought it was hysterical that the two Harvard professors disagreed with each other. Like, how could that be? But there you have it.
So I'm going to talk basically based off a few points from my book, Our Dollar, Your Problem. I actually finished this book before I knew who would win the election, and I'm grateful for that because I don't know what I would have done. I had thought of changing the title at the last minute to Our Donald, Your Problem, but it would have been very hard to follow him. I actually was concerned about both sides. I thought the progressives had a lot of nutty ideas and were trying to implement them, and so many of the things I talk about, central bank independence, problems with fiscal policy, to me it didn't matter who won in that particular sphere.
I'd say the reason I wrote the book was I did feel we were at a hinge moment in history. I mean, little did I know, but I felt that in kind of looking over where the world was going geopolitically, economically, and I thought it was sort of a good moment to take stock and try to give historical and analytical perspective. And just speaking again of Dick, you know, whenever graduate students would present a mathematical model, he'd be pushing them to do that. And so I think I was taking a page out of his book.
And I think, you know, in some cases I changed my mind about things I thought for a long time. In other cases I got new interpretations. I also think I wrote it because I just had an idea about how I wanted to write the book. You'll have to read it to see what it is, but I think it's quite unusual, you will find, for an economics book. I use quite a few personal anecdotes, but it's certainly not a memoir. In order, first of all, to make it so that AI couldn't have written it yet, and also, no offense to the journalists, but a journalist couldn't have written it. But also I felt I had something I wanted to say, and if you don't write it in a way that anyone wants to read it, they won't pay attention.
And I would say if there's a theme in the book in terms of the economics, it's I feel the profession has forgotten political economy, that I think is very central to thinking about issues. They just think it's like, you know, setting a thermostat, and you could come from fiscal policy to central bank policy to international policy cooperation. There were a few specific issues that I'd worked on a lot the last 10 years where I felt I wanted to emphasize them more in this way. And one of the issues is China. I'll come to another issue is how to think about interest rates and debt. And certainly another one is the dollar. Each of these pieces based on various strands of my work. And, you know, in a way I use the last theme as the way to try to hold it together.
And I have, I think it's very important to look at history, and I have so many people, you know, say to me, 'Oh, the dollar is never going to go away. Everything's going to be the same.' You know, who are you kidding? And actually when I was telling colleagues and people who I guess are in tech or financial markets about this as late as January, they were just, 'Oh, you know, who would care?' And then of course Liberation Day came and everybody, everyone said, 'Wow, your timing was great,' and made me feel like I'd understated some of the cases. And I'm just going to show you a map from my work with Ethan Ilzetzki and Carmen Reinhart where we have an exchange rate classification. I don't have details, but you could look at a lot of different ways to look at it. Red is places that are dollar-centric. This is 1950.
Europe's dollar-centric here. That's after World War II when the United States was sort of the last country standing, accounted for, who knows exactly, but about 40% of world GDP. And the Bretton Woods system, that's the fixed exchange rate system that came after the war, put the US at the center and everyone else was supposed to fix. But of course it wasn't the whole world. I mean, Russia, China were doing their own thing. There were many countries in blue, the light blue, are countries in the French franc zone. Green is the UK. There were countries still on the pound. I mean, these things didn't happen overnight. And if you read the book, you'll see there are these ebbs and flows.
The title of the book comes from one of the downshifts in the dollar. In 1971, the US went off the gold standard once and for all. Of course, in 1933, in the early 30s, the US stopped redeeming treasury bills for gold. That was a default. That's another story. But the system after World War II was that everybody had to, everybody being really the very limited number of countries in red there, nobody else was playing the game, but everybody was supposed to fix to the dollar and have dollars to do that. And the US was supposed to give them gold for the dollars if they asked. And I'll come to that later. And, you know, at some point that didn't work. I would say much earlier than most people thought.
And in 1971, Nixon went off the gold standard. And the Europeans were furious because back in those times they were holding reserves of a comparable level as a share of their income to what the Asians are holding today. And they're looking at us inflating. And Nixon sent John Connally over to meet with them. Connally had been governor of Texas and actually was in the car the day John F. Kennedy was shot. He was badly injured but recovered, became Treasury Secretary, very tough Texan, and he confronted his European colleagues and he said, 'Well, it's our dollar, it's your problem.' And I think that always spoke to me because first of all I don't like that arrogance. I believe in cooperation is better for us in the long run. I think it's a big mistake to reject that. But also it was our problem when we got rid of the gold standard. We hadn't invented independent central banks yet. Almost no one really had an independent central bank. Maybe Germany and Switzerland, the US a little bit later, and we had the big inflation of the 1970s because of this.
So if we fast forward to 2015, which in my book I regard as the peak of the dollar standard, Europe is actually gone. And that's a point worth noting. They're on the euro, of course, and I've got this is again from my paper with Ethan and Carmen where countries that literally anchor to the dollar or their monetary policies follow it very closely, and, you know, it's just a sea of red there in the whole world. I'm not going to show you another graph because I'll come to it. My book was not allowed to have color graphs. It would raise the price too much. It's a university press. They did a great job and it ended up selling quite a lot of copies anyway, but I don't have a color version of this, but it's diminished a lot. I mean, obviously Russia's not on it. China has loosened quite a bit since 2015, and you can look at other measures like reserves and stuff, and it's gone down.
So let me just briefly, you know, say there's, you know, why is it so great being the dollar? There are a few different reasons I think they're not totally appreciated. One is of course you get a lower interest rate for a given amount of borrowing. It doesn't just say the US gets a lower interest rate than Germany. It says the US gets a lower interest rate controlling for borrowing. A second one is that part of this is because of dollar dominance. The US is the back office to the financial world. A lot of clearing goes through the United States and that gives us a lot of information. That's why our sanctions are so effective.
And of course, one of the reasons that I think eventually China just can't stick with the dollar is eventually they're going to try to acquire Taiwan and we're going to put financial sanctions on them as much as we can. They know that and they're preparing for that, and I think a lot of other countries feel that way. I don't have time in these limited space to talk all of the issues around exorbitant privilege, but there's one concept is the low interest rate you get on debt, another is that the United States has been the banker to the world and we were able to invest a lot in the rest of the world at a time when Giscard d'Estaing, who was then prime minister and later became president of France, coined this phrase exorbitant privilege. What made him mad was not so much just having to hold the treasury bills, but Americans seemed to be buying up Europe, building factories, getting very big profits from these factories.
And one of the pictures I couldn't put in the book because it just wouldn't be good not in color was my aunt Henrietta actually was one of these people. She designed shoes, or she aspired to, but it was too expensive to make them in New York. She moved to Italy and produced shoes there which she imported back into the United States. And I tie this to a lot of other things, but this is actually a picture of her shoes from McCall's magazine in 1952, done by Andy Warhol, which she commissioned. And I follow through in the book. Had she only bought this picture instead of treasury bonds, which she had in the 1970s, she would have been a lot richer.
So I think there are a number of moments where the United States was lucky or aggressive or good, you can decide, to maintain this dominance that it had. And I think one was the case of the Japanese yen, where it's one of the episodes I give of having changed my mind. I think this happened in 1985. The Plaza Accord, I see Ted Truman here, you know, was very involved in that. I was in a little way writing some background papers and I talk about it. And the accord itself didn't do everything, but the accord and the period that followed was a huge screw-up for Japan. This is the yen falling from 260 yen per dollar down, and it hit almost 120. It fell by more than half in a short period, and the intention of the Plaza Accord was a 10% depreciation. That was, you know, what everyone had marked, and didn't quite work out that way.
You can also even go back to the Soviet Union where I'm old enough to remember when we didn't know how badly it would do. And I talk about my professors at Yale, Samuelson's book, everything predicting with a lot of confidence that the Soviet Union was going to do better, and frankly it might have in a different history. There were the Brezhnev-Kosygin reforms in the mid-60s which were quite a bit like what China did much later, but, you know, that fell short. The yen's an example, the euro is another example where the euro actually had a bigger market share before the euro crisis, and then it declined, of course, in the euro crisis by almost any way that you try to measure it. And I think it may come back.
I will advertise a paper, not yet public probably so I can't say too much about it, that's coming out next week's Brookings by Tarek Hassan, who's an amazing professor at Boston University, who's another student of mine, who basically makes the point that if you make the tariffs much higher, the US just won't be the reserve currency, it will be the euro. And I had a paper 25 years ago with my co-authors showing that if you raise barriers to trade in general equilibrium, it hurts you a lot in everything. It hurts you also in capital markets.
I think the euro made this huge mistake of bringing Greece in. I think if it hadn't brought Greece in, we'd just be in a different world with where the euro is today. It made it much harder to get rid of. I had an interesting debate about all this with Otmar Issing, who was the first chief economist, also board member, in the European Central Bank. He had a lot of power as being chief economist. He came to my office and he didn't like some of the things I was saying, and I always give credit, again as with Dick, he was very civil about it. I mean, he really didn't like what I was saying. I think I'd given a press conference where I was kind of implicitly critiquing the ECB by asking, we were in a recession, would there be recovery, and I said, well, if Europe wants to see a recovery, they'll have to watch it on TV, while the United States was having a recovery.
But he presented me this book, which I still have. This is a novel by Stefan Zweig. It's called The Royal Game in English, a chess novel in German. And I tried for a while to figure out if there was some symbolism of it, because the theme of this story is that this person becomes a prisoner and plays chess in their head and goes crazy. Actually, if you've ever seen, was it Fight Club with Ed Norton, it's basically the same idea. But I later determined he just wanted to disagree.
I go on to talk about China, where I think they stuck with the dollar for too long. They were wrong, I think, and I think they're paying part of the price for this. This is another picture I couldn't put in the book. This is the Chinese Executive Leadership Academy in Pudong. I gave a talk there in 2005. And that's where you go to move up to a higher job. It's like their business school and you get retrained. And I was shocked because people would ask very candid questions. I couldn't believe it, you know, in front of everybody. And I was told, you know, here you're allowed to say anything. And I think about that again, you know, some days in our environment.
So I did, as Jason mentioned, I had been very concerned that China would have a growth slowdown based on real estate, but until I met Yuanchen Yang, who's now at the IMF, who came as a graduate student visiting Harvard, I didn't know how to put meat on that. And she's just amazing. And we did a series of papers together which, when they first came out, were rejected by the China scholars, rejected by the journals, and just thought to be crazy, saying that China was running out of steam. This was, our first papers were in 2019. It was, you know, called, you know, about the China housing bubble and infrastructure bubble.
One of the most striking statistics we had was just how much they had built in China, the overbuilding, and this is a measure of per capita housing space that we had. And another shocking thing is this is a measure of the, you can, it gives both 2022 and 2023, but the value of the Chinese housing stock at market prices compared to their everything else. And of course, if you have a housing problem there and people think housing prices are going down and everybody thinks housing prices are going down, it has a tremendous effect. We not only had trouble steering this through academics, it's eventually done very well and we have a Brookings paper coming. We also, of course, the Chinese didn't want to hear about it, but that's changed.
So Yuanchen, you know, was censored. The IMF let this through but with like a year delay and everything when she got there. I mean, for understandable reasons, but she was just awarded this prize given every two to three years in China for the top young economist in China. So that's totally official. This is basically her body of work. And so it's really remarkable that I go from, you'll see this episode in the book where I'm in 2016 talking about this to the China Development Forum and wondering if I'm going to be allowed to leave the country. And, you know, now I think it's more accepted.
There's also crypto. The world underground economy, according to World Bank estimates, is over 30% of GDP in developing countries and 17% of GDP in the advanced countries. The underground economy is tax evasion and there's illegal activity, terrorism, everything, but tax evasion's the big one. There are many different ways to try to estimate this. I have one that I think is kind of cool that just came out in a paper this year, which looks at Europe, looking at how much value-added taxes they collect and what they ought to be collecting based on surveys that they do, the European Commission does in different countries. And this is just a little table giving the mean, our mean estimate for what the tax evasion is, and then we actually give annual estimates, that's the standard deviation. They correspond remarkably to what people have gotten. Completely different methods. They're not all the same, but they correspond remarkably.
However, my, Stephanie Stantcheva, who's just won the Clark Medal in the US, she's French-Bulgarian, has a lot of family in Bulgaria. So, you see Bulgarians 20%. She said, 'You're not right. You just don't know what you're talking about.' I said, 'What do you mean? It can't just be 20%. It has to be something a lot larger. You know, I spent a lot of time there. You know, nobody pays taxes.' But I make this point because that's the market for crypto. There's a big market, and I have some papers about this with Carmen Reinhart and Clemens Graff on Weisser, where we're showing that crypto is being used for capital flight, using some I think kind of cool methods.
In the process of doing this, Clemens was in Lebanon for a while, personal reasons. So he was in Lebanon for a period and couldn't get any cash, and he actually had Bitcoin, and so he wandered around Beirut to find a place where he could exchange it, and he found this place. I've actually, I didn't put this in the book, I'll explain why, but I've taken as much identifying marks out of the picture as possible. He wanted to trade Bitcoin and found himself in a very sleazy part of Beirut, and so he got cash. And he later, he's able to see at least one of their wallets, they're doing $100,000, $1 million, he can see what's going in and out of it, and there was only one guard, and they're using cash, paper cash that you're being handed for your Bitcoin back and forth, and there was only one guard outside.
And he later realized, oh my god, this is a Hezbollah bank and this is how they're laundering money. And the reason I took all the identifying marks out and I didn't want to put it in the book is I'm definitely very pro-Israel, but I didn't want to give them a bombing site that they would have. So let me just conclude with talking about the US. I apologize, Jason, I'm running a bit over.
So there's something called the Triffin paradox, which was a prediction of Robert Triffin at Yale, who was actually there when I was an undergraduate, and I unfortunately didn't take his course, but he basically said the US is getting a smaller and smaller share of world GDP and our gold stocks not really rising at that rate. So how can you guarantee the dollar's good as gold? Eventually it blew up. There's this notion of a modern-day Triffin paradox where you look at US debt held abroad as a share of GDP. It's about 30% now. And the US share of global GDP has been steadily declining and there are concerns that it may cause problems. I won't talk about it here, but one of the themes I pick up is that I think what's changed is that we go through very long cycles in interest rates.
This is from the American Economic Review a year ago, a paper with two other former students, Barbara Rossi and Paul Schmelzing. Again, as with all my other students who far surpassed me in their technical competence and everything. But we look at eight centuries of data, and if you look at the US and the United Kingdom individually, as I do in the book, you get a similar view where it's very, very volatile. It's not as volatile as it looks because if you stretch out eight centuries they don't look as volatile. And then the blue line is an attempt at a smoothed curve, and it's declining, although if you go back starting about 1900 it's not so obvious that it's been declining. And I draw a little circle there about what I call the Rachel-Summers period.
That's a wonderful Brookings paper by Luc Laeven and Larry Summers written in 2019 where they focused on that period where I've drawn the circle and just declared there's a declining trend in global real interest rates. I'm trying to speak quickly and I apologize. This is a measure of the long-term real interest rate here, and I had debated that with Larry around the world saying, you know, there was a financial crisis, Volcker, they raised the interest rate a lot. I mean, I don't know if this is a trend. I lost every debate. But one thing people say now, there are very smart people who still think the interest rates are going to get lower and lower. There are very smart people who are not so sure. Larry Summers definitely now being one of them.
Where our August AER paper looked at the correlation between demographics and the real interest rate, and red the real interest rates in blue. Red is demographics. And you can see that over most of time, and you can break this down a lot more, it's not so obvious. And we can talk about the economics, aren't that obvious either. Now, it's true we could have AI, and also spend quite a bit of time on that in the book, and that could provide great growth. But the thing I would say a caution about that is aside from it could take a lot longer. I played the first great chess program in the mid-1970s when I arrived at MIT, and it really took another 40 years before, you know, they got to be really good, or certainly 30 years and 40 years, and I wouldn't be surprised of having a similar cycle here. There are other things like electricity, copyright law, and other things.
But above all, I would say if you're thinking about tax collection and growth, it's a lot harder to tax capital than it is to tax labor. Capital is mobile. Just aside from the simple point, the tax rates are lower. So we're in a world where labor share is just going to decline and decline. Very hard to resist that. It's been going on from globalization, but I think it'll continue. So anyway, this is when we have military spending coming, this is actually a game, someone's here from the Norwegian embassy. This is an exhibition game I played against Magnus Carlsen, who back then and still today is by far the best player in the world. And I hadn't played...
in 30 years. But this was an exhibition game for charity, and I actually made a draw, which is another story, and I just wanted to show it.
And one other thing to finish with: I did a debate with Brad DeLong in 2016, and Brad's actually been, you know, kind of on the forefront of some of these ideas. I thought it was Chatham House rules, and Jason shaking his head as there's no such thing with Brad. Yes, I thought it was Chatham. I was told it was Chatham House rules.
And so the next day I find myself quoted on his blog, and he's drawn a picture. That's the blue is the Treasury bill rate, 10-year, that's the one I've been drawing. Red is the inflation rate, has just about come to zero. And I was saying I've seen God with chess. I think AI is coming, and I also think the financial crisis was responsible for part of why interest rates are low. And in my debates with Larry, I'd said a year earlier we did a debate in front of the G7 finance ministers and central bankers, and I said in 10 years no one is going to be talking about secular stagnation. Of course, I lost the debate, but Larry's, no one can win a debate with Larry. But with Brad, I said nine years because I said, well, I said 10 years a year ago with Larry, so I've got to say nine years. He quoted me, and of course I put this, I do put in the book, and I thank Brad immensely for memorializing this discussion, which I'd been saying, but anyway.
And this is my earlier book, This Time Is Different, with Carmen Reinhart, and there's some elements of similarity here, and trying to, people extrapolating what are really short-run trends, which, you know, maybe aren't, without taking some perspective on longer history. So let me stop there. I ran way over, but...