In the introduction, I explained you guys just crossed a trillion dollars in global assets. I didn't mention your new book, which your hat is promoting: Stay Calm: Learn to Embrace Uncertainty in Investing and Life. We're going to talk about that in a few minutes, but first I just want to start with your background because it's kind of fascinating. You go to University of Kansas for a bachelor's in economics and then the University of Chicago for a PhD, where you become future Nobel laureate Gene Fama's research assistant and TA. Tell us a little bit about the original career plan. That sounds like you're going to be an academic.
Well, no, that's the reason I went to... Is David's mic not on? Hello. Uh, there you go. You're set. Okay, the um, yeah, I went there, the idea of being a professor in finance, and then along the way I realized the world would be better served if Gene Fama did the research and I tried to figure out how to apply the ideas. So that's, um, it was, you know, a transformative time in life, and the decision to leave, as the dean of the business school says, was a good decision for me and for the business school.
And that would be the Booth School of Business at University of Chicago. So when you decide you don't want to be an academic, you end up working with Mac at Wells Fargo, who a lot of people don't realize he created the first index fund. How did you find your way to Mac, and what was that job like?
Well, when I decided I wanted to leave the PhD program, I went into Gene Fama's office and said I wanted to leave. And so he said, 'Well, you know, I have this guy who always wanted one of my students. I'll give him a call.' That was Mac. And he was starting, among other things, indexing out at Wells Fargo.
So how do you end up at Wells Fargo heading to Brooklyn to launch Dimensional Funds? What was that transition?
Well, there were a lot of things happening between, and there's about a 10-year gap in there. But eventually we came up with the idea to start Dimensional, and the first idea was just a small-cap fund. And we were the first people to treat small-cap stocks as a separate asset category, or a separate dimension, or a separate factor, if you will. So inadvertently, we created factor investing without having a label for it.
So you guys were the first people to apply Fama's research and come up with an approach, and if my research is correct, this was really not even small-cap. This was micro-cap. That was the first fund.
And how did that fund do?
Well, it kind of started off kind of rocky. We had a rough nine years. When we started out, the small-cap stocks have never underperformed the S&P by as much as they did for over nine years.
Yeah, right. Well, basically 82 to 90, nine years. And for example, the seven and a half years ending in '90, the S&P compounded at 14% and we compounded at 2% a year. So it's, you know, a challenge for new entrepreneurs. You know, you start out with an idea, you have no track record, this is your first idea, and it's disappointing. I do have to add the last 36 years have been terrific. The first nine, though, were pretty nasty.
So what gives you the confidence to stay with the theory? And to be blunt, that was an unproven, untested theory in the 1980s.
Well, it was, but we had an overwhelming idea. Shows you the power of a good idea. Our sales pitch, if you will, was we'd go into large institutions. Our first clients were all big pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, institutional investors, and we'd say, 'Look, seems sensible if you're forming an equity portfolio, you would have stocks of large companies and small. You wouldn't just have large.' And go, 'But you're not holding the small.' And they go, 'Well, that's true,' because, you know, they were all trying to pick stocks, and there weren't many firms that could handle institutional-size money and still invest in small-cap stocks. So we go, okay, that's our pitch, we'll give you access to small stocks. So at the end of that nine years the results were disappointing, but we did what we said we were going to do. And in fact, over that 45 years we've significantly outperformed the benchmark index through better trading and market mechanics.
Do you ever stop and think: we launched the firm in the early '80s, we had a tough first decade, and now 45 years plus later the firm is headquartered in Austin, you employ more than 1,600 people and manage more than a trillion dollars. Was that imaginable in 1982?
No, it was just we were really trying to apply the new ideas that were coming out, trying to apply the sciences as you mentioned, evidence-based science. You know, the idea of you can't help but being optimistic if you really understand the science. And that's really kind of what we try to do is help people better understand how public markets work.
Man, that's the perfect segue into helping people understand markets. Your new book, Stay Calm: Learn to Embrace Uncertainty in Investing and Life, just published a couple of weeks ago. Let's talk a little bit about that. One of the themes throughout the book is uncertainty isn't something to fear, it's where possibility lives. Explain that. I love that quote.
Well, people naturally shrink away from uncertainty. And yet, it's uncertainty that creates the opportunity in life and investing. Without uncertainty, you wouldn't have been able to take advantage of the opportunities you've had and progress. And similarly in investing, if there were no uncertainty in investing, then investing would be riskless and all investments would have the riskless rate of return. So it's uncertainty that creates the opportunity, and what investing and life is about then is really managing uncertainty rather than eliminating it. You know, control what you can control and manage what you can't.
So let's stay with that theme: plan, don't predict. You can't foresee the future. Making financial decisions based on predictions is essentially making decisions based on worries or wishes.
Well, that's right. The um...
Well, that's your words. So, of course.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I mean, that's pretty clever there. You know, there was particularly one of the biggest problems I've observed over 50 years in the business is that anytime there's a market drop, people panic and want to get out. And so what we're trying to do is help people think through a rational story for staying invested. If I do another book, it may be called Stay Invested, but Stay Calm is adequate for the first one. So the idea is, you know, the market reacts to new information. You take the pandemic, it hits, everybody goes, 'What's going to happen?' I go, 'I don't know what's going to happen, but the pundits say this problem is going to be maybe two or three years.' So the market's down 20 or 30%. That's about right given what we know about the pandemic. So there's no reason to get out now. You know, prices have already adjusted. So if we can get people to stay invested, then over the long haul they'll end up being better off.
The question then, you know, why do stocks have the rate of return they have over the long... over the last hundred years, stocks have done about 10% a year, a little bit more. You know, why is that? Because the relatively riskless assets have returned about four or five, so you have this five or six percent risk premium for stocks. How do you explain that? And that goes back to the pandemic. We go, people are saying, 'What's going to happen?' I don't know what's going to happen, but here's what I believe, and here's why I think you get that 10% return over time. You know, when bad things happen to people, they don't just sit there and take it. They figure out what it takes to get back on track. And you know, the pandemic has hit, there'll be a lot of firms that have been hit hard with something. They'll figure out new ways to go forward. New products will come out, and there'll be winners and losers. I don't know who the winners and losers will be, but it's that human ingenuity that will get us back on track. It's people taking advantage of, viewing the uncertainty as an opportunity, taking advantage of that and transforming their firms that will get us back on track faster than you might think, which is what happened. You know, that recession in 2020 only lasted one quarter. That's human ingenuity at work. And arguably the peak to trough, the market was down 34 days. It's nothing.
But what you mentioned about being calm in the face of a down 34% over 17 trading days. How much of this is essentially Gene Fama's efficient market hypothesis? If the market is reflecting the downside of the pandemic, what good does it do you to sell down 34%?
Well, that's right. It's already too late. I mean, so you look, we have the pandemic, it hits, the market's down 34%, whatever the... you know, that's about right. I mean, it's about what it should be. The market's doing its job. It's setting prices so that going forward you have a positive expected outcome, you know. So you look at the marketplace, are investors coming in? Are trades getting done? There was a lot of trading activity. So somebody's out there buying [laughter] and...
Two sides to every trade, right?
Well, the two sides of every trade. Yeah, that's right. And over the... there's not much correlation between people's anxiety and future stock returns. In fact, if anything, the more the anxiety, the higher the future stock return, because the higher the anxiety, the more the stock price drops.
That's right. You get a VIX over 40 or 50 tends to be a better buying opportunity than a selling opportunity.
Yeah. That pandemic, the last three quarters of the year, the market was up like 50%. So it ended up 20% for the year even though you had that horrible stretch to begin with. That's why that's the important thing of staying invested. You know, there's a huge opportunity cost for being out of the market. If you want that 10% return of the market, you got to be there to get it. There are no mulligans like in golf, or there are no do-overs. If you missed out on that 50%, you missed out on that 50%.
So there are a lot of advisors in the audience who appreciate the theory, but they want to know how can they put this into effect in their clients' portfolios. One of the things you write about in the book: control what you can and manage what you can't. Explain that.
Well, I mean, you can't predict the stock market. You can control how much risk you take. And so there are two ways of controlling risk. The primary one is how much do you have in risky assets like the stock market and how much do you have in relatively riskless assets like a money market fund or whatever. Then on the equity side, buy the whole market rather than taking the risk of individual stocks. You know, individual stock prices can go to zero. The stock market is not going to zero. So it's about controlling the amount of risk you take, is controlling the uncertainty, and then managing it through the process of these various risk controls.
So let's talk about... the book's title is Stay Calm. Let's talk about a source of un-calm. You write about the modern financial media, saying it is designed to capture your attention, presenting commentary, stories, and expert forecasts that are nothing more than distracting noise. That's a pretty extreme statement, isn't it?
Yeah, that's a little strong, but it captures the right idea. You know, there's not much evidence that people can predict markets, and trying to time short-term movements in the market is definitely, I think, a losing game. So yet you have the chatter every day. I mean, these financial news, they have to come up with something every day, a new story every day, and most of that's just noise. So if you're investing for 10, 20 years, how much does non-farm payrolls or what the Fed does with rates this week matter to your 401k?
Yeah. Well, that's right. I mean, I don't know why people pay attention to the... Well, I do know it's important to pay attention to what's going on in the market because it can impact, you know, your whole life. I mean, the amount of your wealth, the value of your portfolio, may determine, you know, vacations you take or whatnot. You want to consider what's going on in the market in the light of your overall situation.
So there's another quote of yours from the book that I enjoyed: 'In investing, success often comes not from doing more, but from tuning out more.' Is it fair to say investors should be tuning out more? Because whenever I say just ignore the noise, the pushback is you can't ignore the noise. People are humans and they're going to respond.
Yeah, that's... it's really important. And that's why people need financial advisors, I think, to help them stay the course. You know, people's instincts often lead them to get out of the market just at the wrong time. And having wise counsel, an advisor you can trust, I think can help you stay the course.
So to me, the most interesting thing about the book is that it's about more than just investing. It's about how to think about investing, how to think about life, and the things that really matter. Taking stock of what really matters. What made you go in that direction?
Well, it occurred to me after about 40 years in the business that dealing with uncertainty applies to more than just investing. You know, investing is complex and uncertain. So is life, you know. And as you start thinking through how you've dealt with uncertainty in life's issues, the parallels are kind of strong to how we deal with uncertainty in investing. Control what you can control. Can't control the market, we can control how much risk to take. Plan, don't predict. You can't predict the market, you can develop a sensible plan that you can work. Now, of course, you want to be flexible and adaptive. You know, there's no just kind of one decision that works forever. You got to pay attention to what's going on. And so life lessons, you know, how did you decide issues like parenting? You know, anybody that's had a two-year-old realizes you're not in total control there. You know, control what you can, and then adapt to what you can't.
So let's talk about some of the adaptation you've done. You start out working with Gene Fama, eventually the Fama-French factor model. You begin working with Ken French. There's a run of different Nobel laureates and people on your board of advisors and other people you've worked with. Where does Arnold Schwarzenegger fit into that group of academics?
Well, I wouldn't say he's an academic, but he's an incredibly bright man. It's just that's a long story, but anyway...