CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jill Lepore gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jill Lepore
Professor of American History and Law; Staff Writer, The New Yorker, Harvard University

Are We Repeating The 1930s? with Jill Lepore

📅 Oct 22, 2025 Hasan Minhaj 49 MIN 309571 VIEWS 136 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Hasan sits down with Harvard history and law professor Jill Lepore to discuss her new book “We The People: A History of the U.S. Constitution” to talk about technocracy, A.I. president and the 1939 Madison Square Garden Nazi Rally. Co-Creator & Executive Producer: Hasan Minhaj Co-Creator & Executive Producer: Prashanth Venkataramanujam Executive Producer/Director: Tyler Babin Executive Producer/Showrunner: Scott Vrooman Cinematographer: Austin Morales Producer: Kayla Feng Associate Producer: Annie Fick Editor: N/V Moore Editor: Will Feinstein Talent Coordinator: Tanya Somanader Executive Assi...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:00Do you think Batman would vote for Donald Trump?
  2. 3:21So that for sure happens with people as they think about our political circumstances too, right?
  3. 6:09Do you feel like there's a parallel between that type of propaganda influencing the masses in the 1930s and kind of social media and Web 2.0 in the 2010s and 2020s?
  4. 10:27These are all things we're still talking about, right?
  5. 14:54And what happened at that rally?
  6. 18:53Now, was this a cool story? What's going on here?
  7. 22:36What do you mean by that?
  8. 24:53Who would your 39 delegates be?
  9. 28:52But like, is that inevitable? Is that not reversible?
  10. 33:14... do you foresee the speed at which they are working and the fact that the current justice system and the current government is so analog, the speed of digital, and that these technologists, they're essentially the new founding fathers?
  11. 39:29Wait, so you believe in dead internet theory?
  12. 43:07You mean his father, Errol Musk?
Host 0:00 ↗
Do you think Batman would vote for Donald Trump?
Jill Lepore 0:03 ↗
So really, which Batman? Adam West? No. Um, the Christopher Nolan Batman? Yes. What do you think?
Host 0:11 ↗
I don't think Nolan Batman. Nolan Batman definitely is not registered to vote.
Jill Lepore 0:16 ↗
Okay, that's fair. That's fair.
Host 0:18 ↗
Jill Lepore is an author, New Yorker staff writer, and professor of history and law at Harvard University. She expects a lot from her students and her readers. Her 2018 book, These Truths: A History of the United States, was 955 pages. Holy [__]. Her new book, We the People: A History of the US Constitution, is 720 pages. Thank you so much for being considerate. But these aren't just Zoom meeting bookshelf decorations. These are gateways to understanding how our history shapes who we are and where we're going as a country. Now, have I finished reading either of these books? No, but I have followed Professor Lepore for years because she understands that the best way to explain the present is to talk about the past. So, we get into it. We talk about technocracy, propaganda, AI presidents, and the 1939 Madison Square Garden Nazi rally here in New York City. And I ask her a question on behalf of America's tech oligarchs.
Isn't the manifesto basically just a constitution with more cocaine?
The moon could be holding over $1 trillion worth of platinum in its craters. This is such a wild concept that I had to check it out on Ground News, which is today's sponsor. Ground News shows a breakdown of publications reporting on a story, including the ownership, factuality, and political leanings of that story. It's not about eliminating bias. We've all got biases. It's just trying to make you aware of potential biases or the veracity of different publications as you analyze an event or an issue. For example, when I read about the moon, I was able to scroll between some of the 17 reporting publications. 84% of the sources were considered high factuality by Ground News, while others were not. Though, I probably could have guessed that by the headlines. One article was titled, quote, 'A sensational treasure is hidden on the moon. Whoever gets it could become very rich.' I'm skeptical, but I am listening. Use the link in the description or go to groundnews.com/han to get 40% off their Vantage plan, the same one we use here at HMDK. That breaks down to just five bucks a month for unlimited access. Visit groundnews.com/hassen. Subscribe today.
You teach history at Harvard University and you're also a law professor. You wrote a 955-page history of the United States. Many people have it on their bookshelf. Um, I saw it as decoration for owning it.
Jill Lepore 2:58 ↗
Yeah. Yeah. I saw it as decoration. You know, the Zoom meeting flex. It's in the background of like, it has some heft to it.
Host 3:03 ↗
That counts.
My question to you is, are Americans too dumb about history to realize that we are reliving history right now?
Jill Lepore 3:10 ↗
No. History as an academic discipline. Okay, set that aside for a minute. But just like we live in a world where we're constantly orienting ourselves in relationship to the past. Yeah.
Host 3:21 ↗
So that for sure happens with people as they think about our political circumstances too, right? I don't think it means, oh, you have to have taken AP US history.
Jill Lepore 3:33 ↗
Sure. Sure.
Host 3:33 ↗
Or you have to have gone to college. And like, I think people have a real sense of change over time because that's just, it's like how we steer the boat. But do you think on some level we feel intuitive historical deja vu of like, this has to have happened before?
Jill Lepore 3:48 ↗
I think we are flooded with historical arguments. Like 'Make America Great Again' is like a four-word historical argument, right? Like it just presupposes a past. It makes a claim about who could change the future. Like our whole politics is oriented around, like, progressivism, right? Is like an argument about progress. Conservatism, and it's an argument about conserving the traditions and history. Like we just live that. Like maybe we're not as... I mean, like my job is to think about this stuff all day, so I think about it all day, but I don't know that people think about it all day. But I do think we are immersed in a world of daily lived experiences and popular culture and politics where the place of history looms exceedingly large, maybe, you know, maybe even too large.
Host 4:40 ↗
I speak for the casuals. I speak for people that are just feeling it in the comment section, in the streets as I mill about here in Midtown Manhattan. And one of the things I keep hearing from a lot of people is we are living through a 1930s moment. This feels like the 1930s all over again. As a historian, what are the parallels that you see between the 1930s and the 2020s? What we're living through right now?
Jill Lepore 5:07 ↗
Well, I think when people say that, they're talking about the rise of the Nazi party in Germany, and they're talking about the abdication by ordinary Germans of a moral voice that could have stood in opposition to what Hitler and the party were doing over the course of the 30s. They're thinking about the appeasement on the part of the European powers famously like kind of appeased Hitler for a long time. Yes. And so they're thinking about that. They're also thinking about what was at the time called the strategy of terror. The Germans had this crazy effective PR machine where before they were going to invade or do anything, they would on the radio sort of broadcast effectively that they had already done it.
Host 5:58 ↗
Yes.
Jill Lepore 5:58 ↗
And just terrorize the population into giving up before they even rolled in the tank.
Host 6:03 ↗
So this is so interesting. You've written about this. You wrote about the power of radio as a form of media.
Jill Lepore 6:09 ↗
Yeah.
Host 6:09 ↗
In the 1930s. Do you feel like there's a parallel between that type of propaganda influencing the masses in the 1930s and kind of social media and Web 2.0 in the 2010s and 2020s?
Jill Lepore 6:21 ↗
Yeah. I mean, yes and no. I mean, like with most parallels, it's like it's parallel, but it's also perpendicular. Like you can kind of get lost in this.
Host 6:29 ↗
It's not perfect. It's not perfect.
Jill Lepore 6:30 ↗
It's not perfect. Right. So the thing about radio that's just kind of almost impossible to, you know, when you have like your earbuds in and you're listening to a podcast and you have that like that total intimacy with the voice of the person.
Host 6:43 ↗
Why are you calling me out, professor? That's me on the train.
Jill Lepore 6:45 ↗
Like you feel so intimate. Like, okay, so think about when radio was new, right? And you have this device in your kitchen, you know, in your living room, and these voices are coming in and you don't respond, like you're just listening. So there was a huge amount of research at the time, like the whole like modern experimental psychology is kind of based on the study of the radio because the power of persuasion that that made available was extraordinary. And Germany's minister of propaganda, Goebbels, like understood that, right? He required everybody to have a radio in their house and he could basically push a button from his desk and tell the German people what to believe. And in the US there was a really determined effort to not allow that to happen, to not allow radio to become that. And there are all these kind of fantastic... So we think about like FDR and the fireside chat, like well maybe that is propaganda, like he wanted to like talk to have Americans gather around their fireside and he would tell them we have to close the banks. But there was also this incredible outpouring of democratic radio that was designed to say, okay, no, let's actually use this tool, this kind of crazy new technology that could be so dangerous, let's figure out how to use it to fortify our ideals of democratic participation, representation and deliberation. Like NBC had this show called, I think it was called The Town Meeting of the Air, and it begins with like this bell ringing and this town crier.
Host 8:11 ↗
What decade was this?
Jill Lepore 8:12 ↗
It was called The Town Meeting of the Air. It's so cool. You can listen to it on YouTube. So there would be like on the radio every week and they'd get this panel of people to like deliver. They had these topics like they were kind of like voted up, voted down topics. So it'd be like...
Host 8:23 ↗
So still thumbs up, thumbs down.
Jill Lepore 8:25 ↗
Yeah. Still thumbs up. Should we have like national health care? Should the Communist Party be outlawed? Whatever. Like, and they'd have people with different opinions debate them on the radio, and you were supposed to listen at home and then continue the debate. Like in the US, people tried to use radio to defend the United States against the rise of fascism, whereas of course in Germany it was used to advance fascism. So I guess your question is like is it parallel or not parallel? The thing is, I don't think any of the pro-democracy technologies that we associate with social media have ever worked. Maybe you can think of one that is working or has worked, but there are like a lot of dreams about that.
Host 9:08 ↗
Tell me about the federal program in the 1930s called the Federal Forum Program.
Jill Lepore 9:13 ↗
Yeah, this was this crazy good idea. It's kind of mindblowing. Really great idea. So this guy, I think he was maybe superintendent of schools in Detroit or Cleveland or one of these big Midwestern industrial towns, and he thought, all right, democracy is really in crisis. So the 30s in the US were very much like this moment, to get back to your bells, in the sense that everybody was worried about the future of democracy, like democracies are falling all over Europe and American democracy seemed pretty fragile. So there people would have these debates and you know whole issues of magazines would be like, what is the future of democracy? So this guy was like, 'All right, well, let's actually do some democracy. I have at my disposal all of the public schools in my entire school district that are empty every evening. Like why don't we use these buildings, like this bricks and mortar, to try to like bring people together to have these debates?' And so he would, they would do like door-to-door, like knock-on-the-door polling, also like up vote, down vote, ask people what they were interested in debating. And you know it could really be anything. And he would just then hold these meetings at the local schools. They would have the debate that the people in the neighborhood or the precinct had chosen. People come in, like give us some information. The public would, they would just have this kind of like big forum about...
Host 10:27 ↗
There's two things that you laid out that I thought were so interesting, which, well, number one, it was federally funded. Okay. And then number two, the topics seem so prescient. Should the power of the Supreme Court be altered? Do machines oust men? Must the West get out of the East? Do company unions help labor? Can we conquer poverty? I mean, I'm like, are these 1930s, just redo those? Like, let's just do like take... Is this like the Bernie and Zoran, you know, democratic socialism campaign? These are all things we're still talking about, right? We didn't solve them.
Jill Lepore 10:59 ↗
We didn't solve them.
Host 11:00 ↗
No.
Jill Lepore 11:00 ↗
But I do think it is pretty cool that like...
Host 11:03 ↗
You know, this was IRL debate. This isn't about social media clout. People had to put their shoes on and say that [__] to your face.
Jill Lepore 11:09 ↗
Yeah. You're all about putting shoes on.
Host 11:11 ↗
Put your shoes on. Yeah. This is about Thanksgiving dinner, but you're not forced to go. You're willingly engaging in some form of...
Jill Lepore 11:19 ↗
Yeah.
Host 11:20 ↗
Discourse. And even if it is about ego, did you find that people maybe found it as a more healthy way to resolve their differences?
Jill Lepore 11:28 ↗
I think it just like got people out of the house, stretched their muscles, like renewed their democratic habits. I mean, the closest we have in modern day, I think, was the January 6th riots, obviously. We had a representative government, number 45. He tweeted out a time and location. He was like, 'Pull up. Come one, come all.' People clearly put their shoes on. Some put on a Viking helmet. It could have used a moderator. But discourse happened. Seven people were killed. Two were cops.
Host 11:56 ↗
Yeah. Political protest is a different tradition. Political violence is a different, I guess you could call it a tradition. But those are, I will put to you, inimical to public debate. Like that is, to go and seek to overturn an election through violence is the opposite of the founding principle of democracy, that we agree to lose.
I don't know if you saw this post on Truth Social that was written by the president. Let's take a look at this. But essentially, the president here is directing this at Pam Bondi, and DJT is basically saying, 'Hey, Bondi, I need you to go after Comey, Adam Schiff, and Letitia James.' So, is it safe to say when friends and fellow citizens here in society are saying we are descending into fascism, is this fascism?
Jill Lepore 12:47 ↗
You know, it is in this sort of Orwellian sense, fascism becomes overused when both sides use it as a term of ready opprobrium, and then it loses its power, which is part of the problem with using the word fascism. You've probably noticed lately that it is far more preferred by journalists who are covering the Trump administration, by political scientists writing about executive overreach, the decay of the separation of powers, the failure of the Supreme Court to uphold its obligation to defend the Constitution against executive overreach. That really authoritarianism is, I think, a more accurate term. Fascism is a kind of cultural-wide phenomenon that we could talk about differently, but I think, you know, the outrageous Truth Social, whatever it is, post is classic authoritarianism, right? Like it is wildly unconstitutional, and the publication of it is even weirder, right? People are like, 'Did he mean to put that online?' Wasn't that just like...
Host 13:54 ↗
No, he meant... Yeah, he did. Yeah, he's got a lot of problems.
Jill Lepore 13:57 ↗
He did. He did. He did. But so I think it's tricky because there is a kind of dilution of the meaning of words that is also associated with fascism, right? So, but it is worth stepping back a minute and saying like, remember when, you know, Biden was like, 'I'm running, I'm running. We're the party defending democracy.'
Host 14:18 ↗
Yes.
Jill Lepore 14:20 ↗
And yet Biden didn't want to step aside. And yet the Democratic Party didn't want to hold an open primary or have a mini convention. Like there are institutional ways in which the Democratic Party, while touting itself as the party of democracy, was being profoundly anti-democratic, which really weakens our ability to think about democracy in meaningful terms. So, if you're willing for short-term political gain to use a term to advance your own party's aims without consequence for what it does for our ability to speak with clarity to one another, then damn you. That's how I feel about that.
Host 14:54 ↗
We're here in Midtown Manhattan. Literally a few blocks over is Madison Square Garden, aka the Mecca. I think one of the greatest arenas on planet Earth. Now, it's had many events held there. This was not a good event. In 1939, there was literally a Nazi rally at Madison Square Garden. What were the underpinnings of what happened there that allowed Ticketmaster of the time to issue tickets, have people come, all 17,500 seats get filled up? And what happened at that rally?
Jill Lepore 15:27 ↗
There is a really truly beautiful and profoundly distressing documentary film about that rally that I would really recommend to everyone by the director Marshall Curry.
Host 15:39 ↗
Yes.
Jill Lepore 15:39 ↗
Where he restored the footage that was taken, and there's just incredible audio of those addresses. If you ask what we are actively fighting for under our charter: first, a social, just Gentile-ruled United States. Second, Gentile-controlled labor union free from Jewish Moscow-directed domination. It is just really chilling to look at that space where you're like, you're used to seeing, I don't know, LeBron James or Larry Bird or whoever it is, you know, like these guys, and they have this giant banner of George Washington behind them, and they are selling Nazism as Americanism. That's in a way the thing to me as a historian that is really most shocking about it, the kind of repackaging of the ideals of the Nazi party as consistent with a particular party.
Host 16:44 ↗
How did they fundamentally sell this German authoritarian, fascist ideology to what was considered to be one of the world's leading democracies?
Jill Lepore 16:55 ↗
Yeah. So, it's important to remember they totally failed. They sucked and they failed and they were...
Host 17:00 ↗
Hot take. They sucked.
Jill Lepore 17:01 ↗
Yeah, they sucked.
Host 17:02 ↗
I agree. I agree, professor. I agree.
Jill Lepore 17:04 ↗
Also, like, it's also a tribute to the United States that they were able to hold an assembly. Like that is what our First Amendment is about. No one said you can't have this meeting. And the fact that they had the meeting really inspired people to think differently about just how perilous the possibility was of the United States falling to fascism. It was revolting, I think, to Americans at the time to see that this event had happened. You know, there are journalists who report, Dorothy Thompson, the great journalist, reports on that event. There's a protester who is, you can see this in the documentary, who is just jumped on and dragged out of the meeting. So it is what, you know, there are the, what they're arguing is the same crap that is being marketed by the far right across the history of the United States, right? In times of economic weakness where ordinary people are suffering and looking maybe for an explanation, looking for a group of people to blame, it can be sold to them as a political product that there's a particular group of people to blame and their difference from you is one that is immutable, and their presence in the United States is itself a defilement of the founding ideals of the country. I mean, it's like, it's not hard to make the list, right? It's sort of similar, like you could take that list of those topics at the debates held in the federal debate forums of the 1930s, and you can also take the list of the talking points of the Bund, the German Bund, which held that rally in 1939, and they will come across as very familiar.
Host 18:53 ↗
Well, this is something that was quite chilling. I mean, when you, I don't know if you saw this the other day, but it was reported that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, he called upon not just the top US generals, but the top US generals from around the world. Now, keep in mind, obviously, for those of our listeners that don't know, there's over like 750 bases, military bases that the United States has all over the world, and Pete Hegseth called them for an in-person meeting. Now, I know we're having a return-to-work moment, and I get it, but that's a lot of top generals that have to pull up and have a meeting in person, and that seemed unprecedented. But then a retired lieutenant general tweeted this. I don't know if you saw this. Ben Hodges goes, 'July 1935, German generals were called to a surprise assembly in Berlin, informed that their previous oath to the Weimar Constitution was void and that they would be required to swear a personal oath to the Führer. Most generals took the oath to keep their positions.' And then Pete Hegseth quote-tweets him and says, 'Cool story, General.' Was this for real? Did he really do that? This is for real. Now, was this a cool story? What's going on here?
Jill Lepore 20:05 ↗
No. Now, I'm a little stricken by the idea that he retweeted that.
Host 20:09 ↗
Yes. Quote-tweeted.
Jill Lepore 20:10 ↗
Effectively, what the Trump administration has done this second time around is instead of attempting to abide by the Constitution, even notionally, has been very explicit that the Constitution is what Trump says it is. That he does not have a duty to uphold the Constitution, and he has said as much himself, although that is in fact the oath that the president swears on his inauguration. But for Trump, the Constitution is malleable, can be whatever meaning he wants to attribute to it. So the 14th Amendment guarantees birthright citizenship, Trump says no, it doesn't, and therefore what he says is true's general rule is right, whatever I say is true.
Host 20:56 ↗
So he treats himself almost as a quasi both president and Supreme Court justice interpreter of the Constitution, essentially.
Jill Lepore 21:02 ↗
Yeah. So he has, just to be clear, there is no constitutional role for the president of the United States in interpreting the Constitution. The interpretation of the Constitution is left to the judiciary.
Host 21:13 ↗
Um.
Jill Lepore 21:14 ↗
But certainly presidents have always had...

65 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lepore, J. (2025, October 22). Are We Repeating The 1930s? with Jill Lepore [Interview transcript]. Hasan Minhaj. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146651/

MLA

Jill Lepore. "Are We Repeating The 1930s? with Jill Lepore." Hasan Minhaj, 22 Oct. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146651/.

BibTeX
@misc{lepore2025_3146651,
  author       = {Jill Lepore},
  title        = {Are We Repeating The 1930s? with Jill Lepore},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Hasan Minhaj. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146651/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}