CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jill Lepore gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jill Lepore
Professor of American History and Law; Staff Writer, The New Yorker, Harvard University

Dr. Jill Lepore on “The Rise and Fall of Artificial State” | New Dialogues S2 EP5

📅 Nov 06, 2026 The New School 47 MIN 23 VIEWS 65 SEGMENTS · 3 SPEAKERS
Dr. Jill Lepore, award-winning American historian, New Yorker staff writer, and professor of law and American history at Harvard University, joins Natalia Mehlman Petrzela, co-director of the Center for the American Experience and professor of History, for a conversation on her new book, “The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State.” In the book, Lepore examines how modern states have increasingly relied on bureaucratic systems, algorithms, and engineered institutions to manage society, raising urgent questions about who controls these artificial intelligence structures and what they mean for de...

What Jill Lepore said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Jill Lepore, professor of American history and law at Harvard and staff writer at The New Yorker, discussed her book 'The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State' with Natalia Melman-Paraella at The New School. She defined the artificial state as government by machine in lieu of government by consent, arguing that the public sphere is now a privately owned digital infrastructure dominated by bots. She traced its rise through a 1958 IBM chess programmer's scheme to simulate the electorate for the Kennedy campaign, and its fall through science fiction parables. Lepore criticized the rollout of large language models as a mistake, citing Sam Altman's firing and Anthropic's formation. She argued that universities are complicit in their own erosion, and predicted that human services will become a luxury for the rich while machines serve the poor.

Key takeaways

  1. Lepore defines the artificial state as government by machine in lieu of government by consent, eroding liberal constitutional democracy.
  2. Lepore calls the rollout of large language models a giant mistake, citing Sam Altman's firing and Anthropic's departure over ChatGPT's release.
  3. Lepore says universities are like elephants deforesting their own habitat by pushing AI tools on students and faculty.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
1958 Year Alex Bernstein programmed a computer to play chess at IBM timeline 6:53
1956 Year of the Dartmouth conference on artificial intelligence timeline 6:53
1960 Year of the Kennedy campaign that used the people machine timeline 8:18
2015-2016 Period of the Cambridge Analytica scandal timeline 10:26
1787 Year the US Constitution mandated a national census timeline 15:07
1880s Decade of the Census Bureau contest that started IBM timeline 15:07
1971 Year ARPANET was put together timeline 26:12
1996 Year of the Telecommunications Act that opened the internet to commercial traffic timeline 26:12
2022 Year ChatGPT was released to the public timeline 28:00
2,000 pages Size of FBI files Lepore processed with AI metric 32:53

Chapters

  1. 0:00Defining the artificial state
  2. 4:04The rise and fall narrative
  3. 6:53Turning points in history
  4. 12:08Private corporations and accountability
  5. 15:07Tech CEOs and politics
  6. 20:00Masculinity and tech culture
  7. 24:55Universities and AI
  8. 35:40Humanities in the AI age
  9. 37:14Attacks on higher education
  10. 44:19Career advice and courage

Questions asked in this interview

10
  1. 0:39So let's start with a very basic question, but a fundamental one. What is the artificial state?
  2. 3:49What's our role in it too?
  3. 6:22... curious because you have better than anyone a grasp on this long history: were there particular turning points or particular decision points when things could have gone differently, either because of political events or individual choices?
  4. 12:08So is the private piece the issue?
  5. 14:16... whether you think there's this kind of inextricable or irresolvable tension between representative democracy and sort of things that are good for humanity and the rise of this technology, or do they sometimes dovetail and work together?
  6. 19:23Is there a conflict of interest there?
  7. 19:51You know, you mentioned these men in the tech world, and another audience question was, why do you think it's so many men who are kind of the architects of this state?
  8. 21:22And that's where the science fiction stuff is also really interesting because it's part of the cult of the laddishness of these guys, right?
  9. 35:07No, and I think it's also who's doing it, right?
  10. 42:34Like everything about getting out and going to the classroom, not just the educational piece of it, right?
Narrator 0:00 ↗
This is New Dialogues, a new school podcast.
Jill Lepore 0:03 ↗
When I describe the artificial state, I mean something dystopian, but actually for a number of these very powerful men in the tech world, it is a utopia. So this is what they want. So, you know, Sam Altman of OpenAI, you know, started saying some years ago he thinks an AI president would be better than a human president.
Narrator 0:26 ↗
In this episode, renowned author and historian Dr. Jill Lepore and Professor Natalia Melman-Paraella discuss Lepore's new book, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State and the Impact of AI on Our Future.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 0:39 ↗
Thank you so much for being here. I'm thrilled to talk to you. Longtime reader, first time discussing, so you know. So let's start with a very basic question, but a fundamental one. What is the artificial state?
Jill Lepore 0:50 ↗
Yeah, it was founded here in New York. That's a joke. No one even got my joke. Thanks for that. Cool. I'm sorry. I'm still reeling from trying to map this New York history of my books. So my last book, We the People, was a history of the US Constitution and broadly of written constitutionalism and the founding of the world's first liberal democracies. And I ended that book with an epilogue called The Future of Constitutionalism, in which I reflected on the question: can an 18th century constitution, you know, an artifact of the age of the printing press, truly deal with questions of fundamental law in the 21st century, relating both to the natural world, which we had a very different understanding of — the framers of the Constitution had a very different understanding of than that prevails today — and increasingly the artificial world, and it's down to artificial intelligence. And I found that very tricky epilogue to write. It was quite inconclusive.
And then I thought about what sort of set me back on my heels, thinking, what is actually going on with liberal constitutional democracies. And I ended up writing this, for me, very short book in which I argue that the liberal constitutional nation state is being eroded and slowly replaced by what I call the artificial state, which is government by machine in lieu of government by consent.
Government by consent is an invention of the late 18th century. It's a fragile and precarious thing, something people achieve and lose for many different reasons. What's for me fascinating about the rise of the artificial state is how much we have surrendered to it. So it's sort of the digital infrastructure that automates political behavior and controls political behavior by way of prediction and simulation, and increasingly replaces the human work that is required in a democracy, which has three legs, you know: representation, participation, and deliberation.
So people like, well, are we living in an artificial state? I mean, there are elements of it that I think we are very much living in. I think the public sphere is really no longer a public sphere. It's a privately owned digital infrastructure in which the majority of traffic is by bots, not humans. Those bots are not humans. They're not citizens. They're owned by corporations. They're foreign actors. And yet most people here and around the world get their news — a majority of people get their news through social media, which is a platform owned by corporations and dominated by nonhumans. That's an artificial state.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 3:49 ↗
So you very compellingly track this rise, and we're definitely living in a moment of the rise of the artificial state. But this is about the rise and fall. And so is that a call to action? Is that a prediction, which most historians don't like making? How does the fall come about? What's our role in it too?
Jill Lepore 4:04 ↗
Yeah. You know, honestly, the title is a little bit an artifact of optimistic days.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 4:10 ↗
No, no.
Jill Lepore 4:11 ↗
Well, no, no. I was asked to give the Tanner lectures at Yale, and there are two of them. So I had to divide my topic into two parts.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 4:19 ↗
So, real talk.
Jill Lepore 4:20 ↗
All right. Well, the rise and then the fall. Those will be — it'll be pretty straightforward, and I'll have to think through both. So the first half of the book is really kind of a history of science and technology that explains, and a political history that goes back to antiquity, right? Sort of talk about what are the technologies that states use to operate, and what does it mean when corporations take over those technologies. So that's the rise story. It's really a history of science and technology. The fall story is actually a history of science fiction. So it's a little bit of a misnomer in the sense that the fall of the artificial state is predicted in every science fiction story that anticipates its rise. And I actually think that science fiction really is worth our attention as humanists, and has largely — we have flown above it. It lies below it. I don't know what the metaphor is, right? You know, it's trash. A lot of it's trash. So people don't want to admit that they read it or watch it. But the story of what I call the parable of the artificial state is evergreen in science fiction and has been at least since the 1860s, and arguably quite a bit earlier. So the second half of the book really is a literary study. But I do argue, certainly over the course of the book, that I think we live in a discourse of the inevitability of the artificial state, right? Like, oh, we can't possibly stop AI, we can't possibly control — like it's just going to march on ahead, and you know, we just have to get used to it and accommodate it, and there's no stopping the power of a Silicon Valley company. Like this aura of inevitability is a big part of the power of Silicon Valley. But I actually think what's inevitable is that that all collapses.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 6:09 ↗
Okay. Well, first of all, I just, you know, this is — I really appreciated the entire science fiction piece of this. I mean, this is like an American studies book even though it's billed —
Jill Lepore 6:20 ↗
It is totally.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 6:22 ↗
And I love that, and so thank you for that. You know, I want to stick with this inevitability piece because, you know, technological progress has been sort of the story of certainly the lifetimes of everyone in this room, but the story you tell really does not feel inevitable. It feels like there were these moments when things could have gone differently. And I'm curious because you have better than anyone a grasp on this long history: were there particular turning points or particular decision points when things could have gone differently, either because of political events or individual choices?
Jill Lepore 6:53 ↗
Yeah. And you know, there still are. So let me give you two answers to that question. So one would be a turning point that I really love because I found it in an archive, and it was really fun to bring it to light. So this Alex Bernstein, computer scientist playing chess against a computer — he's the first person to program a computer to play chess at IBM in 1958. He had been at the conference at Dartmouth, the first conference, the artificial intelligence seminar in the summer of 1956, was like a leading founder of the field of artificial intelligence. But he was roped into this scheme in 1958 by a Madison Avenue adman, a madman named Ed Greenfield in 1958, to start a company that was going to devise what they called a people machine, where they would feed into this, you know, giant mainframe computer hundreds of thousands of punch cards containing all the election results that have ever been put on punch cards, all the public opinion polls of Gallup and Roper, and yeah, so public opinion and census data, and they would create a simulation of the electorate. When this was finally revealed to the public, it was so dystopian that it led to the publication of a dystopian novel that is the basis for The Matrix. Like this is — that is like what people thought, like they could see, right, that what you would end up with. Just why would you need the people if you could just simulate them?
So there's a moment when the madman, the Madison Avenue guy, he sends a copy of his proposal out to leading Democrats because he ends up selling his services to the DNC and then to the Kennedy campaign, but he sends it to Newton Minnow, who was the closest adviser to Adlai Stevenson. People thought Stevenson was going to run for the Democratic nomination again in 1960. People maybe know Minnow because he went on to be the chairman of the FCC in the Kennedy administration. Anyway, Minnow reads this proposal and he's like, 'This is the scariest thing I've ever even heard of.' And he sends the proposal to Arthur Schlesinger, the American historian at Harvard, who reads it, and he said — Minnow writes to me, he's like, I know I'm not supposed to — like this is confidential and everything, and they don't want anybody knowing about this, but I had to share this with you, and I got permission to because I think this is the most dangerous thing that has ever been invented. Like this would destroy democratic politics. Like I don't think it's going to work, so I'm not that worried. But if it does work, who will ever have any capacity for leadership if you just ask the machine what to do? Well, in fact, this is what Kennedy did. He like, how much should he talk about his Catholicism to, you know, Protestants and Jews in the Midwest? How much should he talk about his foreign policy in the southern states? What should he do about the Black vote? Like he just ran all this stuff through the machine. And then when the company took credit for his election, his campaign said, 'We've never even heard of that company,' because that's how embarrassing it was. Like the headline was, 'Kennedy's been elected by a robot.' And people freaked out. And so they just lied. But I love the Newton Minnow letter, which is just like this smart moral person saying, 'Wow, if you, you know, think about this, this isn't how our politics is supposed to work. Like we don't have a direct democracy, we have a representative democracy, and we can't be answerable to predictions,' you know. So there are plenty of moments when — and Schlesinger writes back and says, 'Well, I agree, but if it would help Kennedy win, let's do it,' which is the answer that everybody gives, right? And that's why they proceed.
I had a different answer that I wanted to give you to that. Like that's sort of a way you can — there's a lot of turning points where people kind of just make, I think, the, you know, maybe the wrong choice, maybe the right choice. I don't know what I would have done. But the fact that we haven't had that moment is largely to do with this is work that is done in that way by private corporations. So I often tell my students, if you think about the, you know, major areas of research in the 20th century — chemistry, physics, biology, genetics, computer science — each has had a moral reckoning due to a catastrophe. So, you know, physics with the atom bomb: we have treaties, we have nonproliferation, we have test bans. Chemistry: think of chemical warfare after the First World War, you know, again revisiting in later wars including Vietnam. Biology: Nuremberg, you know, protocols around testing on humans. Genetics had cloning: we agreed not to do cloning. Computer science: why did we not have that moment? And the reason is, you know, there's plenty of great computer science research that's done at universities very responsibly, but all this tech is being built by private corporations that are not answerable to, you know, human subjects review boards. Like if you think about the Cambridge Analytica scandal from 2015–2016, that could have been, you know, the Hiroshima moment, be like, wow, this is really — we should have a — but Facebook existed outside the world of accountability within a university structure.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 12:08 ↗
I have plenty of questions about universities after. But I am curious: do you think the problem is just the private nature of these companies? Because I mean, you have plenty of examples in here of governments having, you know, a lot of control over our media, and that doesn't end up so well either. So is the private piece the issue? And I should say one audience question that came in was — actually more of a comment than a question, it's perfect for a university. This person said, 'I actually think the real problem is — or it's a bigger problem if a government controls this technology. Better to have a kind of marketplace of competition among a bunch of different companies.'
Jill Lepore 12:46 ↗
Yeah. I mean, I wouldn't say it is the only problem here is that universities aren't involved. You know, there's been plenty of — you know, in the 1960s, there were plenty of student protests at Harvard and MIT because of work that was being done for the Department of Defense that students found to be immoral. Although there was accountability, right? MIT does not do top secret work on campus anymore. Like there, they just, you know, there were decisions that were made that were about this is a community and were answerable to other standards then. So, but in terms of, you know, what's the solution — do I want these technologies to be controlled by governments? No, but there's other things besides governments. They are called laws, and they are called constitutions. So like a thing that always drives me nuts about the discourse around artificial intelligence — let me just say the book's not really about artificial intelligence, it's about a lot of other things — but is, oh, the idea that we're working on alignment, we're going to align these tools with human values. Like we have things that align things with human values: they're called laws and constitutions, right? The idea we'll like invent some tech solution to the rule of law, like that we accept that even as that it isn't questioned every time that word comes out of someone's mouth on a stage, is perplexing to me.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 14:16 ↗
Oh, absolutely. So I want to talk about the political dimension of this, and I think today it's very common. We sort of associate these tech bros with a kind of right-wing politics, whether it's Musk or Zuckerberg's turn. And I know my students are surprised to hear about the kind of idealism of Silicon Valley in the 70s and the sort of idea, even with early social media, we will all be connected in these new ways. And I'm curious, in the much longer story that you tell, there are kind of pieces of that that I learned about in the book where, you know, counting people and sorting people has been very important for representation, for allocation of state resources. So I'm curious whether you think there's this kind of inextricable or irresolvable tension between representative democracy and sort of things that are good for humanity and the rise of this technology, or do they sometimes dovetail and work together?
Jill Lepore 15:07 ↗
No, I mean, nor do I think that the political affiliation of the current set of CEOs of the biggest companies with the Republican Party is anything permanent. I mean, that's totally instrumental and transient. And I don't nor do I think they are ideologically aligned with Republicans in any meaningful way. They have their own politics. I mean, I think that, you know, historians of technology will say it's really not the tools, it's the politics, right? So, you know, the US Constitution of 1787 is the first to mandate a national census. We have one every 10 years because we invented proportional representation as a thing that we believe is the right way for people to have a voice. Counting the people is not a bad thing. Using the — you know, the Census Bureau had a contest in the 1880s over who could invent a machine that could count the census, tabulate the census more quickly and more efficiently. That's how IBM was started. The guy who won the contest started IBM. Like there's nothing wrong with that. The first mainframe computers sold commercially were built for the US Census Bureau. Like I don't have a problem with any of these tools. Like I'm not an anti-technology person. It is the case that Nazi Germany used those very same tools to have punch cards for every person so that they could track people that they wanted to murder. Is that — I, you know, they did use IBM computing. Is that IBM's fault? Is that the fault of the computer? No. You know, it's the problem with Nazism. So it's not the tools. There's, you know, even — I mean, we have the bad tools that we have because Congress sucks.
We could have these same kinds of tools that could do really great things. It's the lawlessness, the unaccountability, and because the US Congress has left all these — allowed all these tech companies to exist outside the law and bought their arguments that no matter what we do, it's going to be great for democracy, even though that never turns out to be the case. So just leave us alone. We then export those lawless tools around the world, and we see the consequences. I mean, like it'll be clear, like there are protests going on across Europe. Like this is not like I blame Mark Zuckerberg or something. Like I don't have a totalizing explanation. I'm calling — trying to call attention to the degree to which a fantasy — because when I describe the artificial state, I mean something dystopian, but actually for a number of these very powerful men in the tech world, it is a utopia. So this is what they want. So, you know, Sam Altman of OpenAI, you know, started saying some years ago he thinks an AI president would be better than a human president. It'd be so immediately responsive and could, you know, be making policy constantly adjusting itself to the majority opinion, respond to everybody's needs, like the tentacles in each of our brains. That has nothing to do with how I understand representative democracy or the office of the presidency, our system of government, the nature of, you know, anything about how we or other constitutional democracies are devised and given authority by the people.
Mark Zuckerberg, when there was a little bit of criticism after the Brexit Cambridge Analytica scandal, Facebook started its own Supreme Court. That's not a Supreme Court. A judiciary is not something that a corporation puts in place to say leave us alone. An actual Supreme Court, you know, a federal judiciary — are judges appointed or elected by the people, or appointed by the president or by a national legislature. They're accountable in one way or another. They have a system of laws that, you know — or Anthropic earlier this year released a constitution for Claude, written by Claude.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 19:23 ↗
Is there a conflict of interest there? You know, like they sort of like, we don't want to actually have any part of your democratic governance, but we'll be happy to borrow some buzzwords and make it seem as if we believe in constitutional democracy.
Jill Lepore 19:37 ↗
Yeah. It's actually astonishing to see there's both this kind of like marketing speak of we believe in democracy and representation and all these things, but then at the same time this unapologetic, you know, who needs a human president, which I think is an astonishing kind of tension.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 19:51 ↗
You know, you mentioned these men in the tech world, and another audience question was, why do you think it's so many men who are kind of the architects of this state? So I don't know if you want to comment on that.
Jill Lepore 20:00 ↗
Yeah, and I mean, I guess I would issue the blanket caveat that like there are plenty of great people that work in Silicon Valley who are doing great engineering projects and devising really interesting tools that can help all kinds of people who need all kinds of — like I, it seems unfortunate to kind of smear Silicon — like talk about people in Washington or something. Like I don't, I don't like — and also even within, you know, Peter Thiel is not Sam Altman is not Mark Zuckerberg. I do think that, and you know, it's a very low-hanging fruit to talk about the particular brand of masculinity. But I, and I so I try not to do that, but I think there is, you know, the kind of armchair psychology of it all is these are guys who — they're my age and they wear, not that I'm well-dressed, but they have a kind of uniform of like they're wearing sneakers and jeans and t-shirts and hoodies and baseball hats, and they're 50 and 60 years old, and no one has ever said no to them since they were 17 and a half.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 21:13 ↗
And you know some of those people in your world and that they're not the best people.
Jill Lepore 21:20 ↗
We're not sending our best people.
Natalia Melman-Paraella 21:22 ↗
And that's where the science fiction stuff is also really interesting because it's part of the cult of the laddishness of these guys, right? It's easy to — they all kind of look like supervillains now in popular culture, but of course for decades they were our superheroes, and the press made them our superheroes. So, you know, starting — it really starts in the 80s,
Jill Lepore 21:47 ↗
with Apple and Steve Jobs, and into the 90s, there's, you know, when the dot-com guys like Marc Andreessen is like on the cover of Time magazine on a golden throne, and Musk in 1999 when he makes his first millions. There's like a documentary about him like getting his first DeLorean delivered, and then he's on the cover of Rolling Stone as the real-world Tony Stark. And then he has a cameo in Iron Man movies. That their self-fashioning is rooted in their boyhood pop culture of video games and Dungeons and Dragons and science fiction and comic books and superhero movies. All of which I love. But they're still fashioning themselves after that like in late middle age. One of the stories that I actually find really heartbreaking about this is, you know, Jeff Bezos talks about how what an avid devotee he was of Star Trek as a kid, as was I, and you know, famously his high school graduation, he was a valedictorian in Florida, and he gives this how we're going to go to space, and it's, you know, even everything he's done is about trying to go to space. And maybe it was last year, he went up in a Blue Origin rocket with his new — I guess maybe she was his girlfriend, then wife — and brought William Shatner, who played Captain Kirk, who I think was maybe 91, 92. And they go up, and there's this — you can watch it on YouTube. They come down, they land, this amazing — so cool that they could do that. They get out, and Bezos and his wife are like popping champagne, and it's like a frat party, and they're like soaking each other, and like — yeah, yeah, like it's like a little Pete Hegseth kind of vibe. Like it's very like, we did it. Like it's really, you're like, ew.

28 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lepore, J. (2026, November 6). Dr. Jill Lepore on “The Rise and Fall of Artificial State” | New Dialogues S2 EP5 [Interview transcript]. The New School. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3206128/

MLA

Jill Lepore. "Dr. Jill Lepore on “The Rise and Fall of Artificial State” | New Dialogues S2 EP5." The New School, 6 Nov. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3206128/.

BibTeX
@misc{lepore2026_3206128,
  author       = {Jill Lepore},
  title        = {Dr. Jill Lepore on “The Rise and Fall of Artificial State” | New Dialogues S2 EP5},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, The New School. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {nov},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3206128/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}