Constitutional theorists would say when a constitution is no longer effectively amendable, when it's effectively unamendable, it has no legitimacy.
Coming up: why is it so difficult to amend the United States Constitution, and how does that affect our democracy? I talk with historian Jill Lepore about that and some of the other themes in her Pulitzer Prize-winning book, "We the People." That's next on "Conversations from the Sun Valley Writers' Conference." Stay tuned.
Funding for this program is made possible by contributions to the Friends of Idaho Public Television from viewers like you. Thank you.
Hello and welcome. I'm Marcia Franklin. My guest today, Jill Lepore, didn't have any desire to become an historian when she was growing up. In fact, she started her college career on a R.O.T.C. scholarship studying math and then decided to become an English major. That's because Lepore did always know she loved to write. After auditing history classes at Harvard University when she was a secretary there, though, she decided to go into the field of American Studies. And that pursuit has led to a robust career as a historian.
Since 2003, Lepore has been a professor of history at Harvard University, where she once was a secretary. In 2024 she also became a professor at the Harvard Law School. But her passion for writing has never dimmed. She's well known as a staff writer for The New Yorker, and her articles for that magazine were nominated for a Pulitzer Prize. Lepore is also the author of nearly 20 books, including: "New York Burning," a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize; "Book of Ages," a finalist for the National Book Award, and the bestseller, "These Truths: A History of the United States." Lepore's 2025 book, "We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution," won the Pulitzer Prize for History in 2026. Her newest book, "The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State," published in August 2026, debuted at #4 on the New York Times Bestseller list. I spoke with Lepore just a month before that at the Sun Valley Writers' Conference.
Well, welcome. Welcome to Idaho. I understand you've been to Idaho before. I know you were in Boise, but you've not been to Sun Valley before.
And you went fly fishing today?
I did, yeah. Caught a few small rainbow trout.
Well, I know you were in Boise in 2025 speaking at The Cabin, and I did not realize until I read a New Yorker article that you wrote that you did speak to young people, but instead of it being, like, a required event, there was some consternation or something like that that you might...?
Yeah. And I'm not sure I have all the details here correct, but I was — I love to go speak at public high schools when I'm visiting a place. It's a really important part of going to a new city or a new town. And so I had been asked to speak at what I thought — I think it was going to be like 9,000 students. Something like all the students in history classes at all of the Boise high schools, and they'd be bused over to some big auditorium at one of the bigger schools. This was in last fall, so the Charlie Kirk shooting I think was in September of that year. So I was told that some parents had objected that making it a requirement to see me constituted political indoctrination, liberal political indoctrination. So, because it was going to be a mandatory activity. I was lecturing, just giving a history of the Constitution. And so students could opt in to come. So it was like 3,000 students instead of 9,000 students. It was great. The students were fantastic. The faculty were fantastic. It was, like, it was tremendous, but it was like only the students who had chosen to be there, as opposed to the poor kids who had got left behind, probably watching something on TV. So I don't know. It was the first time I've really encountered anyone directly accusing me of political indoctrination. I mean, like, you know, I'm not that person. I'm not a flamethrower. It was a misapplication of what was in any event a really ridiculous policy, right? I mean, parents shouldn't decide who comes and who does not come to a school. And preventing kids from going to a lecture about the American Constitution seems a real betrayal of the purpose of public education. But it was a great visit all the same.
We seem to be seeing more of this, reaching down into local history classes and, you know, tinkering with textbooks and things like that.
Yeah. I mean, honestly, it's been a tumultuous time for about the past decade in terms of American history teaching around the country, and in universities, colleges and universities as well. I think it just puts public school teachers, librarians in really difficult positions. And the idea that schoolteachers are not doing their very best, working really hard trying to teach kids the basics of American history, it really troubles me. And to put kids' education into this political minefield, it's pretty tough to see.
Well, some of them may really have been wishing that they heard you, because subsequent to that you won the Pulitzer Prize for this book. And how do you hear about that? How did you hear about that?
Hearing about the Pulitzer Prize? You get a phone call. I was with a friend of mine. We were headed out; I think we were going to go kayaking or something. Got a phone call. I guess we did go out kayaking. Then we came back and we stacked wood together for a while, so. Yeah. I've been a finalist twice before, so it was nice to win. Really nice to win.
There's a metaphor in there somewhere.
I think people in Idaho will understand.
Yes, people in Idaho will understand that you stacked wood. Let's talk about "We the People." I mean, as we approached our 250th anniversary in this country, you could have written about any number of subjects. You chose the Constitution. And I think I've heard you say colloquially that it was in part because we have a "crappy history of the Constitution for public memory." What do you mean by that? What's wrong with the history that we have right now for the public?
I think for most people, the Constitution means two things. It's the sort of visual iconography of it, right? The parchment with the calligraphic "We the People" on it, right? Like, it's the object. Here's this old-looking document. And so we know we have an old Constitution. It's an icon. And then people think about the Constitution; they think about the Supreme Court. They probably even picture the Supreme Court building. And I just think that's a really poor representation of what the Constitution is, was, has ever been, could ever be. And it's not like, "Oh, people are stupid for thinking that." I just think, like, we've really kind of evacuated the larger history of the Constitution from most curricula. Constitutional history used to be taught in history departments. That stopped decades and decades ago, and constitutional history moved into law schools, where there are a lot of constitutional scholars. And some of them are interested in history and some of them are not, but they're really interested in constitutional interpretation. And history departments became dominated by just a very different kind of curriculum, right, as generations of American historians turned to social history or cultural history or what we call the new political history. Maybe they were labor historians, maybe they did African American history, they did women's studies, they did gender and sexuality studies, whatever it is. But things that migrated out of history departments included economic history, which moved to economics departments, and constitutional history, which moved to law schools. So it just means that even in college, you're not really likely to be exposed to constitutional history in any sophisticated way. Even just thinking, if you look at high school textbooks, it's not like they're teaching wrong things about the Constitution, but you kind of learn about the writing of the Constitution and then that's kind of it.
One of the misperceptions is to fail to remember that 1776, which is what we're celebrating this year, is the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, but it's also the 250th anniversary of the first written constitutions in the United States, which were written in the states. So starting in January of 1776, New Hampshire wrote the first constitution. And what they're doing is experimenting with, "What even is a constitution?" England's Constitution is unwritten. So this was a new thing that the former colonists were trying to do. They were going, "We're going to write this down." They were mad that they couldn't point to a paragraph and sentence in the British Constitution that they thought Parliament had violated by taxing them. They were like, "A constitution needs to be written down." And so they were experimenting with that and some things worked and other things didn't work. But the Constitution that the delegates drafted in Philadelphia in 1787 couldn't have been written without these earlier constitutions. So sort of one correction to offer to constitutionalists would be just like, "The Constitution doesn't begin in 1787. It begins earlier than that." And then, it's not like the Ten Commandments etched in stone on the top of Mount Sinai, you know. It is a document that's written to be amended. Like, if you draw up a contract with someone and something changes in your circumstances, you want to be able to amend that contract. So they put in an amendment mechanism into the Constitution that would make it possible if things in the Constitution weren't working that well or if circumstances just changed, that there would be a way to fix the Constitution, to improve it, to repair it, to correct it. And this book that I have written really argues that this philosophy of amendment is a founding principle of American constitutionalism, of American republicanism. And we have forgotten it because it turned out not to work as well as the framers had hoped that it would work.
Yes. Ultimately, it has become extremely difficult to amend. I was astonished to learn from your book that there's been almost 12,000 attempts in Congress alone, not to mention petitions from ordinary citizens over the years. And we just are at a stasis. It's been since 1971 since it was meaningfully amended?
Which was to change the voting age?
There was an amendment in 1992, but it was first introduced in 1789. So it doesn't really count as a new idea.
Right. I mean, you could have chosen a lot of different aspects of constitutional history to write about, but you chose the amendment process. And I assume it's because you feel strongly that there are effects to the fact that it is so difficult to amend now.
Yeah. I mean, I don't have a political agenda.
You don't have an axe to grind, yes.