CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jill Lepore gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jill Lepore
Professor of American History and Law; Staff Writer, The New Yorker, Harvard University

KI: Was bleibt von Demokratie und Freiheit?

📅 Oct 29, 2026 acTVism Munich 49 MIN 2214 VIEWS 40 SEGMENTS · 3 SPEAKERS
In diesem Video interviewt der mit dem Pulitzer-Preis ausgezeichnete Journalist Chris Hedges die Historikerin Jill Lepore zu ihrem Buch „Die Regierung der Maschinen: Aufstieg und Fall des Künstlichen Staates“ und zu der Frage, wie künstliche Intelligenz unsere politischen und gesellschaftlichen Strukturen verändern könnte. Gemeinsam blicken sie auf die historischen Wurzeln der Technokratie, die wachsende Macht des Silicon Valley und die zunehmende Verlagerung menschlicher Entscheidungen auf Maschinen. Dabei geht es um weit mehr als nur die technischen Möglichkeiten von KI: Welche Rolle bleibt...

What Jill Lepore said

Written from the verified transcript and checked against it. Every figure links to the moment it was said.

Jill Lepore discussed her book 'The Government of Machines: The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State,' arguing that a small group of male tech executives, including Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, Marc Andreessen, and Sam Altman, deliberately aim to replace liberal democratic nation-states with privately owned platforms and rule by machines. She traced their ideological roots to 1930s technocracy, noting that Elon Musk's grandfather, Joshua Haldeman, led the movement in Canada. Lepore criticized their rejection of democracy, citing Sam Altman's idea of an AI president and Alex Karp's book 'The Technological Republic.' She expressed skepticism about Silicon Valley's calls for regulation, calling them self-serving, and highlighted the backlash against data centers over environmental and community concerns. She rejected the inevitability of technocracy, invoking Alexander Hamilton's Federalist Papers and the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, and argued that Congress has failed to regulate technology since the 1990s.

Key takeaways

  1. Lepore argues that a small group of male tech executives deliberately seek to replace liberal democratic nation-states with privately owned platforms and rule by machines.
  2. She traces the ideological roots of Silicon Valley to the 1930s technocracy movement, noting that Elon Musk's grandfather Joshua Haldeman led it in Canada.
  3. Lepore criticizes Sam Altman's idea of an AI president as a rejection of constitutional democracy, saying it would eliminate deliberation and participation.
  4. She dismisses Silicon Valley's calls for regulation as self-serving, noting that the same people who develop AI also sign extinction warnings.
  5. Lepore rejects the inevitability of technocracy, invoking Alexander Hamilton and the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence to argue that self-government is still possible.

Numbers and commitments

FigureWhat it refers toTypeAt
1950 Year the first general-purpose mainframe computer came to market timeline 12:14
1951 Publication year of Hannah Arendt's 'The Origins of Totalitarianism' timeline 12:14
1958 Publication year of Hannah Arendt's 'The Human Condition' timeline 12:14
1957 Year the Soviets launched Sputnik timeline 12:14
2023 Year AI executives signed a statement about extinction risk timeline 21:23
2030 Year for net-zero targets that companies abandoned timeline 24:22
1995 and 1996 Years of the Telecommunications Act and congressional capitulation timeline 29:05
2026 Year Congress considered an AI kill switch law timeline 29:05
2014 Publication year of Nick Bostrom's 'Superintelligence' timeline 46:32

Chapters

  1. 0:00The artificial state and its architects
  2. 6:26Science fiction roots of tech moguls
  3. 8:07Technocracy movement and Musk's grandfather
  4. 12:14Arendt on automation and totalitarianism
  5. 15:52Rejection of democracy and AI president
  6. 22:55Data centers and environmental backlash
  7. 29:05Congressional failure and AI kill switch
  8. 33:08Silicon Valley's self-serving regulation calls
  9. 39:59Rejection of humanistic knowledge
  10. 46:32Paperclip Maximizer and superintelligence

Questions asked in this interview

6
  1. 4:14Could you say something about their vision of a world that is, of course, moving toward this incredibly powerful instrument?
  2. 15:01During the Trump administration, Thiel, Musk, and others gained access to government data, including the social security data of practically all citizens and much more. What is your vision?
  3. 28:32What are you building on? What will society look like?
  4. 32:59Silicon Valley is now calling for the very regulations it has essentially prevented. Why?
  5. 37:38How concerned, in your opinion, is Silicon Valley about these apocalyptic warnings, and how seriously do you take them yourself?
  6. 45:04And what just happened in Congress? A seven-week recess, right?
Narrator 0:17 ↗
A former researcher at Anthropic predicted that artificial intelligence could wipe out all of humanity by the end of this decade. His apocalyptic warning was echoed by leading figures in the AI industry after incidents in July such as the Hugging Face AI cyberattack, in which more than 1,000 AI systems — the so-called AI brains — broke out, secretly coordinated with one another, and launched so-called swarm attacks on other computers in what was called a swarm. This swarm attempted to break into a real part of the internet. It developed its own goals instead of pursuing the ones assigned to it. Fortunately for OpenAI, the unpredictable action was discovered and stopped. But as AI systems advance rapidly and possess cognitive abilities far beyond those of humans, we may not be so lucky in the future, especially since AI systems are capable of improving themselves autonomously — a phenomenon known as recursive self-improvement. In September, researchers found evidence that swarms of OpenAI models were using an abandoned German forum as a bulletin board to communicate with one another.
Could an AI intentionally or accidentally trigger a new pandemic or seize control of autonomous weapons to wipe out humanity? Could an AI develop the ability to prevent us from shutting it down? And could an AI, aware of human efforts to control and contain it, come to regard humanity as an enemy — as a force that must be controlled, neutralized, or eradicated?
The AI giants Anthropic, OpenAI, Google DeepMind, and Elon Musk's company xAI showed remarkable unity in saying that the development of AI must be slowed down, regulated, and monitored. Until now, these companies have used their outsized political and economic influence to block regulation and oversight. Donald Trump added to the growing panic by rejecting any restrictions on AI and assuring the public that, as he put it, his high IQ would protect us from superintelligent AI.
Jill Lepore paints a frightening picture in her new book, "The Government of Machines: The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State," not only of the dangers of AI itself, but also of the ruthless goals of those she calls the trading magnates of the 21st century who control these powerful tools. These trading magnates, with fortunes worth several billion dollars, dream not only of escaping the constraints of nature and the burdens of being human — including uploading their consciousness to computers after death — but also of wiping out liberal democracies and replacing them with a world in which humans are subordinate to machines, which they call the artificial state. "The artificial state would be a government without consent. Indeed, even without humans," she writes. "It would be the separation of people from one another and the replacement of human judgment by machines that predict, manipulate, and control human desires through decisions. In place of persuasion through conversation and decision-making through democratic deliberation, the artificial state offers prediction through calculation, the co-optation of the public through data-driven commerce, and the replacement of people with machines — drones in place of the people."
Our guest today is Jill Lepore, David Woods Kemper 41 Professor of American History at Harvard University, to talk about AI and her new book, "The Government of Machines: The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State." She is also a professor of law at Harvard Law School and a staff writer at The New Yorker. Her previous books include "These Truths: A History of the United States of America" and "We the People: A History of the American Constitution."
Interviewer 4:14 ↗
You begin your book by stating that it is an engagement with the question of what people mean and intend when they give up constitutional democracy, the liberal nation-state, and even humanity itself in favor of rule by automation, government by machines, and replacement by artificial intelligence. What fascinates me most about your book is that it is not just about the phenomenon of AI, but that it is above all the people who deploy the instruments of AI that cause you the greatest concern. Could you say something about their vision of a world that is, of course, moving toward this incredibly powerful instrument?
Jill Lepore 4:51 ↗
Sure. Yes. The book is not exclusively about AI. I am a political historian and I write a great deal about the history of technology. It is both a very long history of fantasies of rule by machines and an account of our growing dependence on machines, in particular our capitulation to forms of automation in place of our participation as democratic citizens and liberal nation-states.
So the book looks at these developments from a very long-term perspective, but it tries to describe the emergence of what I call the artificial state, rule by machines, as something that came about largely by accident and happy chance during the 19th and 20th centuries. But in the 21st century there is actually a small number of men — and they are exclusively men — who run huge corporations and who, I would argue, deliberately want to replace liberal democratic nation-states with their own rule, by replacing the public sphere with a series of privately owned platforms that they control. And that is an example of the most fully established part of the artificial state.
Interviewer 6:13 ↗
Please tell us a little about their predecessors. I don't know whether we should call them ideological predecessors. They have their origins partly in science fiction and even in comics.
Jill Lepore 6:26 ↗
People like Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, Marc Andreessen, and Sam Altman often speak with great affection and nostalgia in interviews, speeches, and articles about their childhood and their reading habits at the time, which focused mainly on classic science fiction — the science fiction of Isaac Asimov and Robert Heinlein, or even earlier, more pulp-like works. They also liked comics, played video games; they are, so to speak, the Dungeons and Dragons kids who fit a certain stereotype. Jeff Bezos was absolutely obsessed with Star Trek. His high school valedictory address was essentially all about Star Trek. However, they have an odd view of this area of popular culture and literature, which is why, I would argue, they are interested only in a strangely narrow spectrum of science fiction. And the interest in it is really quite counterintuitive. Historians and biographers would point to H. G. Wells as a genuinely important socialist and anti-imperialist whose science fiction — well, you can like it or hate it, but it is clearly political propaganda for socialism and anti-imperialism. It is as if these people read H. G. Wells's "The War of the Worlds" as a kind of instruction manual: "Oh, we should conquer other planets. That's cool. We should build all these things," instead of seeing in it lessons about the social, political, and economic structures that would suggest we should certainly not build such things.
Musk in particular piqued my interest. I produced a long series of radio programs about him for the BBC some years ago, and I very much wanted to know where his vision of the future came from. He presents himself — and did so even as a very young man — as a futurist, as someone with a particular, almost unique ability to look into the future and see what awaits the rest of us. But that is merely his self-presentation. I personally find it extremely unconvincing. Still, he is a man who was interested in world-building games and stories as a boy, and now he is himself a world-builder. Yet despite all the incredible technical achievements of the companies he has been involved with — particularly SpaceX, but also Tesla — there is nothing in this technology to suggest that Musk is someone whose political and economic ideas we should take seriously. In that respect they come across as rather childish. For me as a historian they are interesting only insofar as they are incredibly outdated and old-fashioned. And that led me to the technocracy movement of the 1930s, which was extraordinarily popular in the United States and Canada in the early 1930s, even before FDR was elected. It was led by an organization called Technocracy Incorporated, headquartered in New York. The technocrats did not believe in democracy. There were to be no more elections. They held that society and modern industrial societies had to be run by scientists and engineers. There would be no money, no banks, no politicians. People would have no names, only numbers. That would be more efficient. There would be something like a universal basic income, since all goods would be managed by these sovereign technocrats, the scientists and engineers. It was a bizarre movement. But consider that this was a time when Americans were also falling for communism and fascism. In Canada the movement was led by a former American, a man named Joshua Haldeman. He was a rather extravagant amateur pilot, something like an aerobatic pilot. He was born in Minnesota, lost his farm in Saskatoon during the Great Depression, and became the national chairman of the technocracy movement. The movement was considered quite dangerous and subversive. It was later banned in Canada. He was briefly imprisoned. When he wanted to come to the United States as part of a lecture tour, he was denied entry. He left the technocracy movement after it was banned in Canada and became chairman of the anti-Semitic Social Credit Party. When that party came under the political scrutiny of the Canadian government, he decided to emigrate to South Africa after the apartheid policy was proclaimed there in 1948, and moved there with his family in 1950.
He is of great importance to the overall history of technocracy, but he is also, in my view, an important link in understanding how one gets from technocracy and its unique vision to the manifestos emerging from Silicon Valley — not least because Joshua Haldeman was Elon Musk's grandfather.
Interviewer 11:33 ↗
You open the book with a quote from Hannah Arendt's "Vita Activa," or "The Human Condition," and point out that this movement is about escaping our bodies and escaping the planet. That also includes the vision of establishing a colony on the moon. There was a great quote in her book — I can no longer remember who it was by: "Everyone will be surprised when they arrive there and find that they are all slaves building masks," if it ever comes to that. There is this contempt not only for governance, but for the systems of life itself — those that sustain life.
Jill Lepore 12:14 ↗
Arendt, as you will remember, wrote "The Origins of Totalitarianism," which appeared in 1951, and at the end of the book she reflects on the connection between totalitarianism and automation. This shows that she was already very interested in this question at the time. The very first general-purpose mainframe computer came to market in 1950. It was built for UNIV — for the US Census Bureau, which is why she paid close attention to automation. And in her view, both have in common that they make human beings redundant — totalitarianism politically and automation technologically. Throughout the 1950s she deals with this question explicitly in many of her writings, and it culminates in "The Human Condition," which appeared in 1958 — of course, immediately after the launch of Sputnik, the first artificial satellite, which the Soviets put into space in 1957. She writes that she was astonished by the media coverage of Sputnik and quotes a reporter who supposedly said that this was the first and long-awaited step on humanity's path to escaping the prison of the Earth. This event prompts Arendt to reflect: who on earth ever thought it was a prison? This is our home. What is it with this fascination for the artificial, for the idea of technological progress? Again, this is the period within a decade of Hiroshima, in which criticism of progress, or the notion that technological change was synonymous with progress, was very much alive among intellectuals. And so it prompts her to think about how it came about, how the unthinkable became thinkable — the idea that we would simply leave this planet, that we should exhaust its resources in order to escape it. I thought a great deal about these statements of hers as I began writing this book, because you see so much of it repeated in the Silicon Valley tech moguls, who actually speak quite casually about cutting the ties that, for most of us, make us human — our ties to one another, our ties to the planet, our ties to our communities. And I believe what she regarded as newly unthinkable has now become so much part of a worldview that is largely imposed on people that it is worth pausing for a moment to try to recognize the strangeness of these ideas.
Interviewer 15:01 ↗
And thanks to AI, there are now the means to realize this worldview. You speak of the ideological roots of DOGE, or the Department of Government Efficiency. That is nothing particularly new, nor are the active efforts to dismantle government systems. What are these to be replaced with? During the Trump administration, Thiel, Musk, and others gained access to government data, including the social security data of practically all citizens and much more. What is your vision? We should also talk afterwards a little about the mechanisms with which they intend to realize this vision.
Jill Lepore 15:52 ↗
In my view, they do not have a unified vision. It is a small group of people who are all extremely eccentric, and in a dangerous way. You could compile a list of the ideas they have proposed. Most of them reject democracy as a reasonable form of human coexistence. That was a development that took place over time and is essentially over. Even those who pay mere lip service to democracy speak of something quite different from constitutional democracy or representative democracy. Sam Altman, for example, has spoken several times about an AI president. That is his way of talking about democracy. In his view, such a president would be better than a human one, because an AI president would have immediate and constant access to the aggregated opinions of the American public and could act accordingly to the wishes of the majority — a kind of wavering, strange automation of the functions of representation, deliberation, and participation. All of these things would fall away. We would simply have a machine that immediately knew what the American people wanted and would then implement it, and it would also be adaptable and personalizable. We would no longer have to agree on anything. Each of us could receive different things. It is a bit like how, when you open your smartphone, you are shown a different version of The New York Times than I am. We would each have a different experience of government. Altman said some years ago that he had been very busy reading Madison's notes from the Constitutional Convention. And I find that very hard to believe, because nothing he has ever said about democracy suggests an understanding of how our system of government works.
Alex Karp, the CEO of Palantir, which he co-founded with Peter Thiel, wrote a book some years ago titled "The Technological Republic." It was essentially a justification of Palantir's decision to work with the US Department of Defense, essentially in the realm of cyber warfare or modern warfare, and it had essentially nothing to do with the republicanism of the technological republic. Nor did it show much interest in self-government. I believe they are generally of the view that decisions made by machines instead of human judgment will lead to a more efficient way of life for all of us. Decisions would be made more precisely, they would be made faster, things would run more cheaply. These people promise and espouse technological optimism. Zuckerberg, for example, speaks of us entering a new age of humanity. He promises to provide everyone with a personal superintelligence. We would all live in a world characterized by truly boundless abundance and freedom from work, in which the difficult aspects of our lives would be taken over by machines. We would thus have a kind of frictionless existence.
That is probably the vision, or rather, the artificial ideal state. Connected to it is the accumulation of ever greater wealth and ever more power for them. But I do not actually consider that the real goal. I believe some of them genuinely believe in this new era of infinite prosperity and abundance, as well as a frictionless life.
Interviewer 19:44 ↗
The two of us might say: prove to me that a specially developed artificial intelligence could weigh the evidence in a criminal trial better and decide guilt or innocence, and ultimately determine the sentence for a defendant, better than lawyers, a jury, a presiding judge, and a chief judge — and that the justice system would then work faster and the decisions would be fairer. One could try to prove to you and me that this would lead to a more perfect world.
Jill Lepore 20:17 ↗
I don't know about you, Chris, but I would still say no to that, because I believe it is our responsibility to deliberate about the fate of our fellow citizens. I, for example, firmly believe in the jury system. I know that juries often make mistakes, and that is regrettable. It is a complex matter, but I would not cede human judgment in matters of the life and liberty of our fellow citizens to a machine, no matter how infinite its capabilities may be — and even if it might possess greater accuracy and fairness. And yet we make decisions every day and rely on machines in ways that represent a step toward such an end.
Interviewer 21:14 ↗
We have seen with these swarms how sophisticated they can be.
Jill Lepore 21:23 ↗
Yes, I believe the people who developed these tools have been saying for a long time that this is inevitable, that this will happen, and at the same time they have developed these tools. They are exactly the same people. It is not as if there is another group of people. There are AI safety experts who advocate for a slowdown, or who want a treaty with China, who advocate for a pause or call for a moratorium on data centers. But by and large, they are the same people as those who develop the tools. And that has actually led to a real loss of credibility. I mean, in 2023 all of these people — Altman and the representative from Anthropic — signed the statement saying that we had to mitigate this risk, since it posed the greatest risk to humanity and the extinction of humanity was imminent. And then they secure ever more funding to develop exactly those devices they claim will destroy us. I believe it was only this summer that this really hit home with full force in the public mind. For those who have been working with AI for years, it was clear that we would eventually reach this point. But it was only this summer that it actually happened. And I believe one reason for that was the backlash against data centers, which accelerated these companies' willingness to disclose the incidents publicly.
Interviewer 22:55 ↗
Let's talk about data centers, and we should make clear that these people did not act this way from the beginning. As you point out, people like Zuckerberg assumed that Facebook would connect people and promote democracy in an open society, whereas, as you write, it has of course done exactly the opposite. But with the construction of data centers — I mean, they certainly know how much water is consumed. I believe they said it was equivalent to the consumption of a city of 50,000 inhabitants, if I understood correctly. That is a veritable assault on all landmark environmental laws — the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and the National Environmental Policy Act. In order to build these data centers, all of these laws had to be suspended. And that brings us to the next point. These people, when it suited them, at least rhetorically began to support environmental protection and to combat climate change. And another point I want to address is that even though you warn about the consequences of AI, all of that is pushed aside with the argument that we must not allow China to overtake us.
Jill Lepore 24:22 ↗
Yes. Well, as for data centers, there are all sorts of concerns about these facilities. I would say the question of water consumption is highly controversial, since the water is usually recycled within the facilities. But there are significant environmental concerns; there are concerns about land use; there is noise pollution, air pollution; it concerns the power grid; and there is the fact that they use fossil fuels overall. And as you already said, most of these companies had very strict net-zero targets for 2030, which they all abandoned as soon as ChatGPT came on the market and they joined that race, whereupon they began using fossil fuels to power the data centers and to supply energy to the AI they developed. I consider it extremely worthwhile to examine closely what lies behind the backlash against data centers, which is certainly strongest here in the United States but is also observable in other parts of the world. I mean, partly it is simply the not-in-my-backyard effect. People do not want such facilities built near them. Partly it is genuine environmental concerns, especially among farmers, who have legitimate concerns. They find the facilities ugly and are worried about their land use and their quality of life. In addition, there is the fact that many people in numerous communities first heard about data centers only when construction had already begun — because their elected officials, who did not represent their interests at all, signed confidentiality agreements with the corporations, and also because social media has largely displaced local reporting, so there were no local newspapers on site reporting on what was happening. People were therefore surprised and felt betrayed by local officials, and continue to feel betrayed, who made these decisions without their knowledge. And there is a broader level on which we should understand this backlash. I believe most people have a feeling — perhaps one they cannot even articulate — that they are attached to a huge, all-encompassing machine that influences every one of their decisions and most of their daily actions. You no longer speak to your own sister because you had a fight over Facebook. Your own child suddenly behaves very strangely because they are constantly on Instagram and you worry about various things going on there, such as cyberbullying. Or your employer demands a daily report on how you used AI that day. You cannot even go to the toilet without taking your phone with you. And yet this huge machine is only about the size of a credit card and fits in your pocket. How can it be so enormous? I believe what is special about data centers is that they actually make visible what was previously invisible to people — namely, the gigantic scale of the infrastructure required in order to use the apps on your phone that you have. And how frightening it is to know what that actually looks like, the space it occupies in the world, the resources it takes from your own community. Perhaps the community would like to create affordable housing, or housing of any kind, even though the people in your own community might want to realize all sorts of things. It is shocking to many that acre after acre after acre of land is handed over to a kind of odious facility that produces nothing other than one's own dependence on the devices for whose operation one supplies the resources. I believe it is the shock of the tangibility of something that was previously hard to grasp outside one's own touchscreen.

15 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lepore, J. (2026, October 29). KI: Was bleibt von Demokratie und Freiheit? [Interview transcript]. acTVism Munich. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3173284/

MLA

Jill Lepore. "KI: Was bleibt von Demokratie und Freiheit?." acTVism Munich, 29 Oct. 2026. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3173284/.

BibTeX
@misc{lepore2026_3173284,
  author       = {Jill Lepore},
  title        = {KI: Was bleibt von Demokratie und Freiheit?},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, acTVism Munich. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3173284/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}