We are a very complicated country with a very complicated relationship to family, community. I think all Americans kind of wrestle with that, celebrate that, wrestle with it, wonder whether we have lived up to the nation's ideals. These are questions maybe more at this moment than in any other as we're on the eve of the Nation's 250th anniversary.
Jill Lepore, Pulitzer Prize-winning historian of the United States. I think from your voice, I feel that this weighs very heavily on you, this moment in time.
I think it weighs heavily on everyone, whether it's their job to think about it all day or not. We are in free fall off a cliff. I don't know when we land.
From Bloomberg Weekend, this is The Mishal Husain Show. America's big birthday is upon us. It was on the 4th of July, 1776 that a relatively short text, the Declaration of Independence, was formally adopted in Philadelphia. A final departure of British troops from the United States was still some years away, as was the other foundational document of the time, the US Constitution, which was only drafted in 1787. This July 4th, we have the Harvard historian, professor Jill Lepore with us to take us through her monumental work on the US Constitution. It's this book, We The People, which is not only about how the Constitution was drafted, but how it was intended to change over time.
This is not, however, an episode entirely set in the past because Jill Lepore is someone who's acutely alive to the pressures of the moment, to contested senses of what America is or should be. She's also unusual in her background and you'll hear us talk about this early on. She's very far from an ivory tower type historian. She's served in the US military and her route into teaching history at Harvard is a sideways one. Plus she is prolific: articles, a podcast series on Elon Musk and many books. We The People has just won her a Pulitzer Prize and her next book, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, which is all about technology and democracy, is out next month. So here is Jill Lepore on America past and present.
I'd love to begin with a sense of you before we move on to your work, particularly because I was struck by the fact that you are one of the foremost scholars and writers on American history and yet you have an unusual background as a professor of history because neither of your first two degrees are in history.
None of my degrees are in history. I always wanted to just be a writer and graduated early with a degree in English as I couldn't afford to stay in college. I worked as a secretary, actually here at Harvard for a while, and wrote novels during the workday and sat in on classes. I was a high school athlete, you know, Girl Scout, person with a great sense of civic duty. I had no money for college and I got an ROTC scholarship to go to college.
Which is the system by which your tuition fees and other expenses are paid for in exchange for agreeing to serve in the military afterwards.
And agreeing to serve. Yeah, yeah.
So then what happened? What changed? You're talking to us now about your books on constitutional and other history, but you could have been sitting in the Pentagon listening to Pete Hegseth speak.
I do sometimes think about that. Yeah, and all my friends in college were ROTC kids. You incur a service obligation when you go into your sophomore year and I actually loved ROTC, but at the time Reagan's foreign policy was really interventionist. For instance in Haiti, and in particular Reagan was exploring what was colloquially known as the "Star Wars" program, the Strategic Defence Initiative. He was going to build a missile shield, something like the Israeli Iron Dome, right around the planet to end the Cold War. And so all the students were engineers and everyone thought the "Star Wars" plan was completely nonsensical as an engineering design and I thought politically it was also nonsensical and I went and had a meeting with my commanding officer and I said, I don't think I could work on that. And he said, cadet, you can't be in the military, you don't get to choose. This is not going to be for you if you're going to be evaluating the projects that are coming out of the Pentagon as to whether or not you're ethically willing to comply with them. He was a lovely person and he was a very wise man.
So it was a fork in the road moment. So how did history come into it then? Did it happen while you were working at Harvard as a secretary?
I don't think that my interest in history is necessarily the same as that of many of my wonderful and distinguished colleagues who I think often are interested in the debates among historians about how to interpret moments or forces of change. I am interested in the relationship between the past and the present in a very vernacular way, in the sense of I think we all walk through our lives wondering how we got to where we are, how the institutions we work for or the companies we work for or the farms on which we work got to be where they are. I'm just really interested in inquiring into the relationship between the past and the present and finding explanations that in my mind often offer a way for me to think about how to escape sometimes what feels like difficult present moments.
I'm also wondering to what extent the past and your relationship with America's past was there in your family life because the grandchild of immigrants, aren't you, Italian immigrants, is it true that your grandmother never spoke any English? You could never actually communicate with her?
Yeah, no, she did. As far as her Italian, we were always told mainly she was swearing. She was a hilarious, very earthy woman.
But do you remember thinking about America's past in this very real way, it was a country that your grandparents chose?
Yeah, absolutely. I mean my father was born here in 1924 and was given the middle name Amerigo after Vespucci, but because he was born in the United States in 1924, which is also the year that Congress passed the Immigration Act that essentially closed the doors of the United States to immigrants, certainly from Eastern Europe and to a significant degree from Western Europe as well. I don't know, I remember my dad telling me about that, when he was confirmed he changed his middle name to Edward. That was his confirmation name and there was a real kind of erasure. He was one of those second generation immigrants who, he was completely fluent in Italian but never spoke it with us. He didn't want us to learn to speak Italian.
You mean because he was embarrassed?
Oh, no. I think most Americans grow up with some version of their account of the nation's history as a version of their family story. Whether you yourself are an immigrant or your family has been in this country for generations upon generations.
Do you think your father changing his middle name was a deliberate act of integration to try and be like everyone else?
Maybe. I think he was maybe a little bit embarrassed by it, but I once wrote an article called The Everyman Library about my father's books because when he died I inherited these books that he had, which are basically his college textbooks and he had a copy of the Aeneid that he had really marked up, which is a journey about trying to get home, much like the Odyssey. And I think my father had a very complicated relationship with the idea that he had come from someplace else. He was so rooted in the United States. I think for anyone, also an Italian-American fighting in the Second World War, fighting against the Axis powers that included Italy, was really complicated. My mother was descended from Germans and her father had worked for the Navy during the First World War, but was a German-American who was essentially pushed out of that kind of work. He had been at MIT and German Americans were considered a security risk during the First World War. So I don't think there's anything unusual in my story really.
I do think we are a very complicated country with a very complicated relationship to family, community. The idea of the nation state, the tension between the universal and the particular, what makes America both distinctive and the fountainhead of universal ideas or ideas that have been embraced around the world. I think all Americans kind of wrestle with that, celebrate that, wrestle with it, wonder whether we have lived up to the nation's ideals. I think these are questions maybe more at this moment than in any other, as we're on the eve of the nation's 250th anniversary. We are swimming in our history right now. The question is really whether we're drowning in it.
So let's come right up to the present day then and your book, which is heavy in its subject matter and physically heavy as well because it's a big work and it's about the US Constitution, We The People, tell us about it, particularly the fact that you focused on how it was intended to be a living document, not a tablet of stone.
Yeah, I think we have, to the degree that Americans kind of carry around with them any sense of the Constitution as having a history as opposed to just being a piece of parchment that you could go see at the National Shrine in the National Archives or something that members of Congress will wave these kind of pocket editions at one another, to the extent that we have an idea that it has a history that we could trace it over time, that idea really relies on the Supreme Court. So in law schools, I'm speaking now from the Harvard Law School, law students are really taught to learn a series of Supreme Court decisions and that's how lawyers and judges are going to argue about the meaning of the Constitution, this in reference to earlier decisions of the Supreme Court. And as an American historian interested in the story of the people as a whole, that always seemed to me something of a problem because it presumes that the court itself has created a fiction, which is that the Supreme Court is the only authority on the Constitution and the only mode of constitutional change that is possible is seeking change by way of the Supreme Court, when in fact that is absolutely a crucial way that the Constitution changes and the Supreme Court has an unparalleled role in changing the Constitution. But if we think about the history of the Constitution only that way, we miss that the Constitution was written in an age that celebrated what I call the philosophy of amendment, the idea, a very Enlightenment idea, kind of almost Panglossian, like the world is getting better every day in every way. The idea that if you're going to write down a constitution, which was new, which is a new idea in the 18th century, if you're going to write down a constitution and it's an ingenious thing because then it's going to be transparent, the powers that government has, the limits to the powers of government, the rights of the people, all those things are going to be written down. We can inspect them, we can hold the government accountable to those things. We can insist on those limits, we can insist on those rights. This is a genius idea, but if you're going to write something down, there has to be a way for it to change over time and it can't be changed by the forces of tyranny, which will be the inevitable mode of change that all of human history explained to the framers of the US Constitution, that humans for almost the entirety of human history have been ruled by tyrants, been ruled by force and violence. So you have to have a mechanism for change and that mechanism is amendment.
And it's within the document because I'm holding one of those pocket versions.
Okay, yeah, it's written into it.
And it's there, Article five, setting out the way that the Constitution can be amended, which was essentially a key part of how it ended up getting passed and agreed to in the summer of 1787 because without it, it was the way to bridge the disagreements to say, this is the document we're agreeing to right now.
Yeah, I mean it was necessary at the convention in the summer of 1787 where there was a tremendous disagreement and the entire Constitution is the subject of very strenuously fought compromise. But everyone understood there was going to be an amendment provision because that's why they were there in the first place, because the previous frame of government was essentially unamendable. It required unanimity to amend what was essentially the treaty that united the 13 states, the Articles of Confederation. So they were there to come up with a new constitution because the other version couldn't be amended. So they knew they were going to have to make it amendable and they did, but it would not have been ratified. So in September of 1787, the Constitution is sent to the 13 states, at least nine of which have to approve it in order for it to become law. But in practical terms, all 13 states have to approve it because what's going to happen to the other four, they're just going to walk away. So it's a very close call. People have a lot of problems with the Constitution. The states propose some 200 amendments to it even before they're willing to ratify it. And so the Federalists, who are the proponents of the Constitution, say, look, it's okay. We know it's not perfect. We did our best. None of us are really entirely happy with it either. Everyone had a problem with something in the Constitution or something that wasn't in the Constitution, and so their whole kind of slogan was, if it was a bumper sticker, it's ratify now, amend later. Just let's ratify it. We're in chaos here as a country, we have to have a constitution. Please just ratify and we promise the first thing we'll do when Congress sits for the inaugural Congress is we'll send amendments to the states, and in fact, they did. That's what the Bill of Rights is. But over time, over the sweep of these 250 years since Independence, not since the Constitution, it has been amended very little.
Yeah, there's a whole field of political science that studies amendments, amendability, amendment rates, amendment difficulty. The US Constitution, while undoubtedly the most influential constitution in the world, is one of the least amended and one of the most difficult to amend. It's not at the top of that list, but it's very, very high up in both of those counts. It has been amended really only 17 times. It has proven to be the case that for most of American history it's very difficult, if not impossible, to amend the Constitution and then something pushes that door open and a flood of amendments come in. Then the door slams shut again, and then for decades and decades and decades, it's impossible to amend the Constitution. We are in a period now where it's effectively impossible to amend the Constitution. It requires a two-thirds supermajority in both houses of Congress and then a ratification of three-fourths of the states and the degree of polarization in the country today just effectively makes that impossible. I mean, think about two-thirds is also the necessary bar in the Senate for impeaching a president.
Yeah. So in your view, is that a good or a bad thing? Do you dislike the idea of it being amended or do you think it's an important and necessary function of democracy and we should be able to get there?
I don't honestly have a prescription. I do think it's important to recognize that the Constitution hasn't been meaningfully amended since 1971. That means that because change is going to happen, like a river is going to find, you can put a dam in, but the water's going to go somewhere. The water runs to the Supreme Court and then the Supreme Court has far more power than it was intended to have, which is a deformity of our politics. Then Supreme Court nominations become hugely controversial. The public is really engaged in them. The Supreme Court justices have become really celebrities, personalities, characters that people know, the people know about them, their lives. They write memoirs, they go on book tours. That's not how the Supreme Court was meant to function, and I think it has contributed to presidentialism. That is to say that the celebrification and magnification, exaggeration, amplification of the role of the executive who in this instance, in this iteration of effectively an amendment drought, this president's view is that whatever he says is in the Constitution is in it, and what he says is not in it is not. I think that's actually essentially a continuation of the kind of deformity of the separation of powers that has been out of whack since the Constitution became unamendable. So there's another argument why it would be good to amend the Constitution more often. I would suspect most Americans don't know the US Constitution is amendable for one thing and we don't feel ourselves to be the authors of our own constitution, and that is the principle on which the nation was founded and arguably is crucial to the legitimacy of the Constitution. So a lot of the political instability, constitutional instability we see now I think we would describe as insurrectionary and amendment was the mechanism that was meant to prevent insurrection. If you as a people wanted to fundamentally change the government, adjust something significantly like impose term limits on Congress for instance, you ought to be able to do it peaceably. You ought not to need to use political violence to secure that result. That was the genius of the amendment provision in the first place.
I suspect that we're going to go back and forth in time, Founding Fathers, present day quite a lot in this conversation because those are the threads you are already touching on. But let's hear then from President Trump. I'd like to play you these words from him when he was being questioned by NBC News about the deportation of Kilmar Ábrego Garcia, wrongly, as US government officials acknowledged, to El Salvador.
Your Secretary of State says everyone who's here, citizens and non-citizens deserve due process. Do you agree, Mr. President? I don't know. I'm not a lawyer. I don't know. Well, the Fifth Amendment says as much. It seems it might say that, but if you're talking about that, then we'd have to have a million or 2 million or 3 million trials. Don't you need to uphold the Constitution of the United States as president? I don't know. I have to respond by saying again, I have brilliant lawyers that work for me and they are going to obviously follow what the Supreme Court said. What you said is not what I heard the Supreme Court said, they have a different interpretation.
So when you heard those words, as I'm sure you did at the time, what did you think?
He can't not know that it is his duty to uphold the Constitution. That is the oath that he swore when taking office. I think the overwhelming majority of the legal scholars consulted across the political spectrum are now convinced that we are in a considerable crisis regarding the rule of law in this country, because Trump's behavior has been entirely different in this administration, in this second term, which is to do whatever he wishes to do and hope that the court blinks without regard to its constitutionality or its legality, to just proceed and do it and see what happens.
I think from your voice, I feel that this weighs very heavily on you, this moment in time.