CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jill Lepore gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jill Lepore
Professor of American History and Law; Staff Writer, The New Yorker, Harvard University

Jill Lepore | We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution

📅 Oct 02, 2025 Author Events 68 MIN 8058 VIEWS 78 SEGMENTS · 5 SPEAKERS
In Conversation with Kate Shaw Published on the occasion of the 250th anniversary of the nation’s founding—the anniversary, too, of the first state constitutions—We the People offers a wholly new history of the Constitution. “One of the Constitution’s founding purposes was to prevent change,” Lepore writes. “Another was to allow for change without violence.” Relying on the extraordinary database she has assembled at the Amendments Project, Lepore recounts centuries of attempts, mostly by ordinary Americans, to realize the promise of the Constitution. Yet nearly all those efforts have failed....

Questions asked in this interview

9
  1. 8:49So can you talk a little bit about what is an Article Five, what we know about why Article Five was included and shaped the way it was in the Constitution, and in general terms how we have used Article Five?
  2. 12:03So I guess maybe talking about that question of difficulty in Article Five in the context of, you know, other kind of paths not taken in terms of state constitutions, sort of how should we think about those requirements today?
  3. 18:21So Jill, can you just talk a little bit about what the amendments project is?
  4. 26:48... to go deep on all of this, but I guess what would a fuller, better understanding of the 14th Amendment mean in cases like the ones I just mentioned, or in general when it comes to the Supreme Court's interpretation of the 14th Amendment?
  5. 32:58So you have the income tax amendment, you have direct election of senators, right?
  6. 38:42And and you also sort of you you a little bit allude to this, but there is this kind of proto-Phyllis Schlafly figure, right?
  7. 40:03Is that a fair kind of distillation of of of the book's perspective on Roosevelt?
  8. 50:04So in 71 we have the 26th amendment guaranteeing the right to vote for people 18 and over and also almost get across the finish line with an amendment abolishing the electoral college. Right?
  9. 55:58And not cherry-picking, not kind of, you know, just determining what you want it to mean, but but literally understanding the very broad view of history. What does that look like?
Host 0:05 ↗
Good evening, everyone. Good evening and welcome to tonight's Free Library of Philadelphia Foundation author event with Jill Lepore. This is one of the most talked-about books of the fall. Yeah, who's excited for this event? Who's excited? This is one of the most talked-about books of the fall, and we are thrilled to have her here. We have an extraordinary fall season lined up, complete with artists and novelists and historians and politicians. Last week we hosted Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, and later this season we're hosting Congressman Jim Clyburn.
We sincerely hope that you will join us for more events. But tickets are selling fast. They really are selling very fast. So please do register, which you can do through our web page, freelfoundation.org. I want to say just a few quick words about our organization in general. The foundation works together with the Free Library to support programming and advance its mission of promoting literacy throughout the Philadelphia region. As a nonprofit, of course, we are relying upon your support to achieve these goals. So please do consider donating, which you can also do through our website. Again, that's freelfoundation.org.
Before we get to tonight's program, there are a few people and organizations I would like to thank. I'd like to thank Uncle Bobby's, our partner bookseller, and the Philadelphia Citizen, our media partner. And finally, I would like to thank the volunteers, a dedicated group of library patrons whose loyalty to this program is unmatched. You would have seen them as you came in the auditorium this evening. We are so grateful for their support.
And now I'm going to turn things over to Toby Dictor, a member of the foundation's board of directors and a tireless supporter of the Free Library and the author series. Toby generously endowed this lecture in honor of her mother, Melia Gordon. Without her support, tonight's program and much else would not be possible. Thank you all again for being here. Please join me in welcoming Toby Dictor. Toby.
Toby Dictor 2:31 ↗
How about that? So, what's the secret sauce of Jill Lepore? How does this professor of both law and history, staff writer for the New Yorker for 20 years, author of countless books and prizes, wife, mother, cheerful commentator, pull us all together in thinking about the past? I think her genius lies in three things. One, her genuine enthusiasm for the subject. She calls history the great time machine.
Two, her sense of fairness, or as she calls it, the asymmetry of history, the imbalance when the story is told by those with power. She ferrets out the backstory of the forgotten characters, as she did in The Life and Opinions of Jane Franklin, and in the defeated Native American tribes in King Philip's War, and about in the 1741 slave rebellion in New York burning. The third is that she's a storyteller and knows how to grab the piece that will make the past come alive for us, as she does in this book with Justice Scalia, or in the history of feminism as The Secret History of Wonder Woman, which she introduced on this very stage in 2014, and even previous to that, her earlier books. She thinks this is the third or fourth time she's been here. So do you want to know the history of this Wonder Woman? Jill Lepore was the first in her family to go to college, a teenager who had no interest in college but went after receiving an ROTC scholarship to Tufts University.
Tufts University. Did you think Joe New... a teenager who had no interest in college, and she began as a math major. After a year she dropped both ROTC and math and switched to English, finishing her degree at Tufts in three years, while working as a secretary at Harvard where she sneaked in to audit history classes. Can you believe it? After earning her PhD from Yale, she held professorships at the University of California, San Diego, and Boston University before returning to Harvard to lead the department that she had sneaked in to audit.
So poignant. Most relevant tonight is her founding and leading the amendment project that gave rise to this book. I love what Daniel posted on our website about it. At a time when the Constitution's vulnerability is all too evident and the risk of political violence is all too real, We the People, with its shimmering prose and pioneering research, hints at the prospects of a better constitutional future as amended and amended America.
You should get this book even if you've read the cover story in The Atlantic or read The New York Times or watched last week's PBS Evening News or CNN, because, to quote Lepore about her style of narrative nonfiction, she won't give you the argument on the first page, but will convince you that you need to read the whole book to find out what happened. So, let's find out and welcome the remarkable Jill Lepore in conversation with Kate Shaw, another force of nature, professor of law at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School, and I think some of her students are here, co-host of the Supreme Court podcast called Strict Scrutiny, and a contributing opinion writer with The New York Times. We are in for a treat. Please welcome professors Kate Shaw and Jill Lepore.
Kate Shaw 6:27 ↗
Well, good evening, Philadelphia. What a pleasure it is to be here tonight in the place the Constitution first emerged to discuss this wonderful new book, We the People, by historian Jill Lepore. So Jill, I want to start by asking you to read from the beginning of the book.
Jill Lepore 6:45 ↗
Sure. Hello, everyone. Good evening. It's such a treat to be here even on this rainy day. Happy almost 250th anniversary of the Pennsylvania Constitution. Just getting you guys warmed up. Okay. Thank you so much, Kate. We the People. The Constitution of the United States is made of things that are born, live, thrive, decay, and die. Insects, animals, plants, ideas... in order to form a more perfect union. Each of its elements began long ago in the loamy earth, hatching and creeping or slipping, slick and squealing from the womb of the mind.
Establish justice. Ensure domestic tranquility. The text is written on parchment made from sheep fleeced, their hides soaked in lime, stretched and dried. Provide for the common defense. The ink came from the buds of oak leaves swollen to the size of musk balls by the eggs of wasps. Promote the general welfare. Its words were shaped by quills fashioned from the feathers of molting geese. Secure the blessings of liberty. Its lofty, momentous ideas came from the minds of men long since dead and from the books they read. To ourselves and our posterity.
Of the nearly 200 written constitutions, the Constitution of the United States, the most influential Constitution in the world, is also among the oldest. A relic as brittle as bone, as hard as stone. Do ordain and establish. Yeah.
Kate Shaw 8:49 ↗
So as that opening just so beautifully distills, the book develops an argument that the Constitution is an organic being, that the document drafted in 1787 right here was really just a start, and that it was intended to be subject to regular amendment, but that at various periods in our history, including in this moment, we have strayed from that essential truth. And if amendment is central to the Constitution, the degree to which the prospect of amendment feels out of reach today throws into question the entire constitutional project. So, the book has tons in it. I want to cover as much as we can in the limited time we have tonight. So I'll ask a handful of questions and then we'll have an opportunity for audience questions as well. So maybe let's start with mechanics. So Article Five sets forth the process or processes for amending the Constitution. So can you talk a little bit about what is an Article Five, what we know about why Article Five was included and shaped the way it was in the Constitution, and in general terms how we have used Article Five? We'll obviously go deeper on some specifics, but just to start, give us a picture.
Jill Lepore 10:02 ↗
Yeah, sure. So Article Five is the amendment provision of the US Constitution. It works, it's meant to work, allowing for a couple of different methods for proposing amendments to the Constitution and then methods for ratifying the US Constitution. And the methods that have been used chiefly involve Congress proposing amendments that then have to pass a supermajority in both houses of Congress, after which the proposed amendment goes to the states for ratification, and three-quarters of the states need to ratify an amendment for it to become part of the Constitution. There are other methods. The states can petition Congress to propose amendments, and if then they pass Congress, they go back to the states for ratification. The states can call for a constitutional convention to propose and deliberate over amendments, which then still need to be ratified. None of those other methods have ever actually succeeded.
Kate Shaw 11:13 ↗
So in terms of what we've actually done, supermajorities in each house of Congress, supermajorities in the states, and you know, this is something I'm sort of fixated on. The Constitution has a few places where it imposes these very high bars. So convicting on impeachment, right, requires a conviction of two-thirds in the Senate. The 25th Amendment, the part of it that allows the vice president and the cabinet to oust a president who is unable to perform the office, but if the president objects, two-thirds of each house of Congress has to override the president's effort to hold on. Thinking about presidency a lot recently. But there, it's a handful of places and important ones where the choices made, sometimes in the original document and sometimes in amendments, require significantly more than a simple majority vote.
So I guess I'm curious as to Article Five in particular: why make it so difficult to amend the written Constitution, and how do we understand those supermajority requirements today? And maybe I'll sort of pair that with another question because you mentioned the state constitutions, right? So the US Constitution is the subject of the book, but obviously every state also has its own constitution. Many of them predate the United States Constitution. They loomed, some of them, very large in decisions made about what to do with the United States Constitution, and they are all a heck of a lot easier to amend than the federal Constitution. So I guess maybe talking about that question of difficulty in Article Five in the context of, you know, other kind of paths not taken in terms of state constitutions, sort of how should we think about those requirements today?
Jill Lepore 12:50 ↗
Yeah, I think we really should not think about the US Constitution without the context of the state constitutions. In that, I think in law schools in particular, which is mainly where people talk about the Constitution, I think those things are quite distinct, right? When people are talking about constitutional law, they're largely talking about the US Constitution, but the US Constitution is a product of state constitutionalism.
So in 1776, before Jefferson drafted the Declaration of Independence in July, June and July of that year, the states were already writing their constitutions. Because if you think about it, the war starts in 1775. Once the war starts, the royal governors start fleeing, going back to England. The colonial assemblies collapse because they were appointed by the royal governor. A lot of the colonial assemblies, those people were loyalists. They too are turning tail and leaving for England. There's no government in the colonies anymore. And so by January of 1776, the Continental Congress starts saying, 'Okay, hey states, turns out you probably need a government if we're going to act in concert to continue the war. Like, you can't even muster troops and your state's being invaded.' So the states start writing constitutions in January of 1776.
And John Adams gets very upset because he's like, 'These things need to happen in order. Every state needs to write a constitution. Then we need to declare independence. Then we need to write a constitution for the new nation.' And the rest of the Continental Congress is like, 'Dude, we're at war. Like, you might like to do things in that order, but that's not how they're going to happen.' So it's just kind of this chaos. Pennsylvania writes its first constitution that spring.
But the states, even though they are in the midst of war, people are fighting this war because they believe in self-government and they haven't had it. So they have to invent it. And the way they're inventing it is in each of their constitutions is a different experiment. It's like a science experiment, right? We're going to run, you know, we're going to put blue dye in this petri dish and green dye in this petri dish, and this will be our control group, and this one will, you know... And so every state has, you know, Pennsylvania's first constitution. You guys probably know this. I think there's no governor. The laws have to be posted in every pub in the state for a year before anyone can vote on... like, there's a lot of drinking going on in Pennsylvania, I think. But like, each state has a different way of doing things because they're just trying to figure it out. In some states you elect the judges, and in some states they get appointed by the governor. Pennsylvania is a unicameral, there's only one branch of the legislature.
So, no, briefly, at the beginning, and then that gets immediately overruled. Pennsylvania has the most democratic constitution, and it's the one that the framers of the US Constitution most want to leave behind. So there are all these different experiments, and one thing that's not working are the Articles of Confederation. I feel very silly talking to you. You're this esteemed constitutional lawyer, and so you correct me when I get this. So the Articles of Confederation, which are the only thing holding the union together for the sake of fighting the war, require unanimity to amend. All 13 states have to agree. And yet the articles are quite weak because they were just sort of thrown together. They don't grant Congress the power to tax, to resolve debts, to resolve disputes between the states.
So Congress is sort of useless, which might seem very familiar. But then someone thought maybe we ought to do something about that. And so in 1786, they decide to hold a convention to revise the Articles of Confederation. And sadly, no one shows up. This is going to be in Annapolis. So the few people who do show up say, 'No, let's meet in Philadelphia. We'll meet in Philadelphia the next year, and we're done with revising these useless Articles of Confederation. We're going to write a whole new Constitution.' So everybody understood from the beginning that the Constitution was going to have to have a good, usable, useful amendment mechanism, because the reason they were meeting was because the Articles of Confederation had a useless one, and the states by now have all — not all of them, but most of them — have written amendment provisions into their state constitutions.
So in a way, when they meet in Philadelphia, you know, they come here in May, early May, and writing Article Five — there's a reason it's Article Five, it's like kind of one of the last things they do because everything else is harder — and they're like, 'Okay, we all agree about this one. We know we need to have an amendment provision. It's got to be not requiring unanimity. It shouldn't also be super easy. I mean, we don't want to make it like a basic majority vote or something.' But the distance between those two, how they get to two-thirds, that's actually about other compromises that they've already made. But it's sort of like the no-brainer part of the Constitution in some way. And it's also — when are we now? September 24th. It's still pretty warm down here. They were so hot.
Kate Shaw 18:00 ↗
The windows are all closed, right, to keep things secret. They're so hot. It smells terrible.
Jill Lepore 18:05 ↗
They have woolen underwear on. They've spent the whole summer in Philadelphia. There's no air conditioning. They have the windows now. They just want to go home. So, like, they kind of just throw it together, and here we are.
Kate Shaw 18:21 ↗
Okay. So, one of the many things the book does that's amazing, I think, is to remind us how central state constitutions are to the entirety of the United States Constitution. And another thing it does is really self-consciously expand the historical record when we study the Constitution, and in particular, of course, the topic of amendment, which is the topic of the book. So there have been, as the book shows, efforts from the beginning to amend the Constitution, and some of those efforts have created the sorts of historical records that are easy to access. But many, many more efforts to amend the Constitution that this book surfaces for the first time don't even result in a document introduced in Congress. Like, you find them elsewhere. And so before the writing of the book, right, came this enormous project of amassing thousands, right, of new documents as part of this amendments project. So Jill, can you just talk a little bit about what the amendments project is? And then maybe we could talk a little bit about how some of what you learned through that project expands the way we should understand both the successes and the failures of amendment.
Jill Lepore 19:32 ↗
Yeah. So, as was mentioned in that lovely introduction, a lot of my work really is about the asymmetry of the historical record. That we know so much about some people and so little about other people. And just strikingly, nowhere is that more true than in the historical record as it is construed by the US Supreme Court. For the court, the historical record — which the court is fascinated by the 18th century — but its understanding of the historical record is just an incredibly shrunken, bounded thing. I mean, they're beautiful documents: the Constitution, the Federalist Papers, Madison's notes on the Constitutional Convention, the notes of the ratifying convention. They're hugely important, of soaring importance, and they're fascinating and of course apt in every way. But from the vantage of a historian who works with the large sweep of American history and the experience of many different kinds of people and individuals and groups, they're just like a vanishingly small oddity, you know.
So, when I've thought a lot about how strange that is and how unlike historical reasoning and the standards of historical evidence the court's current way of thinking about the historical record is, I really sort of like, what about all — what about what everybody else wanted? And especially people that couldn't vote, couldn't even vote for people to go to ratifying conventions in the states, say, because there actually has been a lot of historical scholarship about what sometimes historians call the people out of doors, or they were called even at the time the people out of doors. Like people who would gather around carpenters, like who would just be, you know, they're in there writing our new government, like people would just go out and hang out and be difficult around the building. And a lot of people would send in letters and protests to their ratifying conventions, or send in petitions of complaint or proposed formal amendments in the states. And there is just a quite lively, unruly...
just font of agitation, of constitutional agitation, both in the moment, you know, beginning in 1776 when the states are writing, like 3,000 people gather in Philadelphia to say, 'Isn't it great? We're going to have a constitutional convention to write a state constitution.' Like it's this huge celebration. Everyone gets drunk again. There's a lot of drinking and a lot of arguing about how the government should work. And I'm just kind of puzzled as a citizen by why that history is not part of how we decide what the meaning of the Constitution is. And I think, you know, someone who has that judicial philosophy could defend it, but they can't defend it as history.
So I started this project partly because I really wanted a new body of evidence to work with within my students in teaching. It turned out when I would ask students who were like, 'I want to do some research on, you know, efforts to insert the word God into the US Constitution,' it would be almost impossible to do. There was no central place to go look to see who has ever tried to do that, when, and why, and what happened to those efforts. So I got this wonderfully generous grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities to work with undergraduates for, I think we did, it was like a five-year project to collect and digitize and tag by topic every meaningful attempt to amend the US Constitution, including petitions submitted to Congress, you know, letters, social media posts, sort of, you know, anything that we could find.
And it was really illuminating, but even the way we defined what a possible, like a meaningfully proposed amendment was, even that bar was kind of too high for me because I felt that it was impossible to really put in. So for instance, you may know that right after Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence, it was published and printed and people celebrated all over the United States and read it out loud and, you know, shot darts at pictures of the king and like it was really fun and they drank a lot. But there was, for instance, this black minister in Connecticut, Lemuel Haynes, wrote a response called 'Liberty Further Extended,' which is an extended reflection on the Declaration of Independence and its failure to end slavery and the intellectual and moral inconsistency of the document. And in my mind, that tract is essentially a proposed amendment to the Declaration of Independence, which has become constitutionalized.
And yet it's not like anyone in the Supreme Court is ever going to cite 'Liberty Further Extended.' And nor is it even in the amendments project because it doesn't sort of meet my bar. It's before the Constitution. It's not addressed to a specific state constitution either. But I think that if we want a richer, fuller, more democratic constitutionalism in the present, we actually need to have it in the past. And I don't think we actually have had that because so much of the story that we tell ourselves as a nation about the Constitution is essentially the story of a series of Supreme Court decisions.
Kate Shaw 25:07 ↗
And that is definitely an impoverished and inaccurate way to understand the Constitution, is just by reading Supreme Court opinions. But I am going to ask about a couple, if that's okay. And you did mention the Supreme Court, and I think this does tie to the amendments project. So I thought I would ask about the 14th Amendment, which is ratified in 1868. It is the middle of the three amendments that are added in the five years between 1865 and 1870. So the 13th Amendment ends slavery. The 14th has a bunch of components which we'll talk about. And the 15th, right, prohibits racial discrimination in voting. So the 14th has been at the center of a number of Supreme Court cases, both recently and upcoming.
So just last year in Trump versus Anderson, right, the Supreme Court — so that case involves the third section of the 14th Amendment, which disqualifies officeholders who have engaged in insurrection from again holding office. And the Supreme Court held that the state of Colorado couldn't keep then-candidate Trump off of the presidential ballot under Section Three of the 14th Amendment. That's 2024. In 2023, the Supreme Court held that the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment prohibited universities from considering race in higher education admissions. I think the court encountered but did not reach the merits of the constitutionality of the day-one executive order purporting to end birthright citizenship. But I think in the next year or so, the court is likely to have to answer the question of whether the Constitution permits the president, through executive order, to end birthright citizenship. So that is just, you know, like a sampling of things this Supreme Court has done in recent years, or I think will soon do.
And so, Jill, you write that — and again, this ties back to the amendments project — that the roots of the 14th Amendment lie not in the halls of Congress but in meetings in cities and states, state constitutional conventions, so-called colored conventions. So what, I guess, can you just say a few words about what is that fuller picture of the origins of this incredibly important, maybe the most important constitutional amendment, the 14th Amendment? And, you know, it would probably take too long to go deep on all of this, but I guess what would a fuller, better understanding of the 14th Amendment mean in cases like the ones I just mentioned, or in general when it comes to the Supreme Court's interpretation of the 14th Amendment?
Jill Lepore 27:28 ↗
Yeah, the 14th Amendment is so important. It's like a whole new Constitution. And it was really thought about that way at the time. There were writers who said after the ratification of the 14th Amendment, 'Well, we'll stop celebrating 1776 as a country because we should just celebrate 1868. Like, this is actually the founding of the country. Like, it was an incomplete founding in 1776 or 1787, but this is our second founding, our new founding.' And I think a lot of historians, in fact, legal scholars also think about the 39th Congress that drafted the 14th Amendment in 1865 as essentially a constitutional convention. So there's a really kind of almost like when you renew your wedding vows somehow, but you've been married for long enough that it's a really deeper, different kind of experience. And the people who are there with you to celebrate it are richer, deeper friends that you've had for many seasons of your life. There's a kind of that feel to the 14th Amendment. It's just like a transcendent...
Kate Shaw 28:44 ↗
But you're also divorcing the original Constitution in a really profound way. So we have to complicate it a little bit.
Jill Lepore 28:49 ↗
It actually raises an interesting question. This is a diversion, but I promise I'm going to get back to the origin of the 14th Amendment. When the first amendments were proposed, which became our Bill of Rights, there was a big debate in Congress about what to do with them, because a lot of people thought you should go back in and edit the Constitution and like scratch out the things that the Bill of Rights negate. And other people are like, 'No, that'll be so messy. We should just put them at the end and we'll just call it something else. Like this will be like the list of the amendments.' And so they also thought, 'Well, we'll call it the Bill of Rights and then people will shut up about it' or something. But there was a huge debate, and it really would have been very different if you think about it. There also was like a printing cost problem. People were like, 'We already printed so many copies of this thing. Now we have to go and people are going to have two different versions.' But then the lawyerly people who were not so worried about cost were like, 'Yeah, but as a lawyer, what if I have like Article Three is contradicted by Amendment Four? How do I... it's going to lead to all kinds of problems of interpretation in the future,' which was true.
But if the 14th Amendment had — if the choice had been to edit the original Constitution and then release a revised version, the 14th Amendment would have overwritten quite a bit of it. But the debate about where the 14th Amendment comes from and what it means, based on what it meant at the time, is like probably the biggest constitutional matter of disputation in the last hundred years, certainly since Brown v. Board of Education, where the debate in Brown v. Board of Education, when it was argued and reargued, was like, what did they mean by the 14th Amendment? You, the NAACP, are saying the 14th Amendment was intended to prohibit segregation, but you all, the segregated schools, are saying it was intended to prohibit no such thing. Who has the better historical evidence? And that's why it was reargued.
And then Earl Warren says, 'Your historical evidence is completely inconclusive. Here's the thing. It's wrong. Segregation is just wrong, and we're going to do that. We're going to end it.' That was a different moment in judicial history. But in any case, that was a really important moment because it was like Warren saying, it's not that history doesn't matter, but like we can't find answers in the past, or we will be trapped, we'll be shackled to the past.
So my point, though, for my analysis of the 14th Amendment, is even then, when they had assigned all these people, 'Go, please, go all over the country, scour the evidence, find out what they meant,' no one looked at the records of the Black conventions, which were constitutional conventions held by Black men, more than 200 of them across the free states, starting in 1828, 1829, in which Black men got together. They had state conventions, they had national conventions, they had regional conventions. They gave speeches. They raised toasts. I'm sure some of them drank. Many of them drank. They published their proceedings. And they argued about the Constitution. And those just have no place in our history of the Constitution, like bizarrely. Like there's some fantastic research on these. There's a great website called the Colored Conventions Project that has collected a transcription of all the proceedings and has quite a bit of details about it.
It's not like these sources are not available to the courts or even, you know, to law schools where teaching constitutional history. It's just that the speeches and writings and gatherings and conventions of Black Americans were not constitutionalized. I would argue they were constitutionalized. That is what the 14th Amendment is, right? Like those are the origins of the 14th Amendment. And oh, is it a big secret? It's not. They're printed, like you can read about them in any newspaper of the day. So if we — but if we can't see that, then the 14th Amendment just is far more mysterious than it is required to be.
Kate Shaw 32:58 ↗
So there's so much more I want to ask you on that, but I want to make sure to cover a bit more of what is in the book. So okay, so after the Reconstruction amendments, you have a long period of no amendments to the Constitution, and then you have this surge between 1913 and 1920. So you have the income tax amendment, you have direct election of senators, right? Originally it was just state legislatures that picked senators. You know, not until the 17th Amendment do senators get directly elected. Prohibition, the 19th Amendment, right, guaranteeing the right to vote for women. So there's that kind of flurry of activity. And then there is another break, although not nearly as long as the break that precedes that kind of cluster of amendments.
But actually after that 1920 passes, you have — and this is again, I'm sorry, I'm coming back to the United States Supreme Court because it really is such an important player and often villain in the story that you are telling. So the effort to do a child labor amendment, which if you're like, 'Wait, which amendment is that?' No, so that one never makes it, but it comes really close. And I guess maybe do you want to talk about what the impetus is to amend the Constitution, right, to prohibit child labor or to make clear that Congress can do so, and sort of what the failure tells us, and that I think maybe will bring us up to kind of FDR and the New Deal, which is of course a really important part of the story you tell.
Jill Lepore 34:26 ↗
Yeah. So if you think about that set of four amendments that are ratified between 1913 and 1920, they're all ones that...
that people had been fighting for for decades. It takes decades and decades and decades to get any of them through. But they are all in different ways an attempt to address the problems of the industrial economy and the political powerlessness of the poor and of women and children. And they're all attempts to remedy that. So right, the income tax amendment is just about the poor, just just taking getting rid of tariffs and taxing income in a graduated way so that the bureaucrats will have to pay to support what is becoming, you know, some social welfare provisions. The direct election of the Senate, right, just to try to enfranchise people to to have more of a control of their own lives. The prohibition, however bad an idea it was, was really a feminist agenda, which was a way to to so stop the abuse of women and children by men who could not work because they drank all day. It really was an attempt to protect women and children from drunken husbands and from from domestic violence which was really and remains very associated with alcoholism. So it was a women's campaign and it was a feminist campaign and the granting women the right to vote. The argument always had to be made this will be good because women will be able to protect children. And so the whole package really is about the weak and the poor, the politically weakened and and the economically poor and child labor was the natural next amendment in that sequence also because like the 16th amendment, the income tax amendment, it was it was the only way to address the Supreme Court decision in this case too. So the the Supreme Court had ruled in the 1890s that an income tax was unconstitutional. So the only way to affect it even though Congress had already passed a law was to get a constitutional amendment.
Congress twice decided that Congress the Supreme Court twice decided that Congress had no power to regulate or to tax prohibitively child labor. So the only way to end it was with a constitutional amendment. And it it had huge public support, really widespread public support. It passed the house on the day it was introduced. There had been child labor laws and constitutional amendments in many many states and the ad but the advocates for the child labor amendment did not understand because they had not progressives progressivism at the time was across the parties. It wasn't a political ideology per se or a partisan position. Progressives had not encountered the kind of opposition that was waged against the child labor amendment, which was this extraordinarily well-funded campaign chiefly led by owners of southern textile mills who who wanted to continue to be able to employ children in the mills, especially black children. And they just waged a very effective ground game. And this is also the beginnings of mass communication. So there's radio, newspapers, the advertising industry has emerged and you can lie about stuff pretty well when you have mass communication. And so their their big their big message was especially to rural Americans, make sure to tell your state legislators not to vote to ratify this amendment because if they do, you will no longer be able to tell your daughter to wash the dishes or your son to bring in bring in bring the and from the field that like there your farm would fall apart. It was an extraordinarily effective campaign and it really caught progressives up short. It also ended the progressive era of constitutional amendment and it also provided a model for later opponents of the progressive like the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments. The progressive amendments all had a spirit of moral reform behind them. It really seemed to suggest that moral reform and social progress could not be achieved by way of constitutional amendment if moneyed interest could be mobilized so effectively against them.
Kate Shaw 38:42 ↗
And and you also sort of you you a little bit allude to this, but there is this kind of proto-Phyllis Schlafly figure, right? Mary Kilbreth. There's so
Jill Lepore 38:49 ↗
Mary Kilbreth. I love her. She's fantastic.
Kate Shaw 38:52 ↗
I had not heard of her. Maybe I should have, but there are so many there are so many very familiar figures and storylines and so many that are totally unfamiliar. And for me, she was one of the very unfamiliar ones.
Jill Lepore 39:01 ↗
Yeah. She's this genius conservative political operator who is dedicated. She wrote she she publishes a newspaper called The Woman Patriot that is I think the subtitle is like opposed to socialism, feminism, suffragism. Then she drops suffragism after women get the vote. And like I it's just it's just she's just like a one-woman political movement. She's unbelievably effective. And really hardly anyone has ever written about her. She didn't leave papers anywhere. You know, there's like one senior thesis and then like a a brilliant dissertation, but she's just it's kind of astonishing how someone with such political power could be so neglected. And that's sort of the other piece. Like I'm not like resurrecting just people that I like or I agree with. I really disagree with Mary Kilbreth, but like she's a really important American who had a lot of constitutional ideas and left behind a lot of a lot of a pretty big paper trail expressing them.
Kate Shaw 40:03 ↗
Okay. So, the child labor amendment in part because of Mary Kilbreth's efforts and in part because sort of, you know, capital using the sort of then new forms of mass communication is just successful in mobilizing opposition. So, it passes Congress but stalls to a halt in the states at ratification. And and then so so I want to now sort of move forward into FDR's presidency and the New Deal. And that's a story that I felt like I understood just in some in somewhat different ways after reading this account. So, you know, people are going to be varying degrees of familiar with this standoff, right, between President Roosevelt and the very conservative Supreme Court that is striking down New Deal initiative after New Deal initiative and also at the same time invalidating lots of state efforts to regulate in ways that protect workers and consumers and families. So this very conservative Supreme Court that is hostile to progressive legislation or action, whether state or federal. And Roosevelt responds with the court packing plan. And the way the kind of story is told is, you know, there's a bit of a standoff and he's unsuccessful in getting this court packing plan actually through Congress, but kind of wins at the end of the day because the Supreme Court backs down. There's the switch in time that saved nine and the court starts upholding New Deal actions in 1937. Okay. So, that part of the story is familiar probably to varying degrees to people. But there also is in a way Roosevelt ends up sounding kind of like the villain of this part of the story, at least the amendment story, which is essentially by deciding not to pursue formal constitutional amendment to kind of enshrine in the document the power of the federal government to do really big important social welfare work. He relies on the Supreme Court to uphold to bless the ability of both the president and Congress to act. And what the Supreme Court giveth the Supreme Court can take away. And so that is sort of the beginning of the kind of deemphasis of formal constitutional amendment in favor of this judicialization of the most important constitutional fights and settlements that we sort of engage in. So I guess you know is it right that this this visionary president in many ways with respect to the constitution right in his constitutional day speech in 1937 he famously says the constitution is not a lawyer's contract it's a layman's document he urges Americans to revere the constitution not because it is old but because it is ever new but ends up thwarting inadvertently our ability to actually meaningfully make change at least through the formal amendment process. Is that a fair kind of distillation of of of the book's perspective on Roosevelt?

23 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lepore, J. (2025, October 2). Jill Lepore | We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution [Interview transcript]. Author Events. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146668/

MLA

Jill Lepore. "Jill Lepore | We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution." Author Events, 2 Oct. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146668/.

BibTeX
@misc{lepore2025_3146668,
  author       = {Jill Lepore},
  title        = {Jill Lepore | We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Author Events. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {oct},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3146668/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}