So it's such a thrill to be here with Jill, who I've only met for the first time today. I've often been an interviewer or moderator at the Book Festival, but usually when I'm asked to do one, then I have to go and scramble and read the book quickly. In this case, I was already reading Jill's book because I read all of Jill's books. So I wanted to just dive right in and ask you: you've written this fascinating history of the Constitution, but it's really focusing on the efforts to change it, to amend the Constitution, which is a story of frustration, of struggle, often of failure to change the document. So why did you decide to write a history of things that often did not happen?
Sheer perversity. I am really interested in theories of how change happens. And we live in an age where I just really noticed this with my students and with my kids, where their conception of change is largely technological. They measure change in like which version of the iPhone or which version of ChatGPT they have. Like, that's technological progress is really just how they understand change. And, you know, the 19th century theory of change was evolution. The 20th century's theory really was growth, economic growth. And the 18th century's theory of change, the Enlightenment theory of change was progress. But they really meant moral progress. So I kind of really became fascinated with how the idea of amendment embodied that moral theory of change. And it's in the word itself. We make amends for the wrong things that we do. We mend our ways when we have erred. And I actually just think it's a really beautiful idea, honestly. It moved me to think about what it meant to invent amendment with the invention of constitutionalism. So written constitutions are an 18th century invention. And when you think about it, it's the kind of one of the great ideas to celebrate about the American Revolution at this 250th anniversary is the idea that the government has to write down what the rules are. And so that the people can hold the governors accountable to those rules. But if you write down the rules and the fundamental rules, the other idea of the revolutionary era was you have to be able to fix them if they're not working. And that idea of fixing, repairing, improving, making amends, mending is the idea of amendment and it doesn't work anymore. And it kind of never really especially worked. So I just got, I don't know, I just kind of-- I go off on these tangents and I just got like, I want to find out everything about amendments.
So you, you quote the immortal American sage Bugs Bunny and this great--
He really should be quoted more often.
In this great video from the 70s where you should, you should all look this up where he sings, ♪ It was intended to be amended ♪ ♪ The Constitution. ♪
And then Daffy Duck runs on stage. Bugs Bunny is a professor, and he's got the mortarboard and the tassel and the gown, and he's singing this ode to the amendments and Daffy Duck, like, dressed like a vaudevillian, shuffles on stage and says, Linda, Linda, Linda, Linda, Linda. So we could do it.
Yeah, we should take us on the road.
And you note how the founders themselves believed that it should be amended from time to time. That's why they created this mechanism. Did they realize they were making it difficult to amend or did they want it to be a more straightforward process, or did they mean for it to be difficult?
You know, it was one of the last things they actually put in the draft. Like, remember they met in Philadelphia? It was pretty hot today right here in Washington. Like they met in Philadelphia starting in May. And they finished, you know, they were done signing the like calligraphy version on September 17th. They were so hot in August when by the time they got around to like, what should the amendment thing say? Like they knew all along.
No, they knew all along there was going to be an amendment article. But but then it was a math problem. And we kind of forget that a lot of the Constitution is a math problem. And these are the people whose math brought you the 3/5 clause. So, you know, they were not. We are the first nation to have a mandated census. We count the people every ten years because the Constitution was aiming to solve the math problem of representation. This is one of the great inventions of the revolutionary era, is that the people should be represented proportionate to their population, and that was new. They didn't know and they discussed it like, maybe we should do it by wealth, maybe we should do it by land. You know, there are a lot of other. And then they decided to do it by population. Then they had to figure out this problem, what to do, how to count people who were held as property and not deemed under the law to be persons, anyway, just to say, like the whole thing was kind of a math problem. And then by the time they get to, well, they figured out the Electoral College and what are we going to do about amendment? We want it to be possible, but we don't want it to be so easy because we already think it's going to be a hard sell convincing people to ratify this wholly new system of government. We have to-- People got to be willing to try this thing for a while, kick the tires for a few years before we go in and decide, you know, we know we need snow tires or whatever. I got lost in my metaphor. So they want to make it amendable. They really believe in that. And the state constitutions have been experimenting with that. The state constitutions start in 1776. And it's really just like a Goldilocks problem, you know, not too easy, not too hard. And the solution they come up with, you know, there were other options on the table, but they come up with that. It has to pass a two thirds majority in both houses of Congress, and they go to the states. And three quarters of the states have to ratify. And that seems hard, but not unachievable in the way that so impeachment is also a two thirds, two thirds vote, treaty making. Supermajority is a reasonable, it should be a high bar. The three quarters of the states didn't seem particularly hard. Why their math was wrong is that there was there were no political parties when they wrote that Article Five of the Constitution, and by 1800 there are political parties. And then when people are voting as members of Congress or as senators in obedience to their parties, rather than for the country or the best interests of the country, it becomes very difficult to get over that bar. And in our era of polarized politics, where Congress can't meet a 51, you know, a bare majority, the two thirds majority is completely unattainable.
Well, there's one thing that seems to lead to constitutional amendments. You write that Article Five is a sleeping giant, and what wakes it up is war. Why do American wars lead to constitutional amendments?
Yeah, I wish I had a better answer to that question. Do you have a theory about this, Carlos?
Yeah, this is the lazy professor's move. That's a great question.
What do you think? How would you answer that? It is a weird pattern, right? So amendments have always, in America, just come in bursts. So one really easy thing to say is, I would suspect that most people in this room do not have in their mind, like a list of the five constitutional amendments they most want, because we've forgotten that it's even a possibility, right? It's just not. We don't talk about it. You don't read in the newspaper about different constitutional amendments when I mean, like Biden proposed a constitutional amendment on his last day in office. That was a Supreme Court restructuring amendment. But, you know, they're just balloons thrown up into the--
Almost like interesting legislation that no one's going to vote for.
It's just a symbolic act. There's not like a movement around any of these things. So part of the reason that they happen in bursts. This isn't the war question is just that it takes, like George Washington always called the amendment provision a constitutional door that shall forever be left open to the people. But it's mostly locked. So eventually something comes along, picks the lock, and then when it's open, people are like, oh yeah, I want to do this and I want to do this. And they kind of you kind of push through a few at a time. But the thing that picks the lock seems to be war, which is to say it's like a just a, a reset, like it requires a whole new political settlement. So the first ten amendments are ratified all at once. We call them the Bill of Rights. They didn't call them that at the time, but they were really the after effect of the Revolutionary War. Like this set of rights were what people believed that they were fighting for. They weren't in the Constitution. They immediately asked for them and they got them. So that's 1 to 10, 13, 14, 15, our Civil War and Reconstruction. Well, there you can say, well, the southern states didn't have any representation in Congress. So it was like a one party congress.
Really illegitimate amendments.
And in the southern states often then afterwards said like those were not constitutionally ratified.
They had a term for it. It was, what do they call it? Something amendments. It's in the renegade amendment.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then the next sort of big wave is the Progressive Era, which is right around World War One starts just before the war, 1913 to 1920. There's four more. There's four amendments passed in the 19th between 1961 and 1971. I just think that, these were all wars in which there was a draft. So we have had wars since 71, but the effect is not across the population in the same way, the cost of war in an age without the draft is borne by the poor. So it just doesn't have the same, our entire political order is thrown up, kind of for--
The sense of having to reset is gone. Now you've tracked amendments throughout American history, and one of the one of the parts I love about the book is that every few chapters there's like a list of all the amendments and you know, what party proposed them and what they were about. And you sort of see the evolution over time and how they grow over time. What are the issues that have most consistently attracted sort of calls for amending the Constitution?
Making amending the Constitution easier is an evergreen.
There haven't been a lot of calls for that lately. The Progressive Era was just riddled with those, you know, all the time people were trying to get, make it easier to amend the Constitution. Reforming or later abolishing the Electoral College. I think that's first introduced really formally in Congress. Round of applause. Yeah, we could do a little public opinion survey here.
Yeah. I think that's first introduced in 1803. So really early.
Really early on. Right. Because the northern states understand that the Electoral College favors the slave states because of the 3/5 clause. So their obvious proposal is let's just get rid of that. What even is it? Even then people were like, what even is this again?
That hasn't really changed. And the Electoral College abolition? I spent a lot of time on this in the book because in 1969, it passes the House and is defeated in the Senate by, I think, six votes. And it is one of the narrowest. 80% of Americans wanted to abolish the Electoral College in 1969. So presumably if it had passed the Senate, it would have achieved ratification. It might have been a close battle. I don't know who the interest might have, might have emerged. But that's one of the stranger pieces. But, you know, it's interesting that how the amendments that have been achieved have generally taken decades, decades and decades. It requires a kind of across generations commitment. I mean, obviously, ending slavery requires generations and generations of struggle. The 19th amendment is passed and ratified in 1920. It's essentially first proposed by women in 1848, arguably first proposed by women in 1776. So it just takes a very, very long time to change the Constitution.
You quote letters from Abigail Adams to John Adams, and one of the things that I love about the book is that we all look back to Philadelphia in 1787 and you know, what the weather was like and all that. But really, you chronicle all these parallel gatherings of, of Native Americans, of, of Black Americans, of women's groups that are convening informally and, and petitioning for change to the Constitution. In some ways, this is the heart of the book. How did those efforts eventually inform kind of the more formal attempts to change the Constitution?
Well, I think you can find interesting patterns. So, for instance, there were more than 200, historians refer to them as Black conventions. They were called at the time, colored conventions in the 19th century, beginning in 1829, huge gatherings of elected delegates who met in all of the free states, in major cities and statewide and national and municipal, essentially constitutional conventions at a time when Black men and women could not vote anywhere in the United States, and had no part of the revising of state constitutions. So across the 19th century, states are holding constitutional conventions pretty much constantly. Because new states are entering the union, they need to write a constitution. And then every time they do, they come up with some idea. And the older states are like, wait, we like that thing they're doing in Michigan. Let's have a constitutional convention or.
Even like copying each other.
Yeah, they're all copying. They have like it's a huge, big printing industry to publish these manuals of constitutional ideas. People are just, it's this big explosion of constitutional ideas. But women and Black men and native people and Chinese immigrants, none of these people have any representation at any of these state constitutional conventions. So they start holding their own, women hold their own conventions, Black men hold their own conventions. Native nations, beginning in 1827, hold their own constitutional conventions. And the thing that's so fascinating to me is they leave behind. They always print their proceedings. I mean, it's just that's kind of a world you would have-- You would meet and you'd print your proceedings. And they are in the sense that we discuss like they are failures, they are failed amendments. Generally what they're doing is saying, we want this in the Constitution or we don't like this in the Constitution, but we don't think we-- Like historians even, but certainly judges don't think about those as constitutional texts. It's a huge body of evidence of the constitutional preferences of all the people who couldn't vote. Like, how is that not part of our constitutional history? So, yes, I'm looking at failures, but actually I'm just trying to open that constitutional door to the broad body of evidence that lies and each of these rooms like this. It's hundreds and hundreds of people getting together and arguing about the Constitution. None of those proceedings has ever been quoted in a Supreme Court decision. Like as if these things didn't happen or these people didn't have constitutional ideas. So if we want to have a better constitutional future, like we actually need a better constitutional past.
Well, thanks to this book, that is part of the history now. Let's stick with the states for a second. One of the paradoxes of the book is that it's so much of it is about how hard it is to amend the Constitution. Like the, the, the American Constitution, the nation's constitution. But the states were like, amending like crazy, like, all the time. You have this Tocqueville quote saying that like, nowhere is-- I'm going to mangle it. But something like nowhere is the law more changeable than in America or something like that, because, you know, they just they're constantly changing the Constitution. So is it simply a procedural, technical question that allows for all the change to happen in the state constitutions versus the federal level, or is there something about the states versus the nation that allows for that change in one case and precludes it in the other.
That's a really good question. Well it's both. There's some of the same forces apply, but then some of the forces are different. I mean, in the states where people are having these constitutional conventions constantly and where the Black conventions and women's conventions and native nations, people just really believe in convening, like it is-- You're not going to the movie theater. There's nothing on TV. You can't sit by the radio. We're going to go to a convention. Everybody goes to conventions. There's temperance conventions, like just, you know, vegetarian conventions. Everybody goes to-- mechanics conventions. Everybody goes to conventions. This is partly what Tocqueville is talking about, the associational American like, people just like to get together and hang out, and they like to argue about stuff. And the convention becomes and a lot of commentators, including Tocqueville, say it is like the visible embodiment meant of democracy. Like, you can see that the people are sovereign because they're always gathering together and making the laws all over again, like that. Just that act is about like we are, we are the people, and we're going to change the laws again. And that we don't do that anymore is like a huge part of the problem. Like the last time a state had a regular constitutional convention in the United States was Rhode Island in 1986. Like a lot of people don't know that states can just have a convention and amend there. But like, we just don't trust one another to sit in a room and not, I don't know, take out guns, whatever it is people are afraid of. So there's just a difference. But that doesn't explain the federal piece. The federal piece is there have been a lot of explanations, but I think what happens is that up until the time of the Civil War, there are a lot of requests to have constitutional convention, one of which is to get rid of the Electoral College. But sectionalism develops so quickly. You know, it's by 1832 that South Carolina is about to secede over the tariff. Yeah. So I'll give you a little South Carolina history. No one is willing to, actually, no one in Congress is like, they just don't-- When the states apply to hold a constitutional convention, Congress is like, we can't even because we know by 1833 Congress has passed a gag rule. You cannot even read a petition about slavery on the floor of Congress by 1833. This is what, like John Quincy Adams spends the rest of his life trying to overturn, to be willing to even speak the word abolition in Congress like there is no free speech. This is where the free speech party comes from. This is where the slogan free speech comes from is, is from the attempt to overturn the gag rule. Like there is the way in which, like we think we couldn't possibly sit down and argue about stuff. The thing they couldn't-- The reason they could not meet to have a constitutional convention was they just, the powder keg, that was the dispute over slavery. So then by the time you get to the Civil War, I think it is very reasonable to think of the 39th Congress, which meets starting in January, December, January 1865, as a constitutional convention, because they write the 14th amendment and the 14th amendment is effectively a new constitution. I mean, it's just like a wholly new arrangement. But it's just northerner, you know what I mean? It's just the reason they can do it is Confederates can't hold office. So I think if we counted that as a constitutional convention, we'd probably have a more accurate sense of the history. So then you're like, okay, but then what about since then? Why did-- You know? And then it's like, well, the country got through a century without having them, like then there's just the inertia of it. And this is what Madison always warned about. James Madison, who wrote the first draft of the Constitution and drafted what became the Bill of Rights. Like, he's like the problem with the Constitution writing it down is that the older it gets, the more people will venerate it, and the less willing they will be to revise it. And so therefore, they will lose their sense that it is their constitution to revise.
You've said like 15 things that I want to follow up on. So I'm going to stick with the Civil War for a second. You spend a good bit of time in the book on the fate of Jefferson Davis after the war. Why is that important to the story of the Constitution?
You know, I think it might have been compensating for the fact that I never knew the story of Jefferson Davis.
She was just telling me that whenever she wants to learn something, she teaches a class on it.
Yeah. You know. I was like, whatever happened to Jefferson Davis? This was right about the time of the Trump trials. So I became really interested to understand how I really became really interested in the Confederate Constitution, which is somewhat understudied and really interesting. It's definitely understudied. And it is it is genuinely fascinating. But I became really interested in how the 14th amendment, which 14th amendment establishes birthright citizenship and guarantees the equal protection of the laws to all persons. And the thing that we forget, I don't know, I forgot that the 14th amendment does is also bar people who have been involved in an insurrection against the Constitution from holding federal office. Former federal officeholders.
Does it bar them? Anyone who's waged insurrection or anyone who had sworn an oath to the Constitution?