Good evening, everyone. If you are just coming in now, please join us and take a seat. If there are none further back, please feel free to come on up. There are a few here at the sides in the front.
Good evening, everyone, and a very warm welcome to you all. A special welcome to our sponsors at Aegon, whose generous and long-standing support makes evenings like this one possible. Also to our private donors, thank you for your belief in our mission, and to the Arbeiderspers and the American Book Center for bringing books into the room, and above all, to you, our audience, for joining us in such great numbers tonight.
My name is Ian Kenny, and I have the pleasure of serving as the fifth executive director of the John Adams Institute. In a year when so much feels uncertain, it's genuinely meaningful to stand here together in community and in the shared belief that the pursuit of ideas and inquiry itself is not a feeble act. Ideas have power to inform, to challenge, and to inspire, and to help us make sense of the world that we collectively inhabit. So, on behalf of our small but dedicated team and board at the John Adams Institute, thank you all for being here tonight.
250 years ago, a rough-and-tumble collection of colonies on the western edge of the Atlantic set out on a radical experiment. Tired of distant powers and arbitrary rule, they imagined something new: a society grounded in self-government, in liberty, and in the audacious idea that ordinary people might shape their own destiny. The rest, as they say, is history, and not a simple one. From the Declaration of Independence to Gettysburg, from Selma to the beaches of Normandy, what began as a rebellion became a nation whose influence stretches far beyond its own shores. Never perfect, always contested, and permanently under construction.
As the United States approaches its 250th anniversary, the temptation is either to celebrate uncritically or to despair. But at the John Adams Institute, we try to resist both. Instead, we look at the many different Americas that have existed across time: the conflicts, the contradictions, the unfinished struggles, because they illuminate not only the past, but the choices facing us in the present. And for Europeans, this is never only an abstract story. Our economies, security, technologies, and political cultures remain deeply entangled with the United States.
At a moment when the transatlantic relationship feels strained, when democratic norms feel fragile, and when our assumptions about stability are being tested, it becomes even more important to slow down, to think historically, and to look carefully rather than reactively. I often think of the Atlantic, not simply as a stretch of water, but as both a window and a mirror. We look across it to understand another society, sometimes with admiration, sometimes with concern. But in doing so, we also see our own values reflected back at us: our vulnerabilities, our own responsibilities. Engaging seriously with America is therefore also a way of engaging more honestly with ourselves.
That is the spirit in which we are marking this anniversary year here at the John Adams Institute. Throughout the year, we will bring some of today's most consequential American thinkers to the Netherlands. Not to provide you with easy answers, but to deepen understanding, encourage dialogue, and to connect ideas across borders and generations. And it is therefore a privilege to open this year with none other than Dr. Jill Lepore, David Woods Kemper Professor of American History at Harvard University, returning tonight to the John Adams stage for the third time.
Across her career and across media, from books and essays to podcasts and public lectures like the one we're about to witness tonight, Dr. Lepore has shown an extraordinary ability to connect the past to the present without flattening either. Her work brings overlooked voices into the historical record and insists that history is not merely something that we inherit, but something we actively interpret, contest, and reshape. Her landmark book, These Truths, and her most recent work, We the People, offer precisely the kind of wide-angle lens, and yet morally serious as well, that this anniversary moment demands.
Jill is to me at the least one of our guiding lights. Someone with the chutzpah for questioning comforting narratives, the patience to grapple with complexity, and the conviction that historical understanding should serve the public good. Tonight we've asked Dr. Lepore to deliver a State of the Union address through the lens of We the People and her other work, examining where the United States finds itself at this pivotal juncture, and what its constitutional story can teach us about democracy, power, imagination, and responsibility. She reminds us that the American experiment has always required renewal.
In her keynote and in conversation with NRC journalist Bas Blokker, she will explore the Constitution not as a sacred relic, but as a living document shaped by generations of citizens who expand the meaning of rights, belonging, and democratic possibility. At a time when American democracy faces deep pressures from inequality and technological power to polarization and institutional strain, these questions could not be timelier. What does it mean to live up to revolutionary ideals? How resilient is an 18th-century framework in a 21st-century world? And what responsibilities fall to the next generation of citizens?
A brief practical note before we go further. Throughout the event, you are welcome to submit questions via the QR code and session ID above me. After Dr. Lepore's keynote and her conversation with Bas Blokker, we will turn to your questions gathered by my colleague Shawn Coulson-Lennon, and I will then briefly return to share a preview of our upcoming program before we continue the conversation with book sales, signing, and a reception. Dear members, sponsors, and honored guests, please join me in welcoming Dr. Jill Lepore as she opens our year-long program marking 250 years of the American experiment.
Good evening. It's really so wonderful to be here, and thank you all for coming out on this slightly moody night for this slightly moody topic. I really want to thank the John Adams Institute for the invitation. It's a real honor to be here with all of you. I think really to struggle over the state of the American Union rather than for me to pontificate about it. And so I'm grateful to Ian for the lovely introduction, which I think kind of captures some of the spirit of honestly of moral anguish with which I and my fellow citizens confront this moment in history that feels like a remarkably historical time. I really long for a time that didn't feel so historical.
So, you know, the State of the Union is the name of a presidential address given every year that is an institution in the United States that has decayed. The president appears before a joint session of Congress and offers a speech which used to be something you'd watch on TV and it would be a bit of a snooze. And the day's paper would come in the morning and you'd forget about what that State of the Union was about. Even our State of the Union addresses in the United States today are matters of tumult, heckling, pushing and shoving, general kind of mayhem within the halls of Congress. So I have no address to offer you, but I wanted to just begin with a series of reflections and then I'm really looking forward, of course, to the conversation.
It feels like a historical time for many, many reasons. It just also happens to be the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States. We celebrate this July 4th the Declaration of Independence, which remains, I think, a soaringly beautiful piece of prose for all of its blemishes and inadequacies. It does declare these truths that we hold, we Americans hold to be self-evident: that all men are created equal, that we are endowed by our creator with certain inalienable rights. Among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That governments are instituted among men to promote their safety and happiness. And when governments betray those goals, they can be altered or indeed even abolished.
I think of this sentiment among the sentiments of the Declaration of Independence as the idea of a right to revolution, but I think more often forgotten is the notion of what I think of as the philosophy of amendment. The idea that was so pivotal and crucial and revolutionary in the 18th century that things can get better. That we as ordinary people have the capacity within ourselves to determine our own fates, to decide how we will live together, to determine the means by which we will govern ourselves. And if our governments fail to promote our safety and happiness, that we can improve our governments by amendment, by revision, by peaceful means. Amendment was invented in the United States in the state constitutions that were first written in 1776.
If you were going to write down a constitution, the idea was you had to have a way to change it, or else it would become too brittle. And I think that philosophy of amendment is something that has very much been forgotten in the United States and something I really cherish and hope that this anniversary year can be an occasion for remembering.
Honestly, it's weird to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the country. These birthdays are just weird, right? Like, why? What is it about 250? So, I actually spent a lot of time recently going back and trying to understand how Americans got so much in the habit. You know, as colonists, they used to celebrate the king's birthday. So, I think they like the idea of these parties, but of course, on the 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, July 4th, 1826, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson, who had really together written the Declaration of Independence, died on the same day, within hours of one another, thousands of miles apart, but knowing that they were each on their deathbed. And this moment really etched the notion of a 50th anniversary into the kind of bones of the United States, so that 50th anniversaries of the signing of the Declaration of Independence became really mandated almost kind of in honor of the just really spooky coincidence of Jefferson and Adams dying on July 4th, 1826.
But 1826 was also, as the 50th anniversary, a really crucial turning point. And in a way, you can use each of these 50th anniversaries as a kind of yardstick for whether the United States has lived up to the best ideals of its founding or whether it has betrayed those ideals. One of the really interesting things that happened in that Jubilee year is that black abolitionists in the north began insisting that the Declaration of Independence, 'All men are created equal, endowed by their creator with liberty,' meant that slavery was unconstitutional.
Americans often conflate the Constitution, which was written in 1787, with the Declaration of Independence, which was written in 1776. But in a way, the reason they do that is because abolitionists knew they really needed to import the Declaration of Independence into the Constitution in order to defeat slavery. And that really sort of big intellectual and political maneuver began in 1826.
If you jump ahead to 1876, the centennial anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, falling after the Civil War, there was a huge world's fair in Philadelphia that was a celebration of the Industrial Revolution. The big thing everybody wanted to see was the Hall of Machinery, which had these giant steam engines and row upon row of typewriters. People complained that there were too many typewriters in the Hall of Machinery. But it was a really sort of a celebration of American economic prowess, aided by mechanization, and increasingly America's growing role on the world stage.
But that 1876 celebration also did something that the abolitionist Frederick Douglass anticipated that it would do. It really erased the story of slavery from the story of American history because in 1876 the North and the South, whites in the North and the South pretty much agreed to abandon a multi-racial democracy that had been the promise of the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments to the US Constitution that ended slavery, guaranteed equal rights regardless of race, granted the right to vote to black men. All of those Reconstruction Amendments were abandoned in 1876. So, that year also becomes a turning point with regard to kind of betraying the ideals of the Revolution and the Amendments that came about in the aftermath of the US Civil War.
If you jump ahead to 1926, the 150th anniversary, this one was kind of a real disaster because it was technically the Sesquicentennial. And the branding people are like, 'Let's call it the Sesqui with like an exclamation point.' And you try to imagine people getting really excited about the Sesqui. And you'll get a sense of why 1926 was not a big success as a celebration of America. Also, the KKK managed to get permission to hold a Klan convocation in Philadelphia on the anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. Black activists protested, Jewish organizations protested, and that permission was denied. But instead, the Klan held a massive march in Washington, D.C.
So, for kind of using these 50-year eras as ways to check in on American history and the struggle between ideals and the betrayal of the ideals of equality, independence, and freedom, you can see at every one of these 50th anniversaries just how much tension there remains between the idea of the United States as a liberal nation-state and America as an illiberal blood and soil nation. That has been the through line of American history. It's a constant struggle and contest. And it was the case as well in 1976, the bicentennial, which was celebrated but also mourned across the United States.
The bicentennial took place in the aftermath of Watergate and Vietnam, the Pentagon Papers, President Ford's pardoning of Richard Nixon. The entire bicentennial, which began really in 1971, was protested by civil rights organizations, by an emerging gay rights movement in the United States, by women's rights activists who were seeking the Equal Rights Amendment, which they were unable to secure, by Native American nations who were protesting very visibly the history of the United States.
So, the bicentennial was just very visibly a kind of rowdy contest over whose America is it, who are Americans, what does American history mean, what counts as American history. But in a way, it had this kind of beautiful unruliness. The official presidential Bicentennial Commission was countered by a people's Bicentennial Commission that held its own counter protests over everything. But the Bicentennial, looking back on it, I think actually managed that contest over the different accounts of American history, the different visions of the country that different groups of Americans had, because it sort of embraced all of them, brought them all out, and you could go to any Bicentennial event, and you were sure to see people dressed up in red, white, and blue saying love it or leave it, this is the best country in the world, but you were sure to see counter protesters, all of whom with rare exception protested peacefully and were not attacked in any way for protesting the vision that the official Bicentennial promoted.
So, I think it is really useful to think about then this moment, the 250th anniversary, as another kind of yardstick. Like, where are we in the United States today? And I will just confess, I do not know. I have never felt so much in a foreign country as I feel in my native country today. And I think I speak for millions, tens of millions of Americans when I say that. As a yardstick, this feels like an especially inauspicious moment to measure the success of the American experiment. And I don't need to offer the litany of what political scientists will call democratic backsliding, but what I think we can honestly call the rise of a new Gestapo in the land of the free. We can think about, we can chronicle the decay of the separation of powers, the abandonment of the rule of law, the US's declining, fast declining, plummeting role on the world stage, the betrayal of NATO, the betrayal of our allies, the appetite for blood and conquest and annexation.
I think we're really looking at a moment where constitutionalism itself is in real jeopardy in the United States. And I say all these things as a person who is really dispositionally never an alarmist. So it would be easy if you don't know me or my work to think here comes another American complaining about all this. These are things I don't usually say. But they need now to be said because I think they're all undeniable.
I just want to make one more point because I think it's easy to focus on what's going on. It is of course essential to focus on what's going on day to day. It's dizzying to attempt to do so, but I think we risk missing some deeper structural changes that are deliberately made invisible to us. And here I'm talking about what I think of as the replacement of the liberal nation-state with what I call the artificial state. I have a new book coming out next year on the rise and fall of the artificial state. And what I mean by that is that public discourse, not just in the United States, but of course here and around the world, is largely controlled by privately owned corporations that own everything that you say in the public square.
And largely determine what you know about what is going on in the public square. The three richest people on the planet own the three biggest platforms for public discourse, which is not free public discourse any longer. It is determined and run by machines that are programmed by people who are interested only in commodifying your ideas. Humans have become much like factory farmed animals under the realm of the artificial state in which corporations, international corporations, whose leaders believe that it is essential that they have powers beyond the boundaries of the nation-state, that they have essentially planetary powers to determine the fate of humankind.
These are people who have no interest in the consent of the governed, human rights, a capacity of people to determine the fate of their own lives, to participate in government in any way. And our complicity in the replacement of the liberal nation-state with the artificial state, with government by machine in which drones have replaced the demos, is something we all, I think, really need to examine. Because the machines that we are building are not encompassed by the rule of law, the written constitutions of the 18th and 19th century that brought democracy around the world.
They were not imagined in the age of those constitutions, they are not encompassed by it, nor is the natural world. And I think these are the two great challenges of our time, and really in the United States of this moment. Our first constitutions, our state constitutions, are 250 years old this year. So I think this year, this anniversary, is in fact an incredibly powerful occasion for people in the United States, but certainly around the world as well. And this is being done far more thoughtfully, more earnestly, and more importantly in Europe than anywhere else. But in the United States, for us to catch up and be involved in a conversation, a set of constitutional deliberations about whether we want to rule ourselves, or whether we prefer to be ruled by machines owned by corporations.
So I really want to celebrate and think about ways to mark this 250th anniversary, not as a moment to look backward, which I think is exhausting, but instead as a moment to look forward, not to a future on Mars, but to a future here together as humans living in a natural world that we are the stewards and the caretakers of. Thank you.
Hi. Hello everybody. If I'm recovering from a cold, so if you hear any weird squeaks, that's just me. Well, we are going to look at the past in spite of what you said. And I know too many interviewers to your liking have asked you to look in the past for earlier examples of the political turmoil the US are in now, and I think you are right to keep those questions at bay and to resist being an oracular guide. I think that's the word. They are really questions about the future, right? People want to know what's ahead of us in these times, and then they turn to you. Do you feel it like that?
I do. I mean we've spoken a little bit about this. It's become a maybe in the last 20 years, it's kind of a tick of journalists to ask historians, is this unprecedented? And I find it to be a dead end of a question in that there's a lot more to historical knowledge and historical thinking than trying to kind of navigate by the stars of the past, you know. And so I think the question, I just bristle at it a bit because it asks us to collapse the distance between the past and the present.
I would forever try to sort of explain this to journalists, and then you just seem like a pedant, you know? No one wants to hear your question is not a helpful one. But, you know, there's just a false analogy and the compression of time I think is a quite dangerous thing. Like when Obama was elected, everybody wanted to compare him to FDR. And you know, there was like a Time magazine cover about the new New Deal. And I just thought how unhelpful that was. Like it just doesn't tell me anything about Obama, and it's a weird misrepresentation of what Roosevelt was and what Roosevelt's legacy is. So, I just get frustrated with it. And because it's a question journalists always ask, I always answer it.
But I wrote a piece this fall in the New Yorker in which I just said, 'I'm done answering that question. Like, I'm done.' Because there is very little that Donald Trump has done that has a precedent in American history. All of it has precedents in the history of other countries. And I, you know, so I say to journalists all the time, 'Talk to a historian of another country because our country hasn't done these things yet.' You know, you could find like a bit of this or a bit of that. Like, 'Oh, this is like the Palmer Raids, and that's like the Alien and Sedition Act, and this looks like Japanese internment, and this looks like when, you know, FDR did 100 executive orders in 100 days.' But that just really distorts the extraordinary, extravagant lawlessness and ruthlessness of this administration. So, I'm sorry, that's a long answer to your question, but like just trying to lay out why I think it's dangerous to just kind of be, 'Oh, yes, it was a little bit like in the depression when we were eating our shoes.' It's not.
We were all living in a shoe box, yeah. Still, there is a sense of the past informing our future, I think. In your last beautiful sentence of this book, We the People, when you say that from the burning scorched earth, new ideas might arise once more, seedlings sprouting, tendrils winding to the sun. There is some hope there, right?
Yeah, maybe that now that you read that, it comes across a little forced.
You know, you always have to end with a little bit of hope. I listened to this podcast once about the filmmaker Steven Soderbergh, and he had a rule for when you go to a pitch meeting, I guess, for all of his writers who would go into pitch meetings, and he said, 'You just whatever, you have to tell them what your movie's going to be about or your TV pilot or whatever, and then you always have to say before you walk out the door, in the end, it's a story about hope.' And it'll always win, and you'll get the contract, you know.
So this was from the pitch meeting?
It was a little bit, I think that sounds a little forced.
But it's just a beautiful sentence, and it could be right, right? You never know. Okay, let's get to the past. Can you take us back to the time before the US Constitution was written? In every state, you just mentioned it, since the beginning of the war of independence, they started writing down ideas because they had to be ruled by a law, a constitution. And where did these men, they were all men, get their ideas, and why did they get more or less the same ideas all at the same time?
Yeah, that's thanks to John Adams. So, um...
I knew we could sneak him in.
Yeah, you can sneak him in to most things. I'm a John Adams hater, so I'm sorry. We've established that.
So, here's what happened. The Americans were like, 'We don't want to pay your stinking taxes.' And the British were like, 'You're going to pay these taxes.' And then the Americans were like, 'No, we're not.' And so the British sent their army. And then the Americans were like, 'Okay, but we have guns, too.' And then they started shooting each other. And at that point, all the colonies had no governments overnight because most of them had royally appointed governors. And the governors were like, 'Honey, this would be a good time for us to return to London.' And they all just got on boats and left. Like, really, there was no government.
And meanwhile, so the only real government was Congress because in 1774, the states, they weren't states yet, but the colonies decided they'd send delegates to Philadelphia to figure out how to negotiate basically a peace with England. But then Adams was like, and by 1775, 'Okay, but these colonies need governments. Like, we have to be able to raise money and have taxes, whatever. We need governments.' And so he started writing what becomes this pamphlet called Thoughts on Government.
Adams had been studying ancient history and political philosophy and what we would call political science since his boyhood and thinking about what a constitution in fact is. He was a brilliant constitutional theorist. So, he was just ready. So, he wrote this pamphlet. It was like, 'Okay, now that we're edging toward becoming independent, even if we don't declare independence, we still need state governments. You should all write constitutions, and here's what they should look like. They should have three branches of government. The branches should be separate. Their power should be separate. They should have checks on one another. We want to have, you know, wide suffrage, but not universal suffrage.' He's just like a program, like a template. And he published it in early 1776.
So, the first state constitution was New Hampshire in January 1776. And basically, Adams is just writing out handwritten copies of this treatise and sending it to everybody in every state saying, 'Use this version.' And some of them are using versions of Adams' constitution, and some are not. They have their own peculiarities. So, in fact, they don't write the Declaration of Independence until June, but all that spring, all the states are writing state constitutions.
And in doing so, the states declare independence first, and they also declare rights. They make these lists of what they believe to be their fundamental rights that the constitution is going to protect. So, by the time you get to June of 1776, when Adams and Jefferson are appointed onto the committee with Benjamin Franklin and Roger Sherman to write the Declaration of Independence, they have all been writing state constitutions. Jefferson was really mad that he was asked to write the Declaration of Independence because he wanted to go back to Virginia because he wanted to write the Virginia constitution, which he thought was way more important. And he kept sending drafts back, and they're like, 'Dude, we've got this. Like, leave us alone.'
Yeah, so there's not uniformity to the state constitutions. They're all experiments, and then a lot of them don't last more than a few months. Like, it's like France all of a sudden. So, I'm glad someone got my joke about France. Mhm. You know, they're writing and rewriting and rewriting them, and each one is a new experiment in, well, how do we set up a government? What needs to be in the Constitution and what doesn't? So, by the time you get to 1787 and the Constitutional Convention for all of the states, there's just a whole world of ideas that have been going.
You know, Pennsylvania's like, we don't really need a governor because that's like having a king. We'll just have a legislature. And then we don't really want the legislature to have much power, so they come up with this fun idea, which is anytime anyone wants to pass a law, it has to be posted in every tavern in the state for a year. And only then can the legislature vote on it. So, Pennsylvania descends into chaos. But like, they're just all different experiments in what would be fair and just.
But is there a focal point in all of them?
The declarations of rights, I think, are fairly uniform. A preference for a single executive, although there's some states that have a multiple executive. Many of them have elected judges. One of the big complaints of the colonists was the appointed judges that the king appointed. Frequent and regular elections. Most of them, but not all, have two branches of a legislature.
Yeah. So, many of their thoughts about this reflected the battle they had raged against the British, right? The elected electors, for instance.
Yeah. So, a lot of them involve those grievances. And this is not a slight thing, but in the north almost all of them abolish slavery. New York does this weird gradual abolition.
This is a big problem at the Constitutional Convention.
Right, this is why the framers make such a terrible compromise over slavery because by 1787 slavery is illegal in the north. And yet it has become increasingly economically important in the south.
Yeah. So I ask you to take us back in time because I think that's what you so beautifully can as a writer. You have this elegant and vivid way to evoke the past. I don't remember who it was, but I think you once described a historic figure in These Truths like having a face of a frog.
Do you know who, remember who it was? No, okay. Okay. Well, so...
There's so many candidates.
So you convey emotions of the past into your readers' head and I think that's very, very beautiful. I really loved reading Benjamin Franklin's writing. 'Few express it so naturally as a certain French lady who in a little dispute with her sister said, I don't know how it happens, sister, but I meet with nobody but myself that's always in the right.' So he's very funny. So I heard an interviewer call that your secret sauce. And I was just wondering who learned you to cook like this. Who influenced you as historians?
Oh. So my dirty little secret is I never wanted to be a historian. And I don't have any degrees in history. That's another, those are two secrets. I only ever wanted to be a writer. And I'm very interested in the relationship between the past and the present, but in the way that I think, you know, every novelist is, right? Like I think we as humans are interested in how do we get here? What the heck happened? And so history was a way to do that. But my inspirations were all poets and writers of fiction. Not that there aren't wonderful historians, and I could, you know, list historians I deeply admire, but I don't... People sometimes say that I don't write like a historian, and I say that's because I'm kind of not one.
But you write like some historians maybe, like Robert Darnton for instance, and the micro historians that you turned out to be, like Natalie Zemon Davis. Those were all people who were very influential in the 1980s when you...
So you didn't get your grade, but you attended college.
Yes. Yes. No, Natalie Zemon Davis is, you know, one of my great heroes.
She wrote The Return of Martin Guerre. That's also a micro history, right? So, what's the advantage of a micro history? It's looking through a very small lens.
Yeah, so what I do, I don't, I mean, I think that term has kind of fallen out in any case, but how I think about what I do is, so, in These Truths, for instance, the book has a lot of years to cover and a lot of big ideas to acquaint the reader with. And my experience is that there's a certain reader who wants to read an intellectual history where you're just watching the play of ideas, and they float around in the ether, and you see them do battle with one another. But, I think that's a somewhat rare reader.
And so, what I do is I find a person who had those ideas, whose life was shaped by those ideas, whose life illustrates those ideas. And then I offer what will appear to be, 'Oh, here's a little story about an obscure person.' So, for instance, when I had to write about 19th century populism, which was left-wing populism and was an alliance of wage workers, urban wage workers, and farmers, who objected to the growing power of corporations, especially railroads, but also the growing power of the federal government, which was taking land by eminent domain for the railroads and then granting those corporations that owned the railroads vast resources.
There's a lot of big ideas in populism, but my discussion of populism is almost entirely through this woman Mary E. Lease, who was a Kansas farmer, who's, I don't know, she was like 7 ft tall. She had 16 children or something. She lived in a mud hut and she taught herself to read by the walls of her hut with which she was raising all of her children, she glued newspapers to them for insulation, but that's how she taught herself to read. And she was known as the tornado because when she went out to speak, she was just a killer orator. Like she just would get up there and she would thunder. She would bring that, like the walls would shake. She could just stir up a crowd and she was so mad about the way she was forced to live like an animal in a world where corporations that ran these railroads that were bribing federal government officials were making it impossible for her to feed her family.
She is a very memorable character. She's also not really a good person. She has this truly evil side and it's excellent. She's also a great villain. She's super, like you'd love to read a novel about her. So I spend a lot of time and people say, 'Well, why do you write this micro history of Mary Lease?' And I would say, like, do you now understand populism? Like, that's the point, right? It's not like, oh this is a cute story. It's this is a person whose life was lived in such rich dimension and color and vivacity and fury and sorrow and grief and rawness and dirt and misery that you can actually experience what it is to be attracted to that set of ideas.
That brought her from Kansas. She became like a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist in New York at some point. Like she's this larger than life character. She's also entirely forgotten. And so it's a delight and an honor to reacquaint readers or to acquaint readers with people they, like, you should know about Mary Lease. She was a badass. You know, like I love doing that. But if you want to read a disquisition on populism, you can go read Richard Hofstadter and that's fine.
Good for you. Okay, so from the mud of Kansas we go to the National Archives in Washington, D.C., in all the marble in the rotunda. There lie the three charters of the American Republic, the Declaration of Independence, Constitution, and Bill of Rights. And I visited there a couple of times and I was always amazed by how in awe all these people were, as if they were looking at the Ark of the Covenant and the Moses tablets in it. And I was thinking about that when I read one of the final sentences of your book, like a butterfly on the glass, tacked down with pins, in danger of wilting. It seems like that, right? That the Constitution is like frozen in something that fossilized it.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, in fact, in this We the People book, I talk a lot about the actual physical Constitution and what happened to it, because it was not always in a shrine. Like, it's put in a shrine in the Cold War. It's this very specific political project that that national shrine is built. It's not displayed to the public until 1924. And that is a kind of the height of American conservatism, the birth of constitutional conservatism. Like, how we treat the physical object is a pretty good index of the rise and fall of a cult of constitutional worship, which is always a conservative political and jurisprudential project, right?
And which is not to say, like, while I celebrate the language of the Declaration of Independence, not a lot of Americans would maybe do that, certainly not a lot of American intellectuals in this moment, but I think it's worth celebrating. It's not worth venerating, because if you venerate it, you've actually betrayed it. The whole point is it's yours to fix. Like, it's an obligation if you believe in the ideas in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, it actually falls to you to honor those ideas and to seek constitutional change if the Constitution is not working right anymore.
So, I would never want to be like mocking people that really have a kind of religious devotion, because I think that for many people, you know, there's a great history of the Declaration of Independence called American Scripture. I think that for a lot of people it maps onto their religious beliefs, especially for fundamentalist Christians. And I have entire respect for that. That's not the tradition in which these documents were written.
And we need to be able to engage in like a free and open discussion of them without people accusing other people of heresy, right? So, that's the reason why you shouldn't treat civil documents as scripture, because it takes us into a terrain where political disagreement...
It's considered blasphemy.
Exactly. I remember very well how an American relative of my wife said to us, 'Well, you know, in Europe constitutions are written by people. Our...' And she's a teacher there. She looks like a normal person.
What's funny is that all the framers of the Constitution said the worst thing that would ever happen would have people actually think that we were gods. And they treat, you know, Jefferson said if we would treat this thing like the Ark of the Covenant, you know, that's the end of the republic. I was once at a dinner party in Canada and some guy that I was sitting next to who was kind of drunk and miserable, I mean, miserable to me. I found him miserable. I don't think he was having a good time. He was like, 'You guys are such idiots for like worshiping your, the guys who wrote your Constitution. Like, I was one of the guys that wrote our Constitution and I tell you we were just drinking.'
He was like, 'I think it would be really good if you guys could be reacquainted with the humanity of those guys.' And I was like, 'Dude, John Adams was one of those guys. So, I know.' Yeah. No, it is a problem.
Well, the central argument in your book obviously is that they were writing a man-made constitution and bound to meet unforeseen challenges in the future, their future. And so, they provided for a way to change the constitution of their country peacefully, the amendment. Why do you think they did that?
I think that they knew it's not that written constitutions were unheard of. There had been some written constitutions and certainly in American history, the colonies had written charters that were constitutional, or in England they thought of the Magna Carta as their ancient constitution. So, the word had been used to apply to written documents, but certainly not exclusively. In England, the constitution remains unwritten and the notion of a constitution as an unwritten thing was far more prevalent than the idea that it was a written thing.
So, when they were doing this, they decided, you know, Thomas Paine famously says, 'Hey, this is brilliant. If you can write it down, then when the king, you know, when your government is abusing it, you can pull it out of your pocket and say, It says right here you can't do this.' And so, it was really a huge commitment to transparency or what they would have called publicity to write it down and also print it, make it available. People could read it. You could hold people accountable to you. These are my rights, they're on my bill of rights, these are your powers, and you have no more powers than these. That was really important, but they also knew that presented a huge problem because as Madison said, 'If the thing lasts, a problem will be things that are old tend to be venerated, and veneration will kill the republic.'
So, they knew that was a problem, and they also thought the longer it lasted, the less likely people would be willing to amend it. And that if they couldn't amend it, the only way to change something fundamental about the government would be by revolution. And these people had just lived through, you know, years and years of a bloody revolutionary war. They did not want to have more revolution. So, the amendment provision, which had already been tried in the states, was a way to say if you write it down, you have to have a peaceful way to fix it. And it can't be the president who fixes it, and it can't be Congress, and it can't be the Supreme Court. It has to be the people. It was a great idea. It didn't really work.
No, because there were no political parties at the time. And so, when they figured out like what is the voting requirement, what are the, you know, it's a double supermajority requirement. For the US Constitution to be amended, an amendment has to pass a 2/3 vote of both houses of Congress, and then 3/4 of the states have to approve it. And this is, well, at the moment impossible, and for most of American history has been impossible because of our party system. And they came up with that math before there were political parties.
Yes, and they came upon that math because they did want to make amendments possible. But was it also because they wanted to have to reconcile the differences between the states that were signatories?
Yeah, I mean they also, in a way the amendment mechanism contains within it the worst compromises of the Constitutional Convention. So, there are two things that lie beyond amendment in the original Constitution. One is you're not allowed to abolish the slave trade for 20 years by constitutional amendment. And that was a concession to the south. The south was like, 'We don't want your stupid amendment provision because we know these northerners just going to try to end slavery.'
And they already had plenty of political power because of the 3/5 clause, which meant that people who were enslaved in the southern states were counted as people for purposes of political representation even though they had no representation, but which meant that the slave states had tons of political power. So, they knew they could defeat most amendments anyway, but they still were like, 'We're going to say right here you can't end the slave trade by constitutional amendment.' And then the small states like Rhode Island and Delaware were like, 'Well, if the slave states get something, we get something. And what we get is you can never end equal suffrage in the Senate by constitutional amendment unless every state agrees.'
So, a huge deformity of American politics is that every state has two members of the Senate no matter the population of the state. Something that James Madison hugely opposed, greatly regretted, has been terrible for the republic. But it was a concession that was necessary or that the framers considered to be necessary for the small states to not walk.
Yeah. And yet Rhode Island, it was...
Just, I think, a two-point, a two-vote difference for the ratification, right?
Yeah, ratification was really close in many... It was so close in many states. Yeah.
It always amazes me because they had almost the same constitutions themselves. What were they opposing?
They were opposing the power of the federal government that had not existed. I'll tell you a story.
Um, we mainly live in Vermont, and in Vermont, this is for Ian because this is a story about maple syrup. Ian's from Canada. So, Vermont famously has better maple syrup than any place in Canada. This is a known fact.
So, kind of, it's almost, I got to get back because we're about to tap the trees, and then you boil the sap, right? And so, you sit in the sugar house and it's like 12 hours a day of just boiling many, many gallons of sap. And so, you can't really do anything because you have to constantly feed the evaporator, put firewood in, and you have to constantly be pouring new sap in and observing the boiling temperature. We can't burn the sap, can't burn the syrup. Anyway, it's like being in a sweat lodge, maybe? Like usually it's a little just weird.
So, one year I was by myself boiling and it was tons of snow. It's maybe 4 ft of snow. You could barely leave the building, and I brought my dogs out and I brought an audiobook of Pauline Maier's book Ratification, which was about the battle over ratifying the Constitution. So, I'm in the middle of nowhere, alone, with a fire and some dogs.
And I'm reading this book, and as the hours tick by and the sugar house fills with steam and smoke, I become angrier and angrier at the existence of the federal government.
And by the end of the 12 hours, I was like, 'Tim, I would never have voted for this stupid thing. I'm fine up here in Vermont. I have my land, I have my animals, I got my sheep. I don't need any of this. This is crazy. Why would I cede all this authority? We're fine in Vermont. Like, these are just merchants. These are these wealthy lawyers. They want to like have armies and taxes. We don't need any of this. What did we fight the revolution for?' Like, I actually, like, it was a little stra— like, it was like a bit of a mental episode.
Because the next day I was like, I think the Constitution's really important. We need a federal government. The country gets to... But like in that moment I became an anti-federalist. Like I just got it. Like the sensibility of the far from the center of power ordinary American, which like, you know, was the EU's fine. Why would we need... Why would we need to have like... That's what they wanted. Those people. They wanted to like the EU. That's enough.
So it's... And that's a streak that goes all through American history, right? Right until this time.
Only now it's much more like a right-wing...
Well, now the problem is these people who are in power now came to power saying that the federal government shouldn't have so much power. Then once they got to power... [laughter] Well, you know how the story goes.
Um, well, one of the objections, apart from state law of state rights versus federal rights, obviously is what you raised in a chapter called All Men Would Be Tyrants. Who are the people in the preamble's first three words, We the People? And you quote Abigail Adams, the wife of your much-hated and our name-giver, John Adams. And she... She writes... Can I please quote it because it's such a beautiful... in a letter of 1776.
She says, 'By the way, in the new code of laws, which I suppose it will be necessary for you to make, I desire you would remember the ladies and be more generous and favorable to them than your ancestors. Do not put such unlimited power into the hands of the husbands. Remember, all men would be tyrants if they could.' Oh my, was she right.
Yeah, I mean, what Abigail Adams is pointing out is that she's just emphasizing the basic political principle on which the revolution was waged, right? That you need to have restraints on government because humans are terrible and there need to be restraints. Like, given the opportunity to seize power, people will become tyrannical. So, there need to be limits placed on that power, and those limits in our system of laws take the form of constitutions.
And she knew this was exactly when John Adams was writing his Thoughts on Government, the little template that he was going to send to everybody in all the states to say, 'Here's what your constitution should look like.' She wasn't... This wasn't like a flighty remark, which is often presented, they think, when people like perform this exchange. She was dead serious. She was... She was a very learned person. She's like, 'Okay, look, you're doing this. So, what you actually, you have to remember... [snorts] ...all men includes husbands.'
And he just laughed and laughed. He writes back a very dismissive letter. But, what... And I, you know, everyone, this is a famous exchange in American letters, but I hadn't really quite realized how pissed off she was when he... he says, 'I cannot but laugh.' She's like, you know, he writes back and he says, 'What do you think? Like, blacks should have the vote one day? Children of lads of 21 should be allowed to vote?' Like, he's like, 'The next thing you know, servants will have a right to vote.' Like he just... And she's like, 'Well, yeah.' But...
So, he brushes her off in this very dismissive way. But, she then writes to her friend Mercy Otis Warren, who was a famous playwright and who becomes a very important historian, and says, 'I think we need to submit a petition to Congress because John's basically ignoring me.' And I think they probably did submit such a petition because there's actually... It's not just this letter from Abigail Adams. There's quite a lot of evidence. Certainly not the overwhelming population of women, but many, many women were really shocked that the Constitution...
ignored them. And women are really not persons under the original Constitution. And I think there's quite a groundswell of sentiment about that. And there's some considerable evidence, I think. Well, not considerable. There are hints that petitions sent by women to Congress and to state legislatures were just routinely trashed.
They really... So, yeah, because I remember that you wrote about Jane Franklin, too, right? Asking her brother basically the same thing. So, who's more product of their time, more exemplary of their time? The men dismissing all this or the women demanding this?
I think they both are. Yeah, I mean, it's just that the men win and they also kind of control what evidence survives to tell us what that was all about.
Mhm. And the same goes, of course, for black men and women. They had to wait a very long time for their right to vote. And as you just mentioned, in the reconstruction years, hardly anything came of it.
Yeah, no. And there's... It's just such an incredible body of research on the history of kind of the black struggle to end slavery and for equal rights and the right to vote. And it is the story of American history, right? The other stories kind of all circle around those because that is the fundamental challenge, right? Like when I talked about 1826 and all these black abolitionists reinterpreting the Declaration of Independence. And you know, that's what they do with the Civil War and Reconstruction amendments. They revise the Constitution. That's what the struggle of the long Civil Rights Movement in the 20th century, in the middle decades of the 20th century, is. It's really the spine of the struggle to call on Americans to realize the promise of those founding documents.
And it took two amendments, that 13th and the 19th, to repair this, to amend this. I love, by the way, how you explain what all the meanings are hidden in the amendment. Maybe you can elaborate on that here, too.
Yeah, actually, like the way this book works is because the US has one of the lowest amendment rates in the world and one of the highest levels of difficulty of amendment, we've only ever ratified 27 amendments, one of which was repealing another one, so you can't kind of really count those two. There's just very little amending has ever been done.
I really emphasized in this book. I got a big grant to make a database of every attempt to... every meaningful attempt to amend the US Constitution, and it's tens of thousands of proposals, like 12,000 of which were introduced on the floor of Congress, and many have other lives that... I think in a way I do spend quite a bit of time on the ratified amendments, but the book really is about... Let's... I came across an article years ago where some political philosopher said, you know what would be really interesting would be using the archive of the failed attempts to amend the US Constitution as a history of the will of the American people.
And it does really work that way. Because it's impossible to do it, it doesn't mean that people don't try. And the trying is its own record, and I think it's a kind of... it's an inspiring record, and it's a little bit emancipating to think about these efforts. They're not... I don't agree with most of them, honestly. Like, most ideas are... well, I mean, I don't like that idea, but that people are trying to do that, trying to actually enact the civic obligation that we have in a constitutional system to ask ourselves whether the Constitution is working for the public good anymore. I really spend a lot of time on that. So an example that... [clears throat] ...I would give, because I actually find this fascinating.
People will remember Earth Day in 1970 in response to the moon landing. A Wisconsin senator is like, enough with going to the moon, what about the Earth? So Earth Day was on April 22nd, 1970 in the US. It was the largest single mass protest ever held, and it still goes on, of course, you know, around the world. But among the things that happened with Earth Day was an attempt to amend the US Constitution to include an environmental protection amendment and an environmental rights amendment, the right basically to a healthy environment, which looked like it could well have passed.
That's the era when, under Richard Nixon, who considered himself the environmental president, we got the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, the National Environmental Protection, the Endangered Species Act. It looked like constitutional... The Constitution had only just been amended in 1971. It was the last time. People didn't know that was going to be the last time the Constitution was amended meaningfully, but it turned out to have been. But around the world, a lot of places amended their constitution in the early 1970s and put in environmental rights provisions that turned out to be really important. In the US we never did that.
And now under the second Trump administration, all of that legislation, Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Environmental Protection, Endangered... all that stuff has been completely gutted. It doesn't exist. The Environmental Protection Agency essentially no longer exists. Like, the reason to do a constitutional amendment is because it can't... it's very hard to overturn.
So I think that story of like the missed opportunities, the amendments that didn't pass, I think those are really important parts of American history. Kind of just to render visible, to surface for people. You know, people are like, 'Why do you care about the failed things?' Well, because they still tell us quite a lot.
Yeah, they do. And what was your favorite... What's the saddest amendment that didn't pass?
Oh, all the attempts in the early 19th century to end slavery, largely by way of ending the Electoral College. I mean, in our modern life, sure, for me it would be the environmental protection amendment, but in the larger course of American history, that 4 million people live in human bondage in the world's first modern democracy for all of those decades under a constitutional system of laws, it's just hard to reconcile with any faith in the decency of human beings.
Mhm. Mhm. I actually read in your book that they tried to have an amendment to preserve slavery for all eternity, right?