CEOInterviews.AI
Start App
Get an email when Jill Lepore gives a new interview
One email per new interview. Unsubscribe in one click.
Jill Lepore
Professor of American History and Law; Staff Writer, The New Yorker, Harvard University

Jill Lepore on Why We Should Amend the U.S. Constitution

📅 Dec 09, 2025 Persuasion 77 MIN 993 VIEWS 57 SEGMENTS · 2 SPEAKERS
Jill Lepore is the David Woods Kemper ’41 Professor of American History at Harvard University and professor of law at Harvard Law School. She is also a staff writer at The New Yorker. Her latest book is We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution. In this week’s conversation, Yascha Mounk and Jill Lepore discuss why historians have neglected the story of America, how to fix the toxicity in higher education, and whether we need more constitutional amendments. Please do listen and spread the word about The Good Fight. Podcast production by Mickey Freeland and Leonora Barclay. Email: po...

Questions asked in this interview

12
  1. 0:00You know, is the United States a story of great triumph, a story of building, you know, one of the largest and most successful, most inclusive democracies in human history, or is it the story of marginalization and exclusion and injustice?
  2. 5:00... done is to tell, I think, a rather too simple story of, you know, consisting of an exclusive focus on the atrocities in American history, and in that sense, part of it is simply that it isn't engaging in some of those questions, right?
  3. 15:01So how do we reform the university and how do we fix some of these problems, you know, without falling into that trap?
  4. 19:14So what is the problem of university in your mind?
  5. 26:10Or did he also stop writing history?
  6. 32:17... the academic system, are captured by loyalists to Viktor Orbán, or perhaps, you know, if you're an intellectual who has, or an academic who has certain views disfavored by their colleagues, you know, in the American academy in 2018?
  7. 40:23So how, as a historian, are you thinking about the successes and the limitations of this document?
  8. 43:11is it a statute? What is it?
  9. 49:22Like, if we take that as seriously as a concern as you do, you know, what does that mean about what we should do?
  10. 58:26And so, you know, would you be excited about a constitutional convention in the United States?
  11. 1:03:52Is there a pattern in which it takes a very deep crisis and it takes, to some extent, moving beyond that crisis to have a moment of constitutional renovation?
  12. 1:07:24Or is, you know, the amount of cacophony about this actually what we should expect?
Interviewer 0:00 ↗
Jill, welcome to the podcast. Thanks so much. I'm really looking forward to this conversation. I've been reading you for a long time. I feel like one of the themes of your work and one of the themes of the public debate for the last 10, 20 years has been, you know, trying to figure out how to think about the United States. You know, is the United States a story of great triumph, a story of building, you know, one of the largest and most successful, most inclusive democracies in human history, or is it the story of marginalization and exclusion and injustice? And it seems to me, not to put words in your mouth, but you would kind of answer something like both. Tell us about how you're thinking about this question and how that inflects your historical work.
Jill Lepore 0:48 ↗
Sure. Yeah. I mean, I guess I should maybe begin by saying I certainly never started out as a historian wanting to write this kind of national account, right? Sort of being a national historian or trying to reckon with the question that you pose: how should we think about the United States? That was really never my question. I think it is an urgent public question and one that historians have generally failed to answer or even really to engage with, because of course, like these national history questions tend to be very dangerous, right? They tend to be very self-satisfied and smug, and they, you know, national histories veer very easily into blood and soil nationalism, right? Trying to offer up an account of a nation's origins and its meaning and some sense of its possibility historically is just very closely associated with a kind of defensiveness about the idea of the nation. So American historians in particular, really since the 1960s, scholars of American history have not been principally engaged in asking this question: what is the meaning of the United States? How should we think about the United States and its past? Largely been done politically, and that's what a lot of American politics revolves around, right? So we have a very hyperpolarized political discourse in this country, and to some degree, academic accounts of American history, which have generally been aligned with the left, take the position that American history can be best understood as a kind of a litany of atrocities that have never really been reckoned with fully. And popular history, which is more closely aligned with the right, takes the position that American history is the story of a march of progress and prosperity and freedom, and the United States is a beacon of liberty around the world. And those two accounts of the past, the one popular and the one academic, are not in conversation with one another at all. They are themselves the product of our, in part the product of our hyperpolarized politics. So for me, as a historian interested in groups and conflict and social history and labor history and the history of race relations and women's history and all the other kinds of histories that were largely left out of the kinds of accounts of the American past that I was exposed to, you know, as a kid or even in college, I just came to be really troubled by the public, by the popular account that misses all of that and therefore is just wildly impoverished. And meanwhile, the academic discourse became more and more untethered, I think, to the greatness of the American story and to the genuine promise of the United States' founding ideals. So I would say I'm a quite reluctant historian of the American nation as a project. But in the 2010s, I became really concerned about the gap between these two accounts and started writing more and more about the idea of the United States, and really beginning probably with the Tea Party movement, you know, which began in 2008, 2009 during Barack Obama's election and early presidency, which saw its legitimacy in telling a particular story about the American Revolution that was unrecognizable to me as a historian of the American Revolution. Its account of the American Revolution is bafflingly bizarre. And I did a lot of reporting. I spent a lot of time with people in the Tea Party, and it just kind of convinced me that, wow, we are responsible for this gap. We academic historians are responsible for the gap between what the public thinks about the American past and what scholars know. And so I've been trying to bridge that gap in the work that I have done. I wouldn't say it's my passion as an intellectual. Far from it. It just feels more like my duty as a citizen and as, you know, someone trying to contribute to civil society.
Interviewer 5:00 ↗
Well, well, I'm glad you feel that call of duty and that you are doing and have done that work. I mean, two thoughts on what you've said so far. One is that part of what academic history has often done is to tell, I think, a rather too simple story of, you know, consisting of an exclusive focus on the atrocities in American history, and in that sense, part of it is simply that it isn't engaging in some of those questions, right? I was a graduate student at Harvard where you teach, and I think for a long time there wasn't a course offered in the history department, the American Revolution, for example. So there is simply no real attempt to grapple with some of those big questions in a lot of academic history. I mean, the other thing that comes to mind is a conversation I recently had in this podcast with your colleague Randall Kennedy from in the law school. That what appealed to me about These Truths, your one-volume history of the United States, for example, was that it was a kind of concrete demonstration of a lie that I feel very strongly from both sides of the political spectrum at the moment, and that is that sort of, you know, in order to be patriotic and in order to have pride in America's history, you can't dwell too much on the dark sides to it on one side, and on the other side, that sort of if you want to grapple critically with the role, for example, that race and racial exclusion has played in American history, or with the history that the exclusion of women has played in American history, then really the only way to do that is through a kind of critical race theory lens. The only way to do that is through a lens that really, you know, takes what is actually quite a modern contemporary ideology and sort of superimposes it on, you know, on American history.
Jill Lepore 7:00 ↗
You know, I guess the idea that Harvard didn't teach a, hasn't taught a course on the American Revolution was a kind of right-wing canard for a long time, and it was a, it's just factually not true. There was no course called the American Revolution in the course catalog for a number of years, but my amazing colleague Laurel Thatcher Ulrich taught a huge general education lecture course called The Pursuit of Happiness that was about the founding and about the ideas of the founding, looking at them across the culture and across space and time. My wonderful colleague Vincent Brown taught a kind of comparative revolutions course on slave rebellions in the Caribbean as against the story of the American Revolution. My then colleague Jane Kamensky, who's now the head of Monticello, taught a course on the American Revolution while she was writing her magnificent book about Phyllis Wheatley. I taught a course that I think at some point was just called The American Revolution that was a research course into primary source evidence, accounts of Boston, the American Revolution. It's like none of these, I think it's just they weren't legible in a course catalog way as kind of old school, like first we have the, you know, the founding class, then there's American Revolution, then there's, you know, the industrial revolution, then there's a civil war class, like they didn't look like high school courses. And someone wrote an op-ed in The New York Times complaining that you're like, what are the, who are these idiots at the Harvard history department who don't teach the American Revolution? We're all kind of baffled, like should our course names be more legible? Like what's, what's, what's the problem?
Interviewer 8:39 ↗
I mean, course names in general should be more legible, probably mine as well.
Jill Lepore 8:42 ↗
I think that's fair to me by two Harvard faculty members who were proposing to teach a course about the American Revolution and felt that at the time they were doing that there were no other courses. So I get that. I'm just saying some of your colleagues, it's one of those, it's just one of those things that gets batted around, like who are, you know, that just became a thing online. And I would just point out in the new Ken Burns 12-hour series on the American Revolution, some of the most stunning, I mean, the academic historians who are the talking heads in that series, which is magnificent, are chiefly my colleagues, Phil Deloria, who also covered the American Revolution in his Native American history class, Vincent Brown, Maya Jasanoff, like just it really is stuff that we do teach and think about. So I don't, I don't mean to derail your critique because I, of course, I agree with a lot of the critique as a whole, but I think there's just such a, I kind of tired of being a punching bag around things that make no, like it just makes, that makes no sense.
Interviewer 9:47 ↗
Yeah, I didn't mean to, I, you know, I didn't mean to pick on the Harvard history department of which I have fond memories from when I was a grad student. I was in the government department doing political theory, but I went along to many events in the history department, had colleagues who are PhD students there. But, you know, to name another example from the university where I now teach, Johns Hopkins, there's an initiative to try and make sure that some course that undergraduates take on the way to their, you know, BA degree would need to have a democracy theme. And it could be in one of many different kinds of departments. It could have many different kinds of approaches. Yeah. And there's very strong resistance to this among the faculty. Now part of that is that faculty are always going to be resistant to a university administration trying to impose any of the anything on them, and, you know, so some of this is just normal bureaucratic politics. But I do think that there is a broader concern, which I think we agree, where we're not willing to contest some of those ideas and then they become colonized both by people who have less expertise and by people who might have a rather more simplistic view of this. And to take a completely different example, I've long felt that the ascendancy of Jordan Peterson was in many ways a failure of, you know, more moderate intellectuals, because, you know, he was willing to give very public advice to disoriented young men about how to structure and lead their lives. And, you know, again, I'm sure that there's somebody on the center right and probably even somebody on the center left who was engaged in the same enterprise, but there really was a vacuum that made it easy for somebody like Jordan Peterson to fill it. And so I do think that, you know, in the broader, you know, one way of putting this is that I think there is an instinct towards critique which is trying to tear something down, and that instinct, I think, made sense at a time when a deep understanding and worship for American history was, you know, a really tangible feature of American history, when, you know, every five-year-old would learn by heart the capitals of the American states. And there was this kind of unthinking civic pride. And so there was an understandable attempt to try and tear that down. And I worry that in this moment the sort of basic orientation, not just of history but of political science and of many academic fields, is still to sort of, you know, let's take down this naive image and this naive reverence for things that actually doesn't really exist anymore in society in the way that we presume.
Jill Lepore 12:26 ↗
Well, I think that's fair. And yet it is being required, right? That's what the Trump campaign of patriotic education is, right? Like it's the absence of that that is now mandated by the federal government, right? That, that, that, so I don't, I don't rest as easy about that as maybe you do. But there's absolutely the case that a lot was evacuated from, say, the teaching of American history that Americans really need, that anybody studying in the United States, American or not, really need. So for instance, constitutional history used to be taught in history departments. It isn't anymore. It's not even really taught in law schools. Constitutional law is taught in law schools, which has a historical dimension in which, you know, constitutional law is sort of hopscotched from major Supreme Court decision to major Supreme Court decision, and therefore you come to believe that the Constitution is what the Supreme Court says it is, and there's no other role for any other interlocutors in interpreting or understanding, amending the Constitution. And that's a problem, right? It's a problem the history department stopped teaching constitutional history or stopped teaching electoral political history, right? The kind of the politics that history departments generally taught for some decades was a kind of Foucauldian notion of power rather than how democracies work. So, you know, exactly as you say, there's a kind of compensatory moment now, like, you know what, actually, we do need to be teaching some things about citizenship, and there will be some requirements that history departments, some of the curricula involve explaining the origins of modern democracy. That there is resistance to that. I do, though, frankly, understand because if it were coming from faculty and from students and was emerging from an intellectual commitment and a civic notion with regard to the role of the university, that would be great. But what it often feels like at some of these institutions is capitulation to an increasingly interfering federal government that is dictating what must be taught and who may teach it. And I think that, and my guess is that even at a place like Johns Hopkins, the faculty resistance to 'you must now teach democracy and cherish it with your students' is, is this what we should be teaching because we should be teaching it, or is this what we're trying to sort of defend ourselves against further attacks from the federal government? And that's not okay.
Interviewer 15:01 ↗
Yeah, I mean, to be clear, this initiative at Johns Hopkins started well before 2024, so it's not a reaction to Trump being reelected. But I think that does pose a deeper problem for how to think about this in universities. So I, you know, I wasn't going to jump into this this early in the conversation, but, you know, you recently gave a number of interviews in which you said that, you know, you were so perturbed by, you know, the rise of, for lack of a better word, woke ideas at Harvard and at other universities that you strongly considered resigning your position because the atmosphere had become sort of so unbearable. You know, I think it does pose the question of how do we deal with some of those failings within our universities, and I worry that there is a moment in 2023, 2024 where some of those excesses and some of those shortcomings were becoming increasingly clear, and, you know, the sort of majority of faculty or the plurality of faculty who I think are kind of center-left liberals, you know, bit of a progressive bend but not, you know, all-out sort of left-wing ideologues, were recognizing that and were saying, okay, let's reform. And I worry that in this political moment, some of what the Trump administration does is indeed so extreme, and in particular some of the Trump administration's attacks on universities are so extreme that there's this kind of rallying around the flag effect, where any reform that in 2023 or 2024 you might be able to get a majority of the faculty at Harvard or Johns Hopkins or any other leading university in the United States behind now immediately will read as either capitulation to the demands of the Trump administration or kind of preemptive obedience. But that creates a really bad dynamic where we're unwilling to fix some of the problems that we ourselves in private moments are willing to recognize, because any attempt to do so can quickly be coded and attacked as just capitulating to the Trump administration. So how do we reform the university and how do we fix some of these problems, you know, without falling into that trap?
Jill Lepore 17:12 ↗
Yeah, I do think that's tricky. And I do think it requires being open and candid with one another. Maybe not necessarily always with the public. I'm not sure this needs to be discharged through a public forum, you know, about failures over the last 20 years or so within higher education, which I wouldn't describe as redounding to you the problems of woke ideology. There are a lot of problems with higher education that have nothing to do with woke ideology, whatever, you know, that is meant to be. That I think it has to be possible to identify those things, be honest about them, disagree about what those failings were or whether they still exist, and address them, and not have all of that be seen to be bound up with some kind of capitulation to the Trump administration. But I think that maybe that's an argument for doing that within the walls of the academy and not on a public forum. Which is why I'm not the person who's out there like making a career for myself talking about, oh no, higher education was such a problem. Like there are people that do that, right? That's like a big part of the Jordan Peterson beat, right? That like the sort of exile from higher education, and in a way the space that those characters take up in the public sphere makes it much more difficult for anyone else to speak honestly and candidly, because you kind of, I think most reasonable people fear being classed with those self-congratulatory exiles.
Interviewer 19:14 ↗
So what is the problem of university in your mind? So I agree with you that there's lots of problems, you know, like very high tuition fees, like the fact that often, you know, renovating the gym and making sure that you have the best possible athletic facilities had a higher priority than investing in, you know, paying, you know, adjunct faculty members decent wages. You know, there's all kinds of things that you can complain about the university with very good reason that have nothing to do with that. But, you know, I don't presume that, you know, the fact that perhaps Harvard had sometimes wrong spending priorities is the reason why you resigned your job. I mean, it sounds from what you have said publicly that that does have to do with a kind of intellectual atmosphere in which at least for a few years it was very difficult even for somebody who's clearly left of center and who, you know, I know how you self-describe politically, but who's clearly, I think, in many ways is progressive, you know, felt unable to speak freely without fear of the kind of unpleasantness that made you think, perhaps I'd rather make a life for myself outside of academia.
Jill Lepore 20:27 ↗
Yeah, I mean, I guess it might be useful to think historically here instead of autobiographically, which I don't think is really all that fruitful. I spent a lot of time when I was working on my most recent book, that's a history of the Constitution, thinking about the life of Charles Beard, who's always been one of my intellectual heroes. Beard, whose wife Mary Ritter Beard was also a famous, very deservedly celebrated American historian, pioneering historian of women, had been an eminent professor at Columbia and was most famous for a book that he published in 1913, for which he was really resoundingly attacked, a book called An Economic Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution, and it really shook up. So Beard was a progressive in the old-fashioned sense, right? He was a progressive of the Progressive Era. He was a political historian but also an economic historian. He was a very active progressive leader, right? So very involved in the progressive cause of the 1900s, which chiefly involved attempts to amend the Constitution. And the progressives, in fact, succeeded. They amended the Constitution four times between 1913 and 1920, and Beard was involved in all of those efforts, which culminated in the 19th Amendment granting women the right to vote, which Mary Ritter Beard was also, of course, involved in. But Beard wrote this book about the Constitution in which he argued that the Constitution's origins were chiefly economic, that the framers of the Constitution were wealthy men. He spent a lot of time documenting their incomes and the source of their income, and that they had devised a Constitution that protected their own property rights. It was largely read as an indictment of the Senate, which was considered the millionaires' club at the time. Before the 17th Amendment, the U.S. Senate was elected by members of the state legislatures, and you could just kind of basically bribe your way into the Senate if you had enough money. And progressives had been trying for decades and decades to get rid of the indirect election of the Senate, which had also been a feature of a lot of state constitutions right from the start, and had been amended out of the state constitutions. It's like a wildly anti-democratic provision, right? Like, can't the people elect their own representatives? Isn't that the whole point? And so this had been really successfully amended out of state constitutions, but it was really difficult to get amended out of the U.S. Constitution because it had to get through the Senate, and the members of the Senate had no interest in being elected directly by the people because they all knew they would lose their jobs. So part of the way that Beard's work was really seen was as endorsing what became the 17th Amendment in 1913, by which progressives managed to get the Senate to finally approve the amendment to get rid of their, to be elected by the people, by threatening to hold a constitutional convention. Anyway, so Beard had done this kind of really interesting work, and then he was very defensive about it when reviews came out and said like the book was attempting to amend the Constitution by writing a new history of it. Do you know what I mean? Like that this seemed very instrumentalist to his critics who had some pure notion of the historian who somehow doesn't live in the time in which he's writing. And he defended that, you know, like this is just, this is what I find in the archives. This is the story that I find in the archives, and I wanted to tell it. But the truth...
Interviewer 24:08 ↗
He claimed that he wasn't aiming for political impact, even though that likely wasn't true.
Jill Lepore 24:13 ↗
Yeah, which is interesting to me because I came across, he, all when he was living in New York, he founded and was for a long time a member of like the committee to amend the federal Constitution. Like he was entirely involved, like totally, like a very much a political actor in a way that say like I am not, like I'm not on a committee to amend the Constitution. But Beard was an extremely principled person, and during the First World War, the very, very conservative president of Columbia, Nicholas Butler, who was a constitutional conservative at a time when constitutional conservatism was being founded, required that faculty sign a loyalty oath to the United States. There was so much, as you know, so much, the U.S. entry into the war in Europe was extremely unpopular in the United States. Wilson was despised for it, and therefore, you know, founded this ministry of propaganda to try to convince the American people that the Germans were evil and they needed to be stopped. Beard, who actually supported the U.S. entry into the war, really opposed the loyalty oaths, and when two of his colleagues were fired for refusing to sign the loyalty oaths, he resigned in protest. This is, I think, 1917, right? So it's when the Sedition Act, like this is like right around Eugene Debs is being arrested, and there's a lot of repression, political repression, repression of political dissent, repression of opposition to the war, and Beard, just as a principled matter, retired. And he was, because partly because of that book he had written about the Constitution, he was by far the best known American historian of his day, and he went, he moved to Connecticut and raised cows. And I think a lot about what that took for Beard to leave academic life, academic position.
Interviewer 26:10 ↗
Or did he also stop writing history?
Jill Lepore 26:13 ↗
No, he continued writing history. He went on to write, with his wife, probably the best textbook at the time was called The Rise of American Civilization. It came out in, I think, I want to say '27. But he and his wife, and he alone, they just wrote a series of textbooks. I mean, he did other intellectual work as well, and he was very involved politically. He later taught at the New School for some time. He died in, I think, 1948. So he did have some more academic life, right? But I think it's a good illustration of a principled engagement with the idea of free inquiry and of higher education and of the importance of the study of the American past, especially in times of political crisis, when the trial of ideas, the world of democracy, is in question. Beard wrote a beautiful essay in 1934. I think it's called The Future of American Democracy. Someone who found a way to both celebrate what universities are for and yet could not be in a university. So my point in telling this tale is that I don't think this is a new dilemma. It's not like, oh wow, what a weird time we're living in. Like this is, this is always, there's always a tension between the university and the state.
Interviewer 27:40 ↗
Well, but let me say two things about that. So one is that I think it's clear and obvious to me that restrictions on what people can say are driven either by top-down political demands or by the preferences and moral strictures of a particular social media who has captured a particular part of society, are a very regular occurrence in human history. You know, that, and in fact many of the most famous instances of moral panics that we come to regret in retrospect fall precisely into that category. So the claim certainly is not that there is something unique about the American university in 2015 or 2018 in that respect. But surely the inference of that is precisely that this is, or the better reason to be very clear and upfront about the nature of that and to speak out against it. And you very elegantly answered my question with a historical metaphor. And you know, with, in the case of historical metaphors, there's obvious, or analogies, there's obviously always, you know, an element that is similar and an element that is dissimilar, and you may back that there are elements of dissimilarity here, but, you know, didn't your answer inadvertently compare what it was like, or perhaps advertently compare what it was like to be a professor at Harvard in 2018 to what it was like to be a professor at Columbia in 1917 or in 1932, you know, which is actually quite a striking claim to make.
Jill Lepore 29:29 ↗
Let's think of a different example. I was thinking about Francis Lieber, who is a German intellectual who immigrated to the United States in the 1820s. He's often described as the German Tocqueville, and he couldn't get a job teaching in the North, and he took a job in South Carolina, what was then South Carolina College, now is the University of South Carolina, I believe. And he was an abolitionist, and he tried for decades to get out of South Carolina. And yet he became an owner of slaves. He owned other human beings. He wrote in his diary about these purchases, you know, not like a large plantation owner, but he had a number of women that worked as domestics in human bondage in his service, and he doesn't really manage to get out of South Carolina until after Dred Scott, I think Dred Scott, which is the 1857 decision of the Supreme Court that rules that no Black American can ever be a citizen of the United States. He managed to get out. He goes to Columbia, where he proceeds to deliver a series of lectures on the Constitution, renouncing secession. And it's a really interesting story because you see someone who had wholly compromised a deeply held principle, right? That his opposition, he wasn't like an anti-racist or something, but he was opposed to human bondage. And yet he participated in it, and he wrote these sort of private letters to John C. Calhoun that he was unwilling to publish, and he just let himself be completely suppressed as an intellectual by essentially what we would describe as the academic job market. Like he just couldn't get a job. He couldn't get, and he largely couldn't get a job, I believe, because he was Jewish, although that is very, this sort of contentious. Anyway, then he goes to Columbia, has this real blossoming, and he gives these series of lectures that are widely published in newspapers. You know, Lincoln then hires him to write the laws of, he writes famously what, the Lieber Code, which is the basis of the Geneva Code. It is the laws of war that the United States adopts during the Civil War. So he has this kind of late-stage career in which he, I think, considers himself to be acting in accordance with his principles, but it's a counterexample to Beard's in my mind in terms of the relationship between the intellectual sort of complicity with the ideological position of the state versus one's own commitment to ideas and the freedom of ideas.
Interviewer 32:17 ↗
I want to get into the history of the Constitution and your latest book in a moment, but just a final question on this. I mean, what lessons do you take from this contrast between Lieber and Beard for what it means to be true to yourself as an intellectual at a time when there's tremendous pressures on you, and whether that is being, you know, an intellectual who wants to defend a substantive notion of liberal democracy in Hungary at a time when big parts of a state, increasingly the academic system, are captured by loyalists to Viktor Orbán, or perhaps, you know, if you're an intellectual who has, or an academic who has certain views disfavored by their colleagues, you know, in the American academy in 2018?
Jill Lepore 33:08 ↗
I don't know. Obviously, I wrestled with a lot that, a lot over the last years, and I think I have failed to live up to my own principles, so far be it for me to suggest what those principles can and not be to be for anyone else and how they ought to honor them. I would say you obviously can tell I don't really want to talk about this. I'd much rather talk about the work, but just to finish up this point, for me there were many tough moments, but one tough moment was when some students in a class I was teaching said they wouldn't read the Dred Scott opinion, this 1857 Supreme Court decision by the Chief Justice Roger Taney, which is, you know, considered one of the worst, if not the worst opinion ever issued by the Supreme Court. It's, it's...
Interviewer 33:59 ↗
And I'm sure your goal in teaching it was not to defend it.
Jill Lepore 34:01 ↗
My goal in teaching was surely not to defend it. But the assignment was to engage in a debate in section over with the question of whether the U.S. Constitution did or did not sanction slavery, based on a series of readings on that question from the 1850s, which included writings by Abraham Lincoln, Stephen Douglas, Frederick Douglass, and then the Dred Scott decision. And I remember just sitting in my office thinking, I don't really feel like it's my job to explain that you have to read historical documents even if you don't like them. Like, like that just seemed like the most elementary piece of work for being a human in the world. Like we, I, I guess I kind of prepared something I might say, you know, bring these students into office hours and say, 'Here's a thing I want to explain.' And I just was mad, like who told these people that it was, you could just say, 'I don't want to read that because I find it painful'? Because if that's how you, then you can't read history. History is full of pain. People suffer. Literature is full of pain. Philosophy is full of pain. The human experience is full of pain and suffering and injustice. And to gain any capacity to live a good life, you have to confront pain, injustice, and suffering, and find a way to think about it and reckon with it and remedy it and make amends for it. Like to not engage with, like I just, I really just, like if this is what my job is reduced to, is saying you actually have to do the reading, what am I doing? Like so I think that is a good encapsulation. When I say I found it extremely difficult, sure there's the firings, there is, there's all kinds of nonsense going on, like a lot of daily, day-to-day, like, and this happened, how could this have happened, why the deans allow this kind, but there was at the, at a core of it, there was, there was that, that. And I honestly, these are very young people, I don't blame them, whatever they brought, they got, they didn't get this from me, they got this somewhere, and they, and yet they, they feel it with such tenacity. For me, that, and that's different than Charles Beard's problem, right? That's different than Francis Lieber's problem. That's really not even about the university at all.
Interviewer 36:55 ↗
Yeah, that's perhaps more similar to what Theodor Adorno faced in 1968 when his students had decided that he was actually a terrible reactionary and so started protesting his lectures, etc. Right? I mean, pressure from students is a different thing from pressure from administrators. And the thing that bugs me about this kind of response is that, you know, if somebody says, 'I just want to devote my life to thinking about pleasant things and I just want to read pretty love stories,' you know, that's not my choice. But I think that's a coherent choice, right? You know, if you just love beauty and you want to look at pretty pictures and read nice, I think that's sort of misunderstanding what the most important pictures in the history of art are and what some of the most moving novels that have been written by humans are. But fair enough, you know, like there's worse ways of spending a life. What's sort of so strange and contradictory about this is the sort of parallel insistence that we want to have a very negative view of the world and we want to claim that we're fighting against injustice and suffering of every kind, but we don't want to grapple with its actual historical and contemporary nature because, you know, we're not going to read the text. That's sort of what's strange about it. You know, I find, you know, and I promise that's the last question this direction, I want to ask you, that there was a zeal that some students, was not the majority of students, but that some students brought to the classroom where they wanted to impose a certain view. It wasn't just 'I personally don't want to read this text.' It sent the message that you're a bad person for wanting us to read this text. Right? There was an implicit threat on it, and I haven't found that anymore in the last few years. I don't know if you agree with that, but there's something that I find has changed in the mentality of the students, but perhaps precisely, and it's not that they don't believe in some of those ideas at all anymore. Perhaps it's that it went from feeling to them like an organic movement of their generation to something that they've been kind of taught by the culture or by parts of the culture at least since elementary school or since middle school or since high school. And it's kind of the ideas of the adults, and even they believe in them, it doesn't have the same fervency. But I just wonder whether you've felt that shift among the students in the last years as well.
Jill Lepore 39:17 ↗
Yeah, I do think that it is the case that the students are less prosecutorial in the sense, less prosecutorial of one another, which was really the most painful thing to see, right? Like I can take it, but...
[Laughter] But they are very young to be just snapping at each other and recording each other in class and, you know, shaming one another. There's much less of that. I think that the inclination to take a critical stance on the syllabus, I mean, that's as old as the hills, right? [Laughter] Sure, there's always going to be why didn't you include this and why did you not include that, and yeah, it's going to change from year to year what they think should be included and what shouldn't be included. But yeah, there's not the... zeal is a good word for it. There's a little bit less of the zeal and satisfaction or the sense that that is the only kind of intellectual work worth doing, right? That I think it was the narrowness of that.
Interviewer 40:23 ↗
Let's get to the US Constitution, which you talk about in your latest book. You know, there's something paradoxical about the Constitution, where it's, you know, in some ways the most successful political document in the history of mankind. I mean, it set up a vast continental republic that is about to celebrate its 250th anniversary. You know, it is today the most or one of the two most powerful countries in the world. It has survived largely unchanged, you know, over a time period in which other countries, including other relatively successful democracies, have gone through 10, 20, 30 different constitutional documents. And at the same time, when you look at American politics today, it can feel as though some of the stuckness that animates the political divisions that we see, the political frustrations that are one of the contributing reasons why people feel compelled to vote for someone like Donald Trump, you know, all of that seems to also derive in some ways from the difficulty and from the stickiness of that document. So how, as a historian, are you thinking about the successes and the limitations of this document?
Jill Lepore 41:44 ↗
I think that Americans have, on the whole, relative to other people of other nations, a great deal of veneration for the Constitution that is based partly just on a cultural predisposition, but also is founded in its longevity, which is extraordinarily unusual. Globally, the average lifespan of a constitution is 19 years. Other nation states revise and replace their constitutions all the time. And I think a lot of Americans attribute American prosperity and prominence and stability to the Constitution without necessarily knowing exactly why, or maybe what the mechanism is by which the Constitution is providing that stability. Yeah, I think it's often just assumed. And although state constitutions in the US much more closely resemble the constitutions of nation states, because our state constitutions are revised and replaced all the time, not so much replaced anymore, but, you know, there've been more than 200 state constitutional conventions. My home state, Massachusetts, has the oldest written constitution still in effect. It's adopted in 1780, but it's been amended more than 100 times.
Interviewer 43:11 ↗
A lot of Americans don't even know they have state constitutions. Even when the ballot questions come around that are amendments to the state constitutions, I think it's not always clear what that is. Like, am I passing on... is it a statute? What is it? Yeah.

28 more exchanges in this transcript

Sign in free to read the rest of this interview. No card required.

Sign in to read the full transcript

Cite this transcript

APA, MLA, BibTeX
APA

Lepore, J. (2025, December 9). Jill Lepore on Why We Should Amend the U.S. Constitution [Interview transcript]. Persuasion. CEOInterviews.AI. https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183826/

MLA

Jill Lepore. "Jill Lepore on Why We Should Amend the U.S. Constitution." Persuasion, 9 Dec. 2025. Transcript, CEOInterviews.AI, https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183826/.

BibTeX
@misc{lepore2025_3183826,
  author       = {Jill Lepore},
  title        = {Jill Lepore on Why We Should Amend the U.S. Constitution},
  howpublished = {Interview transcript, Persuasion. CEOInterviews.AI},
  year         = {2025},
  month        = {dec},
  url          = {https://ceointerviews.ai/interview/3183826/},
  note         = {Speaker-attributed transcript with timestamps}
}