Good evening. Good evening. It is wonderful to see all of you and to welcome you to our event this evening. I'm Dana Cunningham, the dean of the Tisch College of Civic Life. It's my privilege to welcome you tonight. We have historian, professor, writer, Tufts alum, Jumbo Jill Lepore here for our Solomont Speaker Series event.
Tonight, we continue a series at Tisch College, a series of events and conversations throughout 2026 that will explore urgent and vital questions about what is next for American democracy. We're considering this theme in the context of the commemoration this summer of the Declaration of Independence. Together, we are asking questions like, 'What is the state of our democracy? How far have we come? Where are we headed? And what threats, concerns, questions, and opportunities must we confront?' So, I hope we will have a robust conversation about those topics.
Tonight we are fortunate to have two experts to lead us through the conversation this evening: Jill Lepore and our moderator, Professor Paul Palud from Tufts's history department. Let me just give you a quick introduction to both of them, and let me say that tonight we have some special circumstances. This is going to be the most timely Tisch event that has ever happened. We are ending exactly at 6:15.
Exactly at 6:15. So if our guests rush out of the room at 6:15, you will understand they have another engagement. So it's just to tell you, we've got to be timely tonight. Professor Jill Lepore is a professor at Harvard Law School and the David Woods Kemper Class of '41 Professor of American History at Harvard University, where she teaches classes in evidence, historical methods, humanistic inquiry, and American history.
An award-winning writer, Professor Lepore is the author of many best-selling books and a staff writer for The New Yorker magazine. And of course, Professor Lepore is a proud Tufts Jumbo, having received her undergraduate degree from Tufts as well as an honorary degree from the university in 2014. Tonight, we're here to discuss her most recent book, We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution, which shares the messy history of the U.S. Constitution while also seeking to rekindle a sense of constitutional possibility. A perfect theme for tonight.
Joining Professor Lepore in conversation is lecturer in the Tufts history department, Professor Paul Palud. Professor Palud is a historian of slavery, race, and emancipation in the United States. He has published widely on race, citizenship, and anti-racist activism, including African-American disfranchisement in early national New York and Black Boston's protests against the film The Birth of a Nation. His first book, Standard Bearers of Equality: America's First Abolition Movement, was a finalist for the Harriet Tubman Prize.
Before I turn things over to our speakers, let me ask all the students in the audience to listen generously. Everybody's a student, right? Yeah, we are all students, lifelong learners, and to think about your questions because tonight's event will also include a short audience Q&A. Short audience Q&A. And with that, let's welcome Professor Lepore and Professor Palud.
Okay. Hi Jill. Welcome back to Tufts. It's great to have you here for, I think, a very timely conversation about a very important book. So let's get right to it. As Dean Cunningham noted, 2026 marks the 250-year anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and also more broadly of American constitutionalism, state constitutions, which you rightly emphasize in your book as early as January of 1776. So, how do you see your book speaking to this moment in light of this anniversary?
Yeah, I actually, I'm not the most planful person, but I did plan for the book to come out this past fall, trying to jump the queue of the onslaught of 250th books because I was a bit concerned that, in fact, the origins of American constitutionalism would be lost in the highly politicized and culture-war-vibing commemoration moment, which also really focuses on the Declaration of Independence, which of course is immensely important. But I just sort of wanted to inject — I was hoping to inject constitutionalism into that conversation.
And we are also, I guess this is another way of speaking to the moment, we're in a moment, and this has ebbed and flowed over the course of American history, where the Supreme Court has a great deal of power. And that always surprises me as a historian — not so much that it has that power, but that people don't think about what other forms of power there are with regard to constitutional interpretation. So the book I wanted to write was one that revealed the long history and tradition of popular sovereignty over the Constitution.
Yeah. Great. So let's get into the book, right? Because so much of this — and you have the immortal words of Bugs Bunny here early on, right? The importance of amendment, right? But of course the Constitution hasn't been substantively amended, right, since 1971, the 26th Amendment that lowers the voting age to 18. It hasn't been amended at all since 1992. So to begin unpacking why that is, can you give us a brief overview of the amendment process, right? What makes it difficult and what it takes to pass an amendment?
Yeah. So here's a brief civics lesson. Amending the U.S. Constitution requires a double supermajority. An amendment has to pass by a two-thirds supermajority in both houses of Congress. If that happens, it goes to the states, and then it has to pass by three-quarters of the states. Antonin Scalia once calculated that, with present demographics — this was maybe 30 years ago — 2% of the people can defeat a constitutional amendment. It's really, it's very, very difficult, and for most moments in American history, it has been effectively impossible to amend the U.S. Constitution. We have one of the lowest amendment rates in the world.
So the Massachusetts constitution, which was ratified in 1780, has been amended, I think, 123 times. It's very common. Most states have replaced their constitution; Massachusetts is unusual in that regard. So most nation-states' constitutions last an average of 18 years. So our Constitution, as the federal Constitution, is very long-lived, and it's very little amended, and it's very difficult to amend. And these are distinguishing features of it. And many people would say that's why it's great, right? It was so good that it has required very little adjusting. That's a common argument that you find across American history.
But the pattern that I'm tracing in the book is that because it is so difficult to amend the U.S. Constitution — which was not intended. Hence the reference to Bugs Bunny, who sings this song called 'The Ode to the Amendments,' where he — it's a vaudeville song, and he says it was intended to be amended. So you can find that on YouTube. It's the epigraph to the book. Everybody asks me about Bugs Bunny.
So the pattern that I'm trying to illustrate in the book is that there are these bursts of amendment activity, like the Bill of Rights — those first 10 amendments are passed all at once. The Civil War and Reconstruction Amendments, three of them, 13th, 14th, 15th, are passed within the space of five years. The Progressive Era amendments from 1913 to 1920, four amendments in seven years. There are four amendments passed between 1961 and 1971. But between these bursts, there's no amending, but there's a lot of constitutional change.
When the people sort of lose the ability to amend the Constitution, the Supreme Court steps in and amends the Constitution by judicial interpretation. And that happens until people get pissed off about it and start ranting about judicial supremacy, and then people kind of regain the power to amend the Constitution. That's sort of been the pattern across American history. I don't actually think that we're in that pattern anymore. I think that pattern has come to an end. But one of the things the book is trying to do is say — I think when Americans think about the Constitution, they think it has a history; they just kind of picture the like calligraphic 'We the People,' and it's like an icon, not really a history. It's a motto, not a history.
And if you think — maybe if you have maybe once took a civics class or you took a legal history class, you might think of the history of the Constitution in terms of like a series of important Supreme Court decisions. Oh, well, there was Marbury v. Madison, then there was Dred Scott, then there was Plessy v. Ferguson, then there was Lochner, then we get to Brown v. Board, then Roe — like, and that's the history of the Constitution. My book is like, no, that is part of the history of the Constitution, but actually all the things that people have wanted and tried to do all along is also the history of the Constitution, and it's sort of largely invisible to us.
Yeah. And I think that's a great bridge to what I was going to ask you next, because I think, you know, one of the virtues of this book is the way it sort of peoples the U.S. Constitution. And of course that builds in large part, right, on the Amendments Project, right, where you and your students documented really thousands of attempts to amend the Constitution over, you know, the long durée of American history. So what does that history, right, of efforts to attempt to, you know, reshape the U.S. Constitution — you know, what does it suggest about popular sovereignty and involvement, and how have those efforts sort of informed 'We the People,' right, and sort of what 'We the People' has meant in practice?
Yeah, I mean, I remember — so I started this data project called the Amendments Project. It's free, it's online, it's a collection of every significant attempt to amend the U.S. Constitution. I did it with some students as a project. It was funded by the now-defunct NEH because I just felt like people should know how many times people have tried and failed to amend the Constitution. Not because these attempts are good ideas — like a lot of those thousands of ideas, I think, are terrible ideas.
But I came across a guy in like 1896 who had done this for the first time, the first person to try to compile this list, and he said, 'You know, I looked at it and I decided it turns out if you look at this list, it's a pretty good index of the popular will.' Like, if you want to know what have Americans wanted constitutionally, making a list of all the things they ever tried to do by way of amendment is a pretty interesting list. Especially if you do, I think, what I tried to do, which was not just to look at what proposals get introduced on the floor of Congress, because there are like 12,000 of those, but — you know, before women got the right to vote in 1920, before the Voting Rights Act in 1965, certainly before the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments, the way that many people living in the United States were completely unable to participate in politics.
That would include Native nations. They participate in their own politics, but they had little voice congressionally, say, even though they were promised congressional delegates before the Constitutional Convention. So what I tried to do was look at — you know, I think most Americans don't know that there were like 200 constitutional conventions held by Black men in the 19th century. I mean, we could think of them as extra-constitutional conventions, but free Black men in the North met regularly in these regional and state and national conventions to deliberate what to do about the Constitution while the states were having their own constitutional conventions that only white men could go to, and women held constitutional conventions, and Native nations held constitutional conventions.
And if you look at all of that aspiring as well and think of those meetings as constitutional aspirations, then you really can kind of, as carefully as possible, come up with an approximation of a history of the American popular will.
So before I ask the next question, I actually want to turn to a brief passage from the opening of your book that I think gets at something really central in your framework in a very powerful and evocative way. So I'm just going to read that briefly before asking the question. 'We the People. The Constitution of the United States is made of things that are born, live, thrive, decay, and die. Insects, animals, plants, ideas.' And then you juxtapose these key phrases from the U.S. Constitution with these sentences: 'In order to form a more perfect union, each of its elements began long ago in the loamy earth, hatching and creeping or slipping, slick and squealing from the womb of the mind. Establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility. The text is written on parchment made from sheep, fleeced, their hides soaked in lime, stretched and dried. Provide for the common defense. The ink came from the buds of oak leaves swollen to the size of musk balls by the eggs of wasps. Promote the general welfare. Its words were shaped by quills fashioned from the feathers of molting geese. Secure the blessings of liberty. Its lofty, momentous ideas came from the minds of men long since dead and from the books they read.'
Now, other than just an excuse for me to read your beautiful writing, in that passage you really bring the Constitution into a more material, human register, I would say. So how should seeing the Constitution in those terms inform how we think about what the document is and how it operates, or maybe I should say how it should operate or ought to operate in American life?
Yeah, I thought a lot about that — that's the beginning of the book. And one of the things that always perplexes me as a historian, and I'm sure you have this in the classroom as well, is that people who don't study history, like, the Constitution is this old piece of parchment, and it has a kind of scriptural quality to it. It has an iconographic quality to it. You can picture it. I think it's a little bit hard to hold it close, but if you're an 18th-century historian like you and I are, you're reading documents that look like that all day long. Like, it's just another document.
Now, not to say it's like not really important — it is our frame of government, but it is also just another document. And you're like, well, how did — like any other document, who wrote it? What were they — when did they write it down? Why was it printed? Who read it? Who helped draft it? Was it revised? Like the process that you would ask of any other historical document. And for me, the materiality of documents is always really, really important. But I was also gesturing there, obviously — it's a paragraph that does a lot of work.
Like, one thing is a big debate among constitutional scholars is, you know, between originalists who ask that we interpret the Constitution with reference only to its original meaning and understanding, and who have a somewhat worshipful notion of the Constitution, and between so-called living constitutionalists who treat the document as a living Constitution that's constantly evolving. They have a kind of Darwinian notion of the Constitution. So I'm sort of — I'm poking fun at both sides in a way there, both at the worship of it and at the kind of gross materiality.
But I'll just say one funny story. That expression 'womb of the mind' — my editor was like, 'Can we please get rid of that? I do not want to think about a womb in the first sentence of a book about the Constitution.' No. And I was like, 'Yes, you do. Yes, you do. That is part of my Constitution.' Yeah. It's part of my point. Like, it is okay. You have to picture a uterus right there, and you have to live with that. Yeah. So it's very purposeful, is I guess my — birth of the nation, right?
Yeah. And I think that's a good pivot to — and you've just named this, because I hear what you're saying where you're sort of, you know, poking at both sides, but of course at this moment in time, our moment in the American experience, right, originalism is pretty dominant for American jurisprudence, right? So your book does challenge the idea, right, that there is this single original meaning of the U.S. Constitution, right, and really points instead to this kind of long history of competing interpretations, of the sort of many, you know, multi-modal sort of efforts to reshape it. So how do you understand originalism in its current form? And where do you see its limits when sort of set against the history that you trace in the book?
Yeah. So, and I think the book could be read as an intellectual history of originalism among other things, because it is also a long examination of how the Constitution has been interpreted and by whom. And I, you know, there are plenty of Supreme Court decisions and cultural postures that are akin to what we would now describe as originalism. The term itself dates to 1980, and it becomes prominent in 1987 when Robert Bork is nominated to the Supreme Court and defeated. He was the nominee of Ronald Reagan. 1987 was also the 200th anniversary of the Constitutional Convention, so it was a moment of real veneration. Originalism really dates to the Reagan Justice Department.
And it prevails on the court in terms of the ideological preferences of the majority of the justices. Although I actually think originalism is effectively dead. So I — we could quibble about that. But in any event, the book traces many different origins of what becomes originalism and many different kinds of constitutional interpretation that compete with a deference to the ideas of the founding.
And it makes a series of arguments. One is that originalism is not original. It's in fact counter-original. The framers of the Constitution have been — they were very explicit: this is not how they wanted the Constitution to be interpreted. And it also makes the case that originalism is not historical. I mean, it's a political movement above all. It is a method of constitutional interpretation that can be defended or, you know, defeated. But it doesn't have anything really to do with history.
Yeah. And I take that point that, right, this book could be a history of originalism and it's nebulous and shifting. But I think what we can all agree on, as we talked about at the opening here, is that amendment has stalled, right? And yet of course change doesn't stop, right? It just moves elsewhere. And so as we know, right, a great deal of constitutional change today is happening through the courts and of course through executive power, right, rather than through amendments. So how do you understand the movement of constitutional change into the courts and the executive, and, you know, sort of the consequences of that sort of overlaid on your narrative?
Yeah. Yeah. Well, let's get to the executive in a minute, but think first about the people versus the courts. And I think it is worth just emphasizing that there's not a lot of principle to be found in the history of American politics. So conservatives like the court when the court is conservative, and liberals like the court when the court is liberal, and then vice versa. Right? So our modern era of constitutional drought, amendment drought, is really a product of progressivism and not of conservatism.
So in the 1930s, when FDR, you know, wanted to constitutionalize the New Deal and the Supreme Court kept striking down elements of the New Deal, a lot of his advisers said, you know, 'Frank, let's go ahead and get some constitutional amendments passed. Like, we just do like four or five. We got to like get this thing in there and like it's got to be solid.' And he was like, 'We won't be able to get over the millionaires' lobby. Like, there's so much lobbying.' There had been so much lobbying to defeat the last amendment that was on the table from the Progressives, which was the Child Labor Amendment. It passed Congress the day it was introduced in 1924, and it was stalled in the states by Southern mill owners.
And he was like, 'We're never — like, it's a depression. We have to get this done.' And he just kind of bullied the New Deal through the court, as we know, the court-packing plan. And civil rights activists also were like, 'We can't go for a constitutional amendment. We can't even vote. Like, how are we going to — we have to go to the courts.' So the middle decades of the 20th century, liberals and civil rights activists all sought constitutional change through the court, principally through the Warren Court beginning in 1953 and all the way to 1969.
And conservatives came to power on the court by arguing against an active court and said the only way to change the Constitution is by amending it, and this court should not be able to do that. But then once they saw that they were about to get power on the court and they couldn't get any amendments passed because they didn't have anything like the popular majorities, supermajorities required, then they came up with a different argument about how to make constitutional change, which was to restore the Constitution to its original meaning, which was to grant basically a new power to the Supreme Court to amend the Constitution, but under the guise of pretending that they were not changing the Constitution, but in fact restoring the Constitution.
And so now you begin to hear progressives say, 'What about amendment? Maybe that's something we should think about.' Like, Gavin Newsom talks about amending the Constitution all the time now, because there's no way to get anything through the court. So, but your question is about executive authority, because what we're living in now since January of 2025 is really — yes, the court has a role, but largely the president just is like, 'If I do it, it's constitutional,' is his view, and he hasn't really been defeated in the making of that argument. But you couldn't get there without abandoning the power of the people and yielding it to the Supreme Court in the first place.
Yeah. And so for the sake of time, maybe I could try to meld two questions here before handing it off to Q&A, because I want to make sure we have some time for that. I'd love to unpack more of the history. I know we don't have a lot of time to do that. You've done a little bit of that really importantly with the New Deal. So, you know, you've mentioned some moments, right, in time, right, and movements like, you know, the Civil War era, Reconstruction era, Progressive Era, right, where you really have transformational constitutional change. Of course, it helps when you have, you know, all Southern Democrats out of Congress, right, after the Civil War. But if you take that, right, and you take other moments, like, are there any patterns that you can sort of identify that helps explain how these transformative moments happen with amending the Constitution?
It usually involves a war. So the Revolutionary War — there's a constitutional settlement somehow, which is, you know, the Civil War, where my argument doesn't work so well with the Progressive Era. But you could say the Vietnam War era works. So I — it's just that there needs to be something significantly disruptive of the existing political settlement that requires a new constitutional settlement.
Okay, good. So then pivoting to today, right? And not to sound too ominous, right? But then what would it take today to re-energize the possibility, right? And I think part of it could be also, as you said, and I totally relate to this even in the classroom, right? Sort of, you know, shaking ourselves from this idea of looking at the Constitution as kind of like sacred scripture, right? And instead see it as this, as this, you know, human construction of time and place. But, you know, are there any, you know, current efforts or ways in which you can imagine sort of amending the Constitution sort of gaining sort of feasibility?
So I don't know about — I have an article in The New Yorker last week about whether AI needs constitutions, sort of response to Claude's constitution. I actually think that AI might put enough pressure on our set of political arrangements that we submit to — are willing to submit to a constitutional convention to figure out a way to move forward as a political community.
Something that could gain steam on both sides of the aisle.
There's quite a lot going on internationally with regard to involving kind of democratic input in the regulation of artificial intelligence. It's a kind of — in the way that the framers of the Constitution, like Alexander Hamilton, would sort of — would have — they would have used the kind of Silicon Valley language of 'It's a new era for humanity. We have founded the United States,' right? We're in that same like, ah, kind of moment.
Yeah. Great. Not a war. At least not yet.
Okay. Well, good. Well, I want to get to Q&A, so we could talk for a lot longer, but I'm going to leave it there. So, thank you so much, Jill. Let's now open it up to the floor for questions. So I'd ask you to please raise a hand. The event staff will try to get to you as soon as they can. Very briefly introduce yourselves, and please make your question very brief because we only have about 15 minutes. So, questions.
Uh — no, sorry. Oh, sorry. Right here. Yeah. Go ahead. Yes. Oh, no, no, no, we have come from behind you, sir. Yep.
Thank you so much. My name is Will Ba. I'm the vice president of the Somerville City Council, originally from Cameroon. I'm also running for state representative in this district. I guess I'm so inspired by your work and your book. And my question is, you know, like, it's about storytelling and power. So who gets left out of this American story today? And how does that omission shape policy and power?
Okay, thank you. Yeah, very succinct and beautifully put, but it's a huge question.