The idea that we can sit in our living rooms and browse the news on our smartphones and post a few thoughts on social media, and that constitutes meeting our obligations as citizens, is a false one.
Welcome to the Vermont Conversation. I'm David Goodman. Is technology killing democracy and destroying our communities? That's the argument of acclaimed historian Jill Lepore in her new book, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State. She writes that the artificial state is the rule of humans by machines manufactured by corporations. It's the fantasy of tech billionaires, and its goal is the end of liberal democracy.
Jill Lepore is one of the country's most acclaimed historians. She is a professor of American history at Harvard University, a professor of law at Harvard Law School, and a staff writer at The New Yorker. Her many books include the bestsellers These Truths: A History of the United States, which Time magazine named one of the top ten nonfiction books of the decade, and We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution, which won the 2026 Pulitzer Prize in History. She hosts the podcast The Last Archive. Lepore lives part time in Brattleboro, which is where she spoke to me. Jill Lepore, welcome to the Vermont Conversation.
Thanks so much for having me.
You write in The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State that historians shudder at the rawness of the news. We prefer our meat cooked. And I like thinking about the past. So why did you, a historian, tackle the rise of artificial intelligence, which is a very contemporary challenge?
Well, what I wanted to do was set this moment, which feels like a turning point in human history and is often written about that way, within a larger historical context and a longer historical context. So I've been writing a lot about the history of technology for the last, I don't know, many years. But I felt a sense of urgency around trying to offer up a sense, a historian's sense, of how we got to be where we are in this moment.
So let's begin by defining terms here. What is the artificial state?
The artificial state is a term that I've given to try to put a name on what it is that I think we're in the middle of now, which is the underway replacement of the liberal nation state, a constitutional democracy in which we are governed by consent, by our own consent, with a government by machine, in which many of the functions of democratic governments are automated, in which really humans are replaced by bots as the predominant participant in public life.
So you've used the story and family history of Elon Musk, and talked about how it sort of exemplifies the ultimate vision of the artificial state. Talk about his story and why you feel like it captures so much.
Yeah. Musk is a kind of central figure in this account, largely because his family story has something to tell us about this history. I did a podcast series about Musk for the BBC five or six years ago now, and did a lot of research into his history. I was really interested in understanding where Musk came from. This was at a time when people weren't paying that much attention to Musk. He was yet to be the world's richest person. He was kind of, you know, he was known in the tech world, of course, and was very important through Tesla and SpaceX, but was nothing like the international figure that he is today.
And one of the things I found was something that hadn't really been reported about Musk, and people certainly hadn't seen the relevant historical documents to do this kind of reporting. So Musk happens to have family ties to a really important political movement from the 1930s that's largely forgotten, which is known as the technocracy movement, and was run in North America by an outfit known as Technocracy Incorporated. Technocrats, as they called themselves, did not believe in democracy. They did not believe that democracy was up to the challenge of the modern industrial economy. And they thought in place of democracy, people should be ruled not by their elected representatives, but by a fleet of scientists and engineers who were the only people who could really understand how society worked and how it ought to work, because it required so much technical expertise. There would be no elections, there would be no voters, no voting.
They also didn't believe in the economic system as it existed. They weren't communists, but they believed, they didn't believe in prices. They believed that engineers and scientists should establish a currency that they called the earth, which was a unit of energy. They believed in something a little bit like universal basic income, I guess. So.
That's a very kind of utopian thing. The idea that governments should provide basic support for people to live.
Yeah. I'm not sure I would identify their views as utopian. Honestly, they were really pretty squarely totalitarian. They just thought that governments should run everything, including the economy, but that governments shouldn't be popularly elected. They should be self-appointed technocrats. They also thought that for greater efficiency, people shouldn't have names. They should have numbers. They really didn't believe in individuality. So they wore identical gray uniforms and drove identical gray cars in what was known as the gray fleet. And it seems very kooky. And of course, it was much mocked at the time because it was kooky, looked kooky to a lot of people at the time, but nevertheless had a huge following at the very beginning of the 1930s.
It really wasn't until FDR's election in 1932 that technocracy in the United States began to unravel, largely because the leader of the American branch of the movement was revealed to have been a fraud. But the movement continued in Canada, where it was led by a guy named Joshua Haldeman, who turns out was Elon Musk's grandfather. So technocracy is important to my account of visions of an artificial state. And Haldeman is important to that account because he was the national chairman of the movement in Canada, and also because he continued to lead the movement into the 1940s, even after it was outlawed in Canada, he was briefly put in prison. He was barred entry to the United States.
But he is, of course, also important because he left Canada in 1950 with his family to emigrate to South Africa after South Africa declared the policy of apartheid, and he became an ardent defender of the regime. So Musk is not responsible for the views of his grandfather. Obviously, he didn't even really know him. Haldeman died when Musk was just a toddler, but he's a really important figure in the ideas that stretch across the 20th century and link technocracy to Silicon Valley. If you read the manifestos of Silicon Valley types over the last ten years or so, they echo a lot of the themes of the technocracy movement.
So, you know, the titan Musk and his fellow titans of Silicon Valley have kind of had a position, it seems to me, around the edges of American politics through money, things they fund. But with the inauguration of Donald Trump, we see in a very visual way at his actual inauguration, all of these guys are centered on the dais with Trump. What do you think that signaled?
You know, that was the kind of the coming out of the tech right, in which those guys, very explicitly, starting in the summer of 2024, really was right after the Butler, Pennsylvania, assassination attempt of Donald Trump, that Musk came out in support of Trump, and then Marc Andreessen and other Silicon Valley figures lined up behind him. But I actually think it's a mistake to identify the tech right exclusively with Trumpism. In fact, I think the MAGA movement is not especially supportive of the tech right. I think they have very different interests and are likely to be part of a schism within the right.
I think as a historian, like, I'm much more interested in how it is that Silicon Valley came to be so libertarian, which was really always the case. I think it was sort of a looser... The idea that these guys who funded a lot of Democratic candidates in the first two decades of the 21st century, the idea that they were liberal, that they had kind of a particular political preference for Democrats, they were just putting their support behind people who they thought could best promote their own interests as an industry. I don't think that was a particular political choice around a set of political ideas, and nor do I really think support for Trump is a particular political choice around a set of political ideas. I don't have any particular reason to believe that Bezos and Zuckerberg are enamored of Trump and the MAGA movement, and they are looking for less government involvement in their industry. And that's what Silicon Valley has been looking for, really since the 1980s.
Do you think it will swing back again where they are just totally political opportunists and back whoever enables them to make a lot of money? Or do you place it in the context of this, you know, this vision of the artificial state that they are pursuing a coherent, you know, worldview?
You know, I think they think that their interests lie above that of democratic politics. They'll, you know, there's a lot of money being spent, a lot of good reporting going on lately about the amount of money that people in the AI industry are spending right now on the midterms. It's a very kind of short-term agenda. They're looking to support candidates who haven't been willing to oppose data centers or to call for moratoriums on data centers. I mean, I don't think that they have, like, an ideological litmus test for these candidates. I just don't think that's what Silicon Valley is about at all. I just don't think there's any affinity with either political party. I think it's just all short-term instrumental positioning.
But the artificial state, your framing of this, places it in kind of pursuit of this larger vision. So how does that square with...
Yeah, I just don't think that for them that vision is even any part of electoral politics. It's just to do with their own use of their economic power.
How does the artificial state advance their interests? Is it just the economics, just that we will be entirely dependent on Silicon Valley tech moguls for our everything?