It got real quiet, real fast. It must be a library. [Laughter] Good evening. My name is Tony Marx, and I'm the president of the New York Public Library. Thank you, everyone, for being with us tonight. [Applause]
Tonight, as we continue our celebration of the country's 250th birthday, an ongoing celebration here, we are highlighting a breathtaking book, "Declare: A Civic Gospel." 250 years after the Declaration of Independence was first published, Arion Press and Thomas Jefferson's Monticello have partnered to create this one-of-a-kind anthology. You can see a copy of it tonight, if you haven't already. It's presented in a bespoke handmade box. It includes three things: the Declaration's preamble, reimagined by celebrated type designer Trey Seals; a suite of wood medallions engraved with the artwork by leading American artists; and an interior volume collecting new commissioned essays and poems by visionary American writers, edited and introduced by Monticello's president and CEO, the acclaimed historian Jane Kamensky.
If you didn't get a chance to see the book, as I said, when you come in, it will remain on display. You can visit it in our shop any time. You can purchase Arion's paperback reader edition. You can take it out from the library. We're very proud tonight to be partnering with Arion and with Monticello. Jane from Monticello is going to speak with two of the book's contributors, the amazing historian Jill Lepore, whose real claim to fame is she was a library lion, and the great novelist Geraldine Brooks. Before that, poet Major Jackson will read his contribution from the book, and Arion Press's Ted Gioia will go behind the scenes in the book's production.
This is, as I said, part of the library's celebration of the 250th. In this room, we displayed one of two spare copies of Thomas Jefferson's by-hand version of the Declaration that includes, of course, the fervent rebuke of the slave trade, which opens all kinds of questions. There were thousands of people in this room, people lining up in the heat on July 4th to see it. We illuminated it on the front of the building. And now you can continue to see the amazing exhibition throughout this whole building entitled "Declaring America: 1776 and Beyond." It includes an amazing collection of documents from the 1776 moment when things were pretty touch-and-go in terms of our independence here in New York. We have a whole separate exhibition on the history of 250 years of protest in the United States since then, also part of the American tradition. We do not whitewash history at the New York Public Library. [Applause]
There's also on the third floor an amazing exhibition of art inspired by the Declaration. We also have, and you can continue to contribute to our storytelling project, "We the People: Reflections on America's 250th," where we ask any New Yorker and anyone to add to our archive. You can learn more about all of this at nypl.org/US250. At the end of tonight's conversation, Jane, Jill, and Geraldine will be glad to take some of your questions. Write them down on the little note cards on your seats when you come in — that you found on your seats when you came in. Some of my colleagues will be around to pick them up. If you're watching online, you can put them in the chat. Live From NYPL is made possible by the continuing generosity of Celeste Bartos, Mahnaz Ispahani Bartos, and Adam Bartos, and of course, by all of you. Thank you for your support. Thank you again for being here. Now please join me in welcoming first, Ted Gioia. [Applause]
Hello, my name's Ted Gioia. I'm a director at Arion Press, a printer in San Francisco, and I'm going to tell you just a little bit about the press before sharing the story behind tonight's book. Arion Press was founded in 1974 as a printer which invites leading artists from Kara Walker to William Kentridge to reimagine literary classics in unique forms. Arion's workshop is the last printer in the United States to make books entirely by hand from cover to cover. Our mission is to preserve and champion bookcraft in a digital era, and to accomplish this, we print limited edition artist books. Yet what distinguishes Arion's work is that our team of bookmakers craft every element by hand. So we can say, that's a spine by Diane Newell, or that's a semicolon by Brian Ferrett. And beyond publishing, we run the nation's last paid hand bookmaking apprenticeships and organize educational activities to share the power of printing across the nation, from a daughter making her first Mother's Day card to the president of the New York Public Library printing the Declaration. And at a time when many traditional crafts are floundering, we're proud to say that Arion is flourishing with larger audiences and more bookmakers on staff than ever. But our goal is not to be the Colonial Williamsburg of letterpress printing. [Laughter]
Our mission is showing why bookmaking is relevant to America today, and perhaps more importantly, tomorrow. And this vision is exemplified by today's book. America is a country founded by printing. The United States were inked into existence when John Dunlap printed the Declaration of Independence as a broadside in 1776. Disparate colonies were forged into a nation through ink, paper, and press. And in this sense, American independence was not simply declared, but crafted. And a quarter millennium later, Arion reaffirms our nation's founding pledge with another radical act of printing, "Declare: A Civic Gospel," an artist's book which assembled hundreds of American hands to create a printed testament to our country's inaugural words. Fifty artists, authors, poets, and artisans across 20 states came together to craft a gospel that honors the Declaration's past while interrogating its future.
Now, this book began with some legendary wood in American lore. We heard about a stash of tulip poplar trees planted at Monticello in Jefferson's lifetime. Jefferson called the poplar the Juno of the Groves and planted two of these titans across the house's portico, which once appeared on the back of the $2 bill. Then last year, a storm knocked over a historic tulip poplar in the Jefferson Family Cemetery as if fate wanted to ensure there was just enough material for an artist's book. [Laughter] And this salvaged wood became the seed of our edition. Transforming dead trees into seeds of a living democracy became the guiding metaphor for "Declare." But how to make a book worthy of this material and this moment? Well, we started with three elements unified by one core idea: gathering a polyphony of American perspectives across discipline, geography, politics, to render an expression of the American mind at this singular occasion.
Now, the first element is a volume of new essays and poems by leading Americans edited by the inestimable Jane Kamensky. And we invited a chorus of essential American voices, from poet laureates to four-star generals, to reflect on our country's founding credo. Pieces run from General James Mattis' exhortation on civilian control of the military to Rita Dove's haunting acrostic. And these are collected in a tidy volume whose exact binding borrows its shape and its shade from Jefferson's own Bible. Second is a suite of ten medallions made from historic Monticello wood engraved with visual commentaries from notable American artists interpreting some aspect of the Declaration. Those medallions are modeled on friendship medals exchanged as symbols of alliance in the early United States. Their iconography soars through a sweep of tones and temperaments from Chip Kidd's mischievous lampoon to Stephanie Sciucco's meditation on the unfulfilled promise of the Declaration's opening word, "when."
Third is a modern broadside of the Declaration's preamble created by acclaimed type designer Trey Seals. While visiting Monticello, Trey overheard a child ask what the document's first line meant, since she could not read cursive. And our lesson was clear: Trey's type treatment would need to place legibility over ornament. And for the verso, Trey adapted an early emblem of unity, the chain of states created by Benjamin Franklin for the $3 bill, to forge a fresh symbol of solidarity. And finally, Trey wanted to inject dynamism into the Declaration. So our preamble is encased in acrylic with a mobile stand asking readers to set up their own display of the immortal words. But now we face a bit of a design challenge. What could hold these very disparate elements, these myriad voices and visions of America? Our answer sprung from tradition. The Declaration was written on a portable desk of Thomas Jefferson, and its birthplace offered a blueprint for its future.
Channeling 18th-century woodwork from the prodigious collection of desks and furniture at Monticello, Arion devised an intricate architectural box designed to give depth, dimension, and dignity to our nation's founding words. There are four layers: the book on top nested in a tray adorned with the image of a tulip poplar, then two pull-out trays of medallions, while the bedrock of the box is the Declaration itself. Unpacked, the atomized elements unfold into a luminous constellation of American thought. But within the box, separate voices meld into a cohesive whole, e pluribus unum, in nine and a half pounds of paper. [Laughter] And this box's humble exterior conceals the extraordinary labor of its birth. There are 38 distinct parts, 6,325 pieces of board, chopped into 25,000 individual pieces. Indeed, fabric and board were chopped, sanded, and sized into the precise building blocks for our Declaration. And here, a metaphor becomes manifest. Raw materials are crafted into the durable cornerstones of a democracy.
In this way, the process of making "Declare" offers both a metaphor and a model for the labor of electoral democracy. Twenty different craftspeople from coast to coast came together as binders, printers, typecasters, and woodworkers, labored to fashion our gospel. And this handwork is our humble attempt to dignify and even, dare we say, sanctify the words within. And now we must ask, why care about craft at a time like this? Why care about the minutia of boards and bindings at a moment when our nation faces such turmoil? And the answer is because craft is a manifestation of how intention, skill, and perseverance can mold small materials into large meaning, whether you're crafting a book, a box, or a nation. And indeed, the courage to believe we can craft a country anew is quintessentially American.
And that brings us back to the subtitle, A Civic Gospel. We went through so many nouns and names to describe this physical book, but the most accurate may be covenant. There is one final detail I want to share. The inside lid is engraved with 14 words: "We mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor." The Declaration's last line. This is the eternal pledge for Americans. And this book, this gospel, is our pledge, our crafted covenant, wrought by American hands to enliven the electric cord at the heart of the Declaration. It is an invitation to feel the force of our nation's inaugural promise, both its feats and its failures, and discover afresh what country we might craft together with this credo guiding our hands. Thank you so much. [Applause]
Good evening. I'm Major Jackson. It's a pleasure to be here this evening. I want to thank the New York Public Library, as well as my friends at Arion Press and Monticello, and thank Ted and Jane for their vision to create "Declare: A Civic Gospel." I'm a poet, and I'm among several other poets who contributed to the book, among them Forrest Gander, Orlando White, Rita Dove, Tim Siebels. I'm going to read my poem, "Among the Living." As a professor, I was intrigued not only by the commission and the invitation, but as a teacher, I get excited when they say, come to Monticello for a study day. [Laughter] And during our study day, we received a terrific tour. And the tour, for me, took me back to something that I always knew about our country, is that history is present even as we look at it as the past. And this poem attempts to articulate something that was quite palpable for me during that particular time, on that day.
"Among The Living." All morning, I reached out my hands to Monticello's ghost, a felt path streaking by, eddies of leaves, echoes of voices in the architect's garden. Were I to bend low to beds laid out like green coffins, and press my heart to earth, and hear a heavy gallop of carriage horses, anvils striking nail rods, pollen settling on boots, or the swiveling arms of overseers flogging dark bodies. Between the guide's thoughtful lessons, I pursued history's fog, listening for a joiner's sign, for a servant's listless song preserved on parlor walls where she dusted the architect's wares. I sought surges of their faint lives, imaginings of a country that altered Albemarle fields' quieter moments, buried artifacts whose value is greater than crop yields, dreams that restore Black limbs to self-evident truths out of a morally depraved system. His words. Bondage birthed my nation's fissures.
Along Mulberry Row, past the Rivanna River, connecting Shadwell and Lego, no signs emerged out of the Misty Valley, and no spirits sprouted from solitary graves of slaves' burial grounds, just democracy's slanting light. As though from clouds, feeling the architect's domed oculus. Yet, when I walked the long cellar passage below, they came, a hundredfold. My drawn breath made shallow, a wind claimed my body, voiceless, I sunk into its deep chill. And in the minute struck by the great clock, saw how the tour was coated with their presence. In Salome's cold stare, in a chambered alcove bed, a telescope, a double-barrel air pump, a polygraph, elliptical archways, all mark the architect's blurred lenses. His paradoxical mind that called to the spheres no less brilliant and exegetical. Thank you. [Applause]
It's great to be here in democracy's slanting light with you all. I hope you feel the surge of honesty and inspiration that has accompanied this project. Honesty and inspiration are allies and not enemies, and that's one of the things that "Declare" insists upon. I think it's a commitment, too, of your wonderful new NYPL Declaring America 1776 and Beyond curriculum, which uses the Educating for American Democracy framework, whose museum and library work is housed at Monticello. So especially wonderful to begin this conversation with two dear young friends here. So I wanted to ask you both, by way of starting here in a place of such significance for books and book arts, in the presence of that transcendent fine press edition of "Declare," you've both been with this project from the very beginning, before there was a prototype, before there was a table of contents, beginning in the spring of 2025 when we first reached out to possible participants. You're busy people. So my first question is, why the hell did you say yes? [Laughter]
Well, thank you, and it really is delightful to be here with all of you and to be in the pages of this truly beautiful work of art. I mean, I was really struck by Ted's remarks about the United States being printed into being, and I love that vision for the project. I think that's something that, you know, here in the exhibit, within this building, that's visible, but I don't think that has been squarely at the center of how Americans have thought about this anniversary. So it was really, I just think it was just an incredibly cool idea. I myself am a big, like, crafts person. I'm like a crafty lady.
She's paint-specked even as she speaks.
No, I have paint all over my hands. But, like, when I knit, I really think about what knitting means as a kind of joinery. And I loved the idea of bringing writers together in a book not just in the way you might think of some regular anthology, but in this embodied object that's so much of, I think, how Monticello is interpreted, which made your poem really, you know, so vividly — the architecture of the thing, the architecture of the place.
I think there were two very strong pulls towards this project for me. One comes from my decade as a reporter and just loving to get up in people's business and get behind the closed doors. And it makes me a very bad tourist. And I had been to Monticello, but it was just the tour, and the thought of being able to get into all the nooks and crannies and crevices and the places where people had actually lived and breathed and found a little privacy in that very crowded house in a nook off the Oculus, to be able to have the behind-the-scenes of Monticello was one appeal. And the other was that writing about the past, I love being a historical novelist. I really enjoy it, but ever since the election, I had found that I was very distracted by politics, that jackhammer.
That jackhammer. That jackhammer that never stops, like waking up, what has he done today? And feeling like writing about the first foreign student at Oxford in 1109 was not what I wanted to be doing at this time. So when Jane called me about this, I was just finishing up working with Kamala Harris on her book, "107 Days," and I loved having somewhere to put just my outrage about things. And I thought, well, I can extend that a little bit by doing something for the country's significant anniversary and thinking patriotic thoughts about what we could be just for a little bit longer.
So I want to stay with you for a second, Geraldine, and talk about the fiction you crafted, which is not a tone of outrage. It's a very quiet piece. It's a deathbed scene. You have the only fictional contribution in the volume, inspired by the fact, and this is a kind of spoiler alert for some of you in the audience, that Jefferson and Adams died within hours of each other on the Declaration's 50th anniversary. I think when you first named this as your subject, I wondered whether you would discover that it was apocrypha and not true. It is, in fact, true. So tell us about that particular fictional window, and then I'd love for you to share more broadly what are things that only fiction can bring to a project like this?
I was a little scared when you proposed, I think as you put it in the first email, a microfiction, because I don't do short. I'm not good enough. Short story writers, everything has to be perfect. In a novel, you can have a little saggy bit in the middle here and there. [Laughter] But it was a challenge and I liked the idea of that. And I've always been struck by this ridiculous, ridiculous coincidence of the simultaneous deaths and on the 50th anniversary and on the 4th of July. And if, as a novelist, you invented that, you would be put in the pillory. [Laughter] And Mark Twain said, fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities, truth isn't. And I thought that thinking about Jefferson on his deathbed and his determination to hang on to the 4th, even though he was in great pain and debility, I thought, I'll be able to explore what you can and can't do in fiction. And so, the piece I wrote is partly short story and then partly stepping back and interrogating myself as a novelist about what you can and can't do. And so, to me, it's always been follow the line of fact as far as it leads. And then, when that line becomes faint and finally invisible, that's when you're allowed to make things up.
And what sort of deeper truth did that invention or communion lead you to in this primal scene of democracy's first major anniversary here?
So I don't think I unearthed any really astonishing truth, but what I enjoyed doing was trying to imagine this great intellect, this quintessential Enlightenment man who had been so many things and so many contradictions in his life. What thoughts would be meandering through his head as his life waned? And the most signal thing I think that I discovered in my research, which is not new to historians, but Jefferson's last words were to his enslaved children and we don't know what they were. And that is astonishing to me and yet it's very human that, you know, his non-enslaved children left that door closed. They could not reveal those intimacies. Whether they overheard those words or not, they were never written down. And it's the things that are never written down that drive historical novelists crazy, but it's also what gets you up in the morning.
Jill, I want to talk a little bit about your lead essay, "To Alter or to Abolish." It's part of a broader season of work that you've undertaken on the people and the Constitution and American democracy here in the 250th anniversary of the United States. So tell us about the exhausting arc of that writing. I've heard you say many times, this is the last thing I'm writing on the 250th, and where this essay fits in.
Yeah, I think I took it as my assignment to think about the document as a piece of writing subject to editing and amending, and then also as a civic creed that has been subject to editing and amending and is itself arguably an act of plagiarism, right? I mean, that goes too far in terms of maligning it morally, but I really wanted to excavate both the before of the Declaration of Independence and the after. I think that the metaphor I use, just out of desperation for a metaphor, and the piece is the bow tie. There's one half of the whole story that is the rich source of not just the ideas but the language of the Declaration coming from state and town and militia declarations of independence, coming from petitions for freedom by enslaved Americans, dating to colonial days, coming from the Magna Carta, the Declaration of Rights of 1689, the whole tradition of declarations. Coming from Virginia's constitution, like all the world of language and ideas that were available to Jefferson, and then all the other side of the bow tie, everything that it generated, the world of declarations of independence in the four corners of the globe, nation-states declaring independence from imperial powers, unions, farmers' granges, workers' parties. The genre of the Declaration of Independence finds its origin in Jefferson's words, which are repurposed by different peoples in different times and places.
As the ball of liberty rolls around the world, as he says, right?
And so to really also look at the knot itself, like what is the language of that? And I think what was a little challenging for me is that you and I, Jane, taught American history for so many decades that it feels a little like, okay, well, then there was the 1773 petition of the 12 Black men of Boston, and then there's this great petition from South Carolina. Like, we know these petitions, and the words of the Declaration and their origins are not altogether surprising to us, but I think they remain surprising to most Americans. I mean, I was just teaching last week, I assigned to my students Lemuel Haynes' "Liberty Further Extended." So Lemuel Haynes was a man from Connecticut who had served in the Revolutionary War, a Black man who became one of the first Black ordained ministers in the United States, and he wrote a response to Jefferson's declaration that just says, clearly, Mr. Jefferson, you did not go far enough. We need to extend your notion of liberty. It's impossible to find the words of this declaration to be true, and for them to not also negate the possibility that any human should ever be held in bondage. It's a beautiful essay, and it wasn't even discovered — it was never published at the time. It was discovered maybe in the 1980s, I want to say.
It was discovered in someone's attic, and it ended up at Houghton Library and was finally published, and it's an extraordinary act of amendment. It's a person, you know, a fellow American, inspired by the reading of the Declaration, read to the troops like he would have heard it in the course of his military service, and you just imagine listening to those words and finding them both beautiful and wanting. And it's the wanting that I find really beautiful, and I have to remind myself that not everybody has read Lemuel Haynes's "Liberty Further Extended," and so it was a real pleasure to bring that to bear in this piece.
Talk just a little bit more about this question of originality. I feel like there are Monticello people out in the live stream audience. I have to bring up this plagiarism question.
Oh, yeah. I don't — yeah, of course.
Where Jefferson says, right, he's harmonizing the sentiments of the American mind. So as we think about, there's an origin story in this project, right, an act of printing, a kind of foundational moment, a signed pledge, and yet there's nothing original about it, as Jefferson himself stipulates later in life. How does it help us think about originalisms?
Yeah, I mean, I think, I don't mean in any way to offer as an accusation of plagiarism.
You know, Jefferson said himself that what he was doing was not offering up an original idea at all, that he was trying to condense the American mind and put it down on paper. John Adams, who was very jealous of all the attention that Jefferson got as the author of the Declaration of Independence, was really grumpy that he was not assigned to the task because he was known as the most obnoxious member of the Continental Congress. The word obnoxious is often used in the 18th century to describe poor John Adams who was indeed something of a horrible person.
I mean, he was a lovely person, but he was a very difficult person. Adams, his whole complaint was like, hey, there's nothing new in there. But Jefferson said, yeah, no, that was not the assignment, right? The assignment, Congress asked me to write down what we as a people believe. And so, you know, he talked about it, he didn't have any books or pamphlets in front of him because that's all that anybody had been reading since 1765 were declarations of independence. What are the truths that we hold to be self-evident? That had been worked out in the American mind for decades and decades and decades, and the reason Jefferson was assigned to the task of doing it was because he could do it better than anyone else. I mean, he's just an exquisite prose stylist, and there are important improvements. I mean, a lot of my pieces about the sequence of editing that really annoyed Jefferson — I will say I'm very sympathetic, I hate being edited. You know, it was allegedly Benjamin Franklin who added self-evident truths.
The documentary editors disagree, but that is alleged.
There's a lot of disagreement about that.
Didn't Jefferson say sacred?
Jefferson said sacred in the original draft, so the question is who changed it to self-evident? But then it went to Congress, and Congress had a lot of edits. There's just differences of opinions about whether there are improvements or not.
Taking out the slavery paragraph.
Yeah, so Jefferson had written a long paragraph denouncing slavery, the slave trade, and in the course of his list of abuses of the king, blaming the king, and Congress took that out. There's a big debate about why Congress took that out. Is it just embarrassing? It's so hypocritical? But our colleague David Armitage has argued that it's actually the climax of the Declaration of Independence. Without it, the Declaration actually doesn't make any sense. It is a strange elision, but it's of course the first of many.
So I want to switch over and talk, Geraldine, about the study day that Major alluded to before his reading in the fall of 2025. A bunch of you contributors came to spend a day at Monticello, poets and artists meeting with experts from both Monticello and Arion. It was an atypical study day for a volume conference in that it included a trip to our stump dump, which is where you all examined the historic tulip poplar wood that became the medallions that Ted Gioia spoke about. I'd love to hear your reflections from that day and whether it changed anything in the way that you approached the story to be there in situ with volumes and spaces.
I always am a big fan of Go There. I do not believe in Google Earthing it. Because you can't — places obviously change over the centuries, but certain things don't change, which is the quality of the light and the shape of the ground. There is a huge value to going to the place that you're going to write about. So for me, you know, Jefferson's bedroom, the deathbed, to actually be in the room where he died and to think about how the light would have fallen on a summer day, not a fall day, but to see those windows and to see that alcove bed and the tight dimensions of it. And that made me think, did he already feel like he was entombed? To see his riding boots that he polished himself, which I found a significant detail. Why would he do that himself? Why did he make his own fires every morning? And this man who had a very strict regime of getting up early was not able to rise from his bed.
Sort of low-key MAHA, cold foot baths and that kind of stuff.