Good afternoon. What a delight to be here with people who are so committed to constitutional deliberation that on, I think, the hottest day of autumn, where we should be home weeping over the Red Sox — I'm just going to say that's what I would have been doing if I weren't here this afternoon — that people have traveled from quite far in many cases to do the work of gathering with people with whom, as Larry indicated, you know, most of us have many forms of disagreement, as many as the kinds of agreement that we have. Thanks, Mike, also for your opening words that help frame the really important discussions over the course of this weekend. I see my task here as kind of setting the historical table, trying to provide a little bit of historical backstory to the deliberations and conversations and presentations that we'll all be having this weekend.
This, my most recent book — well, before the one that just came out — this history of the Constitution really tries to place at the center of our understanding of American constitutionalism what I call the philosophy of amendment. But I also believe that is constitutive of the other key argument of that kind of thousand-page history of American constitutionalism, which is the convention tradition, which I think has been wildly overlooked both by historians and by legal scholars.
Lawyers who write about the US Constitution like to write about the US Supreme Court, but much of the history of the Constitution lies elsewhere. Above all, that history lies in the records of constitutional and extra-constitutional conventions, where Americans have for centuries devised their own constitutional provisions and proposed their own constitutional interpretations. One delegate to a 19th-century constitutional convention in Missouri suggested that every state ought to hold a convention every 14 years, because every seven years every bone, muscle, tissue, fiber and nerve — that is, every cell in the human body — is replaced. And surely in twice that time, every constitution ought to be rewritten as well.
And that in fact has nearly proven to be the case. Since 1776, the states have held nearly 250 constitutional conventions and have adopted 144 constitutions, about three per state. That practice, as we all know, lies dormant, to our great peril. The last state to hold a full-dress constitutional convention was Rhode Island in 1986.
The constitutional convention is both an ingenious American invention and an essential element of the history and tradition of constitutionalism in America.
So to kick off the conference, I want to do two things — three, two — I want to do three things here. First, I will excavate the origins of the constitutional convention and debates in the states between 1776 and 1780, and I will demonstrate that the federal convention of 1787 was a consequence of these debates and was essentially shaped by them.
Then I'll chronicle the explosion of conventions in the democratizing 19th century, and next I'll very briefly recount both the periodic interest in a federal convention over the course of the 20th century, and finally the abandonment of the convention tradition.
The first constitutional convention in the United States was held in the spring of 1776. We celebrate its 250th anniversary this year. That is to say, the first convention to draft a constitution was held before the United States even declared its independence. On May 20th, 1776, 4,000 Philadelphians turned up for a celebration of a resolution passed in the Pennsylvania Assembly calling for such a meeting. 'Conventions, my fellow countrymen, are the only proper bodies to form a constitution,' one Pennsylvanian wrote, 'and legislatures are the proper bodies to make laws agreeable to that constitution.' The Pennsylvania Journal printed this really compelling dialogue, chronicling what had already been established as a set of central notions about what constitutions are, who writes them, and what they are for.
Between 1776 and 1787, deliberations in the states established four elements as necessary for constitutional legitimacy: a constitutional convention, a bill of rights, a ratifying process, and an amendment procedure. Not every early state constitution, of course, included all four of these elements, but with each passing month, expectations for these elements grew. During those 11 years, 13 states wrote and adopted no fewer than 20 constitutions. Some 30,000 men did the actual drafting and revising, serving as delegates in constitutional conventions or special congresses. But political participation in the process was far broader. About 300,000 men participated in constitution-making every two years by way of reading and casting ballots. Much of the rest of the population, which of course totaled at the time four million people, played a part too, enacting their approval or disapproval through petitions and lawsuits and informal complaints and even through folk rituals from festivals to hooliganism.
Consider the state in which we have the great honor of meeting today. Beginning in May of 1776, the Massachusetts legislature attempted to draft a constitution itself. But even before the legislature began its work, the western town of Pittsfield in Berkshire County objected on two counts. First, the constitution would have to be written by a body convened solely for the purpose. As the Pittsfielders put it, 'if this fundamental constitution is above the whole legislature, the legislature certainly cannot make it.' Second, the constitution would have to be submitted to the towns for ratification, because 'the approbation of the majority of the people of this fundamental constitution is absolutely necessary to give life and being to it.'
The legislature obliged the Pittsfielders, but only by appointing one delegate from every town to a drafting committee. But when the exigencies of the war prevented that committee from meeting, the legislature proposed to complete the drafting itself. The towns were displeased.
The legislature, bridling at their interference and their complaints, nevertheless went ahead and drafted a constitution, but acceding to one of Pittsfield's demands, sought ratification in 1778 through a statewide referendum at which any man at least 21 years old could vote. Towns were then to submit the results — they were really just supposed to submit returns saying yes or no. But in the very midst of war, this resulted in a flood of impassioned constitutional commentary.
173 towns out of a total of some 200 in Massachusetts submitted returns. Ratification failed by a margin of five to one. But these towns didn't just submit a piece of paper saying yes or no. They submitted long constitutional complaints.
They refused to submit to the process by which the 1778 constitution had been prepared, and they insisted on their right to hold a convention.
That convention of 312 delegates assembled here in Cambridge on September 1st, 1779. In fact, if we had windows in this room, we could see the site at which they first assembled. It is really a stone's throw from the spot in which we all sit. I think it's worth honoring that moment. It's about where, if you're wandering around Harvard Square, the First Parish Church stands today.
As the delegates began to do their work, a freeholder published in the Boston Gazette his recommendations for the convention, listing four things this new constitution should do. First, make the form of government as simple as possible so that every man might understand it. Second, include a bill of rights. Third, clearly define and limit the power of rulers. And fourth, guarantee to the people the power of removing rulers from their places.
As you know, John Adams, famously calling himself a subcommittee of one, did the drafting of that Massachusetts Constitution, declaring, 'I made a constitution for Massachusetts which finally made the Constitution of the United States.' As he later boasted, his constitution did those four things that that freeholder demanded. Ratification required approval by two-thirds of the towns. The convention printed nearly 2,000 copies of the constitution and sent it to the towns with an instruction reminding the towns that 'it is their right and interest to approve of this constitution and to make and propose such alterations and amendments as they desired.' What less than two years before had been hotly contested, in other words, the people's right to draft, approve, reject, or amend the Constitution had become by 1780, when that revised Constitution was sent to the people, your undoubted right.
And so it was, of course, Massachusetts that bears responsibility for the Philadelphia Convention of 1787. In the spring of 1786, farmers from western Massachusetts — those very towns that had most opposed the legislature-drafted constitution — led by revolutionary war veteran Daniel Shays, determined to overthrow the present constitution. Delegates from 50 towns met in a convention to do so. They wanted to abolish the upper house of the legislature and move the state capital to the middle of the state. James Bowdoin, the state's governor, called out the militia, but the men who were called to put down Shays' Rebellion, who knew that the state had no money to pay them and in any case supported the rebels, didn't bother to show up. Bowdoin wanted to call on Congress for aid. Congress didn't have either the money or the authority to help him.
Congress, meanwhile, appointed a committee to recommend amendments to the Articles of Confederation to address this very crisis in Massachusetts. This committee's work was derailed when Virginia called for a convention of delegates to meet in Annapolis in September. But a week after that convention was scheduled to begin, only 12 delegates had turned up. Not even Maryland, which was hosting the convention, had bothered to send a delegate. The men who showed up in Annapolis cancelled their convention. They went home. Congress then that fall pledged troops to Bowdoin in Massachusetts but couldn't manage to send anyone. Bowdoin paid out of his own pocket for a militia to put down the rebellion, which was accomplished in February of 1787.
Whereupon in Congress, Massachusetts member Rufus King introduced a resolution calling for a constitutional convention to be held in Philadelphia.
That convention completed its draft, of course, in September of 1787. Between December of 1787 and May of 1790, nearly 2,000 Americans served as delegates to ratifying conventions held in the states.
These conventions were hard-fought. Ratification was a very, very close call. It turned on actually a lot of political chicanery and the overrepresentation of Federalists in the ratifying conventions, and turned as well on Federalist domination of newspapers across the United States. But the Federalists successfully secured not only ratification but defeated calls made by Anti-Federalists for a second constitutional convention, whereupon they breathed a great sigh of relief and hope that there would never again be another constitutional convention. But by 1787 — by, certainly by 1790, with Rhode Island's final vote — for all the deficiencies of representation, the convention as a tradition had become firmly established.
What's sort of weird then is why was there never a second federal constitutional convention? That's an open question that historians continue to debate. But I want to take our inquiry in a slightly different direction. In 1787, no one could have predicted, no one would have predicted that another federal constitutional convention would become unthinkable, but that in the states, conventions would be as regular as rain. No one predicted it, but in fact, everyone noticed it.
'America is at the present day the country in the world where laws last the shortest time,' Tocqueville wrote in 1833. 'Almost all the American constitutions have been amended within the course of 30 years. There is not a single American state which has not modified the principles of legislation in that lapse of time.'
Between 1800 and 1865, 36 states held conventions and ratified new or amended constitutions. In those years, only six passed in which no state in the United States held a convention. It's hard to really fathom how much conventions were in the news. People read the news. They read reports from other states. Convention proceedings summaries often appeared in newspapers. Think of Vermont. It wrote its first constitution in 1777. It held conventions in 1786, 1793, 1814, 1818, 1822, 1828, 1836, 1850, and 1857. In one 10-year period, 1844 to '53, more than half the states held constitutional conventions.
Conventions were more than news stories. They were more than things that you knew someone in your neighborhood was serving as a delegate in because they were happening so often. They were also sort of celebrated in many other ways across the culture. This is just this wacky, really weird painting of the Virginia Convention, where serving at this convention was so important that all of the men who served had to be recognizable in this portrait. They have these gigantic heads because they're all drawn from miniatures, so that you could look at this painting and you could tell who every single one of these guys was. That's the sort of pride of having served in this convention.
The ubiquity of constitutional conventions in this era deepened Americans' commitment to the tradition. A convention is the provided machinery for peaceful revolution. They said it is the civilized substitute for intestine war, the American mode for carrying out the will of the majority. The very act of assembling, the convention itself, became the symbol, the visible enactment of the sovereignty of the people. Or as the Supreme Court of Indiana put it, a constitutional convention of eminent citizens is the substitute for the armed mob of other countries.
Americans held conventions to make their constitutions more democratic. In 1800, every state except for New Hampshire and Vermont had some form of a property requirement for voting. By 1865, none did. Between 1824 and '28, the number of voters more than doubled. At the start of the century, in a majority of states, delegates to the Electoral College were elected by state legislatures. By 1824, voters themselves elected those delegates in 18 out of 24 states. In 1800, voters elected their own governors in only seven states. By 1853, voters in all of what were then 31 states elected their own governors. And by 1860, 18 states mandated the election rather than the appointment of state judges. This is at a time when all efforts to make such changes to the US Constitution failed.
And these efforts were made. I for many years worked on a project funded by the National Endowment for the Humanities to compile a complete list of every serious proposal to amend the US Constitution. It's theamendmentsproject.org, and you can find in there the many, many proposals in the antebellum years to abolish the Electoral College, to limit the terms of Supreme Court justices, to make the same changes to the federal constitution that states were making to state constitutions. Changes in the states had a kind of domino effect. The more conventions were held, the more conventions were held. The conventions themselves influenced one another. Kansas relied on Ohio's constitution. California relied on Iowa's.
Borrowing was encouraged not only because of the newspaper reports of the convention, which were vanishing, perishable accounts that no one consulted after their publication, but they also relied on books like this book of the constitution, which is sort of a compilation of state constitutions. At California's constitutional convention in 1848, the explorer Lansford Hastings offered his opinion that all anyone really needed to do to write a constitution was to read this book.
Some delegates objected to all that borrowing. At a convention in Michigan in 1850, a delegate complained about the references made to other state constitutions. 'We should have our constitutions that are particular to our own states,' he suggested. But if states borrowed from the constitutions of other states, they were in no real position to be informed by the records of the state conventions, which is actually something worth dwelling on for a minute because it's one of the reasons the convention tradition has been lost to scholarship. Because although the state conventions were not secret, their records were really unavailable and they were extremely unreliable, even more so than those few that survive for the 1787 convention in Philadelphia.
Records of state constitutional conventions often took decades to appear in print, if at all. Connecticut's 1818 convention's records were not published until 1991. Some records seem never to have existed. Oregon's 1857 convention left no trail. Others were simply lost. The records of a Nebraska convention were stored in a cracker box until they disappeared. And the reports that do survive are riddled with errors, omissions, and misrepresentations.
There's a kind of seat-of-the-pants quality to these conventions. But the records that do survive document delegates across the country confronting common problems, including the difficulty of calling for a convention. In most states, only legislators — the very elected officials who benefited from the status quo — could make that call. A whole slew of conventions then made a priority of amending their constitutions to make it easier to amend their constitutions.
One of the things that was a problem across the country was that political power was held disproportionately by eastern cities, and people in the more rural and western parts of states had a very difficult time successfully calling for a convention. Conventions also altered the mode of ratification. Before 1812, no state outside New England had sought popular ratification for a constitution. But by 1826, only two had done so. Legislatures blocked efforts to adopt popular ratification as much as conventions tended to favor it.
But after 1857, after Minnesota entered the Union, Congress required that new states put their constitutions to a popular vote. This was objected to in what became the Confederacy. As late as the 1870s, only six states of what had been the Confederacy had actually submitted a constitution to the people.
Reformers also wanted to eliminate consecutive session requirements for calling conventions. They also wanted to eliminate supermajority requirements.
Some reformers wanted to wrest the power to propose amendments from the legislature altogether and simply put the question of calling an amending convention to a popular vote at regular intervals. Seven states adopted these periodic revision mechanisms.
A commitment to the convention tradition in the 19th century, the age of the railroad and the telegraph and the power loom, was very much attached to the idea of progress and later in the century to the idea of evolution. These theories of change really influenced a commitment to the convention tradition. 'We live in an age of progress,' the delegate said at a convention in 1850. 'The very purpose for which we are sent here was to make improvements in our system of government, to avail ourselves of all the lights which the experience of other states and of our own furnishes us, in order to make our organic law as perfect as it is to make it.' To a delegate at Michigan's 1850 convention, 10 years between votes on a convention seemed too long given the speed of progress. 'For within the last 10 years, such has been the rapid improvement in the mechanical arts, in scientific professions, the electrical telegraph, together with California coming into the Union, a briefer period would be better.'
In antebellum America, conventions were the dominant mechanism of constitutional reform, of constitutional expression, and even of anti-constitutionalism. The militant abolitionist John Brown held a convention that wrote a constitution. And when the Southern states seceded, they too held conventions and wrote constitutions. Second only to voting, conventions served as the prevailing method of political participation and of social reform. Utopian societies held conventions. Religious sects held conventions. Temperance associations held conventions. So did everyone from debtors in a debtor's prison in New York who wrote their own constitution to squatters in a mining camp in Wisconsin.
We can think, and I think many of you are familiar with, the accomplishments of these state constitutions, which we associate with Jacksonian democracy broadly construed: eliminating the aristocratic provisions of the early state constitutions and inaugurating more democratic processes.
What these constitutions also did by eliminating property qualifications was make it possible for poor Black men who were free to vote, and therefore of great interest to these conventions was addressing the issue of racial restrictions in voting by lifting property requirements. The whole notion of suffrage came into question state by state. So these conventions became places to deliberate not only the question of slavery but the question of race.
Conventions can have wonderful results. They can also have terrible results. Most conventions have both. People are not happy with the results of conventions uniformly. A great many conventions that took place before the Civil War involved adding the word 'white' to state constitutions.
At the federal convention in Philadelphia, after draft language proposed calculating representation in proportion to the whole number of white and other free citizens, the words 'white' and 'free' had been deleted in revision. But in new and amended state constitutions, when describing who was eligible to vote, the words 'white' and 'free' and 'male' were inserted for the first time beginning in 1810. By 1840, what was called universal suffrage meant that all poor white men could vote — a broadness of suffrage that existed nowhere else in the world at the time. By the end of the 1840s, in a Union of 31 states, Black men could vote without restriction only in four states, all of which were in New England.
Yet no word was more fiercely debated at state constitutional conventions than the word 'white.' And no convention was more influential in that regard than a meeting of 126 delegates in Albany, New York in 1821.
Largely because this constitutional convention's records were carefully kept and were published in detail — every roll call recorded, nearly every speech fully described and published in the New York American and other newspapers — a compilation of four different reporters' accounts then appeared in a book of nearly 400 pages.
New Yorkers, an electorate that at the time had included Black men, had voted for a convention by a margin of three to one, primarily on the promise of extending suffrage by eliminating property requirements.
No Black men served as delegates to the convention, but Black New Yorkers submitted a petition to the convention asking it to incorporate a provision in the constitution preventing the legislature from passing any laws interfering with their rights or their ability to exercise the right of suffrage. This became the convention's most contentious question, where the argument in favor of not including the word 'white,' which was early proposed to be added to the convention, was made most forcefully by Peter Jay, the son of John Jay, who had helped draft New York's first constitution in 1777.
One of Jay's arguments was, 'I do not believe your constituents,' he told fellow delegates, 'have authorized you to disenfranchise them,' reminding them that Black men had called for this convention to extend the suffrage.
Jay lost this argument overnight. 30,000 Black men in the state of New York lost their right to the vote. They fought back. The editor of a Black newspaper called Rights for All declared that New York's constitutional convention had acted illegally in restricting suffrage to whites, much as it would have required that all voters be six feet tall. Black men then began calling for their own conventions.
Between 1830 and 1861, Black delegates met in 49 state conventions, two regional conventions, and 11 national conventions.
Native nations, of course, held constitutional conventions too.
sometimes adopting their own national constitutions. We as a tribe will rule ourselves, a convention of Mashpee Indians in Massachusetts declared in 1832-1833. So too American women. The first national convention of anti-slavery women met in 1837, bringing together some 200 women from 10 states. One in 10 delegates were Black women.
To attend a female convention, one delegate wrote, "Once, I should have blushed at the thought." By the 1840s, women were petitioning state constitutional conventions to demand rights for themselves, and of course held their first women's rights convention in 1848.
By 1860, they'd held 19 conventions, 10 of them national. Courts and lawyers tend to forget these conventions of Black men, of white women, of Native nations. They're very seldom cited in legal opinions. And yet, they are as essential a convention tradition as any of the state constitutional conventions. I want to just pause for a minute to think about one of those conventions. Early in 1847, when Illinois debated holding a convention to revise the state's constitution, they engaged in the same rhetoric of a convention being an enactment of the sovereignty of the people.
At the time, John Jones, a Black tailor from Chicago, wrote a petition on behalf of Black men asking that the state legislature repeal all laws making a distinction among people of color. In response, the Illinois Senate's judiciary committee rejected his petition and suggested that he return to the land of his birth. At the convention in Illinois, a motion to prohibit the legislature from ever extending the right to vote to Black men passed 60 to 51. Jones then attempted to convince the voters of Illinois not to ratify this new constitution for reasons that he gave in a series of powerful newspaper essays. It's just an illustration of the degree to which the Black conventions — Jones was the vice president of many Black conventions held in this era — were in conversation with state constitutional conventions. And yet the records of those proceedings have largely been set aside by historians and especially by legal scholars.
The contest over the meaning of the Constitution and the states and the federal government in the authority to interpret it came to a head, of course, in 1857 in Dred Scott. Countering the court and building on arguments that Black delegates had made at over three decades of Black constitutional conventions, Frederick Douglass offered his own amended version of the preamble to the U.S. Constitution.
The convention tradition by the beginning of the Civil War had been established. It failed to stop that war, but the tradition proved unshakable.
It was not until well after the end of Reconstruction that the first serious calls for a second federal convention were made as a means to bypass both Congress and the Supreme Court. I don't know if you guys can see these slides, but hopefully you can get a sense here. We're looking at state conventions held here beginning in 1789 going all the way to 2018, and proposed amendments to the U.S. Constitution.
I think we have here — we have Article V convention applications beginning in 1896, which is the period I want to talk about, moving forward in time here.
In 1893, states began calling for a convention to propose a direct Senate election amendment. Some states weren't willing to wait for a constitutional convention. They didn't have much hope for one, so they came up with workarounds. Beginning in 1901, Oregon put the election of the state's U.S. senators directly to voters in a non-binding election. Oregonians then passed a law requiring candidates for the state legislature to declare on the ballot whether they would honor the vote of these non-binding elections. So if you ran for the legislature and you said you wouldn't honor a popular vote for who should be your senator, you would not win a seat in the legislature. By 1910, 28 other states had adopted this or a similar de facto method of direct election of the U.S. Senate.
In 1906, the governor of Iowa held a conference in Des Moines where representatives from 11 states discussed whether an Article V convention, if it were held, ought to be limited to considering the direct Senate election amendment. By 1909, 28 state legislatures had petitioned Congress to call for a convention. Only 31 were needed at that time. Under these circumstances, Americans became exceptionally interested in the intricacies of Article V. At a time when the breakup of empires and the establishment of new democracies was leading to a surge of constitution writing in Europe, Americans were especially intrigued by remarks offered by foreign observers.
In 1905, Australia's attorney general, Henry Higgins, argued that given the difficulty of amendment, constitutional change in the United States happens only at the hands of U.S. Supreme Justices. And sadly, he offered the view: "It must be admitted that judges are not persons to whom the amendment of a constitution should be entrusted." Amendment by the judiciary, he concluded, was a deformity of American constitutionalism.
Nor was this criticism in the Progressive Era offered only by foreign observers. In 1906, North Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice Walter Clark called for a new convention. He was pretty unhappy with the original constitution but believed that it was now high time, given changing population and changing technology. He urged a series of reforms aligned with the Progressive agenda. Clark wanted to abolish the Electoral College, institute a single six-year presidential term, the election of Supreme Court judges to nonrenewable 10-year terms, direct election of senators, and the abolition of equal suffrage in the Senate.
If the choice were between an amendment or a convention, conservatives who had blocked calls for a convention decided to agree to a series of amendments. The result was four progressive constitutional amendments in eight years.
Weirdly though, this success — the very success of that sweep of progressive amendments — sapped the strength of any movement to hold a constitutional convention, a prospect that lay largely dormant until the Supreme Court's 1954 decision in Brown v. Board of Education, which led Southern segregationists to entertain the idea of calling for a convention to overturn it.
That campaign failed, but meanwhile state constitutional conventions grew in number during the civil rights era. The Supreme Court's decision in Gray v. Sanders in 1963, codifying the idea of one person, one vote, along with the 1964 Reynolds v. Sims decision, led to a wave of apportionment conventions in the states between 1964 and 1970.
After Reynolds, Senate Minority Leader Everett Dirksen led the most significant campaign to call for a constitutional convention since the Progressive Era — a campaign to leave reapportionment decisions to the states, one that grew in success with the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. By 1966, 28 states had petitioned Congress for a convention. By the start of 1967, 32 out of the required 34 had joined this campaign. But that campaign stalled when Dirksen died in 1969, and the apportionment convention movement died with him.
Extra-constitutional conventions, though, flourished in this era as well, in a kind of reprise of the Black conventions and other extra-constitutional conventions of the 19th century. In 1970, the Black Panthers called for and held a Revolutionary People's Convention in D.C. Two years later, 4,000 Black delegates from all 50 states attended a Black National Convention in Gary, Indiana.
In 1977, some 130,000 American women participated in meetings held in all 56 states and territories to elect delegates to what is in fact the biggest constitutional convention in American history, the National Women's Convention in Houston. Women from all walks of life met in hotels and civic centers, in the halls of college campuses, in meetings that were both federally funded and open to the public, to elect delegates. A Spanish edition of the agenda was made available. New Jersey sent out notices folded into telephone bills. North Dakota spread the word in beauty parlors. Georgia handed out information at basketball games.
This convention, though, arguably marked the beginning of the end of the convention tradition. Conservatives had called for a convention since the 1950s, first to overturn Brown and then to repeal reapportionment. For that entire period, liberals had warned of the possibility of an open or runaway convention. In 1963, Charles Black, who had written crucial briefs in Brown v. Board, warned that given the states' rights backlash against Brown, amendments put forward at any constitutional convention would, he said, return us to the Confederacy.
Nevertheless, by 1979, 28 states had called for a convention to adopt a balanced budget amendment. In The New Yorker, Washington correspondent Richard Ravitch warned, "It is at least theoretically possible that another convention could reinstate segregation and even slavery."
Soon after Ravitch's piece appeared in The New Yorker, a Gallup poll reported that 65% of Americans favored holding a constitutional convention. The poll also asked Americans what kinds of amendments they would support if such a convention were held.
Liberals, who could still be found at the time in both parties, had good reason to oppose this convention because if the polls were right, they would have won on ERA, which they expected to win without a convention, so why bother? But they would have lost on government spending, prayer in schools, and school busing, and they would have rolled the dice on abortion, a subject about which, in any event, liberals did not at that point hold any strong or inalterable views. The control of handgun sales was in 1979 even less of a strictly partisan issue at the time. But for both fiscal and social conservatives, a convention, given these polls, looked promising.
After the Gallup results were published, the American Enterprise Institute convened a panel discussion on the subject of a constitutional convention — how well would it work? — to which they invited University of Chicago law professor Antonin Scalia. And I want to just take a minute to watch a little clip of Professor Scalia here.